Israel's prison service has released a video purportedly showing the leader of a three-week-old hunger strike by Palestinian inmates eating in his cell.

The service said Marwan Barghouti had been filmed consuming cookies in secret on 27 April and a snack bar on 5 May.
It did not say how he obtained the food, but sources told the Haaretz newspaper that he had been set up.
Barghouti's wife said the footage was "fake" and intended to break the morale of the hunger strike's participants.
More than 890 prisoners have been refusing food since 17 April in protest at conditions in Israeli jails.
They have issued a list of demands including better medical services, more frequent family visits and an end to detention without trial.
The nine-minute surveillance video released by the Israel Prison Service on Sunday shows a man identified as Barghouti, who was convicted on five counts of murder by an Israeli court in 2004, moving about inside a cell.
The first part, dated 27 April, shows the man opening a white envelope and inspecting its contents before sitting down in the cell's toilet and closing the door. The view is obstructed, but the prison service said the envelope contained cookies.
The second part, dated 5 May, shows the same man opening another envelope, walking to the toilet, and taking out what the prison service said was a snack bar. This time the door is left open and the man appears to unwrap the bar, break off a piece and bring it to his mouth.
The man is then apparently shown eating a packet of salt.
"This hunger strike was never about the conditions of the convicted terrorists, which meet international standards," said Israeli Minister of Public Security Gilad Erdan. "Barghouti is a murderer and hypocrite who urged his fellow prisoners to strike and suffer while he ate behind their back."
The head of the Palestinian Prisoners' Club, Qadoura Fares, called the video a fabrication, stressing Barghouti was being held in solitary confinement at Kishon prison and had no access to food.
"This is psychological warfare that we expected Israel to wage against the strike," he was quoted as saying by the Associated Press.
Barghouti's wife, Fadwa, said Israel was "resorting to despicable acts" and warned that they would "increase the prisoners' insistence on continuing".
Barghouti is the former leader of the Fatah movement in the West Bank and chief of its armed wing, the Tanzim.
His trial during the second Palestinian intifada, or uprising, turned him into household name and he enjoys widespread support among many Palestinian factions.
The 57-year-old has been touted as a possible successor to Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas.


Labour has accused the government of selling off valuable hospital assets to help plug a hole in NHS finances.

Figures from data body NHS Digital show that the amount of NHS land in England earmarked for sale has more than doubled in the past year.
Analysis commissioned by Labour found 117 sites deemed surplus were still in medical or clinical use.
Ministers said selling land would give vital funds for patient care and free up space for much needed new housing.
The government has set itself a target of selling off enough public sector land to generate Â£5bn worth of income by 2020.
The NHS is asked to contribute as a major property owner.
NHS property being included for sale includes hospital buildings and some ambulance stations.
But Labour said hospitals were being stripped of their assets and forced into a "fire sale".
Shadow health secretary Jonathan Ashworth said: "This government's refusal to fund the health service has seen standards of care for patients drop and NHS building and upgrade works pushed back.
"The NHS needs an urgent injection of funding to make up for years of Tory underfunding, but the answer is not a blanket sell-off of sites which are currently being used for patient care."
The Department for Health said disposing of surplus land and buildings reduced running costs and it was right to put sites that were no longer needed to economic use.
It said any income generated would be used to improve the quality of the NHS.


Plans to force the largest companies to disclose more about their tax affairs will be unveiled by the European Union on Tuesday.

The rules will affect multinational firms with more than â‚¬750m in sales.
They will have to detail how much tax they pay in which EU countries as well as any activities carried out in specific tax havens.
The plans come amid heightened scrutiny of the use of tax havens following the Panama Papers revelations.
Lord Hill, the EU's financial services commissioner, said: "This is a carefully thought through but ambitious proposal for more transparency on tax.
"While our proposal on [country-by-country reporting] is not of course focused principally on the response to the Panama Papers, there is an important connection between our continuing work on tax transparency and tax havens that we are building into the proposal."
Country-by-country reporting rules already apply to banks, mining and forestry companies, according to an EU spokesperson.
Under the new proposals, that would be expanded to cover companies accounting for about 90% of corporate revenues in the EU, they added.
The BBC understands that companies will need to disclose information such as total net turnover, profit before tax, income tax due, amount of tax actually paid and accumulated earnings.
The changes come after G20 leaders agreed to follow an OECD action plan to tackle corporate tax minimisation.
This proposal is bound to be controversial. The Commission's plan would oblige companies to report what they earn and how much tax they pay in EU countries. But it would also force them to reveal details of their tax affairs in "third countries which do not respect international tax good governance standards". In other words, secretive tax havens.
This sounds perfectly sensible. Companies which use artificial structures to avoid or minimise tax, or to shelter their gains in tax havens, would find their arrangements exposed to the full glare of public scrutiny. The old legalistic argument that they pay all the tax that they owe might not be enough to deflect bad publicity.
But how do you decide which regions' tax laws aren't up to scratch? Last year, the Commission published a blacklist of 30 'non-cooperative jurisdictions'. The move was condemned by the head of the OECD, who described the criteria it used as unfair and subjective.


World Rugby would support North American teams joining the Pro12, chief executive Brett Gosper has said.

Pro12 officials have held talks that could lead to US and Canadian sides being involved in the future.
Four teams each from Ireland and Wales plus two each from Scotland and Italy make up the current format, but the possibility of the Six Nations moving has encouraged hopes of expansion.
"We'd be supportive of any competitions including US-based sides," said Gosper.
"The US market is a very important market for rugby. It's a high-growth market, it's the fastest-growing team sport in the USA.
"It certainly will, we think, provide us in the future with huge revenues to World Rugby through our Rugby World Cup product, which all gets invested back into the game around the world.
"That competition, or the Aviva [Premiership], or the Top 14, or Super Rugby - they're all competing for players and competing for eyeballs on broadcasts, so we understand why they would be interested in having a US team in their competition.
"From our point of view, it would be great because it would be developing players in that area who otherwise would have to come to Europe.
"Anything that keeps and inspires some home-grown US players can only be good for the development of that sport."
Pro12 managing director Martin Anayi has underlined the desire for North American teams to be included, with Houston and Vancouver earmarked as possible host cities.
He wants the annual Six Nations tournament involving England, Ireland, Scotland, France, Wales and Italy to be moved in the calendar and expects World Rugby to help that happen.
However, Anayi accepts that a long-talked-about global season has to be implemented for any Pro12 revamp to take place, and Gosper suggests it is a delicate issue.
"At the end of the day, the global calendar is a negotiation of what's in the common good for as many of the competitions, clubs and nations as possible," said the World Rugby chief.
"It's not an easy thing to reconcile and movement somewhere creates issues somewhere else.
"All I can say at this point of time is we would support their ambition to include an American side in the [Pro12] competition.
"We'd have to look at, with the other stakeholders, what that would mean in terms of calendar shuffle or change."


A man has been jailed for six years after repeatedly hitting a bottle over a woman's head after she smiled at him.

Liam McGrath struck the woman several times in the unprovoked attack at the Outrageous club in Carlisle during a night out in August.
McGrath, 36, of Greenmill Road in Longtown, admitted wounding with intent when he appeared at Carlisle Crown Court.
The victim has been scarred for life, the court heard.
The hearing was told McGrath was so drunk at the time of the attack, which left his victim with two significant wounds to her forehead, he could not remember it.
Recorder Jeremy Lasker told McGrath: "You should be ashamed of what you have done to that lady."
The court heard the victim smiled at McGrath just moments before he launched the attack at 02:00 BST.
One witness said McGrath drew his arm back to get more power in his blows. Another onlooker reported he appeared to hit the woman "as hard as he could".
The court was told McGrath had previous convictions for assaults on women.
Kim Whittlestone, defending, said: "He is at a loss to know why he reacted in the way that he did.
"He sends his apologies to the complainant."


Australia's prime minister has taken a "farewell selfie" after his final meeting with Barack Obama as the US president.

The two men held closed door talks for 50 minutes at the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation summit in Peru on Sunday.
Both spoke in favour of free trade - including the Trans Pacific Partnership - defying the campaign rhetoric of US President-elect Donald Trump.
Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull praised Mr Obama as a "remarkable leader".
"It's a momentous occasion when one president hands over to another," Mr Turnbull said.
"President Obama has been a remarkable leader of the United States and indeed leader of the world for eight years. There's an element of sadness there but a great sense of achievement too."
The two world leaders privately discussed security issues in the South China Sea and the fight against the Islamic State group.
Mr Turnbull also thanked the US president for his co-operation on the agreement to resettle asylum seekers held in offshore detention centres in Papua New Guinea and Nauru.
Mr Obama in return said it was "not often where I have a meeting and I've got nothing to disagree with".
"Usually there's something to keep us busy."
Mr Turnbull has pledged to work with Mr Trump, declaring on US election night that "Americans understand that they have no stronger ally, no better friend" than Australia.
He described his first conversation with Mr Trump as warm and constructive.
"I've Âalready had a good chat with the president-elect and I'm sure the very strong relationship between Australia and America will continue," he told local radio last week.


A sea wall that collapsed during storms in Portsmouth, revealing a large void, has been temporarily fixed.

About 1,000 tonnes of granite boulders have been used to plug the hole which opened up behind the Pyramids Centre in Southsea between 25 and 26 December.
Council leader Donna Jones said: "I'm very confident that what we've done will stop any further deterioration."
The authority said plans for a multimillion-pound replacement scheme for the sea defences was underway.
Portsmouth City Council said the cost of replacing the 40-year-old concrete defences was estimated at Â£87m.


The ban on laptops in cabins of direct flights from Saudi Arabia to the United States has been lifted according to Saudi Arabian Airlines.

It says two hub airports which serve the US have received clearance from the US Department of Homeland Security.
Riyadh's King Khalid airport is the last of 10 airports to be exempted from the ban.
In March, the US banned laptops and other large electronic devices to and from eight mostly Muslim nations.
US officials will check that Saudi airports are complying with new security measures.
King Abdulaziz International Airport in Jeddah and King Khalid International Airport in Riyadh have both been inspected and cleared to allow laptops in aircraft cabins.
Those two airports have direct international flights from Saudi Arabia to the US.
Saudi Arabian Airlines, also know as Saudia, is the only airline that flies direct to the United States from Saudi Arabia.
Earlier this month Dubai-based Emirates and Turkish Airlines said the cabin ban no longer applied to their flights.
A travel ban on citizen from six majority-Muslim nations remains in place, although has been challenged in US courts.


A garage in Bristol which is barely big enough to fit a Mini car in has sold for nearly £50,000.

The lock-up, in in the Clifton area of the city, had been put up for auction with a guide price of £35,000.
But the unnamed buyer, who lives locally, approached the auction house just hours before the sale and made the offer which was accepted by the seller.
Auctioneer Andrew Morgan said that the 2.7m (9ft) wide and 5.7m (19ft) long space could also be used for storage.
He said interest in garages was always high.
"We recently sold another slightly bigger garage for £67,000 and the buyer flew back from the United States to look at it and then instructed a friend to buy it.
"The prices achieved do vary and fall as you head out of the central areas, but when several are offered in the same location people snap them as potential building sites."


Lewis Hamilton beat Mercedes team-mate Nico Rosberg in a thrillingly close battle at the Bahrain Grand Prix.

Media playback is not supported on this device
With the pair in a league of their own, the battle became a 10-lap sprint after a late safety car period wiped out Hamilton's 10-second advantage.
On the faster soft tyre, Rosberg had the advantage, but Hamilton held him off to the end with aggressive defence.
A frantic battle for third place was won by Force India's Sergio Perez, from Red Bull's Daniel Ricciardo.
Media playback is not supported on this device
The Australian was able to pass Perez's team-mate Nico Hulkenberg, struggling with energy harvesting problems in his Mercedes power-unit, with four laps to go and close in on Perez, who did just enough to keep the Red Bull at bay.
Hulkenberg held off a train of cars including Sebastian Vettel's Red Bull, the Williams drivers Felipe Massa and Valtteri Bottas, and the Ferrari pair Fernando Alonso and Kimi Raikkonen, who took the final points positions.
It was a sobering day for the Italian team and not just in terms of the results, as their world champion driver pairing were literally powerless to beat drivers in teams with far fewer resources but powered by the dominant Mercedes engine.
Before the race Ferrari president Luca Di Montezemolo had criticised the new efficiency-based F1 for being like "taxi driving".
Those claims were made to look ridiculous by a thrilling grand prix that featured breathless action from start to finish throughout the field.
Mercedes were true to their word to let their drivers race for victory untroubled by team orders.
Rosberg started from pole, but Hamilton made a better start and took the lead at the first corner.
Rosberg tracked him in the early stages, keeping within 1.5 seconds, and then closed up as they approached their first pit stops.
The German dived for the inside at the start of lap 18 and was briefly past Hamilton, only to run wide and see his team-mate chop back across his nose to reclaim the lead.
"Warn him that was not on," Rosberg said to his team over the radio.
He tried again the following lap, but again Hamilton held him off, this time by edging him wide as Rosberg attempted to go around the outside of Turn Four.
Hamilton stopped for fresh tyres the next time around, and Rosberg chose to adopt a different strategy when he made his own first stop two laps later, switching to the slower 'medium' tyre for the middle stint of the race.
Hamilton, who fitted another set of the 'soft' tyres, decided to save his 'mediums' until the final stint, and he set about building a lead.
Hamilton was 9.5secs in front by lap 40, when the safety car was triggered by a dangerous collision between the Sauber of Esteban Gutierrez and Lotus' Pastor Maldonado.
Gutierrez was turning through Turn One when Maldonado, who was coming out of the pits, smashed into the side of the Swiss car, sending it into a barrel-roll.
Maldonado was handed a 10-second stop-go penalty during the race. Stewards then gave the Venezuelan a further five-place grid penalty for the next race in China and added three points to his super-licence.
Media playback is not supported on this device
As the field prepared for the race to be restarted on lap 47, Mercedes co-team boss Paddy Lowe got on the radio to both drivers to warn them to "make sure you bring both cars home".
Rosberg appeared determined to reclaim the lead and tried several times to pass his team-mate into Turn One and through Turn Four, each time to be repelled by firm but fair defence.
Finally, with four laps to go, as the edge went off Rosberg's tyres, Hamilton began to build a margin and was able to secure his second victory within a week.
It closes his deficit to Rosberg in the championship to 11 points, following the Englishman's retirement from the opening race of the season in Australia where Rosberg won.
"Nico drove fantastically well throughout, very fair," said Hamilton. "He was very fast on the option tyres at the end. I was on a knife edge throughout but it was great fun."
"I strongly dislike finishing second to Lewis but on the other hand it was the most exciting race I have ever had in my whole career," said Rosberg. "Today was a day for the sport. I hope you all had a lot of fun.
"The team played it as fair as they possibly could today. Let us race flat out. I don't think you need any more evidence that we are here to race and there are no team orders."
The action was just as thrilling behind as Perez beat Ricciardo by just 0.4secs and, four seconds behind them, Hulkenberg held off a train of cars running nose-to-tail all the way down to Raikkonen in 10th.
It was a spectacular event on Bahrain's 10th anniversary as an F1 venue, and on the occasion of the first night race in the Gulf state. And it should lay to bed any criticisms that there is no racing in the new F1.
Bahrain Grand Prix results in full
2014 F1 coverage details


The government is spending more than £9m on sending a leaflet to every UK household setting out the case for remaining in the European Union.

The 14-page document, to be sent to 27 million homes, is designed to respond to public demand for more details about the EU referendum by setting out the facts behind the government's position.
Leave campaigners reacted with fury.
Boris Johnson said it was wrong to try to "stampede" voters while Nigel Farage said the document was "full of lies".
UKIP leader Mr Farage said the exercise was a "scam" and reinforced his view that the EU referendum on 23 June would be "defined by the battle of the people against the political elite".
But David Cameron tweeted that "key facts" outlined in the document explained why the government believed "we are stronger, safer and better off in the EU".
Royal Mail will start delivering the leaflets - entitled Why the government believes that voting to remain in the EU is the best decision for the UK - to households in England next week and in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland after the 5 May devolved elections.
A digital version will be advertised on social media and available on a new website.
The government says the mail drop will cost £9.3m, or about 34p per household.
The designated Leave campaign, and its Remain opponent, will be able to spend up to £7m each on advertising and promotion once the official campaign period starts next week. This includes £600,000 of public grants set aside for free mailshots and TV broadcasts.
A similar leaflet to that being issued was sent out by the government during the 2014 referendum on Scottish independence and in the 1975 referendum on Britain's membership of the European Community.
But in 1975 the leaflet contained a picture and a signed introduction by the then prime minister, Harold Wilson. The latest leaflet does not include any images of David Cameron.
Instead, the leaflet is plain and official-looking, containing pictures of workers, shoppers and families, and concentrating overwhelmingly on what the government sees as the economic case for staying in the EU.
It claims that "over three million UK jobs are linked to exports to the EU" and that "if the UK voted to leave the EU, the resulting economic shock would risk higher prices of some household goods".
Officials described the document as "a straightforward, sober representation of the government case", designed both to change voters' minds and encourage others to register to vote.
They said internal opinion polls suggested that 85% of people wanted the government to provide more information so they could make an informed decision on 23 June.
Environment Secretary Liz Truss said the leaflets would help voters do so. She also emphasised the government's view that EU membership "brings economic security, peace and stability".
The government said the leaflets had cost £458,500 to produce and £5.94m to print and deliver across the UK. An additional £2.89m had been spent on the accompanying website and "digital promotion".
But the move was met with thinly disguised anger by groups campaigning for EU exit.
"I think it is deeply disappointing that the government is going to spend taxpayers' money in a bid to distract the media headlines away from the allegations of offshore banks that have dogged the prime minister," Robert Oxley, a Vote Leave spokesman, said.
"Our money should not be used on propaganda, trying to buy votes. We already send £350m to Brussels each week. We should spend our money on our priorities like the NHS."
London Mayor Mr Johnson, one of the most senior Conservative politicians to back leaving the EU, said the move was a "crazy waste of money".
Both sides needed to be able to put across their arguments fairly to guarantee an "informed" debate, he said.
Conservative MP Bernard Jenkin, a prominent supporter of Vote Leave,  said it was "an outrageous abuse of taxpayers' money" which "flies in the face of the government's claim that they want a fair referendum".
"In this one act, the government will spend more on their Remain campaign than the official Leave group will be able to spend between now and polling day," he said.
Conservative MP Peter Bone, from Grassroots Out, said the move was a "major error of judgement" by Mr Cameron.
"The prime minister promised Parliament that no taxpayers' money would be spent promoting Remain or Leave," he said.
"What is being done is immoral, undemocratic and against what the government has promised. If this is not reversed it will seriously damage the prime minister's reputation."
Officials said it was entirely legitimate for the government to make its case and said there was no legal reason why it could not do so.
The decision to send the leaflet was agreed by the Cabinet sub-committee on the EU and was signed off by Cabinet Secretary Sir Jeremy Heywood.
Speaking in Parliament last June, Foreign Secretary Philip Hammond ruled out sending mailshots during the so-called "purdah period" - the last 28 days before the vote when any official government role in the campaign will be banned.
The government faced a backlash from Conservative MPs last autumn when they sought to relax the rules limiting ministerial activity in the immediate run-up to the poll, only backing down after losing a parliamentary vote.


The first Syrian refugees to arrive in Wales this month will settle in Torfaen, Ceredigion, Neath Port Talbot and Caerphilly, councils say.

About 50 people are due to arrive from refugee camps before Christmas - the first of about 1,000 coming to Wales over the next five years.
The UK government will meet the cost of housing and supporting the refugees.
The refugees will be housed in private rented accommodation and not in council properties in many areas.
The majority of asylum seekers and refugees who come to Wales settle in urban areas with existing minority populations - Cardiff, Newport, Swansea and Wrexham.
But all Welsh local authorities have agreed to help with the current national resettlement scheme after David Cameron said the UK will house up to 20,000 refugees over the next five years.
Torfaen council, which is among the first Welsh councils ready to take in refugees, said it was welcoming two families with a number of young children before Christmas, with another four families due in the new year.
A spokesman said all were identified as having been victims of torture and have been granted five years of full humanitarian protection.
The families are not economic migrants or asylum seekers and they will be able to live and work freely in the UK.
Councillor David Daniels added: "They are families having fled the chaos and trauma of war.
"Torfaen has a strong tradition of welcoming families and I am sure the Torfaen community understands their urgent plight."
Two families will also be given private rented homes in Caerphilly county, with two more likely in the new year and possibly more after that.
In Neath Port Talbot, five families will be given accommodation after arriving in December, half of the total number of families the council will take.
Between 10 and 12 people will also be settled in Aberystwyth, Ceredigion before Christmas.
Ellen ap Gwynn, who is chairman of the council's task and finish group, added: "These people are ordinary people from ordinary backgrounds, who have witnessed events that no-one should have to experience."
Around Wales, some councils have given details about how many refugees it will take, while others are still waiting for more information from the UK government.
Speaking last month, Communities Minister Lesley Griffiths confirmed about 50 Syrian refugees would be  welcomed to Wales before Christmas in four local authority areas.
She said all 22 councils were keen to welcome refugees although 18 were still preparing services for their arrival.
Ms Griffiths added the UK government had vowed that all refugees would be "thoroughly vetted" before arrival to ensure they were no security risk.


Paddy McNair scored twice as Sunderland beat Championship side QPR in the third round of the EFL Cup at Loftus Road.

The visitors fell behind on the hour mark when Brazil midfielder Sandro hooked in a half-volley.
Ex-Manchester United midfielder McNair levelled 10 minutes later, finishing off a one-two with Duncan Watmore.
McNair then tapped in the rebound after Matt Ingram parried Didier Ndong's strike to earn the Black Cats a trip to Southampton in the fourth round.
Both of Sunderland's wins this season have come in this competition, with new manager David Moyes yet to record a Premier League victory since taking over.
Dutch defender Patrick van Aanholt was one of six changes for Sunderland, playing the full game after he was left out of Sunday's 1-0 defeat at Tottenham after medical advice from heart specialists.
Sunderland manager David Moyes:
"We played some good stuff and I'm just glad we got through as it's always a tough game coming here.
"I thought we did some good things, especially in the second half, and I didn't think we deserved to go a goal down when we did.
"We just lacked the experienced forward players who maybe could have finished the game off earlier, but some of our play was quite good."
QPR boss Jimmy Floyd Hasselbaink:
"I don't like losing but if we are to lose to Premier League opposition, that was the way to do it, if you understand what I'm saying.
"If we are going to lose, it needs to be like this. With a gritty, hungry, honest and hardworking display.
"We showed that we are a good team tonight I thought. I'm proud of how we conducted ourselves. I take a lot of positives out of the game, and not so many negatives."
Match ends, Queens Park Rangers 1, Sunderland 2.
Second Half ends, Queens Park Rangers 1, Sunderland 2.
(Sunderland) wins a free kick in the defensive half.
Foul by Sebastian Polter (Queens Park Rangers).
Attempt blocked. Abdenasser El Khayati (Queens Park Rangers) right footed shot from the right side of the six yard box is blocked.
Attempt missed. Tjaronn Chery (Queens Park Rangers) right footed shot from outside the box misses to the left.
Corner,  Queens Park Rangers. Conceded by Patrick van Aanholt.
Corner,  Queens Park Rangers. Conceded by Papy Djilobodji.
Attempt blocked. Massimo Luongo (Queens Park Rangers) right footed shot from outside the box is blocked.
Foul by Didier Ndong (Sunderland).
Niko Hamalainen (Queens Park Rangers) wins a free kick on the right wing.
Substitution, Queens Park Rangers. Tjaronn Chery replaces Jordan Cousins.
Hand ball by Sebastian Polter (Queens Park Rangers).
Foul by Jan Kirchhoff (Sunderland).
Massimo Luongo (Queens Park Rangers) wins a free kick on the left wing.
Goal!  Queens Park Rangers 1, Sunderland 2. Paddy McNair (Sunderland) right footed shot from the centre of the box to the centre of the goal.
Substitution, Queens Park Rangers. Massimo Luongo replaces Conor Washington.
Attempt missed. Jan Kirchhoff (Sunderland) header from the centre of the box is close, but misses to the left.
Corner,  Sunderland. Conceded by Osman Kakay.
Corner,  Sunderland. Conceded by Steven Caulker.
Lee Cattermole (Sunderland) wins a free kick in the attacking half.
Foul by Conor Washington (Queens Park Rangers).
Substitution, Queens Park Rangers. Sebastian Polter replaces Idrissa Sylla.
Attempt missed. Paddy McNair (Sunderland) header from the centre of the box is just a bit too high.
Corner,  Sunderland. Conceded by Matt Ingram.
Attempt saved. Lee Cattermole (Sunderland) right footed shot from outside the box is saved in the bottom right corner.
Corner,  Queens Park Rangers. Conceded by Donald Love.
Goal!  Queens Park Rangers 1, Sunderland 1. Paddy McNair (Sunderland) right footed shot from the centre of the box to the centre of the goal.
Substitution, Sunderland. Lee Cattermole replaces Lynden Gooch.
Substitution, Sunderland. Donald Love replaces Jason Denayer.
Substitution, Sunderland. Josh Maja replaces Joel Asoro.
Foul by Idrissa Sylla (Queens Park Rangers).
Jan Kirchhoff (Sunderland) wins a free kick in the attacking half.
Attempt missed. Patrick van Aanholt (Sunderland) right footed shot from the centre of the box is close, but misses to the right.
Attempt blocked. Jan Kirchhoff (Sunderland) right footed shot from the centre of the box is blocked.
Attempt blocked. Duncan Watmore (Sunderland) left footed shot from the centre of the box is blocked.
Foul by Conor Washington (Queens Park Rangers).
Jason Denayer (Sunderland) wins a free kick in the attacking half.
Attempt missed. Didier Ndong (Sunderland) right footed shot from outside the box is close, but misses to the right.
Attempt saved. Abdenasser El Khayati (Queens Park Rangers) right footed shot from outside the box is saved in the centre of the goal.


Yeovil secured a first ever season in the Championship as they beat Brentford in a tense League One play-off final.

Paddy Madden gave the Glovers an early lead when he fired past keeper Simon Moore from outside the box.
Dan Burn's header from Jamie McAllister's corner made it 2-0 before half-time but Harlee Dean nodded home to reduce the deficit after the break.
The Glovers withstood heavy pressure to seal promotion in their 10th year as a Football League club.
"It is incredible that a team of Yeovil's size can get to the Championship. They stood firm and it is a magnificent achievement."
In his second spell as manager, Gary Johnson has now won promotion with the Somerset side for the third time, having overseen their promotion to the Football League in 2003.
Even before their Wembley triumph, this season had already brought them their highest ever league position, as they finished the regular League One term one place below Brentford in fourth.
The Bees, who succumbed to an injury-time goal against Doncaster on the last day to miss out on automatic promotion, will again feel extremely unfortunate after wasting a number of chances to get back on level terms with the Glovers.
It is becoming a familiar feeling too - this was their seventh failure out of seven in the play-offs.
Yeovil's arrival in the Championship - via only their second play-off campaign - is the more remarkable for having been achieved on one of the division's lowest playing budgets and with an average attendance of 4,071 - more than 2,000 lower than their Wembley opponents' home gate.
The Glovers were well and noisily supported at Wembley, however, and their fans soon had something to celebrate as Sam Foley's shot from outside the area was blocked by Logan and the ball fell to top scorer and former Carlisle striker Madden, who lifted it over Moore for his 23rd Yeovil goal this season.
Yeovil boss Gary Johnson lost a Championship play-off final at Wembley while Bristol City boss in the 2007-08 season
Brentford then began to dominate possession but failed to create clear opportunities, although Harry Forrester should have done better after breaking into the area. As it was, his looping cross-shot was easily gathered by the Glovers keeper and man of the match Marek Stech.
And the Bees were soon made to pay for their lack of clear chances when the resulting corner saw Yeovil double their lead, Burn heading McAllister's deep corner towards goal and Hayter swiping at the ball without making contact to fool keeper Moore and his defender Craig.
Brentford came close to reducing the deficit deep into first-half injury time when Marcello Trotta's header was saved by Stech and, having switched formation from 4-3-3 to 4-4-2, the west Londoners soon went close again when Dean headed Forrester's corner wide.
But the Bees centre-back found the net soon after as he found himself unmarked in the box and headed in from Adam Forshaw's corner to make it 2-1.
With the tension mounting there was a moment of light relief as Bees boss Uwe Rosler was accidentally struck in the face with the ball by his own right-back Shaleum Logan.
Brentford will extend their 20-year absence from the second tier, having failed to return since a one-season stint in 1992-93
Brentford continued to dominate as Clayton Donaldson headed Forrester's cross towards goal and, when that effort was saved by Stech, substitute Bradley Wright-Phillips was unable turn in the rebound.
Fellow replacement Sam Saunders made an instant impact by setting up Forshaw, whose low shot was blocked by the legs of Stech.
Yeovil had what appeared to be a reasonable claim for a penalty turned down when Jake Bidwell caught Kevin Dawson in the box and the Glovers midfielder was subsequently booked for venting his frustration at the referee.
Soon after, Foley fired wide from long range before Wright-Phillips went close at the other end with a shot on the turn.
Logan then flashed a shot wide and Dean headed off target as Yeovil survived a Brentford onslaught to record the greatest success in their side's history.
Full Time   The final whistle goes and the game is over.
Booking      Gavin Williams goes into the book for time wasting.
The referee blows for offside against Clayton Donaldson.  Marek Stech takes the direct free kick.
Jake Bidwell crosses the ball, clearance made by Luke  Ayling. Shot by Sam Saunders from just outside the area goes over the net.
A cross is delivered by Clayton Donaldson, Marek Stech makes a save. Outswinging corner taken by Sam Saunders, Harlee Dean has a headed effort at goal from deep inside the area missing to the left of the target.
Shaleum Logan has shot on goal from just outside the penalty box which goes wide of the right-hand upright.
Direct free kick taken by Vitalijs Maksimenko.
Substitution      Matthew Dolan comes on in place of James Hayter.
Clayton Donaldson concedes a free kick for a foul on Sam Foley.
Paul Hayes sends in a cross, Edward Upson manages to make a clearance. The ball is sent over by Sam Saunders, Bradley Wright-Phillips produces a header from the edge of the box and misses to the right of the goal.
Tom Adeyemi concedes a free kick for a foul on Sam Foley. Direct free kick taken by Marek Stech.
Centre by Sam Saunders.
Sam Saunders crosses the ball, clearance by Byron Webster.
Bradley Wright-Phillips takes a shot. Save made by Marek Stech.
Substitution      Paul Hayes on for Toumani Diagouraga.
Sam Foley has an effort at goal from outside the box which goes wide left of the target.
Shaleum Logan gives away a free kick for an unfair challenge on James Hayter. Marek Stech takes the free kick.
The ball is delivered by Sam Saunders, Dan Burn manages to make a clearance.
Substitution      James McAllister goes off and Vitalijs Maksimenko comes on.
Booking      Kevin Dawson goes into the referee's book for dissent.
Edward Upson fouled by Tom Adeyemi, the ref awards a free kick. James McAllister takes the direct free kick.
The ball is sent over by Toumani Diagouraga, save by Marek Stech.
The ball is sent over by Luke  Ayling, Shaleum Logan manages to make a clearance.
The ball is sent over by Shaleum Logan, Dan Burn makes a clearance.
Direct free kick taken by Sam Saunders.
Booking      Edward Upson receives a yellow card for unsporting behaviour.
Unfair challenge on Toumani Diagouraga by Edward Upson results in a free kick.
Adam Forshaw takes a shot. Save by Marek Stech.
Simon Moore takes the direct free kick.
Substitution      Sam Saunders on for Harry Forrester.
Inswinging corner taken left-footed by James McAllister from the right by-line, free kick awarded for an unfair challenge on Harry Forrester by Byron Webster.
The offside flag is raised against Bradley Wright-Phillips. Direct free kick taken by Marek Stech.
Adam Forshaw takes a short corner, Header by Clayton Donaldson from deep inside the penalty area misses to the left of the goal.
Kevin Dawson gives away a free kick for an unfair challenge on Jake Bidwell. Simon Moore restarts play with the free kick.
Simon Moore restarts play with the free kick.
Substitution      Bradley Wright-Phillips comes on in place of Marcello Trotta.
Free kick awarded for a foul by Paddy Madden on Tony Craig.
Free kick awarded for an unfair challenge on Luke  Ayling by Harry Forrester. Marek Stech takes the direct free kick.
Foul by Edward Upson on Tom Adeyemi, free kick awarded. Tony Craig takes the direct free kick.
Marcello Trotta gives away a free kick for an unfair challenge on Byron Webster. Marek Stech takes the direct free kick.
Clayton Donaldson delivers the ball.
The assist for the goal came from Adam Forshaw.
Goal!  - Harlee Dean -    Brentford 1 - 2 Yeovil        Harlee Dean grabs a headed goal from inside the penalty box. Brentford 1-2 Yeovil.
Outswinging corner taken left-footed by Adam Forshaw from the right by-line,
The ball is swung over by Luke  Ayling, clearance by Tony Craig.
Paddy Madden is ruled offside. Shaleum Logan takes the free kick.
Harry Forrester takes the inswinging corner, Headed effort from deep inside the penalty area by Harlee Dean misses to the right of the target.
Foul by Kevin Dawson on Harry Forrester, free kick awarded. Direct free kick taken by Jake Bidwell.
Toumani Diagouraga has an effort at goal from outside the box which goes wide right of the goal.
The referee gets the second half started.
Half Time    The referee calls an end to the first half.
Free kick awarded for a foul by Tony Craig on James Hayter. James McAllister produces a shot on goal direct from the free kick, Simon Moore makes a save.
Jake Bidwell crosses the ball, Marcello Trotta takes a shot. Marek Stech makes a comfortable save.
Joe Edwards sends in a cross.
The assist for the goal came from Edward Upson.
Goal!  - Dan Burn -    Brentford 0 - 2 Yeovil        Dan Burn finds the back of the net with a headed goal from inside the six-yard box. Brentford 0-2 Yeovil.
The ball is delivered by Sam Foley. Corner taken by Edward Upson,
Inswinging corner taken by James McAllister.
The ball is sent over by Jake Bidwell, Byron Webster manages to make a clearance.
Harry Forrester produces a cross, save by Marek Stech.
Luke  Ayling gives away a free kick for an unfair challenge on Jake Bidwell. Free kick crossed by Adam Forshaw, Marek Stech makes a comfortable save.
Shaleum Logan sends in a cross. Adam Forshaw takes a shot. Marek Stech makes a comfortable save.
Free kick awarded for a foul by Marcello Trotta on Byron Webster. James McAllister restarts play with the free kick.
Luke  Ayling fouled by Harry Forrester, the ref awards a free kick. Marek Stech restarts play with the free kick.
Inswinging corner taken right-footed by Tony Craig from the left by-line, Joe Edwards makes a clearance.
Foul by Paddy Madden on Harlee Dean, free kick awarded. Adam Forshaw takes the free kick.
The ball is crossed by Shaleum Logan, clearance by Luke  Ayling.
Free kick awarded for a foul by Tom Adeyemi on Joe Edwards. Edward Upson takes the free kick.
Corner taken by Harry Forrester, clearance made by Sam Foley.
Unfair challenge on Clayton Donaldson by Sam Foley results in a free kick. Free kick taken by Harry Forrester.
Jake Bidwell sends in a cross, clearance by Byron Webster.
Marcello Trotta fouled by Byron Webster, the ref awards a free kick. Harry Forrester crosses the ball in from the free kick, save by Marek Stech.
Free kick awarded for an unfair challenge on Luke  Ayling by Harry Forrester. Marek Stech takes the direct free kick.
Kevin Dawson gives away a free kick for an unfair challenge on Jake Bidwell. Simon Moore restarts play with the free kick.
The referee blows for offside. Free kick taken by Simon Moore.
Tom Adeyemi concedes a free kick for a foul on Joe Edwards. Free kick taken by Marek Stech.
The ball is sent over by Shaleum Logan.
Clayton Donaldson takes a shot. Save made by Marek Stech.
Shaleum Logan delivers the ball, Byron Webster manages to make a clearance.
Tom Adeyemi gives away a free kick for an unfair challenge on Edward Upson. Luke  Ayling takes the direct free kick.
Luke  Ayling crosses the ball, clearance by Harlee Dean.
Sam Foley provided the assist for the goal.
Goal!  - Paddy Madden -    Brentford 0 - 1 Yeovil        Paddy Madden fires in a goal from outside the penalty area to the top left corner of the goal. Brentford 0-1 Yeovil.
Edward Upson fouled by Tom Adeyemi, the ref awards a free kick. Marek Stech takes the free kick.
Luke  Ayling challenges Harry Forrester unfairly and gives away a free kick. Jake Bidwell takes the direct free kick.
The match has kicked off.
Live data and text provided by our data suppliers


There was no Brussels bust up, no leaders flouncing out, instead, the beginnings of an agreement and the biggest hint yet from the prime minister that you will get a vote on staying in or out of the EU next year.

He has long made a commitment to holding the referendum by the end of 2017. But even after difficult talks, here was what seemed a new confidence from David Cameron that he can achieve a deal and then a public vote next year.
He was careful to say the timetable might slip, acknowledging it is tight. But there is a new urgency.
Mr Cameron came to Brussels promising to inject political momentum into his attempt to change the rules of the EU. It is arguably the biggest project he has undertaken as prime minister, and indeed, his biggest political risk.
He leaves with a promise on paper at least, from the rest of the EU to try to find a deal on all of the four areas of European law that he wants to change - slimming down rules and regulation, slowing down political integration, cutting back on EU immigration and protecting Britain's interests as a country inside the EU but not in the euro.
Even this formal commitment to help has taken time and persuasion, and is a very long way from conclusion.
And the prospect of banning some benefits for EU workers in the UK for four years as David Cameron wants is tiny. For Eurosceptics in his own party his proposals are not enough to change their minds.
There are few clues of how final agreements will be reached, although opt outs of EU law rather than a whole new treaty are possible.
To keep the timetable he has publicly set today, getting to a yes in Brussels, then at home will occupy much of David Cameron's time from now on.
But his officials are somewhat relieved that they have got this far - confident that there is a path towards a deal, rather than a road to nowhere.


A doctor found to have thousands of indecent images of children as well as animal pornography has been jailed for more than two years.

Police found almost 850,000 images of children at Michael Kennedy's Peterborough home, alongside one image of sexual activity with a horse.
It was "the biggest investigation of its kind relating to indecent images seen in Cambridgeshire," officers said.
Kennedy, 52, admitted a number of offences at Cambridge Crown Court.
The GP, of St Pegus Road, who worked at Millfield Medical Centre in Peterborough, was suspended from practising by the General Medical Council after his arrest in March.
He later pleaded guilty to three counts of making indecent images of children, one count of possessing prohibited images of children and three counts of possessing extreme pornographic images.
Read more Cambridgeshire news stories
Most of the victims seen in the images, which were both still and moving, were between five and 10 years old.
Det Ch Insp Neil Sloan said: "Never in my time as a police officer have I seen such an extensive collection of such images; more than 800,000 individual images all stored, filed and categorised like a library."
He said while there was no evidence Kennedy had filmed any of the images himself, it was clear he had "an unhealthy interest in indecent images of children and extreme pornography".
Police also stressed there was no evidence to suggest Kennedy had abused his patients.
Kennedy's defence told the court her client was "appalled with himself".
He was jailed for two years and eight months, as well as being placed on the Sex Offenders' Register for life and being made the subject of a lifelong Sexual Harm Prevention Order.


The outlook for the UK's financial stability "has worsened" in the light of events in Greece, Bank of England governor Mark Carney has warned.

Risks in relation to Greece include a reduction in the risk appetite of businesses and a knock-on effect on households, Mr Carney said.
But the UK's direct financial exposure to Greece is "minimal", he said.
On Tuesday night, Greece became the first developed nation to fail to make a payment to the IMF.
The International Monetary Fund confirmed that Greece had failed to make a repayment equivalent to about â‚¬1.5bn (Â£1.1bn).
This week, Greece closed its banks and restricted cash withdrawals. On Sunday, the country is due to hold a snap referendum on the crisis.


Doctors have reacted with anger after being told an event with Jeremy Hunt was cancelled when it actually went ahead at a different venue.

Fareham Conservatives advertised a "drinks and canapÃ©s" evening with the health secretary that was moved after details started circulating online.
They said a smaller, members-only event was held instead because of "the very real threat of disturbance".
But doctors who bought tickets said they felt like they had been lied to.
Mr Hunt is engaged in a long-running industrial dispute with junior doctors who are fighting the imposition of new contracts.
The original event was advertised as being at the Lysses House Hotel, in High Street, Fareham, between 18:30 and 20:30 GMT on Friday, with tickets costing Â£15.
Conservative Association chairman Thomas Fyfe said: "The advertised event was cancelled on security grounds.
"A smaller private event for party members to meet Mr Hunt was held instead at another location.
"We regret the inconvenience caused to those who had bought tickets and were unable to attend, all of whom will be offered a full refund."
But Dr Kathryn Carey-Jones said the failure to tell non-Conservative ticket holders about the move was "dishonesty at its best".
She said: "I was angry, I was angry at the dishonesty in the way they let me know about this."
GP Emma Nash, who also bought a ticket, said on Twitter she also felt lied to by the "selective communication" used by the organisers.


By the end of this decade, four out of every 10 of the world's young graduates are going to come from just two countries - China and India.

The projection from the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) shows a far-reaching shift in the balance of graduate numbers, with the rising Asian economies accelerating ahead of the United States and western Europe.
The forecasts for the shape of the "global talent pool" in 2020 show China as rapidly expanding its graduate numbers - set to account for 29% of the world's graduates aged between 25 and 34.
The biggest faller is going to be the United States - down to 11% - and for the first time pushed into third place, behind India.
The US and the countries of the European Union combined are expected to account for little more than a quarter of young graduates.
Russia is also set to decline - its share of the world's graduates almost falling by half since the beginning of the century.
Indonesia, according to the OECD's projections, will rise into fifth place.
Is this an end-of-empire moment?
Higher education has become the mirror and magnifier of economic performance - and in the post-World-War-II era, universities in the US, western Europe, Japan and Russia have dominated.
The US in particular has been the university superpower - in wealth, influence and until recently in raw numbers.
Up until 2000, the US still had a share of young graduates similar to China. And Japan had as big a proportion of young graduates as India.
Now China and India are the biggest players.
Their rise in graduate numbers reflects their changing ambitions - wanting to compete against advanced economies for high-skill, high-income employment.
Instead of offering low-cost manufacture, they are targeting the hi-tech professional jobs that have become the preserve of the Westernised middle classes.
As the OECD figures show, this is not simply a case of countries such as China expanding while others stand still.
Across the industrialised world, graduate numbers are increasing - just not as quickly as China, where they have risen fivefold in a decade.
The OECD notes that by 2020, China's young graduate population will be about the same as the total US population between the ages of 25 and 64.
This changing world map will see Brazil having a bigger share of graduates than Germany, Turkey more than Spain, Indonesia three times more than France.
The UK is bucking the trend, projected to increase its share from 3% in 2010 to 4% in 2020.
This push for more graduates has a clear economic purpose, says the OECD's analysis.
Shifting from "mass production to knowledge economy occupations" means improved employment rates and earnings - so there are "strong incentives" for countries to expand higher education.
But will there be enough graduate jobs to go round?
The OECD has tried to analyse this by looking at one aspect of the jobs market - science and technology-related occupations.
These jobs have grown rapidly - and the report suggests it is an example of how expanding higher education can generate new types of employment.
These science and technology jobs - for professionals and technicians - account for about four in every 10 jobs in some Scandinavian and northern European countries, the OECD suggests.
In contrast - and showing more of the old order - these technology jobs are only a small fraction of the workforce in China and India.
The OECD concludes that there are substantial economic benefits from investing in higher education - creating new jobs for the better-educated as unskilled manufacturing jobs disappear.
The OECD forecast reveals the pace of growth in graduate numbers. But it does not show the quality or how this expansion will translate into economic impact.
There are other ways of mapping the changing distribution of knowledge.
A team at the University of Oxford's Internet Institute has produced a set of maps showing the "geography of the world's knowledge".
This measures how populations are consuming and producing information in the online world - mapping the level of internet use, the amount of user-generated material in Google, concentrations of academic activity and the geographical focus of Wikipedia articles.
And in contrast to the rise of the Asian economies, this tells a story of continuing Western cultural dominance.
"In raw numbers of undergraduates and PhDs, the Asian economies are racing ahead," says Prof Viktor Mayer-Schonberger, from the Oxford Internet Institute.
"But what's interesting is how the West persists in its positions of strength - because the West controls the institutions.
"There are more students in China than ever before - but they still use Western mechanisms to publish results, they accept the filters," says Prof Mayer-Schonberger.
"The big question will be whether the Chinese researchers can be as insightful as their Western counterparts - we don't know yet."
The maps also reveal how much Africa and South America are losing out in this new scramble for digital power.
Prof Mayer-Schonberger said he was "completely shocked" at the extent of the imbalance.
Another feature of the Oxford study is to show how research bases and their spin-out economic activity are clustered into relatively small areas.
In the US, says Prof Mayer-Schonberger, there is hugely disproportionate investment around Silicon Valley and the Boston area, with large tracts of "wasteland" between.
"Each era has its own distinct geography. In the information age, it's not dependent on roads or waterways, but on bases of knowledge.
"This is a new kind of industrial map. Instead of coal and steel it will be about universities and innovation."


A man has been charged with murder after concert pianist Natalia Strelchenko was found with fatal injuries at a house in Manchester.

John Martin, 47, is accused of killing the 38-year-old mother, who died after reports of an assault at a property in Culcheth Lane, Newton Heath, on Sunday.
Mr Martin, of Culcheth Lane, has also been charged with the attempted murder of a boy under the age of 17.
He is due to appear at Manchester Magistrates' Court on Wednesday.
Ms Strelchenko died in hospital on Sunday after paramedics were unable to revive her.
In a statement, her family described her as "talented" and "beautiful", they added: "She will be greatly missed."
According to her website, Ms Strelchenko, who was of Russian origin, made her debut aged 12 with the St Petersburg Symphony Orchestra.
Also known as Natalia Strelle, she had performed across Europe, Japan and at New York's prestigious Carnegie Hall.
She was educated at St Petersburg State Conservatory and the Norwegian Academy of Music.


Two World War Two Lancasters have flown together for the first time in 50 years.

The Battle of Britain Memorial Flight's aircraft was joined by the only other airworthy example, which had crossed the Atlantic to Lincolnshire.
The pair was due to pass over Lincoln cathedral last Friday but the flight was postponed due to bad weather.
A series of practice flights near RAF Coningsby will now be performed ahead of a month of events across the UK.
Following a day of maintenance checks after its 3,700-mile journey, the Canadian Lancaster, known as Vera, took off alone on Tuesday evening.
Once this flight was completed successfully, clearance was given for both to fly together.
Large crowds gathered outside the airbase for the double take-off, which took place just after 13:00 BST.
The first aircraft to take to the skies was one of the Battle of Britain Memorial Flight's Spitfires, it was then joined first by the British Lancaster, and finally Vera.
They were in the air for just under an hour but will fly a number of further training sessions.
Stuart Reid, former Battle of Britain Memorial Flight pilot and aviation historian, said: "This will take some getting used to for the pilots. These are big, heavy aircraft and flying together is hard work.
"The first Lancaster will have a relatively straightforward job but the one behind will have to keep in line, watch the other, handle the buffeting from the slipstream.
"Hats off to them, especially in this wind."
Stan Instone, who was a Lancaster flight engineer in 419 Squadron, was among the crowd.
"The hairs on the back of my neck have stood up - that's what the sound of those Lancasters does to me.
"I wouldn't have believed it was possible. There has been talk about getting them together for years and now, it has come true," he said.
The first public display is scheduled to be at Eastbourne International Air Show on Thursday.


MSPs have voted to set a Scottish rate of income tax for the first time, opting to keep rates at current levels.

Holyrood has been given new powers over the income tax rate, with Labour and the Liberal Democrats calling for a 1p increase to raise extra funds.
However, finance secretary John Swinney insisted the rate should stay the same.
After a heated Holyrood debate on the topic, MSPs voted by 74 to 35 to accept the government's plan to maintain the income tax at current levels.
Opposition parties said an increase could create funds to protect services, but Mr Swinney said it would punish taxpayers on low incomes.
Mr Swinney said it was a "historic" day for Holyrood, with a Scottish rate resolution being proposed for the first time.
The deputy first minister defended maintaining the rate at current levels following attacks from opposition members, saying his priority was to protect low-earning households.
He said Labour's 1p tax rise would "punish" people on low incomes, saying the party did not have credible plans. He said: "Labour is targeting working people busting a gut to make ends meet; this government will not punish those individuals."
Jackie Baillie, leading Labour's contribution, said the SNP was "voting with the Tories to continue the cuts".
She said members should "reject the do-nothing proposal", arguing that increasing the income tax by 1p would raise a nine-figure sum to protect local services.
Ms Baillie said there had been "extraordinary claims" from the SNP, saying: "these are cuts started at Westminster and continued by the SNP."
She said: "I call on members to reject hundreds of millions of pounds of cuts and choose to invest in our children and invest in the future prosperity of our country."
For the Conservatives, Gavin Brown claimed there was a "taxpayers alliance" between his party and the SNP, describing the governing party as a "fiscal conservative party".
He said: "We don't think hardworking people in Scotland should be paying more in tax than people in the rest of the UK."
He said it would "send out entirely the wrong message" to raise taxes at the first opportunity with new powers.
Willie Rennie said the Scottish government had failed to live up to "this truly historic day", saying that in the face of cuts "the SNP do not one single thing, they don't take any opportunity to change the climate at all".
He said: "Their whole existence they've been living for this day, and what do they do? Absolutely nothing. How disappointing and despondent is that?"
He said the Liberal Democrat policy of adding 1p to taxes would be "progressive" and would have resulted in a boost to education spending.
"We should be celebrating today that we can undo the damage, but the SNP sit and do absolutely nothing."
Scottish Greens co-convener Patrick Harvie called for raising revenue at a local level to protect public services.
He advocated a "radical and local plan" to raise revenue by unfreezing the council tax.
After an often fractious debate, members voted to support the government's proposals by 74 to 35.


The 2015 Women's World Cup is under way and concludes with the final on Sunday, 5 July in Vancouver.

Every match will be shown live on the BBC, including the final between USA and Japan, with coverage starting on BBC Two at 23:30 BST on Sunday.
You can get goal alerts for every team using the BBC Sport app - find out more here.
All times BST. Schedule is subject to change and new programmes will appear once confirmed.
MONDAY, 6 JULY
USA v Japan, 00:00 kick-off, BBC Two (coverage starts 23:30 BST on 5 July), BBC Radio 5 live sports extra and BBC Sport website
You can view all our TV broadcasts as well as listen to our radio sports programming on the BBC iPlayer.
Media playback is not supported on this device
The BBC Sport website is available via desktop, mobile, tablet and app, giving fast and easy access to the live stream, text commentaries, news, reports, schedules, videos, as well as highlights of the day's action. The BBC Sport app is available free for Apple and Android devices.
Fixtures and start times are subject to change. The BBC is not responsible for any changes that may be made.
National and regional variations have been included in this list where possible, but please check your local listings for more detailed information.


Hurricane Irene has caused flights from the UK to be cancelled after hitting the east coast of the US.

The storm brought winds of more than 85mph (140km/h) to North Carolina and a quarter of a million people have been told to evacuate New York city.
British Airways has cancelled all its flights between London and New York for the rest of Saturday and all of Sunday.
The Foreign Office has advised Britons caught up in the hurricane to follow the advice of the local authorities.
British nationals should leave the area if advised, it added.
British Airways said it was keeping the progress of Hurricane Irene under "constant review".
A spokeswoman said: "Due to the predicted impact of the storm, we have taken the decision to cancel a significant number of services to the eastern seaboard.
"Flights to and from New York JFK and Newark will be particularly badly affected after the local authorities made a decision to completely close the airports for much of the weekend."
A statement on the BA website said: "As Hurricane Irene moves towards the east coast of the USA we are starting to cancel flights to and from a number of US cities.
"Please check the status of your flight before leaving for the airport."
BA axed flights to the Bahamas earlier this week as a result of the hurricane.
Virgin Atlantic has cancelled flights to and from New York as well as some Boston services over the weekend.
The airline warned that some people might have to wait more than three to four days to return home from the US.
"We are focusing all our energy on a recovery plan to bring people back home. Because flights are already very full it will be a little while before everybody is accommodated," it said.
The Foreign Office said travellers could monitor the progress of the hurricane on the US National Hurricane Center website, the Met Office's StormTracker, and local and international weather reports.
The overall level of travel advice to the US had not changed and there were no restrictions in place, it added.
The Association of British Travel Agents (Abta) said up to 10,000 British holidaymakers could currently be in New York.
New York was the single most popular long-haul destination in the world for Britons, the organisation said.
An Abta spokesman said: "If anyone can't get back on their original flight and they're booked with a European airline, the airline will make sure they're looked after with nights in hotels and day-to-day expenses so people won't be out of pocket.
"People on package tours will be in the same position."
Irish airline Aer Lingus said all flights scheduled to operate between the Republic of Ireland and New York and Boston on Sunday had been cancelled.
The carrier said passengers, who are being kept informed by text and email, could change their travel dates on its website.
In total, more than two million people in the US have been ordered to leave their homes ahead of the massive category one storm.
US Homeland Security Secretary Janet Napolitano warned that Irene remained a "large and dangerous" storm.
A first death caused by the hurricane has been reported in North Carolina.
States of emergency have been declared in North Carolina, Maryland, Virginia, Delaware, New Jersey, New York and Connecticut.


Justin Gatlin beat Olympic champion Usain Bolt by one-hundredth of a second to record a surprise 100m win in Rome.

Media playback is not supported on this device
Bolt, 26, was fastest out of the blocks at the Diamond League meeting but American Gatlin, 31, powered past the Jamaican to win in 9.94 seconds.
"I need two months to get ready so I am not worried," Bolt told BBC Sport.
Britain's Phillips Idowu, in his first major meet since his early exit from the London 2012 Olympics, finished seventh in the triple jump with 16.44m.
The 34-year-old Briton produced the leap in the first round but failed his next two jumps and then passed on his final three to bow out of the competition, which was won by America's Olympic and world champion Christian Taylor, 22, with 17.08m.
"Bolt just wasn't very good. He had a very good start and the quickest reaction time, but there was nothing there.
"He was blowing hard to run under 10 seconds and normally that's a stroll for him.
"He won't like being beaten by Gatlin. Gatlin is a controversial figure and a lot of people don't think he should be competing, but he is, and he's looking good for the World Championships.
"But don't write off Bolt - he  always raises his game at the major championships."
Gatlin, however, looked in fine form as he maintained his unbeaten start to the season over 100m.
The 2004 Olympic champion, who went on to serve a four-year doping ban, recorded his third Diamond League success after victories in Doha and Eugene by the narrowest of margins.
Bolt had suffered a hamstring injury last month which hampered him in his opening race of the season in the Cayman Islands, where he could only manage a time of 10.09 seconds.
And although the six-time Olympic gold medallist, who was making his first appearance in the Diamond League this season, jumped well out of the blocks, he was blowing hard by halfway as Gatlin began to impose himself on the race.
However, the American had to dip his head on the line to beat the world record holder, with France's Jimmy Vicaut third in 10.02 seconds.
It was Bolt's first major international loss since his false-start disqualification at the 2011 World Championships in South Korea.
Bolt came second to Yohan Blake in the 100m and 200m at the Jamaican Olympic trials last July but went on to London 2012 success in both events. He was also beaten by Tyson Gay in August 2010 in Stockholm.
Bolt, who ran a season's best 9.95, admitted: "I got the perfect start that I wanted, then about five steps in I stumbled a bit and that kind of threw my game off.
"My legs didn't feel like my legs coming into the straight. I guess I need to do more strength work. I think I just need time to get it back together but the fact I got a good start threw me off. At least I got under 10 seconds.
"It is always a good thing to lose. You can figure how to step it up. I knew I wasn't in great shape but I'm not worried. It takes time to get back into shape and I didn't expect much from this race."
His next outing will be over 200m in next Thursday's Diamond League meeting in Oslo as he builds up to the World Championships in Moscow from 10-18 August, where he will be defending his title over the longer sprint distance.
Gatlin still believes Bolt will be the man to beat at the Worlds.
"It's an honour to be able to race him and compete against him these last couple of years - he's an inspiration for the sport," he said.
"He's brought so much to the sport that wasn't there before. He's a legend - he's done great things. I just want to go out there and fight to the end. I'm working on my race strategy and trying to stay healthy. I'm just trying to get my start back and make sure that the middle of my race is good."
There was another surprise in Thursday's women's 200m where Olympic champion Allyson Felix was well beaten into second by Ivory Coast sprinter Murielle Ahoure.
American Felix, 27, was trailing 25-year-old Ahoure coming off the bend and was unable to catch the Ivorian who ran a national record of 22.36 seconds.
Britain's Shara Proctor, 24, finished third in a competitive women's long jump, just eight centimetres behind London 2012 champion Brittney Reese, 26, of the United States, with fellow American Janay DeLoach Soukup, 27, splitting the pair.
In the 1500m, Hannah England, 26, sprinted clear of the bunch to claim fourth in a time of four minutes, 03.91 seconds, behind Sweden's Abeba Aregawi, 22, who won in 4:00.23, followed by Ethiopia's Genzebe Dibaba, 22, and America's Jennifer Simpson, 26.
And fellow Briton Dai Greene, the 2011 400m hurdles world champion, was fifth in his first race of the season.
Greene, 27, was left trailing by the fast-starting Johnny Dutch and Javier Culson and was unable to catch the duo as they went clear in the finishing straight.
American Dutch, 24, held on to win in 48.31 seconds with Puerto Rico's Culson, 28, second and Senegal's 26-year-old Mamadou Hanne third - Greene was fifth in 48.81.


A rugby union player who died after collapsing on the pitch during a match has been commemorated by his club.

Savanaca Kokoibulileka, known as Tu, collapsed while playing for Rutland-based club Oakham RFC in a game against West Bridgford on 24 September.
The 38-year-old Fijian had just scored a try when he collapsed. He died later in hospital.
A minute's silence was observed before Oakham's match against Stamford on Saturday afternoon.
Steve Knight, Oakham's membership secretary, said he had been a great role model to the younger players.
He told BBC Radio Leicester: "It happened right in front of the whole crowd and players on the pitch.
"It came completely out of the blue, Tu had just scored a try, came back to take the restart and he collapsed.
"He was a very jovial friendly chap, always smiling and always laughing.
"He was a great inspiration particularly to the younger players, they looked up to him and respected him."
A Fijian farewell is due to be sung by the club's choir following the game.
Mr Kokoibulileka was a former British soldier and was married with four children, according to the Stamford Mercury.
His cause of death has not yet been revealed.
About £10,000 has been raised so far for Mr Kokoibulileka's family following his death.
David Smiter, who started the Just Giving page, said he was "one of the greatest men I have ever known".


Ten-man Portugal struggled without captain Cristiano Ronaldo as they fell to a surprise defeat in a friendly at home to the Cape Verde Islands.

Portugal are top of their qualifying group for Euro 2016 but rested Ronaldo against the African side, who are ranked 38th in the world.
Odair Fortes put Cape Verde ahead before Admilson Gege doubled their lead after the break.
The hosts also had defender Andre Pinto sent off after an hour.
Cape Verde - eliminated at the group stage of this year's Africa Cup of Nations - are sandwiched between Wales and Scotland in Fifa's world rankings.
The Islands are situated in the Atlantic Ocean, roughly 400 miles west of Senegal in west Africa.
Match ends, Portugal 0, Cape Verde Islands 2.
Second Half ends, Portugal 0, Cape Verde Islands 2.
Foul by André Almeida (Portugal).
Babanco (Cape Verde Islands) wins a free kick in the attacking half.
Attempt missed. Ukra (Portugal) right footed shot from outside the box is close, but misses to the left. Assisted by André Almeida.
Eder (Portugal) wins a free kick on the left wing.
Foul by Jeffry Fortes (Cape Verde Islands).
Vieirinha (Portugal) wins a free kick in the defensive half.
Foul by Nuno Rocha (Cape Verde Islands).
Vitorino Antunes (Portugal) wins a free kick in the defensive half.
Foul by Rodrigues (Cape Verde Islands).
André André (Portugal) wins a free kick in the defensive half.
Foul by Ricardo (Cape Verde Islands).
Corner,  Portugal. Conceded by Jeffry Fortes.
Attempt missed. Vieirinha (Portugal) right footed shot from the right side of the box misses to the left. Assisted by Danilo Pereira with a headed pass following a corner.
Corner,  Portugal. Conceded by Jeffry Fortes.
Ukra (Portugal) wins a free kick on the left wing.
Foul by Jeffry Fortes (Cape Verde Islands).
Attempt missed. André André (Portugal) header from the centre of the box misses to the left. Assisted by Vitorino Antunes with a cross.
Substitution, Cape Verde Islands. Ricardo replaces Júlio Tavares.
Substitution, Cape Verde Islands. Ryan Mendes replaces Héldon.
Substitution, Cape Verde Islands. Rodrigues replaces Odaïr Fortes.
Substitution, Portugal. André Almeida replaces André Gomes.
André Gomes (Portugal) wins a free kick in the attacking half.
Foul by Sérgio Semedo (Cape Verde Islands).
Vitorino Antunes (Portugal) wins a free kick in the defensive half.
Foul by Babanco (Cape Verde Islands).
Substitution, Cape Verde Islands. Calú replaces Toni Varela.
Foul by André André (Portugal).
Nuno Rocha (Cape Verde Islands) wins a free kick in the defensive half.
Corner,  Portugal. Conceded by Steven Fortes.
Ukra (Portugal) wins a free kick on the left wing.
Foul by Babanco (Cape Verde Islands).
Sérgio Semedo (Cape Verde Islands) is shown the yellow card.
Ukra (Portugal) wins a free kick in the defensive half.
Foul by Sérgio Semedo (Cape Verde Islands).
Foul by André André (Portugal).
Héldon (Cape Verde Islands) wins a free kick in the defensive half.
Substitution, Portugal. Pizzi replaces Cédric Soares.
Substitution, Portugal. André André replaces Adrien Silva.


A man with learning difficulties died on a day trip to a reservoir after going for a walk with a carer, an inquest has heard.

Majid Akhtar, 28, from Nottingham, was on an activity day from Springwood Day Centre in Mapperley.
Nottingham Coroners' Court heard Mr Akhtar had gone for a walk around the perimeter path of Kings Mill Reservoir in Nottinghamshire.
He was found later by passers-by and attempts were made to resuscitate him.
Opening the inquest, assistant coroner Andrew McNamara said the family had been waiting an "awfully long time" to find out the circumstances of Mr Akhtar's death.
A jury of eight men and three women were told Mr Akhtar was taking part in water sports with other people at the centre when he died in September 2012.
He had joined in with the activities in the morning, but it was suggested he did not want to go back on the water in the afternoon as he had taken his buoyancy aid off.
Mr McNamara said: "He set off with a care worker... around the perimeter path of the reservoir.
"He travelled about three-quarters of the way around... and at some point, unfortunately, he fell out of view and he was then subsequently found by two people who were walking their dog at the reservoir."
Paramedics were called to the scene and attempts were made to revive him but Mr Akhtar was pronounced dead at King's Mill Hospital, Sutton in Ashfield.
Earlier on Thursday jurors were taken on a visit to the reservoir.
Majid Akhtar's father Aktar Hussain later told the inquest how his son needed basic care and help with things such as getting dressed and cooking.
However, speaking through a translator, he said: "He loved going out and he loved swimming. He could swim without an aid."
The inquest is expected to last two weeks.


Engineers from Imperial College London have built autonomous "flying 3D printer" drones, which could protect people from nuclear waste.

The drones can "print" a sticky foam on dangerous objects before attaching themselves and lifting the hazard away.
The engineers hope that the drones will one day be capable of printing nests in treetops to enable them to rest and recharge before continuing.
But one roboticist is unconvinced about the device's 3D-printing capabilities.
Dr Mirko Kovac, director of the aerial robotics laboratory at Imperial College London, has been working on the project with a small team.
In a video demonstration, a quadcopter (a drone with four rotors) can be seen printing a sticky foam substance onto a small block, before flying away.
A hexacopter (which has six rotors) then takes the quadcopter's place, landing on the sprayed object and waiting for the foam to set.
Then the hexacopter flies off, with the foreign object attached to its underbelly.
The researchers hope this process will be particularly useful for removing hazardous materials, such as nuclear waste.
According to the New Scientist, the quadcopter acts almost entirely autonomously and is guided by GPS. The foam is said to be made of polyurethane.
The project's abstract states that potential applications could include "ad-hoc construction of first response structures in search-and-rescue scenarios," as well as "printing structures to bridge gaps in discontinuous terrain".
Thomas J Creedy, a PhD student working on the project at Imperial College London, said in a statement: "This is an exciting first step in the lab's development of co-operative robotic systems for building structures inspired by the natural world."
The robots are said to be inspired by swiftlets - birds that construct nests using their saliva.
Noel Sharkey, Emeritus Professor of Artificial Intelligence and Robotics at the University of Sheffield, told the BBC he was not impressed with the 3D-printing capabilities but had high hopes for its future potential.
Having seen the video presentation, Prof Sharkey said: "This could hardly be called 3D printing, although it uses some of the components.
"However, the potential game changer in this application is their notion of using it to repair bridges and other construction works from the air."
On 24 June, 3D printing firm Deezmaker and aerial photography company Velocity Pigeon teamed up to create a less advanced flying 3D printer, which they claimed was a "world first".
Dr Kovac's drones will be demonstrated at the Imperial Festival in London on 9 and 10 May.


Documentary Side by Side looks at the history of film-making and whether the advent of digital technology spells the end of celluloid.

"The documentary for me started with the questions: 'Is this the end of film? Is digital going to replace it? What are we losing if that happens and what are we gaining?,'" says Keanu Reeves.
The actor serves as producer, narrator and interviewer on Side by Side, in which he sets out to examine cinema's transition from film to digital formats.
It seems a niche subject, but Reeves and director Chris Kenneally say they were conscious about making the film for a mainstream audience.
"We wanted to take something that was quite specialised and share enough information so people could understand what we'd be speaking about," Reeves says.
But does the average cinema-goer care or notice what format the film they're watching is in?
"If you're not an aficionado, probably not, as long as it was working," admits Reeves.
"If you go and expect to see a Hollywood studio movie and it looked terrible you'd go like, 'what is that?' So I think it could impact in that sense.
"But a perfect film print projected is something that is remarkable and unique."
Side By Side makes no assumptions that audiences will know the technical aspects of filmmaking, so spends some time explaining how cameras work, the photochemical process of developing film and how the introduction of digital cameras has led to the progression of editing and special effects.
And helping to explain is a cast that reads like a Who's Who of cinema.
Directors Martin Scorsese, Christopher Nolan, David Fincher, David Lynch, James Cameron, Danny Boyle, George Lucas and cinematographers Wally Pfister (Inception, The Dark Knight) and Roger Deakins (Skyfall, True Grit) are all present.
Female filmmakers are represented by the likes of legendary editor Anne Coates, who worked on movies like Lawrence of Arabia and The Elephant Man and Lena Dunham, one of Hollywood's hottest talents thanks to her TV show Girls.
Reeves conducted a large share of the interviews himself, which not only helped the filmmakers gain such unprecedented access but also made for a series of relaxed, open conversations.
"I can't say it didn't help that I've been in the industry for however many years - I was a known quantity in that sense," he says.
It took around 18 months to round up and interview all the film-makers. Luckily, a large number of contributors attended an annual cinematography festival in Poland.
However others weren't so easy to get. Directors such as Steven Spielberg and Quentin Tarantino are notably absent.
"There were people who weren't available or who didn't want to speak," he says. "We got turned down a few times which sucked."
Although mainstream Hollywood films have been shot digitally for about the last 12 years, the first digital film to win an Oscar for best cinematography was Slumdog Millionaire in 2009.
Cinematography Oscars followed for Avatar in 2010 and Hugo in 2011 - also shot digitally.
Some see this as a shift in the attitude towards digital film, which had previously been considered inferior in quality.
Filming on celluloid is an expensive and time consuming process. Reels of film that each contain about 10 minutes of footage are developed overnight, creating "dailies". Viewing them is the first chance a director will get to see the product of his previous day's work.
It is only then they discover if they have the right shots or if they have to go back and re-shoot.
The advent of video cameras showed not only that film-making could be done at a fraction of the cost, but that you could see the results immediately. It also enabled anyone to effectively become a film-maker.
The invention of low price digital cameras further democratised the film-making process.
However, advocates for celluloid include Inception director Christopher Nolan and cinematographer Wally Pfister, who maintain digital images will never have the depth or clarity of film, which they insist on using.
On the other side, the likes of George Lucas, James Cameron and David Lynch profess their love for digital and swear they'll never go back.
Another issue addressed in the documentary is digital film archiving and preservation - where the introduction of new formats every couple of years is proving to be problematic.
Indeed, Se7en director David Fincher says he has videos from the early days of his career in unplayable formats, as the hardware no longer exists.
As a result, when he finishes a film, he now stores the relevant player alongside the rushes in his archive, to ensure he is able to watch them back at a later date.
And even with modern technology, hard drives can fail, leading to the loss of digital content.
It is something Reeves admits he had not considered. "I had no idea about the situation we're in right now where there is no standardised means of archiving digital information."
"I didn't know anything about how it could all just go away - it was a bit jaw-dropping."
The irony is that celluloid is the only format that has stood the test of time over the past 100 years and will continue to do so as long as there are projectors to play them on.
Throughout Side by Side, Reeves maintains his impartiality but with filming complete, he is able to share his thoughts.
"Going into the film I was definitely biased to 'what are we losing?'. Film was being held up as the gold standard and digital was this idea of replacing [it]," he says.
"But what I've come to learn is that it's not necessarily replacing it - but that it's something else. And if it is that, then film has a better chance.
"I'm still confident that it's going to hang around."
Side By Side is out in cinemas from Friday, 15 February through Axiom Films.


Scotland's new package of powers may not be workable and could require an entirely new method of funding devolved governments, according to economists.

The Institute for Fiscal Studies (IFS) said it was not possible to guarantee the powers would not adversely impact on Scottish or UK budgets.
It also said the Barnett formula that calculates Scotland's share of UK spending should be reformed.
This would defy a key recommendation of the Smith Commission.
But in a joint paper, co-written by the University of Stirling and the Centre on Constitutional Change, the IFS said different ways of calculating the block grant Holyrood receives from Westminster, after the new powers contained in the Scotland Bill are devolved, could mean differences of more than Â£1bn a year to Scotland's budget.
First Minister Nicola Sturgeon has said she will block the bill, which will hand new powers over areas such as income tax and VAT, unless it comes with an appropriate funding formula that is "fair for Scotland".
Her stance has been backed by Lord Smith of Kelvin, who chaired cross-party devolution talks after the independence referendum.
The House of Lords economic affairs committee has also argued the process for determining the fiscal framework is flawed and that its design principles may not be workable.
Talks between the Scottish and UK governments over the fiscal framework are continuing, with both sides having said they are hopeful an agreement can be reached.
The IFS said that the precise way in which the remaining block grants are calculated and indexed over time could mean differences of more than Â£1bn a year in the Scottish government's budget in the space of a decade or so.
If an unreformed Barnett formula remained in place it would be impossible to design a system that satisfied the Smith Commission's principle that there should be "no detriment as a result of the decision to devolve a power" while also fully achieving the "taxpayer fairness" principle, the IFS said.
David Bell, professor of economics at Stirling University and co-author of the report, said: "The options available for calculating the block grant adjustments and other elements of the fiscal framework will have major effects on the Scottish government's budget and the fiscal risks and incentives it faces.
"These issues should be part of the public and parliamentary debate, as much as the tax and welfare powers set out in the Scotland Bill itself have been."
David Phillips, a senior research economist at the IFS and co-author, said: "It may now be time for a more fundamental reassessment of how the devolved governments are financed: including whether the Barnett formula should be reformed.
"Reform of Barnett may remove some of the conflicts between the Smith Commission's principles that we have identified.
"The Smith Commission parked these issues to one side by committing to the current Barnett formula. Making the UK's fiscal framework sustainable for the long term may require reopening the debate."


Defending champion Phil Taylor has been drawn in the same group as PDC world champion Michael van Gerwen for September's Champions League of Darts.

Media playback is not supported on this device
Taylor, who beat world number one Van Gerwen 11-5 in the final of the inaugural event in Cardiff in 2016, won a 16th World Matchplay title on Sunday.
The pair will be alongside Adrian Lewis and Raymond van Barneveld in Group A.
Group B consists of Gary Anderson, Peter Wright, Dave Chisnall and Austria's Mensur Suljovic.
The eight-man field will compete for a first prize of £100,000 on 16-17 September, with all sessions of the tournament being broadcast live by the BBC.
Taylor, 56, rose to fourth in the world rankings with his World Matchplay victory, in what was his final appearance in Blackpool before his planned retirement after the 2018 World Championship.


A 71-year-old man has died after he was hit by a car while crossing a road in Troon, South Ayrshire.

The man was struck by a southbound silver Land Rover Freelander on Bentinck Drive, at its junction with Yorke Road, at about 21:10 on Sunday.
He was taken by ambulance to Ayr Hospital where he later died. The 67-year old female driver was not injured.
Police said inquiries into the crash were continuing and appealed for witnesses to contact them.


Derbyshire all-rounder Alex Hughes has signed a new one-year contract.

The 24-year-old was a regular in all formats last season, scoring his maiden first-class century and averaging 35 in the County Championship.
Hughes made 86 appearances in total during 2015, scoring 1,456 runs and taking 60 wickets in all competitions.
"Alex performed well across all three competitions, making several match-winning contributions," said elite performance director Graeme Welch.
"He's a versatile player who provides options with both bat and ball. It's important that he now kicks on and continues to perform to a high standard."


Convicted fraudster and former Nigerian state governor James Ibori has been awarded £1 ($1.30) for being unlawfully detained for 42 hours in the UK.

Ibori was jailed in the UK for fraud totalling nearly £50m in 2012.
He was due to be released on 20 December but instead was held in immigration detention.
After he was released he launched his claim against the Home Secretary Amber Rudd for damages for false imprisonment and breach of his rights.
On Monday Mrs Justice Cheema-Grubb said the home secretary had been "wrong throughout her dealings with Mr Ibori over the weeks leading to his release" and that he had been unlawfully detained.
However, she rejected Ibori's claim for £4,000 in damages. Instead she awarded "nominal damages" of £1.
The judge also said that the decision to keep him in immigration detention was probably because of millions of pounds the authorities have still not recovered from him.
A Home Office email, published in the court judgement, recommended to keep him in immigration detention to buy time to work out how to recover at least £57m.
"The best course of action at present is to place him in immigration detention and review the position in February or when we know more about the confiscation process", it said.
On 21 December a High Court judge ordered his immediate release from prison. Ibori eventually left the UK in February.
Who is James Ibori?
James Ibori went from petty thief to Nigerian state governor to convicted money launderer. He came to the UK in the 1980s and worked as a cashier at a DIY store in London.
He was convicted in 1991 of stealing from the store but then returned to Nigeria and got involved in politics.
When he ran for Delta State governor he lied about his date of birth to hide his UK conviction - which would have prevented him standing for office.
He became governor in 1999 and soon began taking money from state coffers.
The British police began to take an interest in Ibori again in 2005 after they came across a purchase order for a private jet, made through his solicitor in London.
He evaded capture in Nigeria after a mob of supporters attacked police, but was arrested in Dubai in 2010 and was extradited to the UK.


Nato should consider suspending Turkey, the Lib Dems have said, following its crackdown on the media and other bodies in response to the recent coup attempt.

The authorities have issued a decree closing 131 media outlets while scores of top journalists have been arrested.
The Lib Dems said the "purge" of critics of the government was contrary to the principles of democracy, liberty and the rule of law upheld by Nato.
Turkey is a key member of the defence alliance and ally of the United States.
The Turkish government has been accused of using the coup attempt by sections of the military as a pretext to target journalists and other non-state institutions including judges, academics and teachers.
Three news agencies, 16 TV channels, 23 radio stations, 45 papers, 15 magazines and 29 publishers are to be closed down.
Many of the media outlets are linked to the Hizmet movement of US-based cleric Fetullah Gulen, whom Turkey's democratically elected president Recep Tayyip Erdogan has blamed for the uprising, a claim Mr Gulen denies.
Despite strongly condemning the coup and giving its backing to President Erdogan, the international community has told the government its response must be proportionate, follow due process and avoid indiscriminate reprisals.
But the Lib Dems, who served in coalition government with the Conservatives between 2010 and 2015 but were reduced to eight MPs at the last election, have urged Nato to act.
Tom Brake, the party's foreign affairs spokesman, said the flurry of arrests and closure of media outlets in recent days "should send shivers down the spine of any person who believes in a free and open society".
"Erdogan's ongoing purge of newspapers, academics, teachers and judges has nothing to do with Turkey's security and everything to do with blocking any opposition to his increasingly authoritarian rule," he said in a statement to the Lib Dem voice blog.
"The preamble to Nato's founding treaty refers to it being "founded on the principles of democracy, individual liberty and the rule of law", all of which are under threat in Turkey currently.
"If the UK and our Nato allies want to protect these core principles, it is time to make it clear to Erdogan that his actions will have lasting international consequences, and I am calling on Nato to urgently consider suspension of Turkey's membership."
He told the BBC that the UK - a founding member of Nato - should take a firm stance on the issue and should be insisting that those who had been detained had access to legal representation and anyone who was not charged was speedily released.
"I hope the new government will use this as an opportunity to demonstrate that human rights are at the core of our foreign policy and will not be downgraded in favour of international trade," he said.
Turkey already has a poor track record on media freedom, ranking 151 out of 180 countries in this year's World Press Freedom Index.
At least 246 people were killed and more than 2,000 injured in clashes during the abortive coup - 16,000 people have been detained since then.
Turkey has declared a three-month state of emergency, allowing the president and the government to bypass parliament when drafting new laws and to restrict or suspend rights and freedoms.
Earlier this year the EU called for longstanding talks on Turkey becoming a member to be re-energised although observers have said the coup and the government's response have set back the prospect of any immediate progress.
EU officials have said the accession talks will be suspended immediately, if the Turkish government reintroduces the death penalty.


MPs have praised the UK's response to humanitarian crises but said the government cannot always explain how taxpayers' money is being spent.

The Public Accounts Committee said the UK had shown "agility, bravery and innovation" in helping to contain the Ebola outbreak in Sierra Leone and deal with famine in the Horn of Africa.
But performance in war zones like Syria and Yemen needs "fuller understanding".
It also urged the UK to take a lead in trying to simplify UN aid structures.
The UK has one of the largest foreign aid budgets in the world and last year became the first G7 country to meet an international commitment to spend 0.7% - about £12bn - of its national income on overseas development.
The government has sought to refocus spending in recent years amid criticism from MPs on the right of the Conservative Party that the foreign aid budget has been protected from cuts since 2010 during a time of prolonged domestic austerity.
Spending on humanitarian emergencies trebled in the four years to 2014-15, the cross-party committee said in its report. The Department for International Development spent £1.28bn dealing with overseas crises - 14% of its £9.5bn budget.
The Department for International Development (DfID), the MPs concluded, was doing a "good job" in responding to more than 20 crises around the world caused by conflict, natural disaster, disease and drought.
It singled out for praise the UK's contribution to fighting the Ebola outbreak, noting that it had quickly mobilised resources to transfer 164 staff from other areas to Sierra Leone - putting some lower priority activities on hold to focus on the crisis.
Other countries in which "tangible results" had been achieved include the Philippines, where a UK team has been helping build resilience against typhoons following the devastation wrought by typhoon Haiyan in 2013.
The committee acknowledged that DfID was working in many difficult and dangerous environments - but said it did not often know what constituted success in terms of value for money.
The performance of individual interventions is assessed but the committee said protracted engagements in war zones such as Syria and Yemen were not subject to the same "structured approach" as others, limiting the lessons being learnt.
Among the committee's recommendations are more focus on assessing "longer-running and more complex crises", a review of the use of external contractors, ensuring staff and equipment can always be deployed overseas at short notice, better tracking of how UK funds are spent by other bodies, including UN agencies whose "overlapping remits", the MPs said, can often lead to inefficiency.
"It is important to recognise the Department for International Development has had a positive impact in responding to some desperate situations around the world," said Meg Hillier, the Labour MP who chairs the committee.
"It is also important that, however public money is spent, the government is held to account for that spending.
"In responding to crises, achieving value for money means critical support can be provided more effectively to more of the people who need it. It is vital it looks constantly at the way it spends public money and ensures it is being used to best advantage."
In response, DfID said it welcomed the MPs' recognition "of the success it has had in tackling a range of crises".
"The government's aid strategy places a heavy focus on ensuring value for money, and the UK is playing a lead role in discussions on the future of the international humanitarian system and overseas development, including the role of UN agencies," a spokeswoman added.