Scott Malone scored a dramatic late equaliser as Fulham earned a point against Sheffield Wednesday.

Fernando Forestieri fired in from 20 yards after playing a one-two with Barry Bannan to put the Owls ahead.
Kevin McDonald headed a corner powerfully over the bar for Fulham, while both Gary Hooper and Forestieri had chances to make it 2-0.
Fulham turned up the pressure and equalised when Malone slammed home at the back post in the 91st minute.
Carlos Carvalhal's Wednesday side had lost their previous two Championship matches but started brightly against their in-form opponents, who had beaten Huddersfield and Brentford in their previous two games.
The visitors took the lead after 10 minutes when Forestieri's powerful shot beat Whites goalkeeper David Button and they could have been further ahead had Hooper not spurned a one-on-one and the ever-lively Forestieri hit the target minutes later.
The Italian striker dragged another attempt across goal in the second half before Tom Cairney mustered the home side's first shot on target in the 77th minute.
However, Fulham dominated the closing stages and were finally rewarded when left-back Malone arrived late into the box to smash in a goal which kept Slavisa Jokanovic's side in eighth, one place above Wednesday.
Fulham manager Slavisa Jokanovic: "It was a fair result, we played very well and I'm really satisfied with some parts of the game.
"We did not surrender in any moment. They played the better football and closer to three points. If we had played this game last year we would have lost 3-0.
"We did not offer our best performance but it was a small step where we are learning to compete."
Sheffield Wednesday manager Carlos Carvalhal: "We performed very well. Their team are in good shape, had won the last game 5-0 here and were in good momentum.
"We scored one goal and probably should have killed the game. We are not happy with the scoreline, we deserved more; we felt we achieved one point but lost two.
"I'm very happy with the team and the personality we showed. The Fulham fans will realise just how tough a team Sheffield Wednesday are."
Match ends, Fulham 1, Sheffield Wednesday 1.
Second Half ends, Fulham 1, Sheffield Wednesday 1.
Attempt saved. Fernando Forestieri (Sheffield Wednesday) right footed shot from outside the box is saved in the centre of the goal. Assisted by Adam Reach.
Attempt blocked. Fernando Forestieri (Sheffield Wednesday) right footed shot from the left side of the box is blocked. Assisted by Barry Bannan.
Attempt missed. Tomas Kalas (Fulham) right footed shot from the centre of the box misses to the right following a corner.
Corner,  Fulham. Conceded by Keiren Westwood.
Sone Aluko (Fulham) wins a free kick in the attacking half.
Foul by Glenn Loovens (Sheffield Wednesday).
Attempt blocked. Fernando Forestieri (Sheffield Wednesday) right footed shot from outside the box is blocked. Assisted by Steven Fletcher with a headed pass.
Goal!  Fulham 1, Sheffield Wednesday 1. Scott Malone (Fulham) left footed shot from the centre of the box to the bottom left corner.
Attempt missed. Stefan Johansen (Fulham) left footed shot from outside the box misses to the left. Assisted by Chris Martin.
Attempt saved. Chris Martin (Fulham) right footed shot from outside the box is saved in the bottom right corner. Assisted by Stefan Johansen.
Foul by Floyd Ayité (Fulham).
Jack Hunt (Sheffield Wednesday) wins a free kick in the defensive half.
Keiren Westwood (Sheffield Wednesday) is shown the yellow card.
Attempt missed. Scott Parker (Fulham) right footed shot from the right side of the box misses to the left. Assisted by Chris Martin with a headed pass following a corner.
Corner,  Fulham. Conceded by Kieran Lee.
Attempt blocked. Floyd Ayité (Fulham) right footed shot from a difficult angle on the left is blocked. Assisted by Sone Aluko.
Floyd Ayité (Fulham) wins a free kick on the left wing.
Foul by Jack Hunt (Sheffield Wednesday).
Foul by Scott Parker (Fulham).
Steven Fletcher (Sheffield Wednesday) wins a free kick in the defensive half.
Steven Fletcher (Sheffield Wednesday) is shown the yellow card for a bad foul.
Floyd Ayité (Fulham) wins a free kick in the defensive half.
Foul by Steven Fletcher (Sheffield Wednesday).
Scott Parker (Fulham) wins a free kick in the defensive half.
Foul by Kieran Lee (Sheffield Wednesday).
Delay over. They are ready to continue.
Delay in match Fernando Forestieri (Sheffield Wednesday) because of an injury.
Scott Parker (Fulham) is shown the yellow card for a bad foul.
Foul by Scott Parker (Fulham).
Fernando Forestieri (Sheffield Wednesday) wins a free kick on the left wing.
Foul by Chris Martin (Fulham).
Tom Lees (Sheffield Wednesday) wins a free kick in the defensive half.
Foul by Denis Odoi (Fulham).
Fernando Forestieri (Sheffield Wednesday) wins a free kick on the left wing.
Attempt saved. Tom Cairney (Fulham) left footed shot from outside the box is saved in the centre of the goal. Assisted by Scott Parker.
Attempt blocked. Floyd Ayité (Fulham) right footed shot from the centre of the box is blocked. Assisted by Denis Odoi with a cross.
Substitution, Fulham. Scott Parker replaces Kevin McDonald.
Substitution, Fulham. Denis Odoi replaces Ryan Fredericks.


Google UK's privacy policy manager held a senior role at the UK's data privacy watchdog during the time of its original probe into Street View.

A
          freedom of information request
 revealed that Stephen McCartney left the Information Commissioner's Office to join Google in November 2011.
The ICO had been criticised for its initial investigation - which has since reopened - into data privacy breaches.
The ICO said Mr McCartney "played no part" in the investigations.
In its own statement, Google said: "We don't comment on individual employees."
Rob Halfon, Tory MP for Harlow, told the Guardian that the news was a "shocking revelation".
"Now it seems they [the ICO] have had a cosy relationship with the company they have been investigating," he
          told the newspaper
.
Mr McCartney was head of data protection promotion at the ICO where he had worked,
          according to his LinkedIn profile
, since 2004.
During this time, the ICO conducted an investigation into allegations that Google had knowingly gathered personal data while collecting photographs as part of its Street View mapping project.
The ICO ruled that there had been a "significant breach" of the Data Protection Act, but opted not to fine the company, a decision heavily criticised by campaign group Privacy International and others.
Of the 2010 investigation, deputy information commissioner David Smith told the BBC: "We spent less time searching than others did. If we had searched for days and days we would have found more."
It later emerged that several Google staff had been told that data was being collected, prompting the ICO to reopen its inquiries.
After joining Google, Mr McCartney shared email correspondence with ICO officials discussing issues relating to the ongoing probe.
The documents, obtained by campaigner Peter John, showed Mr McCartney had outlined what he had said were "significant errors" in the media's reporting of the issue in an email dated 4 May 2012.
Christopher Graham, the information commissioner, responded to the email with "thanks for this, Stephen".
In a statement released today, the ICO said: "The published correspondence between Google and the ICO clearly shows that Stephen McCartney was treated like any other organisation's representative,  with his emails receiving nothing more than a polite acknowledgement.
The spokesman added: "ICO employees continue to be legally bound by a confidentiality agreement after they leave the organisation, as part of the Data Protection Act.
"Stephen Eckersley, the ICO's Head of Enforcement, continues to investigate Google's actions with regard to the Street View project."
Mr Eckersley is currently considering a response to
          Google's most recent letter
 on the matter which was received by the ICO last month.


Arsenal have signed Bayern Munich and Netherlands international striker Vivianne Miedema from the start of the 2017-18 Women's Super League season.

Miedema, 20, has won 48 caps for the Netherlands and was part of their squad for the 2015 Women's World Cup.
She scored 14 goals in 22 league games for Bayern this season as they finished second in the Frauen Bundesliga.
"She is seen as one of the best young strikers in the world," manager Pedro Martinez Losa said.


A rare 1933 penny - one of only four in existence - has sold for a world record price of £72,000 at a London auction.

The coin sold is known as a "Pattern" version, as it was presented as a prototype, but never went in to production.
It is the first time that any of the Pattern coins have come up for auction.
Commenting on the record price, a spokesperson for the auction house, AH Baldwin and Sons said: "No other bronze coin has ever come close."
"I think the last was in the region of £15,000," he said.
The coin was bought by a private collector. It is not known whether it will be kept in the UK, or taken abroad.
A further seven pennies, known as currency coins, were produced in 1933 for ceremonial purposes, but none has recently come up for sale.
It is thought the currency coins could be worth twice as much as the Pattern versions.
The reason so few were produced was that the Royal Mint had a surplus of penny coins in 1932, and did not need any more in the following year.
Most of the 1933 pennies are in private hands, although one of the Pattern versions is in the Royal Mint's museum. Others, it is thought, have been buried under buildings as part of a "time capsule".
The eventual price achieved was nearly double initial estimates.


Bristol Rovers defender Tom Lockyer has signed a new undisclosed-length deal with the League Two club.

The Wales Under-21 international has made 40 appearances in all competitions for the club so far this season.
Centre-back Lockyer, 21, began his career at Rovers and has played in 140 competitive games since 2012.
Left-back Lee Brown has also signed a new contract extension for Rovers, who are fourth in table, two points off an automatic promotion place.


RBS has finally reached a £200m settlement with investors who say they were duped into handing £12bn to the bank during the financial crisis.

The RBS Shareholders Action Group has voted to accept a 82p a share offer.
The amount is below the 200p-230p a share that investors paid during the fundraising in 2008, when they say RBS lied about its financial health.
A settlement means that the disgraced former chief executive of RBS, Fred Goodwin, will not appear in court.
A spokesman for the RBS Shareholder Action Group said: "The directors met last night to consider the legal advice and took the decision that this matter will not now go to court."
He declined to comment on whether the decision was unanimous.
Shares in RBS fell 1.1% to 256.85p.
Shortly after the rights issue in 2008, RBS was bailed out with £45bn taxpayers' money. The state still owns more than 70% of the bank.
In contrast, the government recently sold its last remaining stake in Lloyds, which took over HBOS during the crisis before receiving £20bn of rescue funds from the state.
RBS declined to comment.


The first of the missing Nigerian schoolgirls to be rescued from Boko Haram militants has met President Muhammadu Buhari at his villa in Abuja.

Amina Ali Nkeki, 19, was found with a baby by an army-backed vigilante group on Tuesday in the huge Sambisa Forest, close to the border with Cameroon.
She was one of 219 pupils missing since being abducted from a secondary school in the town of Chibok in April 2014.
Mr Buhari said he was delighted she was back and could resume her education.
"Continuation of her education must be a priority of government," he said, after meeting Ms Nkeki.
Mr Buhari's spokesman has said the young woman will also be helped to reintegrate into society.
Africa Live: More on this and other news stories
Who is Amina Ali Nkeki?
After her escape from Boko Haram, Ms Nkeki had an emotional reunion with her mother.
On Wednesday the 19 year old and her four-month-old baby were flown by the Nigerian Air Force to Maiduguri - the capital of Borno state - before going on to Abuja the following day by presidential jet.
She had been held captive for more than two years by militants fighting to establish an Islamic state.
Ms Nkeki was reportedly recognised by a fighter of the civilian Joint Task Force (JTF), who was on patrol as part of a vigilante group set up to fight Boko Haram.
She was with a suspected Boko Haram fighter who is now in the Nigerian military's custody. Named as Mohammed Hayatu, he said he was Ms Nkeki's husband.
Chibok rescue revives Twitter campaign
Inside Mbalala, the town that lost its girls
Chibok abductions: What we know
On patrol in the Sambisa forest
Hosea Abana Tsambido, the chairman of the Chibok community in Abuja, told the BBC that Ms Nkeki had been found while searching for firewood in the forest area surrounding the Boko Haram settlement.
"She was sayingâ€¦ all the Chibok girls are still there in the Sambisa except six of them that have already died."
During the April 2014 attack, Boko Haram gunmen arrived in Chibok at night and raided the school dormitories, loading 276 girls on to trucks.
More than 50 managed to escape within hours, mostly by jumping off the lorries and running off into roadside bushes.
A video broadcast by CNN in April this year appeared to show some of the kidnapped schoolgirls alive.
Fifteen girls in black robes were pictured. They said they were being treated well but wanted to be with their families.
The video was allegedly shot on Christmas Day 2015 and some of the girls were identified by their parents.
The Chibok schoolgirls, many of whom are Christian, had previously not been seen since May 2014, when Boko Haram released a video of about 130 of them gathered together reciting the Koran.
The abduction led to the #BringBackOurGirls campaign, which was supported by US First Lady Michelle Obama and Pakistani activist Malala Yousafzai.
Another campaign group working for the girls' release, the Pathfinders Justice Initiative, said there was a "renewed sense of energy and hope and excitement" among families of the girls after Ms Nkeki's escape.
Executive director Evon Idahosa told the BBC World Service's Newsday programme that there was now "no excuse" for the Nigerian government not to step up efforts to free the remaining captives.
"They [the families] are excited but they have also been disappointed so much in the past, particularly during the Jonathan administration [from 2010-2015]."
'Boko Haram took my children'
Town divided by Boko Haram legacy
Who are Boko Haram?


Martin Canning says that the 8-1 defeat by Celtic last month "hurt" and his Hamilton Accies players are ready to "rectify" their performance on Friday.

The player-manager insists that they are relishing facing up to Celtic again when the reigning champions visit New Douglas Park.
"Nobody's dreading it," Canning said; "We're looking forward to it.
"When you've played in a game like that, you want to get back out there and put it right."
Canning admits that his players did not perform well in Glasgow and paid the price for that but also stressed that the heavy defeat is now behind them.
"You want to show that you're better than you were in the previous game," he said.
"I'm pretty sure the boys are looking forward to the game and going out to do that.
"There will be no extra pressure put on them from me to say, 'listen, we need to go and make up for that game'.
"I would assume the pressure will come from themselves and knowing they're better than they were that night."
Accies have only won once in their last 12 outings, although that 1-0 win away to fellow relegation candidates Kilmarnock came after their trouncing in Glasgow.
"We know that on the night we didn't compete well enough," said Canning.
"We covered the miles, we ran the yards, but we didn't make it hard enough for Celtic. That's something we need to do tomorrow night.
"If you let Celtic get up into their stride then you're running the risk of something like that happening.
"That's something we need to make sure we're well aware of and we compete better than we did.
Although Kilmarnock remain in second bottom spot, they are only a point behind Accies and Motherwell, but Canning is not ready to change his philosophy.
"We will do what we always do and set out to try to win the game," he added.
"Against a team of Celtic's quality, you're maybe having to do more defending than you do against other teams, but we've got to get the balance right."


Pakistan's Supreme Court has lifted a travel ban on former President Pervez Musharraf who is awaiting trial for treason and other charges.

The ruling could allow him to travel abroad to seek medical treatment.
The charges relate to the former general's imposition of a 2007 state of emergency and the assassination of former PM Benazir Bhutto the same year.
Mr Musharraf, 70, denies all the charges and has called them politically motivated.
He was treated for chest pains in January and says his condition is now much worse. He was in hospital on Monday and Tuesday with spinal problems.
A spokeswoman promised Mr Musharraf would return to Paksitan if he were allowed to travel.
Profile: Pervez Musharraf
Will Pakistan let Musharraf off the hook?
Dismissing an appeal by government lawyers, the Supreme Court upheld a high court judgement removing the former military ruler from a list of people barred from leaving the country.
However, it said it was up to the federal government and the special court trying him to decide whether to pass "any appropriate legal order for regulating his custody or movement", Dawn newspaper reports.
Mr Musharraf seized power in a coup in 1999, when he was army chief. He remained president until 2008, when a democratically elected government came into power.
He left the country soon afterwards to live in self-imposed exile in Dubai and London.
However, he returned in 2013, hoping to lead his party into elections - but was disqualified from standing and found himself fighting an array of charges relating to his time in power.
He faces a murder claim for failing to prevent the assassination of Ms Bhutto. Other charges relate to events in the same year - the state of emergency, his suspension of judges during that period and the death of a cleric during a siege at the Red Mosque in Islamabad in 2007.
In January he was cleared over the 2006 killing of Baloch rebel leader Akbar Bugti, his first acquittal in the cases in which he is charged.


Newport Gwent Dragons head coach Kingsley Jones says flanker Ollie Griffiths has a "very good chance" of being picked by Wales.

Griffiths impressed despite Dragons' 21-16 Pro12 defeat by Scarlets at the Principality Stadium.
Wales face Tonga and Samoa in June and Jones believes it will be the perfect opportunity for Griffiths to gain international experience.
"I'd like to think they'll have a look at him," Jones said.
"Justin Tipuric and Sam Warburton I think will go with the Lions so there is an opportunity for him.
"There's lot of good young number sevens. James Davies is an excellent player as well and has a massive influence on the game for the Scarlets.
"Ellis Jenkins has been there and has got a bit of experience. Maybe there's a chance to look at Oliver with Ellis or with James."
Jones described 22-year-old Griffiths as the "complete open-side flanker"
"He's got something special. He's got leadership qualities and is very mature for a young kid of 21," he added.
Media playback is not supported on this device
"He needs to perform at that level consistently and the thing that's going to help him get into the Welsh squad is the team being successful.
"When this team is fourth in the league there will be a lot of players going with the national team but ultimately we need to be more consistent.
Jones was left frustrated despite his side picking up a losing bonus point in the Judgement Day defeat by Scarlets.
"Losing is not acceptable and it's not great but ultimately I couldn't have asked for much more I felt," Jones said.
"I'm proud of the players. They followed the game plan, our lineout game was good and we defended well against a very good Scarlets team.
"There was a period which broke our spirit a little bit with [Adam Hughes'] yellow card and a couple of decisions went against us and we failed to deal with that.
"The scrum was the difference and losing [prop] Lloyd Fairbrother was a disappointment early in the game and it was always going to be a challenge against a good Scarlets scrum.
"But the way we came back at the end is the most promising thing and we scored and excellent try which I think we deserved."
Dragons are away to Edinburgh in their next game on Friday, 28 April and host Cardiff Blues in the final game of the season on 6 May.
Former Wales captain Jones says the target is to finish the season above Edinburgh, who are currently one place above them in ninth spot.
"It's been a tough season and hasn't been a great season, we know that," Jones added.
"We've been 10th for many years and there's an opportunity still to finish ninth.
"Edinburgh are in the same boat as us and we've got to go there believing we can win and we fancy our chances against the Blues.
"We've got to bring that application, intensity and belief and that's the challenge for this group and if we do that we've got a chance of turning this season into finishing ninth."


East Midlands Ambulance Service (Emas) has failed to hit targets to reach the highest priority calls for a fifth year running.

Emas responded to 71.6% of Red 1 calls and 70.2% of Red 2 calls in 2014/15 - missing the 75% target.
Red 1 calls involve life-threatening injuries, while Red 2 calls include serious breathing difficulties.
Emas chief executive Sue Noyes said the service was improving and had hit the 75% target in April and May.
It also missed a target of reaching 95% of both Red 1 and Red 2 calls in 19 minutes by 2.2%.
Ms Noyes said calls to the service were up by 22%, almost 200 more each day, in December and January.
"The figures that we've had for last year reflect the fact that we had that extraordinary winter in terms of demand," she said.
"What we did see last year was that we did deliver all three targets for the first quarter of the year; now that was the first time we've delivered that in five years," she said.
She said the service was mid-table in a list of national ambulance target figures, which are due to be released by the Department of Health on Wednesday.
Emas said it was recruiting 200 extra frontline staff, and investing Â£3.9m in new ambulances.
The ambulance service covers Derbyshire, Leicestershire, Rutland, Lincolnshire, Northamptonshire and Nottinghamshire, and handled more than 643,115 emergency calls in 2014/15.


The pinny, hair curlers and headscarf of Coronation Street legend Hilda Ogden have sold for Â£4,200 at auction.

They were made famous by actress Jean Alexander, who played the battleaxe between 1964 and 1987.
She kept hold of the items, which were among a number of personal possessions sold off earlier, after quitting Weatherfield's cobbles.
Film producer Trevor Beattie bought them and said he may use them in a film called Hilda Ogden: The Movie.
Mr Beattie, from Birmingham, said: "It is a really important piece of popular culture.
"It is like Charlie Chaplin's moustache or Muhammad Ali's boxing gloves."
"I'm hoping to open an exhibition of cultural icons and we may be making Hilda Ogden: The Movie so we'll see."
He tweeted: "I just bought Hilda Ogden's headscarf, pinny and rollers. As you do."
Auctioneer Mike Litherland said the "iconic" outfit was "part of media history". "She wore them in nearly every episode," he added.
Alexander's nieces Sonia Hearld and Valerie Thewlis organised the sale after their aunt died last year.
The pinny and curlers were found inside a wardrobe.
Alexander's childhood teddy bear Ambrose, which she received on her fourth birthday, was sold for Â£260 despite missing an eye.
The auction took place at the Royal Clifton Hotel in Southport.
As well as portraying the downtrodden cleaning lady, Alexander had roles in Last of the Summer Wine and Z Cars.


The government's decision to put a former journalist in charge of ensuring major public jobs are handed out on merit has been criticised by MPs.

The Commons Public Administration Committee said it was concerned Peter Riddell, formerly of the Times, had the right experience for the job.
It also fears he may not get the powers he needs to prevent cronyism.
The man he replaces as commissioner for public appointments, Sir David Normington, welcomed him to the role.
"I know Peter to be a person of integrity and independence who will want to ensure that public appointments are made on merit," said the former top civil servant.
But he added: "I fear he may have his work cut out."
Sir David told The Financial Times government ministers, including David Cameron, had been pushing for Conservative donors and ex-MPs to be given key jobs at the head of public sector organisations since the general election.
And he warned that plans to change the way public appointments, such as directors of the Bank of England or the board of regulators like Ofcom, are made could see "a return to the days of political and personal patronage".
Mr Riddell, a former head of the Institute for Government think tank, was last month quizzed about his suitability for his new role by the Public Administration and Constitutional Affairs Committee (PACAC).
In a report, the committee said it endorsed his appointment, but added that "this endorsement is not unqualified", saying it planned to be a "critical friend" to the new commissioner.
Committee chairman, Conservative MP Bernard Jenkin, said: "While there was no formal objection recorded to his appointment, some members of PACAC expressed their concern that Mr Riddell lacks experience of working in a large organisation, or in a regulated environment, or in making or supervising major appointments."
These concerns were "amplified" by plans to reduce the powers of the commissioner to directly influence recruitment decisions, added Mr Jenkin.
The Public Accounts Committee said it was concerned planned changes to the system, proposed by the businessman Sir Gerry Grimstone, would lead to the "politicization" of major public appointments.
The Grimstone proposals would allow ministers to choose a candidate who the interview panel had deemed "below the line of appointability", although the decision would have to be justified publicly, or ditch the formal recruitment process altogether to secure a specific candidate.
The government says the planned changes will increase transparency and accountability and will include strong safeguards.


Funding of £100,000 has been approved for a project to turn Inverness Castle's North Tower and its look-out into a new tourist attraction.

The money has been allocated from the Inverness Common Good Fund.
Highland Council has set aside £200,000 and Highlands and Islands Enterprise could provide £60,000 to the £360,000 project.
The rest of the 19th Century building would continue to be used as a sheriff court.


A US clothing company has been mocked on social media for selling a pair of $425 (£330; €390) jeans complete with "crackled, caked-on muddy coating".

The jeans are described on Nordstrom's website as typifying "rugged, Americana workwear" and "hard-working action".
But critics on Facebook are scathing of what the company describes as its new design of "heavily distressed" jeans.
"You can achieve the same look for a lot less by rolling in your backyard or gardening," one commentator said.
The company says the jeans are made with muddy coating "that shows you're not afraid to get down and dirty".
Among those to join the chorus of Facebook criticism of what Nordstrom calls its Barracuda Straight Leg Jeans is Discovery Channel Dirty Jobs presenter Mike Rowe who described them as "looking like they have been worn by someone with a dirty job" but "made for people who don't."
"The Barracuda Straight Leg Jeans aren't pants," Mr Rowe wrote.
"They're a costume for wealthy people who see work as ironic - not iconic."
Mr Rowe's followers on Facebook were equally damning of the jeans - made for Nordstrom by New York-based luxury denim brand PRPS.
"Give me your jeans, and for a mere 200 bucks, I'll one-of-a-kind customise them for you... You can choose from horse barn mucker, chicken coop builder, tractor grease, potters clay... $600 and I'll let one of the goats chew a hole on the leg," one contributor said.
Are skinny jeans really harmful?
How the birthplace of denim is making jeans again
The huge success of Colombian butt-lifting jeans
But not everyone was dismissive of the new jeans.
"What's the beef about buying mud jeans?" one commentator on Twitter said.
"If someone can afford $400 for a pair of dirty jeans, so what? Go for it!"
Last month Nordstrom advertised another unusual pair of trousers in the form of jeans with "knee windows" on its website - but for a far cheaper $95 (£74; €87) .


An Indian airline has suspended five crew members who let a Bollywood star sing over its public address system - sparking a row on social media.

Singer Sonu Nigam entertained his fellow passengers with some of his popular numbers on a Jet Airways Mumbai-Jodhpur flight last month.
The airlines said on Friday that the crew had been "taken off from flight duty" after an inquiry.
However, Nigam criticised the decision, saying it "lacked common sense".
"To suspend crew members for asking me to sing on the address system, when the seat-belt signs were off, and no announcements were to be made, is nothing less than punishing someone for spreading happiness," he said.
Nigam's mid-flight performance on 4 January was filmed by those on board, and subsequently went viral on social media.
This month, India's aviation watchdog - the Directorate General of Civil Aviation - told the airlines to suspend the crew members after conducting an inquiry, news reports said.
The watchdog said that crew members had been distracted by the performance, "thus reducing their preparedness/alertness", and that "the frequent movement of the dancing crew may have affected the aircraft's centre of gravity during flight and created turbulence", the Times of India reported.
Allowing the use of mobile phones in the air was also "against present regulation", the paper added.
Jet Airways said in a statement: "All cabin crew on the flight have been taken off flight duty for enquiry and corrective training to reinforce strict adherence to operating procedures."
Sonu Nigam's name began trending on Twitter in India on Friday, with many criticising the decision to suspend the crew members.
However, others supported the airline, saying the performance could have endangered the flight.
It is not the first time a mid-air performance has sparked controversy in India.
In 2014, the aviation watchdog asked another private airline to suspend two of its pilots because they had allowed the crew to dance to a Bollywood number to celebrate the Hindu festival of Holi.


There are now just six months to go until a new-style 'Metro Mayor' is elected to lead three million Midlanders in the region's 'core' conurbation stretching from Wolverhampton to Coventry and including Britain's second biggest city, Birmingham.

On the face of it there is more than a hint of irony about the Government's insistence in the name of local democracy on a leadership model that has been rejected by Coventry's voters and by Birmingham's, twice.
Our one Midlands city which has tried it, Stoke-on-Trent, went on to scrap the role after just seven bitterly divisive years.
So why now are ministers so determined to revive the concept?
Because, they tell us, this time it is not the reheating of an old idea but the introduction of a new one.
Our experience of the elected mayors debate so far has been confined to the boundaries of individual local authorities.
This new political animal's remit will roam across the entire metropolitan area comprising seven councils: Birmingham, Coventry, Dudley, Sandwell, Solihull, Walsall and Wolverhampton.
The council leaders on the West Midlands Combined Authority (WMCA) were left with no option but to stomach the 'Metro Mayor' once it became clear that if they didn't, there was no way ministers would grant them the full  'devo max' deal. The then chancellor, George Osborne, said at the time it was imperative to have a high-profile "focal point for accountability".
I am told many councillors still have serious misgivings about the elected mayor. Mr Osborne said later he had "sweated blood" to make it happen. Inevitably, critics warn that this concentrates too much power in the hands of one person and that what they call the new "Super Council" is bound to trample all over local identities.
But supporters of the devolution deal say far from uploading powers away from local authorities, the new authority and the mayor will download from Westminster and Whitehall more genuine clout for decision-makers than they have ever enjoyed before.
Housing, planning, transport, the economy and skills are, they argue,  responsibilities which run across and beyond individual local authority areas, with up to Â£40m worth of spending power coming their way for each of the next 30 years.
Whatever the outcome, questions are bound to be asked about the democratic legitimacy of this new role.
The mayoral election will take place on Thursday, 4 May 2017. On that day there will be none of the usual council elections in those seven metropolitan councils which make up the mayor's electoral area. It is what they call "a fallow year". So the mayoral turnout will not benefit from any collateral effect of people turning up at the polling stations principally to vote for  their local authorities but also available to vote for the mayor while they are there.  A low turnout, say under 25%, would leave the new mayor facing tough questions about their electoral mandate.
Add to this the ten other councils who have signed up, or are about to do so,  as 'non constituent' members of the combined authority. Their agreements are not exclusive. They can join other partnerships on similar terms. By the same token they have less of a say in the running of the WMCA than the seven constituent members and, crucially, no vote in the mayoral election.
In theory, the mayor's remit extends only to that metropolitan area. But the realpolitik inevitably means the mayor will project their influence across the region, including those non-constituent members: Cannock Chase, North Warwickshire, Nuneaton and Bedworth, Redditch, Rugby, Tamworth, Telford and Wrekin, Stratford-on-Avon, Shropshire and Warwickshire.
And then there are some significant questions about what exactly the powers of the mayor will or should be: too powerful or not powerful enough?
Undaunted, four parties have nominated their candidates:
Cllr James Burn, Green Party
Beverley Nielsen, Liberal Democrat
Sion Simon MEP, Labour
Andy Street, Conservative
Much may yet depend on whether or not UKIP do in the end decide to field a candidate. Their highest-profile West Midlander is the Dudley-based MEP Bill Etheridge. In a Sunday Politics interview with me he categorically ruled  himself out: he told me the 'metro mayor' was a kind of devolution where power was devolved from the people to the elite.
We'll see.
And there will be more on this in this weekend's Sunday Politics  Midlands at 11.00 on BBC One on Sunday morning, 6 November 2016.


It's a record his younger, more famous brother would be proud of were he ever to achieve it again in singles: three back-to-back Grand Slam finals.

Andy Murray did it three years ago; at Wimbledon 2012, the US Open a few months later and then the 2013 Australian Open.
One win out of three ain't bad, at that level, is it?
Of course Murray, competitive to his last breath, would then play his joker: there was also an Olympic final in among that lot.
London 2012 was sandwiched gloriously in between the heartbreak of losing to Roger Federer at the All England Club and the tears of joy when he defeated Novak Djokovic in the Big Apple some weeks later.
Now, at the Australian Open, big brother Jamie is also going for one out of three.
His transformation into one of the most consistent doubles players on the tour has been as sudden as it has been surprising.
Not due to any lack of talent. There can scarcely be a player, in doubles or singles, with better hands at the net, or a better feel for a volley.
It's more a case that this overnight breakthrough has taken nearly nine years.
Lest anyone forget, Jamie Murray was the first of that clan to win at Wimbledon, and claim a Grand Slam title. 2007, anyone?
Without resorting to a search engine, or reading any further: can you remember who his playing partner was?
If it seems a long time since those pictures in the south-west London sunshine of a smiling Jamie Murray holding up the mixed doubles trophy with Jelena Jankovic, that's because it is.
The elder Murray brother was 21 and seemingly had the tennis world, and the paparazzi, at his feet.
He won three titles that year with his then doubles partner, Eric Butorac, and was Wimbledon champion on the hallowed grass in the mixed.
The next year, he reached another Grand Slam mixed doubles final, this time with Liezel Huber. They lost, but surely great things lay ahead.
They duly arrived, although I'm not sure anyone thought they would take the best part of a decade to materialise.
After Butorac, Murray changed partners regularly.
They're a promiscuous lot, those doubles players, in that sense. Other silverware did sparkle along the way; it shouldn't be forgotten that Murray is the proud owner of 14 doubles titles on the world tour.
However, his inability to maximise his talent, or find a reliable long-term playing partner, proved frustrating.
So frustrating that, a few years ago, after his ranking plummeted and the wins dried up, he was seriously contemplating quitting the sport altogether.
Then along came a relatively unknown Australian called John Peers.
They didn't make too many headlines when they began to play together in early 2013.  The titles soon arrived and, more significantly, they became contenders at Grand Slam level, reaching the quarter-finals of the US Open that year.
The pair's perseverance paid off in 2015. They made the final at both Wimbledon and the US Open and also qualified for the end of season World Tour finals, another first for Jamie.
Before that tournament got under way at London's O2 arena, the pair made a surprise announcement. They were splitting up.
Their two Grand Slam finals had both ended in defeat and, as he chose Brazil's Bruno Soares as his new partner, there was a sense from Jamie that the move was tied to his target of actually winning one of the big four men's doubles trophies.
His chances of doing that were done no harm whatsoever in late November. The pretty, medieval, Belgian town of Ghent will now forever be synonymous with one of the great moments in Scottish and British sporting history.
Andy's role in that delightful David Cup triumph is rightly highlighted. Over four ties, he played 11 matches and won them all, a brilliant British backbone for the team, designed and developed in Dunblane.
As, of course, was Jamie, whose part in the proceedings should neither be overlooked nor underestimated. Andy's eight singles wins by themselves wouldn't have been enough.
He needed a giant-killing from James Ward in Glasgow when the Americans came to town.  And he needed a dependable doubles partner from the quarter-finals onwards.
Cue his elder sibling.
Brothers-in-arms, the Murrays mauled France and Australia before famously beating Belgium in their own backyard.
For Jamie, it was top-class, pressure-piled, expectation-laden sport, played out in front of an international TV audience of millions, alongside his global superstar brother.
Oh, and with all of Britain hoping he could help end a 79-year wait for the Davis Cup.
Jamie Murray stepped up to the plate admirably. He played consistently well last year, especially in the Davis Cup. It seems that competition draws out the best in both the Murray brothers.
He capped his best-ever year on tour by helping Britain win its first Davis Cup since 1936.
The penny had finally dropped for the first Murray child that there was a chance to fulfil his true potential, having watched wee brother Andy fulfil his at the Olympics, the US Open and Wimbledon.
Together, they fulfilled their Davis Cup destiny.
An experience that could prove priceless for the rest of Jamie's career, as he knows he can cut it against the best at the very highest level of the sport.
This weekend, in the famous surroundings of the Rod Laver Arena, he has another chance to vindicate his decision not to call time on his tennis career.
Third time lucky? There's every chance against the veterans Daniel Nestor and Radek Stepanek.
But, even if it doesn't happen this time, I get the impression Jamie Murray has a few more Grand Slam finals left in him yet.


"It's impossible for me to say anything that makes sense," says Valeria Collina Kadhija, the mother of one of the London Bridge attackers, Youssef Zaghba.

Ms Collina sits on the floor of the front room of her house.
The lights are off and the shutters are lowered. In the corridor, there is a shelf of hardback books including works by Hemingway and George Bernard Shaw. A certificate on a sitting room wall honours a relative's service in World War Two against Nazi Germany. There are no family photos on display.
Valeria Collina is a convert to Islam. She wears a veil, and speaks quietly to a group of journalists sitting around her.
"From 2016 there were problems with my son - the fact that he was stopped at Bologna airport [whilst trying to get to Istanbul and then to Syria].
"He would say to me 'Come on Mum let's go live in Syria. Over there, they have a pure Islam.'
"I told him 'Are you crazy? I have no intention of going to Syria with you or with anyone. I'm fine in my country.'"
Third London Bridge attacker named as Youssef Zaghba
London attack police find body in river
In pictures: Crowds join vigil to honour victims
London attack: Who were the attackers?
After he was stopped at Bologna airport in March 2016, Italian police began to monitor her son, a move that Valeria Collina supported. The Italians shared information with other countries' intelligence agencies, including the UK's.
But Youssef Zaghba, a 22-year-old Italian of Moroccan origin, was still allowed to travel abroad.
"After the whole incident at Bologna airport, I told him 'You have to be perfect now. You can't look at strange things on the internet or meet strange people.' But then when he went back to Londonâ€¦"
Her voice trails off.
In London she says that her son found work at an Islamic news channel. But she was worried that he sounded very sombre.
"He looked serious in his pictures. So I joked 'Can you send me a picture where you're smiling more?'"
They spoke for the last time two days before he carried out his attack.
"It was a very sweet phone call. We spoke normally."
After she heard of the London Bridge attack, Ms Collina tried to get in touch with her son. But she could not get through.
"We sent a friend of his to look for him at the house [in London]. At that point I thought that my son was afraid that the police would try to connect him to the attack. I thought he was in hiding."
But on Tuesday the police came to her house to inform her that her son was one of the attackers. She thinks now of the families of her son's victims.
"I can understand from my own personal tragedy. But I don't even have the courage to compare my pain to theirs. It's as if I were ashamed to say 'I'm also a mother, I'm also suffering.'"
She supports the decision of imams in the UK not bury her son.
"I understand that it is right and dutiful in this moment to give this strong signal. We need this kind of gesture. Because the press accuses Muslims of not taking a stand. But we do."
She distances herself from her son's actions.
"It's a horrible thing. It shouldn't have happened and it should never happen again. And I'm going to do everything I can to prevent this. We need more education for young people."
We left her alone, contemplating in the dark.


The founder of a flagship free school in Bradford will stand trial in 2016 accused of fraud.

Sajid Raza, 42, and two other members of staff - Shabana Hussain, 38, and Daud Khan, 43 - will go on trial in June 2016 charged with a number of offences relating to their involvement at Kings Science Academy.
The charges relate to the period between April and August 2011.
Leeds Crown Court heard the trial would last six weeks.
Ex-principal Mr Raza, of Spring Gardens Road, Bradford, faces three charges of fraud, three of false accounting, two of obtaining a money transfer by deception and one of fraud by false representation.
Former head of department Ms Hussain, of Wilmer Road, Bradford, is charged with one offence of fraud by abuse of position and one offence of acquiring criminal property.
Ex-director of finance Mr Khan, of Thornhill Place, Thornbury, is charged with two offences of fraud by abuse of position and three offences of false accounting.
All three are accused of abusing their positions as officers of the academy by making a series of unauthorised and unlawful payments into the personal bank accounts of Mr Raza and Ms Hussain from a grant provided to the school by the Department for Education.
No pleas were entered at the hearing on Friday.
The academy was one of the first free schools to open in September 2011.   It has since become part of the Dixons academy group.


School teachers have renewed calls for maximum legal temperatures in heatwave-hit classrooms as the heat continues.

Some teachers have been reporting temperatures topping 32C (90F) and very uncomfortable conditions in class.
And some schools have been dishing out ice lollies and renting air conditioners to help pupils keep cool.
General secretary of the NASUWT teaching union Chris Keates said such heat makes pupils lethargic, can affect concentration and lead to fainting.
Her union wants to see a statutory maximum temperature of 30C in school classrooms. This would mean staff and pupils being sent home if thermometers went above this.
She said excessive temperatures are a major problem for schools and that most are ill-equipped to cope with them.
She claimed teachers and pupils were sweltering in classrooms with inadequate ventilation and sometimes not even blinds at the windows which can be used to provide some limited shade.
Ms Keates said: "The impact of excessive temperatures on teaching and learning needs be given serious consideration.
"Pupils become extremely lethargic, unable to concentrate and, in some cases, faint.
"Lessons are disrupted by constant requests for time out to get drinks of water or to go outside and many tasks take far longer to perform. Teachers report that the quality of work undoubtedly suffers at such times."
Christine Blower, general secretary of the National Union of Teachers, is also calling for statutory maximum temperatures to come into force.
She said: "Clearly, very high temperatures can affect the ability of teachers and pupils to concentrate and to work effectively, and can cause physical discomfort and illness.
"The NUT will continue to campaign to ensure that 26C is the absolute maximum temperature in which teachers should be expected to work."
One teacher told the NASUWT: "I teach in a classroom with no ventilation, no windows and just two doors which open into other closed areas. When the weather is above 24-25C, and more especially if the humidity remains high, the room is too uncomfortable in which to work.
"Any significant movement results in sweating, it becomes difficult to concentrate and there is a complete loss of enthusiasm to do anything beyond basic childminding."
Meanwhile head teachers have been trying their best to help both staff and children keep cool in schools up and down the country which have not yet broken up for the summer holidays.
Some have taken the precaution of cancelling or rearranging their sports days, while others have been encouraging children to stay in the shade at break times.
Parents are being reminded by text message and email to send their children to school in sunhats and to put on sun cream before they leave home.
One head, Simon Hawley of Colham Manor Primary School in Hillingdon, said ice lollies were being dished out to pupils by catering staff once a day.
And like many other schools he has hired extra air conditioners and is ensuring pupils have constant access to water. He has also relaxed the uniform requirements
A school in Cardiff which was not so willing to bend the rules to allow shorts ended up with a group of Year 10 boys mounting a protest by donning skirts instead of their regulation trousers.


A teenager from Flintshire has been accused of being a "fake" for using a wheelchair to cope with a rare illness.

Esther Lowery, 17, from Holywell, suffers from Ehlers-Danlos syndrome, a genetic condition which means her body tissue is not strong enough to hold her limbs in place.
She calls it an "invisible illness" because the symptoms go unseen by others.
Esther can walk short distances which has led to her being branded a "fraud".
But she experiences "agonising pain" when her elbows, shoulders and knees pop out of their joints up to six times a week.
"When I go out to museums or go shopping and I know it's going to be a long day, I'll use my wheelchair", she said.
"But say if it's just walking to the house from the street, I can make it without crutches or a wheelchair, so I think that's what confuses a lot of people when they see me get out of my chair and start walking.
"I remember walking up a couple of steps once, and when some people saw me getting out of my chair they shouted 'it's a miracle!'
"I was really upset because they have no idea how much pain I'm in on a day-to-day basis."
Esther has made a three-minute documentary to raise awareness about the condition.


Ferrari's Kimi Raikkonen set the pace in final practice at the Belgian Grand Prix as the Mercedes drivers were only fifth and seventh.

Lewis Hamilton was the fastest of the silver cars, despite a mistake-strewn final lap on a weekend when penalties mean he will start from the back.
Team-mate Nico Rosberg, who has a golden opportunity to close the title race deficit, was 0.107secs slower.
Red Bull's Daniel Ricciardo was second fastest, followed by Sebastian Vettel.
Mercedes have so far not shown their true pace on an unusual weekend that has been dominated by Hamilton's engine penalties - which amount to 55 places following three engine changes, meaning he will start right at the back - and problems with tyre choices caused by the unexpected heat.
Spa-Francorchamps is more usually associated with unpredictable and often wet weather, even in August, but this weekend has been baking, with temperatures in the low 30Cs.
That means the tyres are suffering - a problem exacerbated by the fact that greater freedom for the teams in tyre choices than previously this year has meant they have leaned towards softer tyres.
The super-soft tyre has never been brought to Spa before, because of the demands of its many long, high-speed corners.
But Ferrari picked seven sets of the tyre out of their available 13, and only one of the more durable medium.
Mercedes have gone the other way, splitting their choices much more evenly between the super-soft, soft and medium.
That meant, with only four sets of the super-soft available, Mercedes did not use it at all until the final minutes of the session.
It was not immediately clear why Rosberg was 0.768secs off Raikkonen's pace, but Hamilton had a lift in the fast double-left hander at Pouhon and then made mistakes at flat-out Blanchimont and on the entry to the final chicane.
Mercedes executive director (technical) Paddy Lowe told BBC Sport that the team were likely to give Hamilton only the least possible running in qualifying - probably meaning only one run in the first session - because of his penalties.
"We'll probably just run the minimum necessary in qualifying," Lowe said. "We want to give Lewis the strongest possible race from the back and with the maximum number of tyres."
Rosberg, despite his lack of headline pace in the final practice session, is expected to take pole, and there will be a tight battle between Red Bull and Ferrari for best of the rest.
Ricciardo's team-mate Max Verstappen, who was fastest on Friday afternoon, did only two laps on Saturday before being hit by a gearbox problem.
Hamilton is not the only driver with engine penalties.
McLaren's Fernando Alonso, who was 11th fastest and two places ahead of team-mate Jenson Button in the session, has a 35-place penalty and Sauber's Marcus Ericsson 10 places.
Belgian Grand Prix practice results
Belgian Grand Prix coverage details


Work on a £500m waste incinerator near Gloucester is set to begin next summer after the county council voted to allow a developer to begin construction.

The scheme at Javelin Park has been delayed for three years due to a series of legal challenges from campaigners.
Gloucestershire County Council's Conservative cabinet voted unanimously to approve a revised contract, allowing Urbaser Balfour Beatty to build the plant.
It is expected to open in 2019.
Plans for the project were approved by the secretary of state in January, following a public inquiry, despite the plans having been previously refused by Gloucestershire County Council.
A further legal challenge at the High Court by Stroud District Council in July failed to get the decision overturned.


A "twin" of London's Marble Arch marking the end of the A5 road on Anglesey should be moved to public view, a councillor has said.

Admiralty Arch is currently on Salt Island - part of Holyhead port - and is off limits to the public.
Trefor Lloyd Hughes said moving it could benefit tourism in the town.
Landowner Stena Line said it would be "open" to the idea of moving the arch but stressed that heritage body CADW would have the final say.
The Grade II-listed monument, which is also known as the Triumphal or George IV's Arch, was completed in 1824 - three years before its more famous counterpart in London.
Mr Lloyd Hughes said: "It's part of our history, no doubt about that, but 80% of the people on Anglesey don't even know its there.
"It was built in the early 1800s with marble from across the island in Benllech Bay. To move those stones to Holyhead at that time, that must have taken some time and some effort.
"It's a shame that a monument like that is in a place where no-one can go and see it.
"When you go across to Ireland on a boat, you can go close to it but otherwise you're not allowed to go there."
The A5 road stretches 255 miles (410km) from London to Anglesey, and was built by Thomas Telford. It was finally completed in 1826, when the Menai suspension bridge was opened.
A spokesman for CADW said: "Listing does not prohibit the relocation of this structure.
"The proposers of the scheme need to liaise with the owner, and Anglesey County Council who would be responsible for deciding whether listed building consent should be approved."
A spokesman for Anglesey council said: "Planning officers would be happy to provide Cllr Hughes with guidance if he wishes to make a formal listed building consent application.
"Any proposal to move Admiralty Arch would need the support of its owner and a strong supporting justification as the presumption is that the monument is best preserved in its present location."
"If a building consent application is received, we would deal with it in the appropriate manner and CADW would be a consulted as part of the process."


Cardiff Blues have confirmed general manager Billy Millard will leave the region at the end of the season.

Millard rejoined Cardiff Blues in 2015 having been backs coach between 2008 and 201.
The Australian has stepped down from his role to move back to his family's home in Galway, Ireland.
"I have thoroughly enjoyed my time at Cardiff Blues and have so many fond memories.
"Despite the challenging climate I am confident the region is heading in the right direction and wish them every success for the future."
Millard was previously head coach of Melbourne Rebels, Australian Men's Sevens and Sydney University.


Two men have been charged with the murder of a 20-year-old man after a "disturbance" outside a nightclub, police said.

The victim, from Redruth, was found unconscious with head injuries in the Chapel Street area at 02.45 BST on Sunday.
He died in hospital on Monday.
Connor Hammond, 21, of Trenoweth Estate, North Country, and Liam Laing, 21, of Brookside, Chacewater, are due at Truro Magistrates Court on Tuesday.
Detective Chief Inspector Mike West, from Devon and Cornwall Police, said: "Offences like this are exceedingly rare in this area.
"We would like to speak to anyone who witnessed a disturbance outside The Zone night club and anyone who was in the area between 2.30am and 3.30am on Sunday."


Derry's Dr McKenna Cup final defeat by Tyrone came at a further cost with Enda Lynn and Brendan Rogers sustaining serious injuries in the feisty contest.

Media playback is not supported on this device
Rogers required 14 stitches in a facial gash following a challenge by Tyrone's Tiernan McCann seconds after the opening throw-in at Armagh.
Slaughtneil man Rogers had the stitches inserted on Sunday and will almost certainly be out for a number of weeks.
Lynn suffered a suspected broken ankle late in the game after a fine display.
Greenlough club-man Lynn's injury appeared to come after an innocuous challenge but the ailment will almost certainly rule him out for several months and end his hopes of featuring in the Football League which starts this weekend.
Rogers, meanwhile, also looks certain to miss a number of Derry's Division 2 matches which start with Sunday's opener against Fermanagh at Owenbeg.
Slaughtneil player Rogers was named at midfield for Saturday's contest and the match video suggests that he may have been caught by McCann's right elbow immediately after challenging for the initial throw-in.
After the ball was thrown in, McCann comes in from the side and the footage shows the Tyrone man clattering into Rogers although the Red Hand county player appears to be focusing on the ball rather than the Derry midfielder when the contact is made.
Rogers' misfortune is also a blow to Queen's as he would have been in line to play for the Belfast university in the Sigerson Cup opener at Maynooth on Tuesday.
Despite requiring the 14 stitches, Rogers attempted to make light of the incident in a tweet on Sunday.
McCann was the involved in controversy last summer when he theatrically collapsed to the turf after having his hair ruffled by Monaghan's Darren Hughes in the All-Ireland quarter-final at Croke Park.
The Tyrone player's reaction to Hughes' action led to the Monaghan man being sent off.
After the outcry following the incident, McCann was handed an eight-week suspension by the GAA's Central Competitions Control Committee but the ban was later ruled out of order following the Tyrone player's appeal.
In terms of the McKenna Cup decider, the Ulster Council may feel the need to peruse several incidents in the match video, including the second-half fracas which led to two dismissals and Derry manager Damian Barton being ordered to the stand.
That particular incident flared up after a dangerous sliding challenge by Derry forward Daniel McKinless on Tyrone defender Ronan McNamee.
Media playback is not supported on this device
That particular incident flared up after a dangerous sliding challenge by Derry forward McKinless on Tyrone defender Ronan McNamee.
The Tyrone man reacted by pushing over McKinless, and appearing to make contact with the Derry man's throat in the process.
As other players and Barton joined the fray, Tyrone goalkeeper Niall Morgan attempted to pull up McKinless up off the ground and the Derry boss then pushed the Red Hand keeper before, in turn, being jostled by Cathal McCarron.
After order was restored by Cavan referee Noel Mooney, McKinless and McNamee were both handed yellow cards which resulted in the Tyrone man being sent off as he had been cautioned earlier.
Derry boss Barton was also ordered to the stand while Cathal McCarron received a straight red card for his part in the melee.
McKinless was sent off late in normal time after picking up a second yellow card although he was able to rejoin the fray during extra-time, which is regarded as a new game under GAA rules.


Menswear retailer Austin Reed is set to make a return to the high street with 50 new stores, months after it collapsed with the loss of 1,000 jobs.

Edinburgh Woollen Mill Group announced the move as part of a £100m three-year revival plan for the brand.
The Langholm-based group bought the 116-year-old chain's brand from administrators in May.
The first of the new stores are due to open towards the end of next year, including a flagship outlet in London.
Administrators of Austin Reed were forced to shut 120 stores in the summer after they failed to find a buyer for the entire business.
The company, which was founded in 1900, collapsed after struggling with debt and plunging sales.
Edinburgh Woollen Mill, headed by billionaire retail entrepreneur Philip Day, has already relaunched the Austin Reed brand online with a new autumn/winter collection.
A larger spring/summer collection will follow early next year.
The move comes as part of a wider expansion plan announced by Edinburgh Woollen Mill Group, which owns fashion brands Peacocks and Jane Norman as well as the Edinburgh Woollen Mill chain.
It wants to open 200 stores group-wide by early 2018, including the Austin Reed shops, which will create more than 2,000 jobs.
The firm said the move came on the back of rising sales and record profits for the year to 27 February.
Steve Simpson, group commercial director of Edinburgh Woollen Mill Group, said: "With the addition of Austin Reed, which we acquired earlier this year, as well as Country Casuals and Viyella, we aim to continue this organic growth, while always being ready to respond to other opportunities as they arise."
The group, which also owns homewares retailer Ponden Mill and golfing brand Pro-Quip, posted a 2.4% rise in underlying annual pre-tax profits to £90.9m after growing total sales to £576.3m from £562.6m a year earlier.
Bottom line profits fell 14.5% to £89.8m.
The group opened 43 shops in the year to the end of February and now has more than 980 outlets across the UK, as well as concessions and online stores.


Durham fast bowler Mark Wood trained with England at Lord's on Tuesday after being added to the Lions squad as he steps up his recovery from injury.

Wood, 26, has had two operations on his left ankle since injuring it against Pakistan in Dubai in October.
The Ashes winner, who has taken 25 wickets in eight Tests, returned in June for Durham against Sri Lanka A.
England are preparing for the first Test match against Pakistan, which starts on Thursday.
The Lions will play a 50-over tri-series against Sri Lanka A and Pakistan A, beginning on 18 July at Cheltenham.
Meanwhile, Middlesex's Max Holden will lead England under-19s against their Sri Lankan counterparts in a series of two four-day matches and three one-day games.
England Lions squad: Dawid Malan (Middlesex, captain), Daniel Bell-Drummond (Kent), Ben Duckett (Northants), Joe Clarke (Worcestershire), Brett D'Oliveira (Worcestershire), Sam Billings (Kent, wk), Liam Livingstone (Lancashire), Liam Dawson (Hampshire), Tom Curran (Surrey), Jamie Overton (Somerset), Saqib Mahmood (Lancashire), George Garton (Sussex), Mark Wood (Durham), Sam Curran (Surrey, last two matches only)
Tri-series fixtures
18 July, Cheltenham - Pakistan A v Sri Lanka A
19 July, Cheltenham - England Lions v Pakistan A
21 July, Northampton - England Lions v Sri Lanka A
22 July, Northampton - Pakistan A v Sri Lanka A
24 July, Canterbury - England Lions v Pakistan A
25 July, Canterbury - England Lions v Sri Lanka A
England under-19s squad: Max Holden (Middlesex, captain), Josh Dell, Zen Malik, Josh Tongue, Ben Twohig, Ollie Westbury* (all Worcestershire), George Hankins (Gloucestershire), George Bartlett, Dom Bess**, Ben Green** (all Somerset), Ollie Pope (wk), Amar Virdi* (both Surrey), George Panayi* (Warwickshire), Aaron Beard (Essex), Ed Barnes (Yorkshire), Josh Coughlin* (Durham), Tom Moores** (wk), Jack Blatherwick** (both Nottinghamshire)
* Four-day matches only ** One-day matches only
Fixtures
21-22 July, Loughborough - England under-19s v Unicorns
26-29 July, Cambridge - England under-19s v Sri Lanka under-19s
3-6 August, Northampton - England under-19s v Sri Lanka under-19s
10 August, Wormsley - England under-19s v Sri Lanka under-19s
13 August, Chelmsford - England under-19s v Sri Lanka under-19s
16 August, Canterbury - England under-19s v Sri Lanka under-19s


Mokhtar Belmokhtar - a one-eyed war veteran nicknamed "Mr Marlboro" and described as "uncatchable" - achieved international notoriety for ordering a deadly attack on an internationally run Algerian gas plant in January.

Four months later, he was reported to have masterminded two suicide attacks in Niger, targeting a military base in Agadez and the French-run uranium mine in Arlit, killing at least 25 people.
He has been declared dead many times, the latest by a US air strike on 14 June in Libya, according to the country's authorities. However, Belmokhtar has survived previous announcements of his death. In March 2013, the Chadian army claimed to have killed him, only for him to resurface months later.
For years, the US government has been offering a reward of up to $5m (Â£3.3m) for information leading to his location.
"He is one of the best known warlords of the Sahara," Stephen Ellis, an academic at the African Studies Centre in Leiden in The Netherlands, says.
He became known as "Mr Marlboro" because of his role in cigarette-smuggling across the Sahel region to finance his jihad, which he has recently waged under the banner of the Signed-in-Blood Battalion.
"Belmokhtar has been active in political, ideological and criminal circles in the Sahara for the past two decades," Jon Marks, an academic at the London-based think-tank Chatham House, told the BBC.
Profile: Al-Qaeda in North Africa
Born in Ghardaia in eastern Algeria in 1972, Belmokhtar - according to interviews posted on Islamist websites - was attracted as a schoolboy to waging jihad.
Inspired to avenge the 1989 killing of Palestinian Islamist ideologue Abdullah Yusuf Azzam, he travelled to Afghanistan as a 19 year old to receive training from al-Qaeda.
"While there, Belmokhtar claims [on Islamist websites] to have made connections with jihadis from around the world," says the US-based Jamestown Foundation, in a report published on its website.
"Moreover, Belmokhtar claims to have been to battlefronts 'from Qardiz to Jalalabad to Kabul'."
When he returned to Algeria in 1993, the country was already in the throes of conflict after the French-backed Algerian military annulled elections that the Islamic Salvation Front (FIS) was poised to win.
Belmokhtar joined the conflict, which claimed hundreds of thousands of lives, and became a key figure in the militant Armed Islamist Group (GIA) and later the breakaway Salafist Group for Preaching and Combat (GSPC).
Algerian journalist Mohamed Arezki Himeur says Belmokhtar lost his left eye in fighting with government troops in the 1990s and now wears a false eye.
"He has been condemned to death [by Algeria's courts] several times," he adds.
When the GSPC merged with al-Qaeda in the Islamic Maghreb (AQIM), Belmokhtar headed an AQIM battalion in the desert between Algeria and Mali.
After AQIM stripped him of his title as "emir of the Sahel" as a result of in-fighting, Belmokhtar launched a new jihadist group in 2012, known variously as the Signed-in-Blood Battalion, the Masked Men Brigade and the Khaled Abu al-Abbas Brigade.
The bloody attack on the In Amenas gas facility in south-eastern Algeria was its first big operation, showing that he remained influential despite his marginalisation within AQIM.
Among the hundreds of hostages seized were many Western workers. By the time Algerian forces had brought the crisis to an end, 38 people were dead, of whom all but one were foreigners.
It was thought Belmokhtar's aim had been to move the Western hostages to northern Mali, where French troops had intervened to oust an alliance of Islamist militants.
Sightings of Belmokhtar had been reported in the two main cities in northern Mali, Timbuktu and Gao, since the al-Qaeda-linked rebels seized control of the region in 2011.
"He knows the Sahara Desert very well," says Mr Himeur.
In recent years, Belmokhtar has gained notoriety as a hostage-taker across the vast Sahara, often demanding multi-million dollar ransoms from Western governments which - along with cigarette-smuggling - finances his jihad.
Former UN Niger envoy Robert Fowler was captured by Belmokhtar loyalists outside Niger's capital, Niamey, in December 2008.
"We were frog-marched and thrown into the back of a truck... We began our descent into hell - a 1,000km [600-mile] journey northwards, into the Sahara Desert," he told the BBC.
"I think I know instinctively what they [the hostages captured in Algeria were] going through."
In its report, the Jamestown Foundation said Belmokhtar had been able to operate across borders because of his deep ties to the region.
"Key to Belmokhtar's Saharan activities has been his strong connections with local Tuareg communities... Belmokhtar is reported to have married four wives from local Arab and Tuareg communities," it said.
In June 2012, Algerian media reported that Belmokhtar - described in 2002 by French intelligence sources as "uncatchable" - had been killed in clashes between Islamists and Tuareg separatists in northern Mali.
But this turned out to be untrue.
The Signed-in-Blood Battalion warned in December 2012 against any attempt to drive out the Islamists from Mali.
"We will respond forcefully [to all attackers]; we promise we will follow you to your homes and you will feel pain and we will attack your interests," the group said, according to Sahara Media.
The attacks in Niger, while planned by Belmokhtar, were allegedly carried out by his allies in Mujao fighters - angered by Niger's co-operation with France and involvement in Mali.
Niger's President Mahamadou Issoufou believes the militants who carried out the attack came from new bases in southern Libya.
His country has contributed soldiers to the 6,000-strong West African force in Mali, which deployed following the French intervention in January 2012 and which will be incorporated into the new UN force in July.
After the Niger attacks, an statement allegedly posted online by the Signed-in-Blood Battalion and signed by Belmokhtar urged Niger's withdrawal with this warning: "Columns of commandos and those seeking martyrdom are ready and waiting for their targets."


Ireland beat Hockey World League 2 hosts Malaysia to make it two wins from two in Kuala Lumpur.

Skipper Chloe Watkins got the Irish off to a great start with a fifth-minute field goal and Anna O'Flanagan doubled the lead in the 52nd minute.
Malaysia scored through Hanis Onn but the late goal wasn't enough to deny the Irish victory.
They complete their group series fixtures by facing Hong Kong on Tuesday (10:15 GMT).
Ireland opened the event with a thumping 12-0 win over Kazakhstan.
The tournament is Ireland's first round of qualification for the 2018 World Cup and they want a top two finish to qualify for World League 3, where they could play in either Belgium (21 June-2 July) or South Africa (8-23 July) depending on rankings.
Ireland are the second highest ranked team in the tournament as they sit 16th, with only Italy, 15th, ranked above them.
Pool A has Italy joined by Thailand, Wales and Singapore with rankings of 15, 31, 32 and 43 respectively.


The Women's World Cup gets under way in Canada on Saturday and is poised to be the biggest edition of the competition yet.

The tournament has been expanded to 24 teams and will last almost a month, with record crowds expected and every game shown live on the BBC for the first time.
Here, we look at the some of the personalities and plotlines to watch out for over the next four weeks.
It is four years since diehard Newcastle fan John Herdman and former AFC Wimbledon defender Tony Readings last stood on the touchline together at a Women's World Cup.
Then, Herdman was head coach of New Zealand and Readings was his assistant, but when the two 39-year-olds walk out in Edmonton on 11 June they will be rivals.
In 2011, Herdman swapped the Football Ferns for the Maple Leaf of Canada and Readings stepped into his old boss's shoes.
Fate has thrown the two sides together in Group A and Consett-born Herdman was delighted when he heard the draw.
The former Sunderland youth coach flourished with New Zealand, taking them to two Women's World Cups and the Olympics after becoming head coach in 2006.
Herdman began well after switching to Canada, picking the Canucks up after a disastrous 2011 World Cup to win Pan American Games gold and Olympic bronze.
Readings, who initially moved to New Zealand to play for North Shore United, made his tournament debut as Herdman's assistant and since stepping up has taken his Haka-dancing Ferns to their first Olympic quarter finals.
New Zealand have yet to reach the knockout stages of a World Cup, though, so Readings will make history if he gets the Ferns, ranked 17th, out of a group that also includes debutants Netherlands (12th) and tournament regulars China (16th).
Success for Canada, ranked joint-eighth with North Korea, is nothing less than the world title. Herdman believes it is possible, and the home nation will certainly be willing the Englishman on.
Taking over as head coach of a national side weeks before they are due to make a bid to qualify for a major tournament is brave.
But Thais were grateful that former assistant women's coach Nuengruethai Sathongwien accepted the challenge when she secured her nation's first place at a senior World Cup, men's or women's.
The first female head coach of Thailand's women delivered when her side beat rivals Vietnam 2-1 in a play-off for the last of five Asian places on offer.
It was a pressured match in Ho Chi Minh City, but star midfielder Kanjana Sung-Ngoen kept her composure to score two goals and a ticket to Canada 2015.
That victory ensured women's football dominated the media spotlight in this football-mad country in the weeks that followed the squad's return to Thailand.
Indeed, when they touched down in Bangkok the players were presented with garlands of flowers, serenaded by drum-banging fans and swamped by television crews, photographers and journalists.
The women were front-page news and many have gone on to become role models to boot - their talismanic player Sung-Ngoen receiving Facebook messages from girls inspired to take up the sport.
Thais will watch with interest to see if the sister of one of their more familiar role models, striker Teerasil Dangda, gets playing time in Canada.
Taneekarn Dangda, whose brother once trialled with Manchester City and played in La Liga, was on the bench against Vietnam.
The 22-year-old has some way to go before she can rival her brother's average of a goal every two games for his country.
But she and Thailand, ranked 29th in the world, will reach a World Cup before him.
Ivory Coast, ranked 67th, have no such bragging rights over their men, but they made history when they booked their place in Canada via the play-offs.
It will take even greater efforts to beat the world's top side Germany and 11th-ranked Norway, the clear favourites to progress.
When it comes to legends, the women's game has several, but when World Cup holders Japan defend their title in Canada, their squad will include one of the greatest.
Delicately featured but tough as old boots, free-scoring 5ft 4in midfielder Homare Sawa made her debut in this competition in 1995.
Twenty years on, Sawa will be at the party again, joining Brazil's Formiga as the only players to be picked for six consecutive finals.
Injuries meant it was touch and go for 36-year-old Sawa this time and she was included in the squad despite not having played for the Nadeshiko since May 2014.
Coach Norio Sasaki had watched the former women's world player of the year return for club side INAC Kobe Leonessa, though, and knows the difference Japan's number 10 makes.
"With Sawa's essence added, the team becomes more powerful," he said of the player who won the Golden Ball and Boot as she captained a humble and much-admired Japan side to the world title in 2011.
Sawa, who has twice played professionally in the United States, said she almost cried after being included in the squad for Canada.
The veteran swiftly repaid her coach by scoring in a warm-up win over New Zealand, her 83rd goal in 198 appearances.
The Asian Football Confederation Hall of Fame inductee will play a crucial role as world number four side Japan face debutants Switzerland, ranked 19th, Ecuador (48th) and Cameroon (53rd).
They call it the 'Group of Death' because it features three top-10 ranked nations and African champions Nigeria, but at least guitar-playing Sweden head coach Pia Sundhage might lighten the mood with a burst of song.
Team dinners, interviews, even the gala Fifa ceremony when she was crowned 2012 women's coach of the year; no matter the situation, Sundhage sings.
It was Bob Dylan's 'If Not For You' at the Ballon d'Or, Simon & Garfunkel's 'Feelin' Groovy' for the press at the 2011 World Cup when she was USA boss. All was not so great in the end - the USA lost to Japan on penalties in the final.
In 2012, however, they beat the Nadeshiko at Wembley to win a second Olympic title under her. It was fitting; in 1989 Sundhage scored for Sweden at the old Wembley, the first woman to do so.
The 55-year-old left Team USA shortly after London 2012 to become head coach of Sweden and a nation rejoiced at the return of a former striking legend who hit 71 goals in 146 appearances, including the winner to beat England to the 1984 European title.
World number five side Sweden meet the USA on 12 June and among the many familiar faces for Sundhage will be the Americans' new head coach, English-born Jill Ellis.
The 48-year-old former college player was once Sundhage's USA assistant, but their friendship will take a back seat in Canada; the world number two side are under pressure to win the title in their neighbour's back yard.
Both coaches will need to be on song, though, with world number 10 side Australia and 33rd-ranked Nigeria, featuring 2015 BBC Women's Footballer of the Year Asisat Oshoala, completing the group.
They call her "Ji Messi" in her homeland but now the world can judge whether South Korea starlet Ji So-Yun is worthy of comparison with the Barcelona legend.
On 9 June 18th-ranked side South Korea play their first World Cup match since 2003.
The stage is set for the battle of the number 10s, with Ji in the Taeguk Ladies' corner and superstar Marta in seventh-ranked Brazil's.
If awards are a guide, five-time world player of the year Marta will trump four-time Korea player of the year Ji.
But Emma Hayes, Ji's manager at Women's Super League side Chelsea Ladies, believes the PFA player of 2015 can hold her own.
"The world will see at this tournament what a top talent she is," says Hayes.
The youngest woman to score for her country (aged 15), Ji had been playing for top Japan side INAC Kobe Leonessa before Hayes snapped her up.
It was a canny move - the 5ft 2in tall 24-year-old is a family girl at heart but she settled immediately at Chelsea and was instrumental in the Blues' agonisingly close title tilt of 2014.
Ji, who honed her early skills playing football with boys, is on form again this season and scored to seal Chelsea's place in August's showpiece FA Women's Cup final at Wembley.
"One moment, one goal, and that's what the best players do," says Hayes. "She needs to be more tenacious defensively to become a complete player, but she's a fantastic learner."
Arsenal Ladies supporters, meanwhile, will be looking out for their own overseas import in Group E, Natalia Pablos, playing for 14th-ranked Spain, who make their debut along with Costa Rica (37th).
As grudge games go, England's opener against France on 9 June will be one of the most bitter.
In the last four years, Les Bleus have been the architects of the Three Lionesses' biggest tournament heartaches.
Chief among them was the crushing 2011 World Cup quarter-final penalty shootout defeat.
Equally humbling was the 3-0 Euro 2013 group stage annihilation that sent England home and effectively ended Hope Powell's 15-year tenure as manager.
Rewind to 2002 and you find France ending England's hopes of even reaching the World Cup after play-off wins home and away.
England's most capped player Fara Williams was there, once saying of the away tie in St Etienne: "Their fans were jumping on cages when they beat us. It was horrible."
It was formative, though, because as a consequence Powell called for - and won - resources for her team, such as conditioning experts, a psychologist and technical analysts.
Four years later England were fit for purpose, avenging 2002 by pipping France to a spot at the 2007 Women's World Cup courtesy of a tense 1-1 draw in Rennes.
That was the first time England had qualified in 12 years; they are now ranked sixth in the world and entering their third consecutive finals.
Head coach Mark Sampson, whose England lost to France in the 2014 Cyprus Cup final, needs his players to kick on in Canada and get beyond the quarters for the first time.
The Welshman admits that overcoming a world number three side that is ever improving under former France goalkeeper Philippe Bergeroo will be "a real tough challenge".
His players are ready. "I know all eyes are on France," says defender Alex Scott. "But these are the games you want to be in, so bring it on."


Chinese search giant Baidu has unveiled an AI digital assistant.

Xiaoyu Zaijia - or Little Fish - responds to voice commands using a combination of pictures, text and speech. Unlike many rival AIs it is dependant on a touchscreen
It can answer questions, find local services, play music, make video calls and control smart home devices.
Baidu Chief Scientist Andrew Ng said that artificial intelligence is "the new electricity".
"AI has been growing steadily - every year our AI has been 50% better," he told the BBC at the CES tech show in Las Vegas.
"Those of us on the inside feel the acceleration now but we have been feeling it for the last decade.
"Just as 100 years ago the electrification of our society transformed industry after industry, I think AI tech has now reached that stage."
Little Fish's hardware has been developed by Chinese robotics firm Ainemo Inc but uses Baidu's AI operating system DuerOS.
Follow all our CES coverage at bbc.co.uk/ces2017
Existing digital assistants such as the Amazon's Alexa and Google Assistant are not screen-dependant but can be used by voice alone. Apple's Siri, however, continues to rely on a display to provide some of its information.
Little Fish will launch initially in China in March 2017 and currently only recognises Chinese languages. Baidu has not yet set a price.
"What we have seen so far in terms of digital assistants and smart speakers is very much first generation and it has all been about voice," said Geoff Blaber, tech analyst at CCS Insight.
"I would certainly expect that over the next 12 months we will see the next iteration of assistants that do integrate a number of different ways of interacting with the device - not just video but also gesture control.
"A richer variety of interaction methods helps bridge the gap in terms of the user experience. When they first start using one, a lot of users find it a steep learning curve."


As Rebekah Brooks returns as chief executive of Rupert Murdoch's UK newspaper group on Monday, she faces some tough choices over the future direction of News UK, formerly News International.

The outlook for traditional newspapers - including News UK's Sun and Times - has looked bleak for some time, with online revenues failing to compensate for declining physical sales.
And in the past few years, the online sphere has also seen a structural shift away from individual news websites, to the sharing of news stories via Facebook, Twitter and other social media sites.
So Mrs Brooks rejoins Mr Murdoch's British newspaper operation at a time of falling profits amid this increased competition.
In June 2014, News UK (or News Corp UK & Ireland, to give it its formal title) reported a 12-month operating loss of Â£3.5m. This came after a Â£51m profit for the year before.
Meanwhile, annual profits at the Sun had almost halved.
Mrs Brooks has "got her work cut out," says Charlie Beckett, journalism professor at the London School of Economics.
It was back in 2011 that Mrs Brooks resigned from her previous time at the helm of News UK in the wake of the phone-hacking scandal. She was put on trial, only to be cleared of all four charges in June of last year.
Recently she has been working for a News Corp-owned video news agency.
Prof Beckett says that since Mrs Brooks' resignation: "I suspect she has been taking a keen interest in digital strategy.
"Online is where you have to build your brand and audiences, and the expectation is that it is going to get harder."
Mrs Brooks will no doubt be looking to see what other news organisations have recently done, such as doing deals with Facebook or Apple.
Currently Facebook is trialling a deal with news organisations - including the BBC - to publish some of their content directly rather than simply hosting it on their own websites.
The news groups taking part are BBC News, The Guardian, BuzzFeed, the New York Times, National Geographic, NBC News, The Atlantic, Spiegel and Bild. They will get all of the advertising revenue they sell directly, and 70% of the revenue from ads sold by Facebook.
As the mobile advertising market has exploded, so Twitter and Facebook have grown to dominate it. For instance, they will soon account for a third of all digital ad spending in the world's biggest market - the US - according to new figures from eMarketer.
Meanwhile, Apple is launching its news app this autumn. It wants to challenge existing social media sites like Facebook, Snapchat and YouTube. Apple hopes its huge iPad and iPhone user base will give it a crucial advantage.
So far 50 publishers have signed up to take part. As with Facebook, they will get to keep 100% of advertising revenue they sell, and 70% of the revenue for ads that Apple sells.
The key decision that now faces Mrs Brooks is how to shape the digital strategy for the Times and the Sun. In particular, she has to decide what to do about both newspapers' paywalls - which means their content is only available to subscribers, and crucially can't then readily be shared via social media sites.
Papers like the Mail and the Guardian have instead opted to make their content freely available online, hoping that by boosting digital viewing figures they will also see a return in online advertising revenue.
The Mail Online has carved out a very successful niche specialising in celebrity stories, while the Guardian pitches itself as an online liberal lifestyle paper.
For specialist papers like the Financial Times, on the other hand, a paywall works. Its global readers are prepared to pay because many can make money from the information it provides.
However, for general newspapers like the Times and The Sun, paywalls have been a mixed blessing.
Subscription numbers for The Times are doing well, says Prof Beckett: "The question is how do they grow that base?"
Mrs Brooks may well opt to make more of the Times content available on other platforms - but while still charging for it, say some.
For the Sun the paywall has been less successful, which is borne out by the paper's most recent web traffic figures.
They show its website is the least visited of any UK national newspaper.  In July 2013 before launching its paywall its website got 1.9 million website readers daily. This July that figure was down to less than 800,000 according to ABC (Audit Bureau of Circulations).
Compare this with the Mail Online's 14.2 million daily users and the challenge becomes clearer.
The Sun focuses on sports and celebrity news, and as there is a huge amount of this around, users can readily go elsewhere for free if this is what they want to read.
Already the Sun is placing more of its content outside its paywall. During this year's UK General Election, for instance, it launched Sun Nation online. This was freely available and was designed to tap into a younger market.
Most analysts expect Mrs Brooks to further lower the Sun's paywall, or even remove it altogether.
In doing this she is expected to have a strong ally in News UK's other new senior appointee, Tony Gallagher, who is joining as the new editor of the Sun.
Mr Gallagher is going to the Sun from the Daily Mail, where he was joint deputy editor. He is expected to push the Sun to compete more aggressively against his old title.
The appointment of Ms Brooks and Mr Gallagher "signals a belief in good journalists being able to solve the disruptive challenges papers face - the internet, social media and mobile device," says Douglas McCabe, a media expert at Enders Analysis.
He adds: "Tony Gallagher will give the Sun newsroom a lot more confidence in the product again."
News UK executives will also be thinking hard about how they can utilise their existing brands to boost their income. Mrs Brooks will know that her main task is to improve the newspapers' profitability.
Prof Beckett says: "Nobody doubts her editorial genius, her drive - she really is a very talented newspaper editor."
Yet he cautions that she has a difficult job on her hands. "She's stepping into an area which is particularly tough."


England head coach Stuart Lancaster says he does not anticipate making "too many changes" for Saturday's Six Nations match with Italy.

Media playback is not supported on this device
Returning trio Geoff Parling, Brad Barritt and Kyle Eastmond will be available for the Twickenham encounter.
But Lancaster described England's victory over Wales in Cardiff as one of the greatest of his coaching career.
And he said: "Off the back of that performance I'll be surprised if there are too many changes."
The coach added: "We haven't made the selection yet, so we'll give one or two guys the chance to put their hands up in training, but we are trying to get some consistency."
Lancaster was delighted with the composure England showed at the Millennium Stadium in Friday's Six Nations opener, recovering from a half-time deficit to win 21-16.
However, he has warned his team that there can be no let-up against an Italy side comfortably beaten in Rome by Ireland.
"The pressure is still on against Italy, but in a different way," said Lancaster.
"For long periods of time the Ireland-Italy game was very close and it was the same when Italy played South Africa in November.
"So we need to be prepared and ready, and we need to show the same attention to detail that we did going into the Wales game."
Lock Courtney Lawes and flanker Tom Wood will not be available to face Italy because of injury, but may be in the mix for the match against Ireland in Dublin on 1 March.
Centre Manu Tuilagi is "still some way off playing club rugby" but Lancaster has not ruled out the Leicester powerhouse playing some part in the championship.


A 38-year-old man has been arrested on suspicion of murder after a pensioner's body was found in Newport.

Gwent Police were called to an address at Cambria Close, Caerleon, at about 04:25 BST on Thursday following a disturbance.
A 66-year-old man was found dead at the scene, police said.
A 38-year-old man from Newport was arrested on suspicion of murder and remains in police custody.


Motorcyclist Guy Martin still wants to race but will not be rushed into making a comeback.

Media playback is not supported on this device
The 33-year-old suffered several broken bones after suffering an accident while leading the Dundrod 150 Superbike race in August.
The TT racer and television personality, who has returned to work as a truck fitter, is now recovering.
"I still want to race, but I'm not going to rush into deciding what or where I'm going to race," Martin said.
"Having a few days off work gave me time to think about what I want to do, and realise all the things that have had to go on hold."
Media playback is not supported on this device
Martin says he does not remember anything about the crash at Dundrod on 6 August.
He lost control of his Tyco BMW at Ireland's Corner on the circuit as he was leading the Superbike race by less than a second from Bruce Anstey.
"I headbutted the ground at 130mph, then skidded into a dirt field and catapulted off a few things," Martin added.
"The impact I hit the ground with was massive.
"I broke five vertebrae and they had to rod my spine because I broke my sternum too.  I broke five ribs and two metacarpals in right hand, too, and my hand's been plated.
"There's no better physio than working on trucks and I know when I'm doing too much, I'm not planning to do anything that puts the recovery back."


Edinburgh City's first competitive match as an SPFL side ended in League Cup defeat to Livingston at Meadowbank.

The League Two newcomers fell behind on 27 minutes when Joshua Mullin headed in a free-kick from Nicky Cadden.
Mullin then provided a neat cross for Daniel Mullen to knock in right on the stroke of half time.
Mikey Miller crashed a shot against the woodwork as the visitors from League One continued to dominate before Liam Buchanan made it 3-0 from close range.
Ousman See went close for the hosts but was denied a landmark goal by a smart save from Liam Kelly.
Livingston move up to second place in Group G, behind St Mirren, who have two wins from two.


A head teacher has defended excluding 72 students from regular classes for not complying with uniform rules.

Pupils at Denbigh High School were disciplined on the first day of term on Monday, for breaches of policy including "the wearing of inappropriate trousers, skirts and footwear".
The students were taken from their normal lessons and moved to a "learning suite".
About 20 of them returned to normal classes by the end of the day.
Head teacher Simeon Molloy said: "We believe that standards across the board, including uniform, contribute to a positive learning environment.
"At the end of the last school year we held several school assemblies that outlined our school uniform policy.
"We followed this up by telephoning parents and sending out letters with photographs and information on the style of trousers and length of skirts."
He added: "We have spoken with every parent of every student involved in this matter to explain individual issues with each pupil's uniform. We will continue to uphold our high expectations."
Students flouting uniform rules were sent home from lessons at a Kent academy - a day after police intervened in angry scenes at the school gates on the first day of term.


Schools in an area of Berkshire are losing out on up to £350,000 a year according to the local authority.

7 October 2016 Last updated at 12:09 BST
West Berkshire Council say parents are not registering their children as eligible for free meals, meaning schools are not able to claim pupil premium funds.
The government introduced universal free school meals in 2015, leading to confusion among parents who now have access to free meals without having to register.


A woman and a 13-year-old girl have been left seriously injured after a crash between two Land Rover vehicles.

They were in a Defender, towing a horse box, on the A82 near Loch Lomond when a Discovery driven in the opposite direction was in collision with them.
The 47-year-old woman driving the Defender and her 13-year-old passenger are being treated in hospital for serious injuries.
The horse that was being carried in the trailer died at the scene.
The crash happened between Duck Bay and the Stoneymollan roundabout.
The 59-year-old driver of the Discovery was not injured.
Insp Adam McKenzie, of Police Scotland, said: "This was a very serious road crash and I would appeal to anyone who witnessed what happened to please get in touch.
"If you were on the A82 around the time of the incident and may have seen either of the vehicles involved driving on the road, or witnessed the actual collision, you may be able to assist with our inquiries, and it is important that we speak to you."


A house fire that killed an elderly woman was like a scene from a "horror movie", a neighbour has said.

It began at about 21:15 GMT on Tuesday in Loddon Road, Ditchingham, Norfolk.
The woman was found dead in her living room, where the blaze broke out. Neighbours tried to break in but were beaten back by flames.
"The windows were exploding and flames were shooting out of everything - it looked like a horror movie," neighbour Carol Buggs said.
"You couldn't see out or bear to breathe."
Updates on this story and more from Norfolk
Norfolk Police said a cordon was in place at the house and officers were working with the fire service to investigate its cause.
Fire crews said the blaze spread rapidly around the 100-year-old home.
Fire spokesman Roy Harold said: "The smoke... was very thick and pouring out of the property.
"There are smoke alarms inside but they've been damaged by the fire so we need to check whether or not they operated."
Carol Buggs and her husband Sidney were alerted by another resident in Loddon Road when the terraced cottage next to theirs was well alight.
They said had the blaze broken out in the small hours they could have "burnt alive in our own beds".
Another neighbour, Jonathan Robinson, who lives three doors away, said he found a side door open but decided not to enter after being met by "thick acrid smoke".
"I feel sorry for [the victim] and for the people who live next door," he said.
"They had no idea at all and if my wife hadn't gone round and knocked on the door and told them to get out of the house... they could have been quite seriously injured as well."