Schalke have signed Manchester City target Holger Badstuber on loan from Bayern Munich for six months.

The 27-year-old centre-back has had a string of bad injuries and has only played 18 out of 135 Bundesliga games over the past four years.
City boss Pep Guardiola, his manager at Bayern, had confirmed his interest in the Germany international.
Badstuber, who has spent his entire career at Bayern, is out of contract at the end of the season.
"I'm thankful Bayern have complied with my request," he said.
"I'd like to get some much-needed match practice at Schalke and I'm looking forward to my time in Gelsenkirchen."


A work by renowned landscape artist Charles Jencks on the site of an old opencast coal mine in southern Scotland is close to completion.

The Crawick Multiverse will be launched to the public for the summer solstice on 21 June.
Materials found on the site - including 2,000 large boulders - have been used to create the work.
It hopes to attract international visitors and boost businesses in nearby Sanquhar, Kelloholm and Kirkconnel.
The Â£1m project - funded by the Duke of Buccleuch - follows on from other works by Mr Jencks including the likes of Northumberlandia in north east England,  the Garden of Cosmic Speculation north of Dumfries and the Beijing Olympic Park's Black Hole Terrace.
He said: "This former open cast coal site, nestled in a bowl of large rolling hills, never did produce enough black gold to keep digging.
"But it did, accidentally, create the bones of a marvellous ecology.
"The landscape had to be healed, it had to welcome the nearby communities of Sanquhar, Kelloholm and Kirkconnel, and help restore the locality both economically and ecologically - and so the Crawick Multiverse, a new version of an old scientific idea, was born.
"This work of land art, created primarily from earth and boulders on the site, celebrates the surrounding Scottish countryside and its landmarks, looking outwards and back in time."
The site is managed by the Crawick Artland Trust which includes trustees from the local communities surrounding the site.
Trust director Duncan Mackison said: "We are very excited to see this ambitious, large scale project nearing completion and are confident it will prove to be a huge draw for visitors from both home and abroad.
"There has been a huge amount of excitement and anticipation locally and we received some extremely positive feedback at our recent community events in Sanquhar and Kirkconnel.
"This fantastic artland will appeal to a diverse range of visitors, including art and design enthusiasts, families looking for a day out with a difference, schools who want an 'outdoor classroom' and local groups and organisations."


(Close): The S&P 500 inched to a new record high as Wall Street shrugged off poor earnings results to finish higher.

The broader S&P 500 index was up 9.86 points to 2175.03, nudging past the record set earlier in the week.
The Dow Jones climbed 53.62 points higher to 18570.85, while the Nasdaq rose 26.26 to 5100.16.
The gains came despite disappointing figures from General Electric and Boeing, although shares in both companies fell.
GE, seen by analysts as a bellwether for the US economy, dropped 1.7% after it reported weak demand for new oil, gas and transportation equipment.
Boeing shares fell early in the day but ended flat. The company announced a $2bn charge that would hit second quarter profits.
Andre Bakhos, managing director at Janlyn Capital, said: "The markets are biding time to see what the next set of earnings bring."
The weak results in the industrial sector were a concern, he added.
Shares of Verizon Communications rose 1.3% as rumours circulated that the company was nearing a deal to buy Yahoo's core internet business. Yahoo shares were up 1.4%.
Rival telecoms firm AT&T, which is also bidding for Yahoo's business, saw its shares climb 1.4%.
Paypal fell 6.8% to $37.27 following results after the bell on Thursday night, despite several brokers raising their price target to between $42 and $50.
Investors will remain focused on quarterly earnings next week. In the tech sector Apple, Facebook, Alphabet and Amazon all report.


The former girlfriend of the man who murdered a police couple at their home has spoken of his "isolation" after spending two-and-a-half years in jail.

The woman, who did not want to give her full name, told France Info radio the couple had dated for five years and remained close after they split up.
But after Larossi Abballa left jail last year, she said, he "preferred to keep his distance and changed friends".
A moment of silence was held for the murdered pair on Wednesday.
The town of Magnanville, west of Paris, was holding a memorial ceremony for police commander Jean-Baptiste Savaing, 42, and Jessica Schneider, 36, who were knifed to death there on Monday night.
Prime Minister Manuel Valls pledged his support for the police force but also warned of further attacks in an interview with France Inter radio.
"We need to tighten the net and give police and intelligence services all the means they need, but we will witness further attacks," he was quoted as saying.
"More innocents will lose their lives."
French police are already entitled to take their weapons home with them under a state of emergency imposed after the militant Islamist attacks on 13 November in which 130 people died. That measure will now be extended beyond the end of the state of emergency on 26 July.
In a video put out by a news agency linked to so-called Islamic State, Abballa was shown confessing to Monday's killings in the couple's home. He said he was heeding a call by IS spokesman Abu Mohammed al-Adnani, who issued a message before the start of Ramadan inciting Muslims to target civilians in Europe and the US.
Abballa's ex-girlfriend told France Info (in French) she had been his last romantic interest.
"After me, he became religious," she said. "He wanted to pray properly.
"That didn't scare me because he was normal. He only said he'd like it if one day I became like him, and agreed to wear the veil. But at no time did he judge me, or stop talking to me because I wasn't veiled, or because I had holes in my jeans or wore leather... at no time."
Her last contact with Abballa, she said, had been a brief exchange three days before the attack in which he died, when he had rung asking to see her for 10 minutes.
She said she couldn't meet then and had rung back on Sunday, but "the number didn't work - as if the line had been cut".
It was only listening to the radio that she discovered that her former boyfriend was a police killer, she said.
On Tuesday evening, President Francois Hollande said that the couple's three-year-old son and a child from Jean-Baptiste Savaing's previous relationship would become wards of the state.
The status - which applies to children orphaned by acts of war, terrorism and in their parents' service to public security - means they will receive material assistance from the state as they grow up.
The couple's small son was at home when Abballa killed his parents. He was taken hostage for several hours, before Abballa was killed during the police assault.
He was later taken to the Necker children's hospital in Paris under the care of his grandparents. During the day the hospital was targeted by protesters against the government's labour reforms who threw projectiles and smashed windows.
Inspecting the damage on Wednesday morning, Mr Valls urged the hardline CGT union to stop organising mass rallies in the capital, condemning this "disgraceful spectacle, this lack of control... over the protesters".


Chesterfield have signed goalkeeper Ryan Fulton on a season-long loan deal from Premier League side Liverpool.

The 20-year-old, who has yet to make a first team appearance for the Reds, played 13 times during a loan spell with Portsmouth in 2015-16.
Fulton could start the season as Spireites number one, with Tommy Lee due to undergo shoulder surgery.
The Scotland youth international has travelled to Hungary to join up with the club's pre-season training camp.
Find all the latest football transfers on our dedicated page.


1. Andy Murray (GB)
2. Novak Djokovic (Ser)
3. Stan Wawrinka (Swi)
4. Milos Raonic (Can)
5. Kei Nishikori (Jpn)
6. Rafael Nadal (Spa)
7. Marin Cilic (Cro)
8. Jo-Wilfried Tsonga (Fra)
9. Dominic Thiem (Aut)
10. Roger Federer (Swi)
11. Gael Monfils (Fra)
12. David Goffin (Bel)
13. Grigor Dimitrov (Bul)
14. Tomas Berdych (Cze)
15. Lucas Pouille (Fra)
16. Nick Kyrgios (Aus)
17. Roberto Bautista Agut (Spa)
18. Jack Sock (US)
19. Richard Gasquet (Fra)
20. Alexander Zverev (Ger)
Other Britons in top 300:
41. Daniel Evans
46. Kyle Edmund
105. Aljaz Bedene
233. Cameron Norrie
244. Edward Corrie
254. Brydan Klein


Serving tea and receiving guests may not be everyone's dream job, but it was a good enough prospect to make nearly 10,000 people apply for one receptionist job.

China's highly competitive civil service recruitment process recently saw a record-setting 9,837 applicants for a post as "China Democratic League public reception staff".
The Democratic League is one of several minority political parties in the country which have very limited powers, and is hardly seen as a prestigious placement.
So why are so many people hoping to be its receptionist?
With so many applicants every year and China's ongoing anti-corruption drive, government departments have started to become more stringent in their hiring, asking for graduates with higher qualifications and more specific skills.
"Some jobs have attracted many people because they have broader requirements for education and professional and work experience," civil service spokesman Li Zhong told People's Daily.
Anyone with a bachelor's degree and two years of "grassroots experience" can apply for the Democratic League job, according to reports.
Meanwhile, 223 openings saw hardly any interested applicants - these included bank regulatory and meteorological jobs in more far-flung regions such as Inner Mongolia and Xinjiang.
Mr Li acknowledged that these remained vacant because of their "more arduous locations".
About 1.4 million people took the civil service examination this year, and overall each job got an average of 49.5 applicants.
But China sees similar figures every year. Last year's applicant to job ratio was 46:1.
In 2013, more than 9,400 people applied to fill the post of "national statistics department's Chongqing and Nanchuan investigation team member".
China's official unemployment rate is about 4%, which translates to a lot of jobseekers in a country of 1.4 billion people. And with high turnovers the norm in the private sector, many still flock to the government.
It is the same story in India with its similar population size and unemployment rate for instance, where last year two million Indians applied for 300 jobs in the state of Uttar Pradesh.
A government job is still attractive in many Asian countries for its prestige and stability.
In China, it is known as eating from an "iron rice bowl", meaning that your source of income, and means of feeding your family, is unbreakable.
One Sina commentary joked that the China Democratic League job was a "golden rice bowl" for its overwhelming desirability.
But the sheen has started to fade: the civil service's reputation has taken a hit in recent years with China's zealous anti-corruption drive. Earlier this week the government announced it had punished 1 million officials for corruption in the past three years.
Some on microblogging network Sina Weibo reacted with cynicism to the latest news on civil service applications.
"What's the point? If you can't get in, your relatives will look down on you. If you do get in, then your relatives will hassle you on a daily basis to pull strings for them," said one commenter.
But others sympathised. "Many of those applying do so because they really can't find a job, or their current job is not good, it's got nothing to do with corruption," said another netizen.
Reporting by Tessa Wong


Celtic defender Kieran Tierney will take just one week off this summer, but the 19-year-old is not complaining.

Tierney acknowledges that a Scottish Cup win against Aberdeen on Saturday "would just round it up to be perfect".
The Hampden final will not mark the end of season for the six players called up to the Scotland squad for next month's World Cup qualifier against England.
"I was injured the last time we played England so I was unlucky to miss that," Tierney said.
"But hopefully if I do well in the next game (the Scottish Cup final) and in training the next week (for Scotland) hopefully I'll get picked for the (Scotland) team.
"After the Scotland-England game I'll get a week off, so I'll use that wisely. It's the footballer's life - that's what you want.
"You want to play games and this is a big, big game for us all so we'll be really looking forward to it."
While Tierney says team-mate Callum McGregor is "very unlucky" to miss out on Gordon Strachan's squad for the England game, he believes the six who have been called up all have a good chance of starting, given the form they have shown under Brendan Rodgers this season.
"It puts them in a good position," Tierney said.
"We saw [in] the last game for Scotland there was a core of Celtic players and it was a great result for us all. That helps the team the way Celtic have played this season, the winning mentality that we've got. That can only be a bonus for the national side."
Only after the Scotland-England match will Tierney get a break. But he will be expected back at Celtic for pre-season on 19 June, as the squad prepare for European qualifiers.
Before international duty, the Celtic defender is focusing on Saturday's cup final against Aberdeen, and "a massive, massive game", as Celtic look to seal the treble.
"It's the biggest game of the season now for us, we're looking forward to the challenge, and it will be a challenge because Aberdeen are a great team," Tierney said.
"They'll put up a great fight against us, but we've obviously won the games against them this season and hopefully we can do that on Saturday."
Tierney admits the feat of going the whole league season unbeaten "was special" although it has not quite sunk in yet.
He said: "It's been amazing so far right. From day one what we've done as a team and how far we've come together, the bond is special just now and the fans can see that on the pitch."


Some services at a world-renowned burns unit in East Grinstead may be moving to Brighton, the BBC has learnt.

The Queen Victoria Hospital (QVH) has an international reputation, largely due to pioneering burns surgery which took place there during World War Two.
But as a small specialist hospital it does not meet the new National Burns Care Standards published in 2013.
As a result, the trust is considering an arrangement with a major trauma unit being built in Brighton, it revealed.
The new trauma centre at the Royal Sussex County Hospital is expected to be ready for use by 2020.
In order to meet the new standards, the QVH is considering admitting adult burns patients to dedicated QVH beds there.
The trust said the change would mean patients could access a wide range of other specialist staff and facilities.
It said experts have found that burns patients admitted as an emergency get the best outcomes this way.
Similarly, children with severe burns could be admitted to QVH beds within the Royal Alexandra Children's Hospital, it added.
QVH at East Grinstead would continue to play the central role in burns care for the region and its other specialist services would not be affected, it said.
Any proposals developed are likely to be up for public consultation before any final decision, it added.
The Brighton and Sussex University Hospitals Trust has not responded to a request for comment.


A gun that is believed to have been used to shoot a mother and her seven-year-old son has been seized by police.

Jayne Hickey and her son Christian were shot when two men knocked on their front door in Gillingham Road in Eccles, Salford on 12 October.
The gun was one of two firearms seized when a vehicle was stopped in Faulkner's Lane, Mobberley in Cheshire on 15 December at about 21:20 GMT.
Two men have appeared in court charged with possession of firearms.
A weapon has also been linked to a man's shooting in Ashton-in Makerfield, Wigan on 30 March.


Wales captain Sam Warburton said he had no regrets about turning down penalty kicks at goal in Wales' 15-6 defeat by Australia in Pool A of the World Cup.

Australia survived seven minutes with 13 players without conceding a point.
The result means the Wallabies advance to face Scotland in the quarter-finals and Wales take on South Africa.
"I felt we needed a try. We were six points behind so it would have needed two penalties to get us level and they were two players down," said Warburton.
"I think any country would have backed themselves to get over. But Australia's defence was fantastic and sometimes you just have to put your hand up and say 'well done'.
"We threw everything at them and I can sit here and say I don't have any regrets."
Warburton also praised the defence of Stephen Moore's team as Wales suffered an 11th consecutive defeat by the Wallabies.
Warren Gatland's team won 12-6 the last time they played the Springboks and were beaten by a last-minute penalty try in Nelspruit in the summer of 2014.
Warburton thinks Wales can overcome the South Africans and reach a second consecutive World Cup semi-final.
"We are already looking forward to that quarter-final - it's against a team we've beaten in the last 12 months," he said.
"And there's one thing our players don't mind it's a challenge and we've proved we can do it in the past.
"I'm disappointed we lost today, but I'll definitely back ourselves next week."
Many doubted Wales would advance from the toughest of all the tournament's pools, which included four teams ranked in the world's top 10.
But victory over England in the second game proved decisive and Warburton feels the win in Twickenham proves they have the players for the big occasion.
"We've had three huge games and I think the players we've got a lot of guys with a lot of caps who are used to dealing with big games," added Warburton.
"Playing these big games in these big stadiums is an absolute privilege. It doesn't faze us, we embrace it."
Wales coach Gatland also highlighted the Wallabies' "courageous" defence as a decisive factor.
"They were throwing their bodies on the line," said Gatland. "We got over the line three times and been held up.
"To me it was just really fine margins. If Dan Biggar kicks that penalty on half-time you're 12-9 down rather than 12-6 down - your mindset changes and you take the three points.
"We did a great job defensively. They didn't really put us under a huge amount of pressure from attack.
"I thought there were times when we played some pretty good rugby as well."


The Russian authorities have introduced a sweeping ban on imports of fruit and vegetables from Poland, depriving it of a major export market.

Russia's food hygiene authorities said the imports had unacceptable levels of pesticide residues and nitrates.
They earn Poland more than 1bn euros (Â£795m; $1.3bn) annually. Russia is Poland's biggest market for apples.
The move follows EU sanctions against Russia over Ukraine - and Poland has condemned Russian actions there.
Poland and some other former communist bloc countries are among the most vocal critics of Russia in the current crisis, accusing Moscow of supplying the separatist rebels in eastern Ukraine with arms and volunteers.
The cost to Poland of the import ban is likely to be 0.6% of GDP (national output) by the end of the year, Polish Deputy Prime Minister Janusz Piechocinski was quoted as saying.
Agriculture accounts for about 3.8% of Poland's total GDP. Polish growers plan to seek compensation from the EU for the loss of earnings.
Poles have been posting images of apples on social media as a way of protesting against Russia.
On Thursday Russia announced a ban on more imported Ukrainian food: soy products, cornmeal, sunflowers and fruit juice.
Earlier Russia banned Ukrainian dairy produce and canned fish and vegetables. Last year it banned Ukrainian Roshen chocolate, produced by billionaire businessman Petro Poroshenko, who is now Ukraine's president.
Previously Russia also imposed such boycotts on Georgia and Moldova - former Soviet republics, like Ukraine, whose pro-Western policies have angered the Kremlin.
Russia is an important export market for Georgian and Moldovan wine. Currently Russia is blocking imports of Moldovan fruit. In each case the Russian authorities say they have public health reasons for imposing a ban.
In January - before its March annexation of Crimea - Russia also imposed a ban on imports of pigs and pork from the EU.
The European Commission says that move was "disproportionate", closing a market worth 25% of total EU pig and pork exports. In 2013 those exports to Russia totalled 1.4bn euros.
The EU has complained to the World Trade Organization, accusing Russia of breaking the rules. The Russian ban was based on some cases of African swine fever among wild boars on the EU's borders with Belarus.


Fleetwood highlighted their credentials as automatic-promotion candidates in League One by beating table-toppers Sheffield United.

Goals from Conor McLaughlin and Devante Cole stunned the Blades and extended the Cod Army's unbeaten run in the league to an impressive 11 games, moving them to within six points of second-placed Scunthorpe.
It was a thoroughly deserved three points as Uwe Rosler's men impressed from the off, taking the lead in the 20th minute when McLaughlin drilled in Bobby Grant's cross that was meant as a shot at the far post.
They should have been 2-0 up at the break, but Simon Moore denied Wes Burns with an instinctive save when the striker went through on goal.
Billy Sharp was United's main threat as they chased an equaliser early in the second half, but Fleetwood killed the game when Cole latched on to Ethan Ebanks-Landell's weak header to lob Moore.
The Blades, who paraded new signings James Hanson and Jay O'Shea before kick-off, pressed for a way back into the game but could not find it and have now taken just one point from their last three games.
Report supplied by the Press Association.
Match ends, Sheffield United 0, Fleetwood Town 2.
Second Half ends, Sheffield United 0, Fleetwood Town 2.
Foul by John Fleck (Sheffield United).
Conor McLaughlin (Fleetwood Town) wins a free kick in the attacking half.
Substitution, Sheffield United. Matt Done replaces Daniel Lafferty.
Attempt blocked. Caolan Lavery (Sheffield United) right footed shot from the centre of the box is blocked.
Attempt missed. Bobby Grant (Fleetwood Town) left footed shot from outside the box is just a bit too high.
Attempt blocked. Ashley Hunter (Fleetwood Town) right footed shot from the right side of the box is blocked.
Ethan Ebanks-Landell (Sheffield United) wins a free kick in the attacking half.
Foul by Cian Bolger (Fleetwood Town).
Billy Sharp (Sheffield United) wins a free kick in the defensive half.
Foul by Cian Bolger (Fleetwood Town).
Foul by Caolan Lavery (Sheffield United).
Cian Bolger (Fleetwood Town) wins a free kick in the attacking half.
Attempt saved. Ethan Ebanks-Landell (Sheffield United) header from the centre of the box is saved in the centre of the goal.
Corner,  Sheffield United. Conceded by Cian Bolger.
Attempt blocked. Caolan Lavery (Sheffield United) right footed shot from the centre of the box is blocked.
Corner,  Sheffield United. Conceded by Cian Bolger.
Caolan Lavery (Sheffield United) wins a free kick in the defensive half.
Foul by George Glendon (Fleetwood Town).
Jack O'Connell (Sheffield United) wins a free kick in the attacking half.
Foul by David Ball (Fleetwood Town).
Foul by Billy Sharp (Sheffield United).
Ashley Eastham (Fleetwood Town) wins a free kick on the left wing.
Substitution, Fleetwood Town. George Glendon replaces Markus Schwabl.
Attempt missed. Cian Bolger (Fleetwood Town) header from the centre of the box misses to the left following a corner.
Corner,  Fleetwood Town. Conceded by Stefan Scougall.
Substitution, Fleetwood Town. David Ball replaces Devante Cole.
Attempt missed. Billy Sharp (Sheffield United) header from the centre of the box is just a bit too high.
Ethan Ebanks-Landell (Sheffield United) wins a free kick in the attacking half.
Foul by Ashley Hunter (Fleetwood Town).
Goal!  Sheffield United 0, Fleetwood Town 2. Devante Cole (Fleetwood Town) right footed shot from the centre of the box to the centre of the goal.
Devante Cole (Fleetwood Town) is shown the yellow card.
Kieron Freeman (Sheffield United) wins a free kick on the left wing.
Foul by Amari'i Bell (Fleetwood Town).
Substitution, Fleetwood Town. Ashley Hunter replaces Wes Burns.
Attempt saved. Billy Sharp (Sheffield United) right footed shot from outside the box is saved in the bottom left corner.
Attempt missed. Billy Sharp (Sheffield United) right footed shot from the left side of the six yard box misses to the right.
Foul by John Fleck (Sheffield United).
Markus Schwabl (Fleetwood Town) wins a free kick in the attacking half.


Scotland's local authorities have been urged to do more to tackle the problem of empty homes.

Around the country it is estimated there are about 34,000 private homes categorised as long-term empty.
This is almost the same number of households which made homelessness applications in 2015.
The Scottish government said it is committed to introduce legislation to reduce the number of empty homes, as well as vacant and derelict land.
The Scottish Empty Homes Partnership (SEHP), which is funded by the Scottish government, said in 2015 empty properties worth more than Â£110m were brought back into use.
Kristen Hubert, the organisation's national manager, said: "The SEHP would like to see all of Scotland's local authorities responding pro-actively to the problem of empty homes.
"We think more powers to tackle the blight of empty homes such as a Compulsory Sale Order would give them the ability to force a long-term empty property or piece of land onto the open market if it hasn't been used in three years and shows no prospect of reuse."
The Scottish government's Housing Minister Kevin Stewart said: "Empty homes are a wasted resource and can be a blight on local communities.
"That's why the Scottish government supports the work of SEHP to deliver real results on the ground. Since 2010 the partnership has brought almost 1,700 homes back into use and helped 17 local authorities to appoint dedicated empty homes officers.
"To add to the range of tools available to tackle empty homes, we are committed to bringing forward provisions for Compulsory Sales Orders as part of on-going land reform measures."
SEHP published a survey which suggested three in every four adults in Scotland thought empty homes directly caused anti-social behaviour.
Anti-social behaviour such as graffiti, vandalism, fly-tipping and break-ins are all associated with properties lying empty for long periods, the survey, carried out by YouGov suggested.
It also suggested a majority (54%) of Scottish adults felt those living nearby the empty homes had a decreased sense of security and 60% thought empty homes contributed directly to a reduction in the availability of housing.
About a half (49%) thought empty homes lowered the value of local properties.
Ms Hubert said: "This survey shows just how concerned people in Scotland are about empty homes in their communities.
"No-one likes to see empty properties being vandalised with graffiti all over them or with fly-tipping taking place. The fact that only 3% of Scottish adults think empty homes cause no problems is very telling."
According to the housing charity Shelter Scotland there are currently about 34,000 long-term private empty homes across Scotland with 150,000 families and individuals  on waiting lists for a home.
In 2015, nearly 35,000 homelessness applications were made by households in Scotland.


Police have warned that drugs stolen from a pharmacy in North Lanarkshire could have "fatal consequences" if taken without medical supervision.

A "substantial quantity" of the drugs was taken from Mint Pharmacy, Calder Street, Whifflet, Coatbridge.
The theft, in the early hours of Tuesday morning, included Fentanyl, Oxycodone, Tapentadol and Morphine.
Police said the haul also included Methylphenidate, Temazepam, Suboxin, Daclatasvir and Sofosbuvir,
Insp Louise Brownlie said: "These drugs, if taken without strict medical supervision, could have potentially fatal consequences.
"I would like to speak to anyone who has been offered these drugs, or may know of their whereabouts.
"Inquiries are ongoing into the theft and anyone with information that may assist police inquiries should contact Coatbridge police office."


The son of an IRA informer killed almost 30 years ago has said Martin McGuinness should be questioned in connection with the murder.

Frank Hegarty was found shot in the back of the head in 1986.
His son, Ryan, said Mr McGuinness "needs to be questioned".
However, the Sinn FÃ©in deputy first minister said he "had absolutely no role in the death of Frank Hegarty".
Mr Hegarty's murder is to be investigated as part of a police inquiry into the activities of Stakeknife, who was said to have been the Army's highest agent within the IRA.
Ryan Hegarty told the BBC:  "In the eyes of the IRA, my father committed the ultimate crime.
"In my eyes, he saved the lives of human beings. But it cost him his own life.
"I have never denied that he passed on information to the security services. It's well documented what my father did.
"My family has been left broken and in misery. It left utter devastation."
Mr Hegarty said that he did not find out what happened to his father until he was a teenager.
"It was terrible living in Derry as Frank Hegarty's son," he said.
"He was known as a tout.
"Whatever my father did, he paid for it. My father was a hero, but to the republicans he's a cheater.
"He (Martin McGuinness) was around when things were happening. He was a regular visitor to my grandmother's house. I'm not implicating him but he was there."
Mr McGuinness has always said that he advised Mr Hegarty's family that he should not meet the IRA if he was an informer
In a statement, Mr McGuinness said: "At the time of these events, I was an elected Sinn FÃ©in assembly member, having been elected to the assembly in 1982.
"I became involved with the family on being told that Frank Hegarty, a well-known Derry republican, had informed them that he had been abducted and taken to England by British intelligence agents.
"It was my duty as a public representative to assist the family. I did this to the best of my ability but there was little I could do.
"There are questions to be answered in relation to Mr Hegarty's death by those with detailed knowledge of this event, including British intelligence."


American Airlines has received an "unsolicited" approach from Qatar Airways which wants to acquire 10% of the US carrier.

In a regulatory filing, American Airlines said Qatar intended to buy at least $808m (£638m) of its shares.
American Airlines said it would respond "in due course".
Shares in American Airlines, which is the biggest airline in the world, initially rose 5% but fell back to a 1.2% rise by afternoon trading.
Qatar Airways said it sees American as a good investment opportunity and would not involve itself in management, operations or governance.
"Qatar Airways believes in American Airlines' fundamentals," the firm said.
In 2015, Qatar Airways took a 10% stake in International Airlines Group (IAG), the owner of British Airways and Iberia.
Then in July 2015 it increased its stake to 20%, becoming IAG's biggest shareholder.
But the airline has encountered turbulence.
Earlier this month, Saudi Arabia, Egypt, Bahrain, the United Arab Emirates, Libya, Yemen and the Maldives cut diplomatic ties with Qatar.
Saudi Arabia, the UAE, Bahrain and Egypt all said they would stop flights in and out of Qatar, and close their airspace to the country's flag carrier, Qatar Airways.
US companies, including American Airlines, have also pressured the White House to take action against Qatar Airways and other Gulf airlines, which they say receive unfair government subsidies.
Seth Kaplan, managing partner at Airline Weekly, said Qatar Airways may be hoping an investment would help reduce those objections.
The firm may also be looking to strengthen Qatar's relationship with the US, which has appeared uncertain amid the diplomatic dispute in the Gulf, he said.
"It's almost certainly not just a financial investment," he said.
American Airlines and Qatar Airways are already partners through the Oneworld alliance. This investment could tighten that relationship, but it is unlikely to have a large effect on consumers, Mr Kaplan said.
It is not clear at this point how American Airlines will respond, Mr Kaplan said.
In its statement, Qatar Airways said it would not acquire more than 4.75% of shares without permission from the American Airlines board.


The success of Scotland's Olympic and Paralympic stars in Rio has been celebrated in Edinburgh.

Athletes were cheered by children and mobbed for selfies as they arrived at Oriam, the new sports performance centre at Heriot-Watt University.
The homecoming event included a Q&A and an opportunity for young people to try Olympic sports such as rowing, judo and tennis, with tips from the athletes.
It was followed by a public celebration in Edinburgh's Festival Square.
Later the athletes attended the Team Scotland Scottish Sports Awards at the Edinburgh International Conference Centre.
About 50 Scottish Olympic and Paralympic athletes took part in the celebration.
Sportscotland said 18 medallists were at the events which the organisation said demonstrated "Scotland's pride" in what the athletes have achieved.
Double silver medal winning swimmer Duncan Scott said he hoped to encourage athletes of the future.
He said: "The biggest advice I could give is work on the little things.
"I think the whole point of being an athlete is trying to inspire the next generation no matter what level you are at.
"It's so important to carry that and keep it going."
Rio 2016 was Scotland's most successful overseas Olympics, with Scottish competitors securing 13 medals - four gold, seven silver and two bronze.
Cyclists Callum Skinner and Katie Archibald won gold along with rower Heather Stanning and tennis star Andy Murray.
Rower Katherine Grainger's silver medal made her Britain's most decorated female Olympian.
Callum Skinner, who won the silver medal in the individual cycling track sprints and was a member of the British team that won gold in the team sprint in Rio, said he was pleased to see so many young people at the event.
He said: "I was inspired by watching Chris Hoy as a kid and sport should be something for everyone.
"It's a great thing to get involved in so the more kids that get inspired the better.
"My medals are not just for me they are for everyone to pass around to see what they are like.
"I saw Chris' Olympic medals when I was younger and that's something I want to pass on as well."
There were 33 Scottish athletes on the ParalympicsGB team. Between them they won 17 medals - the team's best performance since 2004.
Libby Clegg secured half of the gold haul with her two medals on the track while Jo Butterfield won gold in the F51 club throw while Karen Darke took gold in the cycling H1-3 time trial.
Gordon Reid won gold in the wheelchair tennis men's singles.
Sportscotland chief executive Stewart Harris said earlier this month: "This represents the most successful overseas Games for Scots on Team GB and everyone in Scotland can be very proud of their success.
"It's testament to all the hard work by the athletes, sports, coaches and the collaboration between UK Sport and the sportscotland institute of sport that Scottish athletes are delivering record-breaking performances on the Olympic stage."
First Minister Nicola Sturgeon said the athletes were a credit to Scotland.
She said: "On behalf of the people of Scotland, I would like to offer my congratulations to all of the Scottish Olympians and Paralympians.
"They have done themselves and their country proud and will have inspired the next generation of athletes.
"Today's event was a fantastic way to celebrate the achievements of our athletes and it is hard to think of a more fitting venue for us to do this than at Oriam, Scotland's brand new, world class national performance centre."
Wheelchair tennis star Gordon Reid proudly showed off his gold and silver medals from Rio 2016 at Oriam.
He said: "It's been pretty crazy since I got back, the reception has been incredible.
"To be able to come back and share the success is nice and to see so many kids here is great.
"Hopefully the chance to see a gold or silver medal and maybe try it on will inspire them to go and do the same in the future. Days like this are really important."
Sportscotland chairman Mel Young said Oriam was chosen to stage the first celebration as it will be key to future Scottish sporting success.
"Sometimes in this country we're not so good at celebrating success so this is a big three cheers to everyone involved, and we need to build on it for the future.
"We're creating a world-class system here in Scotland with places like Oriam to create more success in the future but related to that, of course, we want more people participating in sport in the wider community, so it should be a win-win for society."


A van driver who died in a crash on the A90 between Perth and Dundee has been named.

Scott McCallum, 36, from Maryhill, Glasgow, was pronounced dead at the scene after his white Mercedes Sprinter van collided with an articulated lorry.
The accident happened near Kinfauns Castle at 15:10 on Tuesday.
Police have appealed for witnesses who saw the van driving westwards on the A90 to contact them.
Mr McCallum's family said he would be "greatly missed".
A report will be submitted to the procurator fiscal.


A gaggle of five-year-olds sits cross-legged on the floor, as Welsh language teacher Eluned Jones holds out a box containing lurid plastic fruits.

The children each take one and, with the help of prompt cards, shout out the colours - "gwyrdd!", "coch!", "porffor!" [green, red, purple]
It's just like an ordinary morning of classes, but there is something that doesn't quite fit.
The view from the window of this tiny school is not of rolling green Welsh mountains, but of the snow-capped Andes - we are not in Wales, but nearly 8,000 miles (13,000 km) away in Trevelin, Patagonia.
As Wales and Argentina mark the 150th anniversary of the arrival of Welsh settlers in Patagonia - when 153 people sailed across the Atlantic to set up a colony - many surviving aspects of the old culture will be celebrated.
Welsh chapels, choirs, tea houses and annual eisteddfodau still exist in these small communities in Chubut province, such as Gaiman and Trelew on the Atlantic side of the country or Esquel and Trevelin, 400 miles (600 km) west at the foot of the Andes.
But it is the extent to which the language has survived, with more than 5,000 people estimated to speak it, that gives people significant pride.
And in recent years Welsh language learning has not only existed, but grown - including many new students who are not among the 50,000 or so Patagonians with Welsh ancestry.
Liliana Carballo, 57, originally from Buenos Aires, is descended from Spaniards who came to Argentina in the 1600s. Yet, as a lover of languages, she was drawn to learning Welsh, and teaches it in Esquel.
"Welsh is a community language here. You cannot explain why you love something, you just do," she says.
Her 16-year-old pupil Michael is of English heritage but is learning Welsh.
"People aren't studying Welsh because they think they will find a job from it. It's more of a cultural thing," he says.
"My friends find it funny - they call it a dead language. But it would be a pity if it died out. For any culture that would be a big loss.
"It's incredible to think the language has lived so long. It deteriorated, then came back stronger," adds Eluned Jones, a retired primary head teacher from Boncath, in Ceredigion.
Eluned, 57, has travelled to Patagonia for the second year running, to work on a British Council Wales project that promotes and develops the Welsh language in Patagonia.
The Welsh Language Project (WLP) - also funded by the Welsh government and Wales-Argentina Society - has sent three teachers each year since 1997. They teach Welsh from nursery level through to adult learners, using formal lessons and cultural activities.
Welsh language learners in Chubut increased by 19% between 2014 and 2015, rising from 985 to 1,174 - the highest in the history of the project.
And there are now two government-registered bilingual Welsh-Spanish primary schools in the province, with plans for a third by 2016.
Some Argentine parents, with no Welsh connections, have even begun sending their children to these schools because they see the intellectual advantages of being bilingual.
They want their children to be culturally aware, or they simply prefer the values and standards of education on offer, says Gareth Kiff, WLP monitor and chairman.
He added: "Learning Welsh has no real financial value in Argentina but people learn it because they see it as something which belongs to their shared past, regardless of their ethnic background."
Until the third generation of settlers, speaking Welsh as a first language was relatively common in Patagonia.
But from the 1930s it was mainly restricted to the home and chapel after the Argentine government changed its previously relaxed attitude to having a multilingual nation.
Things took a darker turn during its period of military dictatorship in the 1970s and 80s, when people were banned from giving their children Welsh names.
Welsh Patagonians born in that era often remember grandparents, and sometimes parents, speaking Welsh in the home. And many would still be exposed to the language at the chapel choir or events including eisteddfodau.
But as it became more undesirable to outwardly display their heritage, parents often opted not to pass the language to their children.
That was the case for Welsh teacher Fabio Lewis, 40, who grew up in Dolavon. His great-great grandparents, Lewis and Rachel Davies, came to Argentina from Aberystwyth, Ceredigion, on the first ship of settlers in 1865, while his paternal ancestors came in 1874 from the Rhondda valley.
"My grandmother's first language was Welsh. She came to live with us and insisted on speaking it. I was always hearing about the dreamland of Wales and how everything was so hard here. She had never been to Wales.
"My parents didn't pass on the language to us but would sometimes turn to Welsh to discuss something they didn't want us to know. Welsh was always in the air."
Fabio's later conversion to all things Welsh was embraced with the enthusiasm of the rebellious teenage convert.
He chose to start learning Welsh at 17 and later became fluent. He was helping out at Welsh language classes in Trelew in 2001 when he met his future wife, Ann-Marie, who had come to Patagonia from her home near Llanelli, Carmarthenshire, as part of that year's teaching contingent.
A year they moved back to Wales and got married. They now have two children - Ifan, seven, and Miriam, three - and both worked at Welsh comprehensive schools in Carmarthen until earlier this year.
To coincide with the 150th anniversary celebrations, the couple decided to return to Patagonia with the WLP, and are teaching in Gaiman, Trelew and Dolavon, until December.
"We can quite happily live in a little Welsh bubble here," said Ann-Marie, 42.


The alarm on Mitsubishi's Outlander hybrid car can be turned off via security bugs in its on-board wi-fi, researchers have found.

The loophole could mean thieves who exploit the bugs gain time to break into and steal a vehicle.
The vulnerability can also be used to fiddle with some of the car's settings and drain its battery.
Mitsubishi recommended that users turn off the wi-fi while it investigates the issues with the system.
Security expert Ken Munro said the investigation started when he was waiting to collect his children from school and noticed an unusual wi-fi access point pop up on a list on his smartphone.
He realised it was on a nearby Mitsubishi Outlander that belonged to a friend who then showed him the associated app and how it could be used to control some aspects of the vehicle.
"I got playing with it and soon realised it was vulnerable so I stopped," he told the BBC.
Mr Munro then bought an Outlander and set about investigating how the car's owner communicates with their vehicle via the app.
Many other car makers use a web-based service that supports apps for connected cars so owners can lock them remotely or otherwise control them. Typically, commands sent to a car pass through these servers before being sent to the car over the mobile network.
By contrast, Mitsubishi has decided to only let apps talk to cars via the onboard wi-fi. Unfortunately, said Mr Munro, there were serious shortcomings with the way the wi-fi has been set up.
To begin with, said Mr Munro, the format for the name of the access point on the car is very distinct. This has led to the location of many Mitsubishi hybrids being logged on websites that gather the names of access points.
"Some were spotted while driving and others when parked at their owner's house," wrote Mr Munro in a blog outlining his findings. "A thief or hacker can therefore easily locate a car that is of interest to them."
Although Mr Munro owned the vehicle, he and his colleagues at Pen Test Partners security firm carried out their investigation as if they had no special access to it. This involved using well-known techniques that let the researchers interpose themselves between car and owner and watch data as it flowed between the two.
The team used this access to replay commands sent to an Outlander allowing them to flash the lights, tweak its charging settings and drain the battery.
Mr Munro said he was "shocked" to find out that he could also turn off the car alarm via this replay attack.
A thief who is sure the alarm could not go off would have plenty of time to use other techniques to unlock a car and gain entry, he said.
The Mitsubishi Outlander is the latest in a series of cars that have been found wanting when it comes to security.
Chrysler's 2014 Jeep Cherokee, the Tesla Model S and the Nissan Leaf have all been shown to be vulnerable to hack attacks of different degrees of severity.
The most startling was the attack staged on the Jeep which allowed the researchers to take control of the vehicle remotely. The discovery led to 1.4 million vehicles being recalled for a software update.
Security researchers fear that the more cars get connected to phones and the web, the more holes will be found.
But car makers are always playing catch-up when it comes to security as it takes far longer to develop a vehicle than it does to find, expose and share the flaws in their onboard computer systems.
"Once unlocked, there is potential for many more attacks," he said. "The on-board diagnostics port is accessible once the door is unlocked."
Access to the diagnostics port could allow thieves to connect customised hardware that would let them start the car, suggested Mr Munro.
A demonstration of the problems with the on-board wi-fi was given to Mitsubishi in the UK on 3 June where the bugs were shown to still work on the latest version of the app.
Mr Munro said he had been impressed by the cooperation he had received from Mitsubishi in exploring the bugs and seeking ways to fix them.
In a statement, Mitsubishi said: "This hacking is a first for us as no other has been reported anywhere else in the world."
It said it "took the matter seriously" and was keen to get Mr Munro talking to its engineers in Japan to understand what he found and how it could be remedied.
It added that although the bugs were "obviously disturbing" the hack only affected the car's app and would give an attacker limited access to the vehicle's systems.
"It should be noted that without the remote control device, the car cannot be started and driven away," it said.
While Mitsubishi investigated it recommended that owners deactivate their onboard wi-fi via the "cancel VIN Registration" option on the app or by using the remote app cancellation procedure.
A longer-term fix would require some action from Mitsubishi, said Mr Munro.
"New firmware should be deployed urgently to fix this problem properly, so the mobile app can still be used," he said.


A 21-year-old drink driver has admitted causing the death of a woman by dangerous driving as she was on the way home from her son's wedding in Glasgow.

Marie Laurie, 57, from Easterhouse, had just got into a taxi when it was struck by a car, driven by Steven Bennie, who was being chased by police at the time.
She died at the scene of the crash, on Edinburgh Road, on 29 November 2015.
At the High Court in Glasgow, sentence on Bennie was deferred and he was remanded in custody.
Speaking afterwards, Mrs Laurie's son, Martin Colquhoun, said the crash had "torn us apart" but added: "We're a very strong family and we'll get through these things."
He described his mother as "a very genuine woman" who "got on with everybody" and "loved her family".
Referring to Bennie, he said: "We saw the boy upset today. He's upset because he's got to go through his life knowing that he has taken someone's life.
"Hopefully he'll learn from his mistakes but this thing has happened before, it's nothing new.
"We all try to learn as much as we can and that's all we can do."
The court heard that Mrs Laurie and her husband James had just seen her son, Mr Colquhoun, get married at a hotel in Cumnock, East Ayrshire, on Saturday 28 November last year.
As the couple celebrated, Bennie meanwhile turned up at a friend's house that night in a Vauxhall Astra.
He lied that he had passed his driving test and the court was told that he only held a provisional licence.
Prosecutor Tim Niven Smith said "at some point" he drank alcohol and later drove to a McDonalds restaurant before eating food with a friend at an industrial estate in Glasgow's Baillieston area.
At 01:30 on Sunday 29 November, police stopped to investigate Bennie's car.
When Bennie saw the officers approach, he panicked and told the friend: "I've not got a licence." Bennie drove off and a police chase ensued.
He was ordered to pull over as police activated their blue lights and sounded sirens but continued on through the city's east end.
The court was told he drove "well in excess" of the speed limit, with his passenger estimating he was going at 80mph.
On hearing this, one of Mrs Laurie's family in court said: "She didn't stand a chance."
Prosecutor Mr Niven Smith said Bennie's friend "repeatedly asked" to be let out, but he "ignored her requests".
Bennie went on to speed through a red light and had to dodge other cars.
The fatal crash occurred at a junction between Edinburgh Road and Springboig Road.
Just before the crash, Mr and Mrs Laurie been been dropped off in a minibus from the wedding and were getting into a black cab to take them to their home in Easterhouse.
The couple were not wearing seatbelts and Mr Laurie was initially standing up, trying to place his wife's flowers from the wedding on a seat.
Mr Niven Smith then explained: "Just as the taxi turned into Edinburgh Road, Bennie's vehicle came across the junction through the red light and collided with the taxi."
The cab spun and smashed into a pole. Mrs Laurie suffered fatal head and chest injuries as a result of the crash.
Her husband and the taxi driver had to be rescued by fire officers. Bennie's friend also had to be freed from his car.
Bennie was questioned by police and "became extremely upset" when told how serious the crash was.
Tests revealed he had 71mg of alcohol in 100ml of blood at the time of the incident. The legal limit is 50mg.
Bennie, of the city's Shettleston, also pleaded guilty to drink driving and having no insurance.


A teenager has admitted throwing a stone at a taxi, leaving a 77-year-old woman with a fractured skull.

The 17-year-old boy said he was drunk and targeting taxis in Birmingham on 25 May.
He appeared with three other youths at Birmingham Youth Court on Monday, where he admitted wounding.
The others, two aged 16 and one 15, were convicted of wounding. All four were convicted of conspiring to damage taxis.
The victim was in the back seat of the vehicle as it drove along Bellevue Avenue, Edgbaston.
She was injured when the stone smashed through the glass and hit her.
She was left with multiple fractures and severe bruising to her eye.
The court heard at least three taxis were hit that night, with Â£1,600 damage caused.
The youths were arrested six weeks after the attack.
In a witness statement to the court, the victim, who does not want to be named, said: "We shouldn't have to put up with this sort of violence.
"If the brick had hit the taxi driver, we could have all been killed."
The teenagers, all from Birmingham, will be sentenced on February 3.


Scientists trying to clean up space junk are considering fitting giant lasers onto the International Space Station (ISS) to blast the rubbish.

Media playback is unsupported on your device
11 May 2015 Last updated at 08:45 BST
Parts of satellites and spaceships have been floating around space since the first space mission in 1957.
According to Nasa there are around 20,000 bits of junk whizzing around our planet.
Now scientists are concerned this rubbish could damage important satellites in space.
So could mega lasers fixed onto the ISS be an option?
Ricky's been finding out...


An inquest into the death of the Manchester suicide bomber heard how he was identified by DNA, fingerprint and dental records.

Salman Ramadan Abedi, 22, detonated a homemade device in the foyer of Manchester Arena following an Ariana Grande concert on 22 May.
The five-minute hearing was adjourned until 1 December, pending the police investigation.
Twenty-two people were killed in the arena attack.
No members of Abedi's family were present at court, which was sitting at Manchester Town Hall.
A full inquest will be heard once the police investigation into the attack has been completed.
The court heard Abedi died of "multiple injuries" when he detonated an improvised explosive device.
He was later identified by genetic markers and his bank card that was found nearby, the court heard.
The inquests for the victims were opened with a minute's silence on 9 June and adjourned until November.
Coroner Nigel Meadows said the victims' inquests, at Manchester Civil Justice Centre, would be adjourned until 24 November and this was a "holding date" which could be moved if the police investigation was still ongoing.
The hearing on 9 June was shown a photograph of each of the victims and told of their injuries. Those who died were aged between eight and 51.
A map of where 19 of those killed in the foyer was also shown to the hearing.  The court heard a further three - John Atkinson, Georgina Callander and Saffie Roussos - died later in hospital.
Some of those who died were standing very close to the bomber, with others as far as 20m (66ft) away.
A further 116 people were injured in the attack.


A post-mortem examination is due to take place on a company director shot dead during an attempted robbery.

Akhtar Javeed was killed when masked men raided his fast food and drink warehouse in Digbeth, Birmingham. He was found lying in the street.
West Midlands Police believe the shooting, at Direct Source 3 Ltd on Wednesday evening, was targeted.
Mr Javeed's family said he was an "honest" man who valued his family more than anything else.
He was in Birmingham to run the warehouse so he could provide for his family and he was planning to move back to London soon, they said.
Officers have been examining CCTV footage to try to identify the two gunmen who fled the scene.
They have refused to comment on claims 56-year-old Mr Javeed, a father of four, may have followed the raiders out of the building before being shot.
More on this story and others from Birmingham and Black Country
Ch Supt Andy Parsons said officers were alerted by a 999 call from staff inside the business premises.
It is not known what type of a firearm was used and fingertip searches and forensic testing have been taking place at the scene.
The force has declined to confirm whether anything was taken during the attempted robbery. It is believed other staff were on the premises at the time of the raid.
Mr Javeed worked five days a week in Birmingham before returning to his home in West Ham, east London, where he lived with his wife and family.
Norman Khan, 28, a car salesman, said he saw him lying on the ground in a pool of blood.
He said: "All his face was full of blood and there was blood on the floor. There were three guys standing there, I think they knew him."
Mr Javeed's death is the third gun death investigated by West Midlands Police since October.
There has been a spike in gun crime in the city in recent weeks with 41 arrests made this year for gun-related crime and 19 firearms have been seized.
Acting Det Ch Insp Martin Slevin has appealed for witnesses or information about the suspects, saying the shooting happened at happened at a time when people may have been leaving for work.


The funeral of Winnie Johnson, mother of Moors murder victim Keith Bennett, has taken place at a Manchester church.

Mrs Johnson, 78, died on 18 August without being able to fulfil her last wish of giving her son a proper burial.
After being diagnosed with cancer last year, Mrs Johnson appealed again to killer Ian Brady to reveal the location of Keith's body, without success.
More than 200 people attended the service, held at St Chrysostom's Church, Victoria Park.
The hearse included floral tributes reading 'Gran' and 'Mam', with a smiling photo of Winnie on top of the coffin.
A book of condolence opened at the church, with a private burial taking place following the service.
Keith was one of five children murdered by Ian Brady and Myra Hindley between 1963 and 1965.
The then 12-year-old was abducted on 12 June 1964, and was the only victim whose body has never been found, despite several large-scale searches of Saddleworth Moor.
During the service, hymns The Old Rugged Cross, Lord Of All Hopefulness and The Lord Is My Shepherd were played.
Elizabeth Bond, a friend of Mrs Johnson, gave a eulogy calling her a "woman ahead of her time".
She said: "Her mother was a great influence in her life, and when she became a mother herself she described it as the best thing that she ever did.
"Sadly in 1964, Keith was taken away from his family and Winnie became more and more of a public figure under the tagline - Keith Bennett's mother.
"I don't want us to forget that Winnie was so much more."
She added: "I hope you are playing bingo with the angels like you said you would and all the ones you loved are by your side when you shout house."
Floral tributes at the funeral included wreaths from Greater Manchester Police and her local bingo club.
Assistant priest Father John Grant, said Winnie was a regular face at St Chrysostom's Church.
"The abiding memory is of her arriving and leaving church in the electric scooter and she used to come in the side door, scoot across, park up and into the front pew," he said.
"At the end of every Sunday service she would go and light a candle for Keith.
"We have commended her into God's care, we have prayed that she will be at peace, we have prayed that she is reunited with Keith."
The day before Mrs Johnson's death, police said they were looking at claims Brady had revealed details about Keith's grave to his mental health advocate, Jackie Powell, from Carmarthenshire, south Wales.
Mrs Johnson's solicitor John Ainley said she had not known about the latest development as "she wasn't capable of accepting it".
Teresa Walsh, who helped Winnie search Saddleworth Moor for any signs to where Keith's body might be, attended the service.
She said: "She was a very strong lady, she loved her family.
"She just never gave up looking for Keith, she just wanted to find her son, that's all she wanted, to find him and lay him to rest."
A fund has been started to provide a memorial to Mrs Johnson inside the church and a community garden at the side of the building.


Fourteen people have been killed and wounded 21 at a social services centre in California after two people entered a social services centre and began firing at a group of county health workers on Wednesday.

Ten victims are still being treated at two hospitals after the shooting and officials are investigating a motive. But police have described how Syed Rizwan Farook, 28, and Tashfeen Malik, 27 had an arsenal of weaponry in their home.
Here is a look at the numbers behind the US' latest mass shooting.
14
people dead in initial shooting at Inland Regional Center
21 people injured
2 police officers injured
While some individual family members have come forward to confirm the loss of their loved ones, police have not named all 14 killed in the attack. Officials are still notifying relatives.
65-75
rounds fired by Syed Farook and Tashfeen Malik during initial shooting
1600 bullets found on couple after they died in gun battle with police
More than 3,000 rounds later found inside their home
While inside the Inland Regional Center, the two suspects fired dozens of shots, but had vastly more ammunition on hand.
Bombs and bomb-making tools
3
pipe bombs attached together left at Inland Regional Center, but failed to detonate
12 pipe bombs found at attackers' house
100s of tools found at home police say could be used to construct more bombs
In addition to large numbers of rifle and handgun rounds, Farook and Malik had a number of already assembled pipe bombs and elements for even more in their home.
deadliest
mass shooting since Sandy Hook Elementary School (2012)
6th Deadliest since 1949 (14 - same number of deceased as 1986 post office attack)
33 Number of people killed in deadliest mass shooting incident overall (Virginia Tech, 2007)
Virginia Tech remains the deadliest single-day shooting in the US but this attack is not far from that distinction, matching the number of killed in a 1986 post office shooting (not including deaths of perpetrators).


Muslims have spent the past month abstaining from eating and drinking from dawn until sunset.

In the intense summer, that can be a challenge for many - but it can be particularly difficult for top footballers trying to keep in peak physical condition.
Borussia Monchengladbach and Guinea winger Ibrahima Traore is one of those who has been trying to balance playing and training with fasting.
He told BBC World Service's World Football programme he has found it intensely difficult - so hard that on some days he has to break his fast.
"It's not easy - we are training so hard and it is so difficult," he said.
"But when a Muslim does a job that is really difficult, and he has to eat or to drink in order to do his job well, he is allowed not to do Ramadan.
"When we have two training sessions, I don't do it. But when we have one training session, or a free day, then I can do Ramadan.
"But with the weather and the training it is not easy at all."
Traore said that the importance of the month for Muslims makes it very difficult for him personally to not fully partake in Ramadan.
However he explained that there are other options for Muslims who are faced with this challenge, such as making a donation to the poor.
And he added that while Monchengladbach's coach Lucian Favre supports his right to choose how Traore observes his religion, he does have concerns.
"He says everybody has to decide for themselves - but as a coach he thinks of my health," Traore explained.
"It's not the fact that he minds that I do Ramadan but he would prefer me not to do it because he says it can be dangerous."
Traore also spoke about his personal view of his religion, and in particular his anger at the actions of Islamist militants.
"We hear a lot about Islamists, but those people are not Muslims - they are not what Islam is about," he said.
"Islam is about faith, and living together. It's a religion where we follow the rules. But I know that I'm a free-minded man, and I'm open.
"I do have fun with people from other religions - my best friend is Jewish. So that can say everything about me.
"It's my religion and I'm really proud of it, but I don't want people to confuse Islam with Islamist (militants)."
This is a big time for Traore and Monchengladbach - they are back in the Champions League group stages having finished third in the Bundesliga last term.
Traore explained that this was the reason he is continuing his break from international duties with the Guinea team.
"For the moment I have made the decision not to go, so that I can concentrate on my club," he said.
"It's a really big commitment. But most people don't know that - they think that it's easy.
"When I started the season with Monchengladbach I was starting every game. But then when I had to go to the qualifiers for the Africa Cup of Nations, I came back too late to training or to the game, I started to play less and less. People don't understand that."


Apple has rejected accusations from Russia's state competition watchdog that it fixed iPhone prices.

The Federal Anti-Monopoly Service (FAS) said it was investigating "signs of price-setting coordination" among iPhone resellers following a complaint from a member of the public.
Apple told Reuters it did not control its products' pricing.
"Resellers set their own prices for the Apple products they sell in Russia and around the world," it said.
A citizen told the FAS that the iPhone 6s and iPhone 6s Plus, which went on sale in Russia in October 2015, were priced identically across all 16 major Russian retailers.
Five of the retailers have denied the claims.
The FAS said in a press release it suggested the price-setting was coordinated by Apple, leading to obligatory recommended prices.
"As the preliminary investigations showed, since the start of the sales of iPhone 6s and iPhone 6s Plus, the majority of resellers have fixed and maintained for a certain period of time the same prices for them. Besides, the anti-monopoly authority has identified similarities in the resellers' prices for other Apple smartphones," it added.
The service, which reports to the Government of the Russian Federation, has the power to impose fines on companies it deems to be behaving anti-competitively.
Apple could face a fine of between 1 million rubles ($15,400 ; Â£11,796) and 5 million rubles, lawyer Oleg Kolotilov from law firm Kulkov, Kolotilov & Partners told the Moscow Times.
The FAS has been contacted for comment.
Apple temporarily stopped selling its devices in Russia in December 2014 after the rouble's value became too volatile.
The previous month it had increased the prices of iPhones, iPads and other products by 20% after the weakened currency left its products cheaper in Russia than the rest of Europe.
Last year a US federal appeals court ruled that Apple conspired with publishers to fix the prices of e-books, resulting in the prices of some titles rising from $9.99 to up to $14.99.


Uzbekistan is voting to elect a new president following the death of Islam Karimov, the only leader the country has known since the fall of the Soviet Union.

He turned the country into one of the most repressive states in the world.
The acting president, Shavkat Mirziyoyev - who has also held on to his position as prime minister - will almost certainly win.
Uzbekistan has never had free and fair elections, and it is common for the incumbent to receive more than 90% of the vote.
Although Mr Mirziyoyev is running for the first time, being acting president gives him access to so-called "administrative resources" - which are often used to guarantee a landslide victory on polling day.
The three other candidates pose little challenge, even though two of them competed during the last election in 2015.
The head of the Senate was supposed to become the interim leader after the death of Mr Karimov. But he opted out in favour of Mr Mirziyoyev - illustrating who holds real power.
The leaders of neighbouring countries have also openly supported Mr Mirziyoyev's candidacy.
Islam Karimov's eldest daughter, Gulnara Karimova, was once among the most powerful people in the country, and regarded as a possible successor to her father.
But she fell from grace several years ago, when US and European authorities launched a corruption probe against her. Uzbekistan's prosecutors also named her in a separate investigation.
In the aftermath, she disappeared from the public eye. Some local media even reported that she has been poisoned and buried in an unmarked grave.
But her son, in a recent interview with the BBC, denied the rumours and claimed that she is still under house arrest in Tashkent.
Islam Karimov Jr told BBC Uzbek that the authorities may try to "eliminate" Ms Karimova by poisoning her.
"They are not interested in freeing her since they will have to answer a lot of questions then," he said.
Local media reports also suggest that the sons-in-law of would-be president Shavkat Mirziyoyev have begun taking over businesses belonging to the family - in this case, from the husband of Karimov's other daughter, Lola Tillayeva-Karimova.
BBC interview: 'Show the world my mum is alive'
To boost his popularity, Shavkat Mirziyoyev has reversed some of the unpopular policies adopted during the rule of Islam Karimov, and has begun improving tense relations with neighbouring countries.
He proposed and signed laws that have a clear populist agenda - on fighting corruption, improving protection of citizens' rights, and simplifying business registration.
He also suggested liberalising currency transactions - one of the most hated policies - as people cannot freely exchange currency in Uzbekistan.
But critics say these changes are just temporary moves to help Mirziyoyev gain legitimacy.
Maintaining the current repressive system would ensure that he stays in power, in the same way Islam Karimov remained as president for nearly three decades.
Once Mr Mirziyoyev fully consolidates power, analysts believe that he will use fear and coercion more openly in order to secure his presidency from any potential rivals.
However, there could still be some economic changes. Uzbekistan wants to attract foreign investment - which would help to ease social discontent.
The peaceful transition since the death of Islam Karimov suggests the political elite have already reached agreement. It is not in their interest to change a system they benefit from.
And one of Mr Mirziyoyev's possible rivals, deputy Prime Minister Rustam Azimov, has kept a low profile in recent months.
Once Mr Mirziyoyev is elected, his influence will only grow.
If his potential opponents do not act before the vote, then they are unlikely to openly challenge him after it.


Ten finalists have been chosen in a $10m (£6m) competition to develop a real-life "tricorder" - the medical scanner used in the Star Trek series.

The Qualcomm Tricorder X Prize, launched last year, challenges anyone to develop a wireless device capable of detecting a range of diseases.
The technology employs sensors and imaging to measure vital signs and diagnose conditions non-invasively.
X Prize officials said the technology was now "fact, not science fiction".
The 10 finalists come from a range of backgrounds, including universities, medical device manufacturers and tech start-ups.
One research team is backed by Nasa and the Bill Gates Foundation, while another is made up of engineering students at Johns Hopkins University in the US.
They now have until the middle of next year to develop workable prototypes of their devices in the hope of winning the prize.
It is not clear what any of the devices will look like yet, but Dr Erik Viirre, technical and medical director for X Prize, told the BBC that they ranged from conventional smartphones with attachments to more "utilitarian-looking" devices that "get the job done".
One of the finalists, the Silicon Valley-based start-up Scanadu, showcased a handheld scanner at the CES conference this year.
It works with smartphone software to monitor vital signs such as heart rate and blood pressure, but it is not clear how such a device would address the more complicated task of diagnosing disease.
To win the $10m, the device is expected to be able to monitor vital signs as well as accurately diagnose 16 different conditions, including anaemia, tuberculosis and diabetes.
The technology must be presented in a portable device that can deliver the information in a user-friendly way, so that patients can self-diagnose without the help of doctors.
Anil Vaidya, founder of SCANurse, one of two UK-based finalists, told the BBC his device would not look exactly like the Star Trek device.
It "won't have electrodes sticking out that you will have to touch", he said, but would have a wearable and a handheld component.
He said the device would employ a range of sensors to take readings from a patient's skin and even their breath, alongside cameras to take visual readings.
Health professionals and medical engineers point out that much of the relevant technology is already available.
For example, it is already possible to use light sensors to gather information about blood flow and oxygen levels without taking a blood sample.
Sensors are also able to pick up gases in breath that may indicate certain diseases, while electrocardiogram (ECG) readings are regularly used to assess heart health.
Mr Vaidya also said his design would use cameras to take visual samples of symptoms to aid diagnosis.
The challenge, he said, was to bring the technology together in one portable device.
"Opinions on whether it can be done or not depend on who you're talking to," he told the BBC.
"Among many physicians the feeling is it can't be done. I come from a medical engineering background, which is quite different."
Dr Viirre, of the X Prize, said the winning device could have a role in the developing world, in areas where people have little or no access to medical services.
But Dr Richard Seabrook, head of business development at the Wellcome Trust health charity, said there was "a debate to be had" on whether such devices should be placed in the hands of patients, stressing the need for training and education.
But he said doctors may welcome the opportunity to offload simpler cases to computers.
"If it creates time for them to spend on more complex cases, then that would be a good thing," he told the BBC.


Leicester Tigers players have let themselves down and must take responsibility for their poor form, according to lock Ed Slater.

Tigers sacked director of rugby Richard Cockerill at the start of the month and have continued to struggle, with their losing run now standing at four games.
They are fifth in the Premiership and out of Europe following a crushing 34-3 defeat by Racing 92.
"Players need to be more accountable," Slater told BBC Radio Leicester.
"Looking at that Racing game you would say that we were not really as a group.
"We have to take on a lot more responsibility - particularly after some of the things that have happened over the last three weeks."
Leicester's Champions Cup exit, coupled with being 18 points adrift of Premiership leaders Wasps, means their season is in danger of ending trophy-less again.
Slater revealed that hooker Tom Youngs, in particular, was furious with last week's display against Racing and told his team-mates so.
"Tom's message at half-time was pretty clear," the 28-year-old added.
"I haven't seen him lose it like he did. It was pretty much straight from the heart and deserved. I don't think there was much more to be said after he gave everyone a blast.
"It didn't quite get the reaction because the game was far gone by then but it said a lot about what was happening on the pitch and the way we were playing.
"It is really frustrating at the moment but there have been a few changes and it is probably going to take a bit of time to see that come out in performances."
Tigers face Glasgow at Welford Road on Saturday in their final Champions Cup match of the season.


Researchers have shown off a "magic carpet" that can detect falls and may even predict mobility problems.

Beneath the carpet is a mesh of optical fibres that detect and plot movement as pressure bends them, changing the light detected at the carpet's edges.
These deflected light patterns help electronics "learn" walking patterns and detect if they are deteriorating, for instance in the elderly.
The carpet was demonstrated at the Photon12 conference in Durham, UK.
The optical fibre network at the heart of the effort makes use of the same types of fibres that transmit data to homes and across oceans, in which light bounces along the fibres' length.
To make them sensitive to the deflection caused by pressure, the researchers carved grooves in the fibres along their length so that the bouncing of the light was less efficient at the point where pressure was applied.
Detectors at the carpet's edge convert the light into electrical signals which are then analysed by a computer. That analysis borrows heavily from technology developed at the university for use with medical scanners.
The developers of the network, based at the University of Manchester in the UK, see its primary use in care homes or hospital wards, to raise an immediate alarm in the case of a fall.
The fibres can be easily retro-fitted beneath existing carpet, and future applications could stretch to private homes as well.
The researchers' aim is to address the significant number of falls experienced by the elderly; it is a leading cause of mortality among over-70s and falls cost the NHS millions each day.
They believe their system can be used to build up a profile of movement patterns for given individuals, so that any deterioration in mobility can be monitored and possibly used as an early warning system for falls.
"Falls are a really important problem for our ageing society," said Chris Todd, professor of of primary care and community health at the university's department of nursing.
"More than a third of older people fall each year, and in nursing and residential homes it is much more common than that.
"So being able to identify changes in people's walking patterns and gait in the natural environment, such as in a corridor in a nursing home, could really help us identity problems earlier on."


Nico Rosberg cut Lewis Hamilton's championship lead to just two points with victory in the Italian Grand Prix.

Hamilton lost what had looked set to be a certain win with a poor start after he had taken pole position with a scintillating performance on Saturday.
The world champion dropped to sixth at the first corner and despite fighting back to second and closing on Rosberg he could not challenge for the win.
Hamilton told his Mercedes team the poor start was his own fault.
Hamilton had been on pole position by nearly 0.5 seconds - a massive margin on a track with relatively few corners and his dominance left Rosberg curt in his media exchanges afterwards.
But the race fell into the German's lap when Hamilton stuttered away from the line and was swamped by the cars behind him, with Ferrari's Sebastian Vettel moving into second ahead of team-mate Kimi Raikkonen, Williams' Valtteri Bottas and Red Bull's Daniel Ricciardo.
As Rosberg streaked away into a race of his own at the front, Hamilton started his recovery, passing Ricciardo at the second chicane on lap two and Bottas into Turn One on lap 11 before the Ferraris pitted out of his way on their two-stop strategy.
Hamilton, like Rosberg on a one-stop plan, was 15 seconds behind his team-mate by the time he was into second place on lap 17.
He closed that to 12.2secs on lap 23 before Rosberg made his single stop the next time around, Hamilton following him in a lap later.
After the stops, Hamilton reduced the gap to 9.1secs by lap 31, with 22 to go, before Rosberg responded and it became clear that Hamilton did not have enough pace while keeping his tyres in shape to catch up before the end of the race.
Mercedes' superiority was underlined by the fact that they were in a race of their own despite running what every other team believed was a slower strategy.
All the other leading teams were on a two-stop and while there was excitement with some battles here and there, it was a largely mundane race.
The Ferraris were comfortably quicker than anyone else in the chasing group, and the excitement in the closing laps was around a battle for fifth between Bottas and Ricciardo.
Ricciardo, choosing super-soft tyres for the final stint rather than the softs on the Williams, closed in after their final stops and pulled a brilliant overtaking move from a long way back into Turn One at the start of lap 47 to take the place.
Behind them, Ricciardo's team-mate Max Verstappen was also on a charge and he grabbed seventh from Force India's Sergio Perez with five laps to go.
Outside the top 10 points positions, Jenson Button put in a superb performance a day after announcing that he would not be racing in F1 next season.
Button has signed a new two-year contract with McLaren but is to take a break from F1 in 2017. The team have an option on him for a return in 2018, but the deal may well end up being a precursor to a full retirement.
Button started 14th, two places behind team-mate Fernando Alonso, but a terrible start left him 20th on the first lap, while the Spaniard moved up to ninth.
Read more: 'There were days Button was untouchable'
Despite that, Button had caught Alonso by lap 43, passing him into the first chicane for 12th place at the start of lap 44.
Alonso tried to come back at Button, but the Englishman had too much pace and pulled away.
Button managed to close on Alonso by running longer on his soft tyres after his first stop, which allowed him to fit the super-softs for his final stint while Alonso had the softs.
He caught Haas driver Romain Grosjean with two laps to go but the Frenchman was able to hold him off.
Button will come to some races in 2017, do simulator work and keep himself current while Alonso and Belgian Stoffel Vandoorne race for McLaren.
Alonso's contract is up at the end of 2017 and he has said he will decide next year whether to extend his career beyond that.
"It was all down to the start," said Rosberg. "I had an awesome start and that made the win."
Referring to the championship, in which there are seven races remaining, Rosberg said: "The race is on. It's always going to be a great battle and I look forward to what is to come."
Hamilton said: "It was the start. I knew my engineers would be worried and nervous of how the start went.
"I don't really know what happened. I will try to understand later. It's hard to overtake here. Live to fight another day."
Italian Grand Prix results
Italian Grand Prix coverage details
Media playback is not supported on this device


Northampton Town earned a comfortable victory against Morecambe to move two points clear at the top of League Two.

James Collins scored on his home debut from a Joel Byrom free-kick, before John-Joe O'Toole doubled the lead when he deflected Ricky Holmes' shot into the back of the net.
Rod McDonald headed a third for the Cobblers and Alex Kenyon had a shot over the bar for the Shrimps.
Paul Mullin scored a consolation goal for Morecambe from a loose ball.
The Cobblers have now won five straight league matches, while Jim Bentley's Morecambe saw their four-game unbeaten streak ended as they fell to 14th.


Women's Super League One club Bristol City have signed England Under-23 midfielder Millie Turner from Everton ahead of the 2017 Spring Series.

The 20-year-old, who started her career at Manchester United's Centre of Excellence, joined Everton in 2013.
"This was the perfect move for me, I needed a fresh start and this will be the perfect place for me to develop," she told Bristol City's club website.
The Vixens were promoted back to the English top flight in 2016.
Manager Willie Kirk added: "Millie's arrival is going to create good competition for places and I imagine she will be a prominent member of the team."


The Himalayan region of Kashmir has been a flashpoint between India and Pakistan for over six decades.

Since India's partition and the creation of Pakistan in 1947, the nuclear-armed neighbours have fought two wars over the Muslim-majority territory, which both claim in full but control in part.
Today it remains one of the most militarised zones in the world. China administers parts of the territory.
Reporting on Kashmir from both India and Pakistan mainstream media is deeply politicized and reflects the tension between the two countries.
Media in Indian-administered Kashmir are generally split between pro- and anti-secessionist. Local journalists work under strict curfews and also face threats from militant groups. Internet access is sporadic and text messaging services are regularly blocked.
In Pakistani-controlled Kashmir, the media are used mainly for propaganda purposes, mainly to highlight the alleged human rights violations in Indian-administered Kashmir.
Key dates in Kashmir's history:
1846 - Creation of the princely state of Kashmir.
1947-8 - Kashmir's Maharaja hesitates over whether to join India or Pakistan, prompting the two countries to go to war over the territory.
1949 - Kashmir is partitioned between India and Pakistan, with a ceasefire line agreed.
1962 - China defeats India in a brief war in a dispute over the Aksai Chin border area.
1965 - Second Indo-Pakistan war over Kashmir ends in a ceasefire.
Rise of Kashmiri nationalism: Jammu Kashmir Liberation Front is founded with the aim of forming an independent state through the reunification of Indian-administered and Pakistan-administered Kashmir.
1972 - Simla Agreement: India and Pakistan formalise the ceasefire line as the Line of Control as part of new resolve to negotiate differences after their war which ended in Bangladesh splitting from Pakistan.
1980-90s - Kashmir insurgency: Discontent over Indian rule leads to armed resistance, mass protests and a rise in Pakistan-backed militant groups. Ten of thousands of people are killed.
1999 - India and Pakistan engage in a brief conflict after militants cross the Line of Control into the Indian-administered district of Kargil.
2008 - India and Pakistan open trade route across the Line of Control for the first time in six decades.
2010 - Anti-India protests in Indian-administered Kashmir in which over 100 youths are killed.
2015 - Political watershed: Elections in Jammu and Kashmir see India's ruling Hindu nationalist BJP party emerge as a major political player in the region for the first time when it forms part of a coalition government with the regional Muslim People's Democratic Party.


Two former army corporals have been cleared of raping a female colleague at a barracks in Germany.

Jeremy Jones and Thomas Fulton, both 28, denied raping Cpl Anne-Marie Ellement, from Bournemouth, in 2009.
The men both insisted the sex with Ms Ellement, who died in 2011, was consensual.
A seven-strong panel at the military tribunal in Bulford Court Martial Centre, Wiltshire, found the pair not guilty after an eight-day trial.
The panel heard the men, who have since left the Army, engaged in a "threesome" with Cpl Ellement in the early hours of 20 November 2009 after a drinking session.
Ms Ellement was later said to have been found nearly naked and crying outside her accommodation.
Following the verdicts, Judge Jeff Blackett told the defendants their conduct towards Cpl Ellement had been "disgraceful".
He said: "This is not a moral judgment and I make no comment upon sexual practices involving more than two people.
"But the way you treated Anne-Marie after your encounter was extremely unpleasant.
"After engaging in sex, you effectively discarded her while you decided to go off to town without a thought for how she might be feeling or how she might get back to her accommodation safely.
"For Mr Fulton to call her those very unpleasant names including the word 'slag' was truly dishonourable.
"You may have grown up in the seven years since this incident and I hope you will never act in such an appalling way again."
Mr Jones, formerly of Close Protection Unit Royal Military Police Operations Wing, and Mr Fulton, formerly of 174 Provost Company 3 Royal Military Police, were initially arrested on suspicion of rape but the case was dismissed.
They were later charged with rape in 2015. They have been found not guilty of all charges by the court martial board.
After the verdicts Emma Norton, a lawyer for Liberty which represents Cpl Ellement's family, said: "Anne-Marie was entitled to have her allegations investigated while she was still alive.
"As the judge himself noted in very strong terms, this case should have been heard five years ago.
"The family welcome the judge's comments about the extremely unpleasant and dishonourable conduct of the defendants. They share the judge's concerns about the culture within the Royal Military Police."
Cpl Ellement took her own life aged 30 at Bulford Barracks, near Salisbury, Wiltshire on 9 October 2011.


Buildings and roads have been hit by flooding in Norwich.

The fire service said it had been called to more than 25 incidents following the flooding caused by heavy rain.
One woman, who lives on Carrow Road, said the water was about an inch away from her front door.
"My house is OK," she said. "I've got the towels down in preparation, but sadly the council weren't able to supply us with any sandbags."
Norfolk Fire and Rescue Service advised people not to wade into flood water, owing to the risk posed by hidden objects.
Flood water in sewers raised a drain cover near St Stephen's roundabout on the inner ring road and a car wheel jammed in the cavity.
Traffic was brought to a standstill for nearly an hour as firefighters tried to free the vehicle.
Outside the city centre, flood water made driving difficult in Sprowston and Rackheath.
People living on Hawthorne Avenue in Hellesdon grew frustrated that their road is flooded again.
One resident, Stacey Connerty, said: "Yet again it is left to local people to risk their safety to save their property and vehicles from flooding.
"This problem arises every time there is heavy rain.
"Despite repeated requests to highways and council to remedy this situation, to date nothing has been done."
There were also reports of flooding on the B1145, between Cawston and Aylsham, in Norwich Road, near to the junction with Allison Street in Marsham, at Crossdale Street in Cromer and on the A1062 at Hoveton.
Ch Insp Chris Spinks said: "Motorists should drive to the conditions and allow extra time for their journeys home.
"Standing water and heavy rainfall makes driving conditions hazardous and I would urge motorists to reduce speed, use headlights and increase the distance between you and the car in front."


Bagged salad can fuel the growth of food-poisoning bugs like Salmonella and make them more dangerous, a study says.

University of Leicester scientists said the moist environment combined with nutrients leaching out of chopped leaves created the perfect breeding ground for bacteria.
The researchers said they were shocked at the way the bacteria thrived, even in the fridge.
They advised people to eat bagged salad on the day they bought it.
Despite their wholesome nature, fresh green leaves and salad foods are often involved in food poisoning.
An outbreak that affected more than 2,000 people across Europe in 2011 was traced back to bean sprouts and this year, officials in England traced an outbreak that killed two people back to bags of rocket leaves.
Washing salad and vegetables: What is the best technique?
Studies have shown that salad can carry bacteria, but the research team showed the bag made things much worse.
Bags are often moist to help keep the salad crisp and fresh and the plants have often been chopped into individual leaves for convenience.
The study showed sugars, proteins and minerals escaped from the cut leaves into the water in the bag.
"That's a reasonable amount of nutrients if you're a bacterium," said researcher Dr Primrose Freestone.
The study, published in Applied and Environmental Microbiology, showed that an initial contamination of 100 Salmonella bacteria would increase to 100,000 within five days.
"That's more than an infectious dose," Dr Freestone said.
She said she was also "shocked" that the bugs did so well in the chilled environment in the fridge.
The studies showed that Salmonella did especially well in bags containing spinach, while E. coli loved rocket leaves.
Dr Freestone told the BBC News website: "Juices that naturally leach from the leaves have the potential to increase the growth of any pathogen that might be present and establish them so strongly that washing wouldn't be enough to eradicate them.
"Don't be alarmed, we still eat bagged salad, but don't keep bagged salad any longer than you need to, we normally buy it on the day we eat it.
"Buy the bag with the best sell-by date, avoid lots of mushed leaves and if it's inflated then don't use it."
There are also suggestions that the bacteria become more dangerous in the bags.
A genetic analysis of the Salmonella showed they had gained the mutations that would help them to infect people.
Dr Freestone told the BBC: "We did see bacteria whose behaviour had turned more to virulence.
"I think the bacteria are making a molecular mistake and mistaking chemicals in the salad leaf for ones in the host."
Giannis Koukkidis, who also worked on the project, added: "Despite a number of published reports on improving the microbiological safety of salad leaf production, very few studies have investigated the behaviour of Salmonella once the leaves have been bagged.
"Salmonella also attaches more aggressively to the inner surface of salad plastic bag when it comes in contact with salad juices."
Dr Jeri Barak, from the Food Research Institute at the University of Wisconsin-Madison, said: "It would be fair to conclude that if Salmonella is present in salads, it might grow to infectious doses.
"The rates of produce that have been found to be contaminated are between 0%-3%.
"Consumers should treat bagged salads as temperature-sensitive food products, like milk and ice-cream."
Dr Kimon Karatzas, from the University of Reading, said: "Avoiding fresh produce is not a solution, but if possible, it would be preferable to buy uncut fresh produce over chopped, and to always wash it before you eat - even the ones that are already washed.
"Furthermore, keeping these foods in the refrigerator is important."
Follow James on Twitter.


Scientists from Swansea University have discovered a possible treatment for the motor neurone disease ALS.

The debilitating disorder - a rare condition affecting the nervous system - came to prominence in 2014 with the Ice Bucket Challenge.
Now researchers, led by Prof William Griffiths, have found that anti-cholesterol drugs could be used to help patients.
There is currently no cure for ALS, also known as Lou Gehrig's disease.
Drugs only modestly slow the progress of the disease in a fraction of patients.
Prof Griffiths, of the university's medical school, has published a survey that shows people with ALS have higher levels of cholesterol in the fluid surrounding the brain than people without the disease.
"We think that people with ALS are unable to dispose of cholesterol from [their] brain efficiently, leading to the presentation of the disease," Prof Griffiths said.
He added he was optimistic the research would provide a way to diagnose ALS, and "a route to development of a new drug" to treat it.
There are about 240 people known to be living with motor neurone disease, or MND - of which ALS is the most common form - in Wales, and about 5,000 across the UK.
Dr Brian Dickie, director of research development at the MND Association, said: "We are delighted to see the results of this fruitful collaboration between the universities of Swansea and Oxford has identified a promising new disease marker in ALS patients.
"The development of effective treatments for neurological diseases, including ALS, will continue to struggle without greater understanding of the changes occurring within the central nervous system.
"These new findings may assist with earlier diagnosis of the disease and potentially open up new avenues to future treatment."