US President Barack Obama has made a strong defence of globalisation as he arrived in Germany on his final visit to Europe before leaving office.

In a joint article, Mr Obama and German Chancellor Angela Merkel said that with the global economy developing faster than ever, co-operation was vital.
Mr Obama arrived in Germany from Athens where he had warned of threats to modern democracy.
He is seeking to calm unease following the election of Donald Trump.
In the article in the business magazine, Wirtschaftswoche (in German), he and Mrs Merkel made a strong case for international trade in contrast to Mr Trump's more protectionist stance.
Trump's rude awakening for Germany
Trump and trade: A radical agenda?
"There will be no return to a world before globalisation," they wrote.
"We owe it to our companies and our citizens, indeed to the entire world community, to broaden and deepen our co-operation."
The two leaders voiced support for the proposed Trans-Atlantic Trade and Investment Partnership (TTIP) between the US and the EU.
By contrast, Mr Trump is a fierce critic of global free trade agreements and welcomed the UK's decision in June to leave the EU.
In Athens, Mr Obama acknowledged that globalisation had created a "sense of injustice" and a "course correction" was needed to address growing inequality.
"When we see people, global elites, wealthy corporations seemingly living by a different set of rules, avoiding taxes, manipulating loopholes... this feeds a profound sense of injustice," he told Greek leaders.
Mr Obama's visit to Greece was marked by street protests by leftist groups which denounced US "imperialism". Police used tear gas against about 2,500 demonstrators who had tried to reach the city centre on Tuesday.
The US president will stay in Germany until Friday and then head to Peru.


One policeman has been killed by gunmen who opened fire on a checkpoint near St Catherine's monastery in Egypt's south Sinai, officials say.

Another three police officers were injured in the attack several hundred metres from the church entrance.
So-called Islamic State group said its fighters carried out the attack.
Located at the foot of Mount Sinai, St Catherine's is one of the oldest Christian monasteries in the world and a Unesco world heritage site.
It is part of the Eastern Orthodox Church.
Tuesday's attack comes just days after bombings at two Coptic Christian churches left 45 people dead.
The attacks have raised security fears ahead of a visit to Cairo by Pope Francis, the head of the Roman Catholic Church.
Egypt's Christian minority makes up about 10% of the pre-dominantly Muslim country of 92 million people.


Irish-American actress Maureen O'Hara, one of the last living stars from the golden age of Hollywood, has died aged 95, her manager said.

She died in her sleep at her home in Boise, Idaho, Johnny Nicoletti said.
O'Hara starred in the 1941 multi-Oscar winning drama, How Green Was My Valley, set in a Welsh mining village. She also regularly featured alongside John Wayne, in films such as the Quiet Man.
Born in Dublin, she moved to Hollywood in 1939 and later became a US citizen.
"Her characters were feisty and fearless, just as she was in real life," her family said in a statement.
"She was also proudly Irish and spent her entire lifetime sharing her heritage and the wonderful culture of the Emerald Isle with the world."
Ireland's President Michael D Higgins said "she will be remembered as an outstanding and versatile actress, whose work especially in film, will endure for many years to come".
Her first credited film was My Irish Molly, her only appearance under her real name FitzSimons.
How Green Was My Valley was her breakthrough. It was enormously popular in its day, beating Orson Welles' Citizen Kane to Oscars for Best Picture and Best Director.
Other well-known works include Miracle on 34th Street, the Hunchback of Notre Dame and the Parent Trap.
The Quiet Man was one of five films where she appeared alongside John Wayne, and was the one she said she was most proud of.
Her family said she had died listening to music from the film.
O'Hara gave up acting for a long period starting in the early seventies, taking over the management from her husband of a commercial airline in 1978 after he died in a plane crash.
Actress Jessica Chastain tweeted: "RIP #MaureenOHara from one tough redhead broad to another. Thankful for the light you shared."


Ed Poole and Guto Ifan of the Wales Governance Centre, with David Phillips from the Institute for Fiscal Studies, examine the deal on how to fund the Welsh Government after it takes on tax powers.

In recent months, the Welsh and UK governments have been locked in high-stakes negotiations to determine how Welsh public services would be funded after tax devolution.
With hundreds of millions of pounds at stake, the stage was set for long, gruelling negotiations: the equivalent Scottish talks had ended in a deadline-day showdown.
But in Wales, it would all be over in a matter of months.
The announcement has big implications for the Welsh Government's budget.
But has it got all it wanted for Christmas?
The crucial aspect of the deal is how tax devolution will be implemented. Once Wales gets the keys to about Â£2.5bn in new tax revenues the Treasury will cut the Welsh block grant - which funds all devolved services like health and education - by an equivalent amount.
In the years to come, this "block grant adjustment" will go up or down depending on what happens to comparable revenues in the rest of the UK.
This means Welsh taxes will need to grow as quickly as England's to keep up with Treasury deductions from the block grant.
If Wales' economy performed like the rest of the UK, this might be reasonable. But Wales has much lower incomes, so linking Wales' budget to English tax growth would lead to losses over which the Welsh Government would have had no control.
For example, Wales has been disproportionately affected by the flagship UK policy to increase the level at which taxpayers start paying income tax - the personal allowance - because more Welsh taxpayers earn incomes around this level than in England.
In a win for Wales, the Treasury accepted this as a problem and agreed to make separate block grant adjustments for each of the three bands of income tax.
This should mean Wales is less exposed to UK policies that have different results across the UK.
However, the agreement offers no such protection for stamp duty, being replaced in Wales by a land transaction tax.
Given the deep-rooted differences in UK property market conditions - especially after Brexit - the Welsh Government will be exposed to risks that are outside its control.
In addition, Wales' slower-growing population may lead to slower revenue growth than in the rest of the UK.
The method chosen to cut the Welsh block - the "comparable model" - means Wales probably stands to lose out, even if revenues per head grow at the same rate as elsewhere in the UK.
This was something the Scottish Government refused to accept. To explain why Wales did accept this, we need to turn to the expenditure side of the deal - the funding floor.
The most striking element is the first major modification of the Barnett formula - which determines how increases or cuts in public spending are shared across the UK - since its introduction.
From now on, changes to the Welsh budget (resulting from increases in spending on services in England) will be increased by 5% initially, and by 15% if funding drops below an estimate of Wales' relative need  - 115% of spending per person in England.
Although there seems to be little logic behind the choice of 5%, this change is intended to stop the so-called Barnett "squeeze" - the tendency for Wales' funding per head to decrease towards the level in England.
Recognition of Wales' higher needs will be much welcomed by the Welsh Government, given the Treasury's reluctance to change territorial funding arrangements in the UK.
On balance, the "Barnett bonus" will likely more than offset the losses from Wales taking on population-related revenue risk.
So this is probably a good financial deal for the Welsh Government - but just how good a deal will depend on spending and population growth over the next few years.
In proportion to devolved revenues, the doubling of Wales' capital borrowing limit to Â£1bn is also considerably higher than the Scottish Government's Â£3bn limit.
But while being a good financial deal, the agreement misses an opportunity to create a more sensible and transparent devolved funding system.  In fact, it adds new complexities and quirks into the Barnett formula.
As with most other aspects of Welsh devolution, it is a product of bargaining and compromise that inevitably depart from first principles.
Because the Welsh Government bears population risk under the agreement, devolved taxes will probably fall short of deductions from the block grant and largely due to factors outside Welsh Government control.
So it will be difficult to assess the Welsh Government's performance in managing devolved revenues, clouding the crucial accountability link that tax devolution was meant to bring.
The agreement is also silent on whether Wales' higher need for spending should be reassessed. This could mean that an estimate of relative need in 2010 may end up impacting Welsh funding in 2040 and beyond.
Nevertheless, Welsh policymakers can breathe a justifiable sigh of relief - for now. Because, perhaps the biggest unanswered question from this agreement is how Wales' funding will change after Brexit, including the future of regional aid and support for farmers.
As the dust settles on this set of negotiations, there are potentially far more challenging talks just around the corner.


Six people, thought to be illegal immigrants, are being questioned after several people were spotted jumping out of a lorry next to the M6 on Tuesday.

A member of the public told police they were seen leaving a refrigerated lorry in Brockhurst Crescent, Walsall, close to junction 8 at about 15:15 BST.
Three people were arrested at the scene and three others were found nearby
The 36-year-old Romanian driver is being questioned on suspicion of facilitating illegal entry to the UK.
Two of the men arrested are believed to be Iranian, another is understood to be a 23-year-old Syrian, while two others are thought to be from Vietnam and aged in their mid-teens, West Midlands Police said.
A sixth man is currently being treated in hospital after being found with two broken ankles.
The six were held on suspicion of entering the country illegally and the driver will be questioned on suspicion of assisting illegal entry to the UK, West Midlands Police said.


French side Racing 92 say former All Blacks Dan Carter and Joe Rokocoko did not have therapeutic use exemptions (TUEs) for "anomalous" drugs tests but insist the players have not done wrong.

Newspaper L'Equipe reported that the pair, along with winger Juan Imhoff, tested positive for corticosteroids before playing in June's Top 14 final.
Racing say the case relates to "treatment by an authorised channel".
They added: "We're on the side of law, ethics and love of a clean sport."
The statement came after Carter and Rokocoko's agent told the New Zealand Herald he had assurances "all the documents around TUEs were in place".
TUEs allow sportspeople to take prescribed medicines - which are otherwise be banned for their performance-enhancing properties - if there is a medical need.
"As far as I know today, there was no request [for TUEs] made ahead of time, but people are allowed to regularise these things after the event," French Sports Minister Patrick Kanner said on France Info radio.
Fly-half Carter, 34, and winger Rokocoko, 33, scored 20 points between them as Racing Metro beat Toulon 29-21 in Barcelona.
Argentine wing Imhoff, who has scored 21 tries in 35 Tests, was also part of the starting line-up at the Nou Camp.
Carter, man of the match in the Top 14 final, played 112 Tests for New Zealand and was part of the All Blacks side which won the 2015 Rugby World Cup.
He is widely regarded as one of the greatest players in the history of the game.
Rokocoko scored 46 tries in 68 Tests between 2003 and 2010.


The Metropolitan Police are on heightened alert for a rise in hate crime following the European referendum result.

It comes amid reports of several race-related incidents over the weekend.
"Racist" graffiti was found scrawled on a Polish cultural centre in Hammersmith, west London, the Met said.
London Mayor Sadiq Khan said he had asked Scotland Yard to be "extra vigilant" following the reports.
The Polish ambassador to Britain Witold Sobkow expressed shock at what he called incidents of "xenophobic abuse" directed against the Polish community.
He said: "The Polish Embassy is in contact with relevant institutions and local police are already investigating the two most widely reported cases in Hammersmith, London, and Huntingdon, Cambridgeshire.
"We call on all Polish nationals who fall victim of xenophobic abuse and on all witnesses to report such incidents to local authorities."
He also thanked the British public for messages of support and solidarity the Polish community had received.
Police are investigating the vandalism at Hammersmith's Polish community building after images on social media appeared to show offensive graffiti smeared in yellow paint across the entrance. It was later removed.
Cambridgeshire Police are also investigating suspected post-referendum racism after notes were allegedly posted through letterboxes of Polish residents in the county.
Laminated cards reading "leave the EU - no more Polish vermin" were reportedly delivered to members of the Polish community in Huntingdon, north west of Cambridge, on Saturday.
Other incidents were also reported on social media, while a hashtag of #PostRefRacism was being used on Twitter.
Sky News journalist Adam Boulton tweeted: "This weekend I and my family have witnessed 3 "when are you going home?" Racist incidents aimed at EU citizens here."
Another user, James Titcombe, tweeted: "Daughter tells me someone wrote '[Child's name] go back to Romania' on the wall in the girls toilets at School today".
And former Conservative party deputy chairwoman Baroness Warsi also tweeted a string of reports of racist incidents, saying: "This is not the post Brexit Britain we want to see. Politicians from all sides need to speak out "
The Muslim Council of Britain said there had been countless incidents reported in the days since the referendum result as well as shocking manifestations of hate speech both online and also on the streets of Britain.
They included a demonstration outside a Birmingham mosque and reports of Muslims and others being told to "go back home", it said.
It called on political and civic leaders to urgently come together and heal the divisions that had emerged as a result of the referendum campaign.
Dr. Shuja Shafi, secretary general of the Muslim Council of Britain, said: "Now we are witnessing the shocking extent of this with reports around the country of hate speech and minorities being targeted. We need leadership now more than ever before."
Mr Khan echoed those sentiments calling on "all Londoners to pull together and rally behind this great city."
He said: "I take seriously my responsibility to defend London's fantastic mix of diversity and tolerance. So it's really important we stand guard against any rise in hate crimes or abuse by those who might use last week's referendum as cover to seek to divide us."


League One side Charlton Athletic have appointed former MK Dons manager Karl Robinson as their new boss.

The 36-year-old left Stadium MK last month after six and a half years in the role and replaces Russell Slade, who was sacked by the Addicks last week.
Robinson has agreed a two-and-a-half-year deal at The Valley and will take charge on Monday.
"Joining such a huge club with a large, passionate fanbase is a really exciting proposition," he told the club website.
Robinson becomes Roland Duchatelet's seventh managerial appointment since the Belgian businessman bought Charlton in January 2014.
Slade was sacked after just 16 league games in charge of the Addicks, with the club 15th in the table. They have won their last two games under caretaker manager Kevin Nugent and are 11th, three points off the play-offs.
Robinson was the third longest-serving manager in the top four divisions of English football before his departure from Milton Keynes, with only Arsenal boss Arsene Wenger and Exeter manager Paul Tisdale having been in their posts longer.
He led the Buckinghamshire club to promotion from League One to the Championship in May 2015, but the club spent just one season in the second tier before being relegated.
Charlton chief executive Katrien Meire described Robinson as the "outstanding candidate" to take charge of the south-east London club, who were also relegated from the Championship last season.
"He is a very talented, forward-thinking manager," Meire said.
"Our main focus is bringing Championship football back to The Valley at the earliest opportunity.
"Karl has vast experience of League One and, having won promotion just two seasons ago, we believe he has the necessary credentials to lead the club forward."
Robinson's first game in charge is set to be against his former side MK Dons in an FA Cup second-round tie on Saturday, 3 December.


Two-time Open winner Greg Norman says golf must embrace the digital age to attract new talent and survive.

Media playback is not supported on this device
The man nicknamed Great White Shark says the game must open up to "savvy, social media, connected with a device [types] with a Twitter account".
Relaxing dress codes and playing music on the course are two ideas suggested.
Participation fell in England last year and Norman, 60, said: "If a kid wants to get in a golf cart and play loud music, let them do it, absolutely."
Norman was speaking to BBC Sport before the 2015 Open at St Andrews, which starts on Thursday.
He added: "The traditionalists will say you can't do that.
"But if you want your club to survive, if you don't want the burden of maintaining it out of your own pocket, you have to bring in the youth.
"If someone wants to play nine holes, fine - but let the son play with his father with his headphones on. Let them dress a little bit differently."
A Sport England survey earlier this year showed the number of people playing golf at least once a week has dropped from 751,900 to 730,300. This number was at 889,100 for the same period in 2005 to 2006, meaning a total loss of 158,800 regular players in the past eight years.
World number one Rory McIlroy, out of this year's Open with an ankle injury, said in December that golf needed speeding up to attract young players
But golf's authorities have been reluctant to bring in changes in the past.
It was only in September that The Royal and Ancient Golf Club of St Andrews agreed to admit women to its membership, with Augusta doing similar in 2012.
Asked about Norman's comments, Peter Dawson, chief executive of the sport's rule makers the R&A, claimed the number of rounds played this year had increased significantly in "most major golf markets" and that he did not want to "talk ourselves into a participation drop that's greater than it actually is".
Speaking at a news conference at St Andrews, Dawson said there was "no one all-embracing solution" to the issue of participation, but did agree that courses should structure their fees to allow shorter forms of the game.
"People have less time, they want faster gratification these days. And if they want to go out and play six holes or nine holes, best of luck to them."
And he said golf clubs wanting to make changes to increase participation were free to do so: "If there are certain parts of the world or certain golf courses or clubs that want to allow that to happen, that's fine. If there are others that don't, that's fine, too.
"I can imagine plenty of golf clubs or golf facilities where if they had that policy it would reduce participation. I can also imagine where it might increase it. So it's a matter for courses and clubs themselves to appeal to their own market, it seems to me."


Playwright William Shakespeare tops a list of symbols which give Britons a sense of pride, a poll has suggested.

He beat the pound, the monarchy and the BBC, according to the poll commissioned by think tank Demos.
Parliament and the legal system came bottom.
Some 75% agreed with the sentence "I am proud of William Shakespeare as a symbol of Britain", but only 47% agreed with the sentence "I am proud of Parliament as a symbol of Britain".
The poll's participants were asked if they were proud of a range of things as symbols of Britain.
The results were: Shakespeare 75%; National Trust 72%; armed forces 72%; Union Jack 71%; the pound 70%; NHS 69%; the monarchy 68%; BBC 63%; sporting achievements 58%; the Beatles 51%; the legal system 51%; Parliament 47%.
Demos said it believed volunteering was the biggest single factor determining how patriotic people were.
About 40% of those who had volunteered in the last 12 months "strongly agreed" with the statement "I am proud to be a British citizen", compared to 25% of those who had not volunteered.
A Demos spokeswoman told the BBC: "People who volunteer were far more likely to say they were patriotic.
"Patriotism isn't a top-down thing when politicians say we should be proud of our flag... that's not how you make the public more patriotic."
The organisation recommended 16 hours of volunteering as part of the UK citizenship test.
People who volunteer also appear more optimistic about the state of the country than those who do not, the poll suggested, with 27% of those who had volunteered in the past year disagreeing with the statement "Britain's best days are behind her", compared with 19% of those who do not.
The Demos poll was carried out by YouGov and polled 2,086 British citizens online and in focus groups between 4 and 9 May.
It accompanies the think tank's A Place For Pride report on pride and patriotism, which is launched on Monday.


A man stabbed on a train station concourse has died, police said.

The victim, in his 40s, was taken to hospital with life-threatening injuries following the stabbing at Plymouth station, but later died.
A 29-year-old man has been arrested on suspicion of murder and is in police custody.
British Transport Police said it was working to identify the man and inform his family and appealed for any witnesses to come forward.
More on the stabbing and other Devon and Cornwall news
Det Ch Insp Paul Langley said: "This was an attack on a man in broad daylight at a busy station in Devon.
"At this time, it is believed the two men knew each other and had an argument at the station, which resulted in one of the men assaulting the other.
"The victim was taken to hospital but he sadly died despite the best efforts of the medical teams."
A spokesman for South Western Ambulance Service said paramedics attended to two male casualties, one with minor injuries and another with head and shoulder injuries.
The ticket office of the station has been closed off due to the incident, leaving passengers unable to buy or collect reserved tickets.
A spokesman for Great Western Railway said: "Access to Plymouth station is restricted and the ticket office remains closed while police continue to investigate the incident this morning.
"The station remains open, with tickets available on platforms and on-board trains."
Network Rail said trains were "running as normal".


Power struggles, personality clashes and conflicting agendas - it could be the plot of a Shakespearean tragedy.

In fact, it is the real-life backstage drama at Shakespeare's Globe theatre.
Artistic director Emma Rice and her predecessor Dominic Dromgoole have laid bare details of the dispute that led Rice to resign last year.
Her decision was sparked by her use of artificial lights and sound, but in an open letter she has said it "was about personal trust and artistic freedom".
She announced her departure in October and will leave the London venue next year.
With applications for her successor closing on Monday, she and Dromgoole have written revealing letters on the theatre's website.
Rice wrote: "Here, I have found my fight and my 'right', I have stood up for what I believe in and tried to do it with kindness, care and seriousness.
"However, in the wake of recent events, the Globe is wrestling with what, at its core, it now stands for. It is still in the process of deciding and clarifying what its fight and its 'right' are.
"I had to choose to leave because I choose myself and my work. Never think that my decision to step down in 2018 was simply about lights and sound, it was about personal trust and artistic freedom."
She added a warning to the person who follows her: "You must make sure that your own freedom is assured."
She decided to quit, she said, because the theatre's board "did not love and respect me back" and "began to talk of a new set of rules that I did not sign up to and could not stand by".
A list of lessons she has learned included: "I have learnt, never again, to allow myself to be excluded from the rooms where decisions are made."
The Globe, she explained, is "not a job, it is a vocation and an all-consuming, delicious tangle of histories, hopes, passions and agendas".
Dromgoole, who was at the Globe from 2005-16, went further in detailing the pressures borne by artistic directors.
The "bile" from external critics "can be disabling", he wrote.
He went on: "Sadly the negativity doesn't only come from without, there is also a fair sum within.
"There are structural problems, there are personality problems, there is too much fighting for territory, and there are too many who feel free to comment on work without ever taking the risk of making it.
"It is absurd that out of the mess of last year, the only person to be suffering the consequences is Emma."
He said he disagreed with Rice's attempts to move away from the traditional "shared light" - in which the actors and audience are in the same light - which he said was "at the heart of her disagreements with colleagues and the board".
But he said: "I cannot respect the blocking of her choice."
He warned her successor to be "exceptionally wary of those who do not want to advise but who want to influence", adding: "Everybody wants to be artistic director. They can't all be. Only you can."
The only people with the "moral strength" to get rid of an artistic director are the audience, he wrote.
"No-one else, not the board, not your supposed colleagues, not the vulture punditry, just the audience. Emma had lost a little of the Globe audience, but all the evidence is that she had gained some as well."
A spokesperson for the theatre said chief executive Neil Constable and the board would not be commenting on the remarks.
The Globe, which opened in 1997, is a reconstruction of a Shakespearean theatre on London's Southbank.
Follow us on Facebook, on Twitter @BBCNewsEnts, or on Instagram at bbcnewsents. If you have a story suggestion email entertainment.news@bbc.co.uk.


Solihull Moors have completed the signing of forward Pearson Mwanyongo from Northern Premier League Division One South side Gresley.

Mwanyongo, 24, is the sixth signing made by boss Liam McDonald since he took over on 14 November.
He had been training under former Moors boss Marcus Bignot at League Two side Grimsby Town but has now opted to join Solihull instead.
"He was attracting attention at league and non-league clubs," said McDonald.
"Pearson is quick and skilful with loads of ability and he'll be a massive asset for us.
"He has recently been on a week's trial at Grimsby Town and impressed, He was due to go back to them but, following a chat with us, he's decided to sign a contract at Solihull."
Mwanyongo, who has proved a prolific scorer in a wide attacking role since joining Gresley in the summer, goes straight into contention for the New Year's Day trip to Chester.
The Moors, now 16th in the table, will be out to do the double, having beaten Chester 3-2 at Damson Park on Boxing Day.
Find all the latest football transfers on our dedicated page.


Clyde moved to within a point of Elgin City and four behind leaders East Fife with victory over Scottish League Two bottom side East Stirlingshire.

Shire led through Thomas Orr but Jordan Cairnie's headed own goal levelled matters.
Scott McLaughlin nodded Clyde in front and Sean Higgins struck their third.
The visitors had David March dismissed and then conceded when Kris Faulds netted but Higgins' second made sure of victory late on.


West Midlands Ambulance Service (WMAS) had the second worst response rate in England for serious emergencies in 2009-10 after Yorkshire's service.

The National Audit Office (NAO) said WMAS had responded within eight minutes 72.5% of the time. The Yorkshire Ambulance Service figure was 70.8%.
The national target is to respond within eight minutes 75% of the time.
Both ambulance services said the data was out of date and they had since improved their response times.
Before the financial year 2009-10, WMAS NHS Trust argued that it was among the worst-funded ambulance services in the country.
An independent study, the Lightfoot report, concluded in September 2009 that WMAS had been historically underfunded.
As a result WMAS received more NHS funding and for the remaining months of that financial year, it achieved all of its national performance targets.
A spokesman for WMAS said: "The Transforming NHS ambulance services - National Audit Office report carries a variety of information (including ambulance response times) up to the end of the 2009-10 financial year.
"It does not carry any information for the year 2010-11 and therefore does not reflect West Midlands Ambulance Service's significant improvement in response times during that year."
WMAS service said its response time to serious emergencies within eight minutes in April 2011 was 76.8%.
The poor performance of YAS in 2009 was reported to the Care Quality Commission, after which it took urgent action to improve, which included addressing staffing issues.
Between April and August 2010 YAS responded to 76.1% of serious emergencies  within eight minutes and in August last year the figure was 78.8%.


League Two Newport County or Plymouth Argyle will travel to Anfield to face Premier League Liverpool in the FA Cup third round.

Media playback is not supported on this device
West Ham will host Manchester City in the pick of the all-Premier League ties, with Everton set to welcome Leicester City.
Holders Manchester United will entertain Reading, managed by former United defender Jaap Stam.
National League Sutton United will face neighbours AFC Wimbledon.
The 32 third-round ties will be played from 6-9 January 2017.
Newport are a fan-owned club and chairman Gavin Foxall said of the prospect of a tie at Anfield: "It would absolutely be a massive financial boost for us.
"Certainly for a club like ours it would secure the future for a season or two at least.
"A game at Anfield against Liverpool would rank right up there in the club's history."
While Liverpool's opponents are yet to be decided, the biggest beneficiaries of the definite ties look to be Championship Preston, who welcome 2014 and 2015 winners Arsenal.
"It is great for the football club," manager Simon Grayson told the North End club website.
"Being at home, it gives your own fans the opportunity to see some world-class players and they don't come much bigger and better than this Arsenal squad at this time."
For holders Manchester United, the visit of Reading will see a return to Old Trafford for former defender Stam, who was part of the 1999 treble-winning team.
"I look forward to that," said Stam's former United team-mate Andy Cole on BBC Two. "He's done very well at Reading. I'm really pleased for him."
The lowest ranked club left in the competition, Stourbridge United, face a potential trip to League Two Wycombe Wanderers, should the seventh-tier Northern Premier League Premier Division club beat Northampton Town in a rearranged fixture.
Of the other non-league sides through to the third round, Barrow will host Rochdale while either Halifax or Eastleigh go to Brentford.
"I think the chairman will be really happy, because at least we're at home," said Barrow manager Paul Cox.
Media playback is not supported on this device


More than 1,110 people have been recognised on the Queen's Birthday Honours list.

Here are 14 of the more famous faces.
Occupation: Author
Honour: Joins the Order of the Companions of Honour for services to literature and philanthropy
Quote: "I'm deeply honoured and proud to be nominated for this honour... and to be included in the distinguished and diversely talented company of the other Companions of Honour."
Occupation: Broadcaster
Honour:  OBE for services to cancer charities through breast screening services and cancer support
Occupation: Double Olympic rowing champion
Honour:  OBE for services to rowing
Occupation: Musician
Honour:  Joins the Order of the Companions of Honour for services to music
Quote: "I'm very happy about this huge honour and with the news coming on my birthday weekend and Father's Day it makes it colossal."
Occupation: Comedian
Honour:  Knighthood for services to entertainment and charity
Quote: "I have an ordinary background and it was never on the horizon when I was growing up that I might get this. I'm not big on pride but whatever the equivalent of pride is that is a bit decent, I've got that. I'm a little embarrassed but deep within me I'm very pleased."
Occupation: Musician
Honour:  MBE for services to music and charity
Occupation: Singer-songwriter
Honour:  MBE for services to music
Occupation: Actress
Honour: Damehood for services to drama
Occupation: Former Great Britain Fed Cup captain
Honour:  OBE for services to tennis, women in sport and charity
Occupation: Designer
Honour:  Joins the Order of the Companions of Honour for services to design
Occupation: Model
Honour:  OBE for services to fashion and charity
Occupation: Broadcaster
Honour: OBE for services to Holocaust commemoration
Occupation:  Boxer, former world light-heavyweight champion
Honour: MBE for services to boxing
Quote:  "It's an absolute privilege and an honour and I'm so grateful to all the people who supported me and put me forward for this award."
Occupation: Captain, Northern Ireland football team
Honour:  MBE for services to football
Quote: "I was shocked and taken aback when I was told about it. I thought it was a joke at first. It was just something that had never registered with me, that I might receive something like this."


A five-month-old girl who died after suffering a fractured skull was unlawfully killed by one of her parents, a coroner has concluded.

Sunaria Hamid-Howells, from Pontypridd, Rhondda Cynon Taff, died in 2012.
A neonatal expert suggested at a previous hearing it was unlikely her fall from a rocker chair four days earlier caused her fatal injuries.
Cardiff coroner Christopher Woolley said one of her parents, Dilshad Hamid or Katherine Howells, caused her death.
"This person, I find, was the person who picked Sunaria up on 30 December in the living room, shook her and inflicted head trauma on her," he added.
"One individual did the unlawful act, it's not possible on the evidence to determine if this person was Mr Hamid or Ms Howells, but it can only have been one of them."
He said the seriousness of Sunaria's injures would have been instantly obvious to the person who inflicted them upon her.
Earlier in the hearing, Sunaria's uncle urged the couple to admit who was responsible for her death.
Michael Howells said: "She was a beautiful little baby - the evidence suggests that either Katherine or Dilshad caused the injury that led to her death.
"One of you caused her death. Please, before we leave this court, my question is who caused her injuries - somebody is responsible for this."
A post-mortem examination showed a brain injury occurred "around the time of collapse and likely to have been present for no more than 48 to 72 hours before death".
Mr Woolley revealed at Wednesday's hearing that South Wales Police had referred her death to the CPS, but the conclusion was there was no realistic prospect of conviction.
He said: "I was satisfied that there may be new information suggesting not only that a homicide may have taken place but that there may have been someone responsible for that homicide."
In bad-tempered exchanges during the hearing, Sunaria's father questioned Ms Howells about the events of 30 December 2012.
In response, she said Sunaria was "absolutely fine" when she put her in a basket before she heard her daughter make a "horrible, vile" noise "fluctuating in pitch as though as child was being shaken".
Denying any involvement in causing her injuries, Ms Howells said: "I wouldn't hurt my baby - I loved that little girl."
Mr Hamid called this a lie. He said Sunaria suffered a fit while he was bottle feeding her and did not make this noise.
When asked by Mr Woolley if he had ever hurt, dropped, shaken or hit his daughter, Mr Hamid said: "Of course not."
He also said he had no idea how Sunaria suffered a fractured leg which doctors believed was caused by a twisting motion.
Finishing his own evidence, he said: "I want to know what's going on, I want to know the truth. I've done nothing wrong with my baby apart from loving her, she was everything to me."
The inquest heard Ms Howells ran to a neighbour saying "there's something wrong with my baby". They called 999 and did chest compressions until paramedics arrived.
Sunaria was taken to the Royal Glamorgan Hospital, near Llantrisant, where doctors discovered bruising and brown marks on her cheeks.
A CT scan showed a skull fracture and bleeding to the brain. She was transferred to Cardiff's University Hospital of Wales where she died the next day.
Doctors found the parents' explanation about previous falls "inadequate" to account for her severe head injury, bruising to her cheeks and marks on her arms.
Sunaria died as a result of brain swelling and a subdural haemorrhage.
Mr Woolley said: "It's clear to me neither [parent] has told the full truth about the injuries to Sunaria, I find the injuries were caused non-accidentally on 30 December 2012."


Twitter has reinstated the account of a white nationalist think tank leader credited with coining the term "alt-right".

The social network suspended Richard Spencer on 15 November.
Since then, he was filmed shouting: "Hail Trump, hail our people, hail victory," at a meeting, prompting some audience members to raise their arms in Nazi-style salutes.
A leading anti-racism campaigner has criticised Twitter's decision.
The technology company told the BBC that Mr Spencer had been temporarily blocked for running multiple accounts and not - as had been speculated - for hate speech offences.
"Our rules explicitly prohibit creating multiple accounts with overlapping uses," said a spokesman for the company.
"When we temporarily suspend multiple accounts for this violation, the account owner can designate one account for reinstatement."
He added that Mr Spencer's other accounts would remain blocked.
Should the BBC use 'alt-right' or not?
Mr Spencer is president of the white nationalist think tank the National Policy Institute.
He has not commented about his reinstatement, beyond posting a Gif from the Terminator film alongside the words "I'm back".
He had previously accused Twitter of "purging" him and others based on their views.
These include support for the idea of "ethno-states" - nations whose citizens share a common ancestry.
Mr Spencer has denied links to neo-Nazism, and defended his supporters' arm gestures at the filmed Washington DC event, saying they were "Roman salutes" given "in the spirit of ironic exuberance".
But one critic has warned that his return to Twitter poses dangers.
"He has access to hundreds of thousands of people and can poison minds, often those of young impressionable people," said Gerry Gable, founder of the anti-fascist Searchlight magazine.
"If the the industry can't get together to put a stop to this, then governments have got to step in and take some action."
Mr Spencer was banned from visiting the UK earlier this year by the then Home Secretary, Theresa May, who suggested his views would "foster hatred which might lead to inter-community violence".
He has also been temporarily barred from visiting 26 other European countries, for taking part in an illegal meeting in Hungary in 2014.
US President-elect Donald Trump has also voiced concern.
When questioned about the alt-right meeting at which the salutes were given, Mr Trump said: "It is not a group I want to energise, and if they are energised I want to look into it and find out why... I condemn [them]. I disavow and condemn."
What is the alt-right?
Supporters of the alt-right movement differ on many points, but are generally outspoken in their attacks on multiculturalism, globalisation and immigration.
Their targets also include what they see as political correctness and feminism.
Steve Bannon - President-elect Donald Trump's chief strategist and former head of Breitbart News, which has covered the movement - defined it as "younger people who are anti-globalists, very nationalist, terribly anti-establishment".
He added that it had "some racial and anti-Semitic overtones".
The Associated Press news agency has expressed caution about using the designation.
"The term may exist primarily as a public-relations device to make its supporters' actual beliefs less clear and more acceptable to a broader audience," its staff were told last month.
"In the past, we have called such beliefs racist, neo-Nazi or white supremacist."


Premiership title hopefuls Exeter Chiefs left it late to secure a bonus-point win against Newcastle Falcons.

After a turgid first half which saw Gareth Steenson and Mike Delany trade penalties, the second half burst into life as Chiefs' Thomas Waldrom scored.
A flurry of tries then saw Sonatane Takulua and Nili Latu score for Falcons either side of Phil Dollman's effort to leave the game tied at 17-17.
However, late scores from Sam Hill and Elvis Taione eased the Chiefs clear.
Taione's late score ensured the bonus point and temporarily put Exeter two points clear at the top of the table, only for Saracens to then regain the lead with a 26-16 win over London Irish in New Jersey.
Much of the pre-match talk focused on the return of Exeter's England hopeful Henry Slade from injury, but despite some flashes of quality he was unable to spark this game into life.
Instead that mantle fell to Steenson, who was excellent with the boot and probed and sniped to give Exeter momentum.
Rob Baxter's Chiefs have recovered from a mini-wobble earlier in the campaign to stake their Premiership claims.
At the other end of the table, the Falcons remain second from bottom after leaving with nothing to show for their determined display following the late tries from Hill and Taione.
Exeter: Dollman; Woodburn, Slade, Hill, Whitten; Steenson, Chudley; Moon, Yeandle, Williams, Stevenson, Parling, Armand, Salvi, Waldrom.
Replacements: Taione, Hepburn, Rimmer, Atkins, Ewers, Lewis, Hooley, Bodilly.
Newcastle:  Tait; Venditti, Harris, Pablo Socino, Sinoti; Delany, Takulua; Rogers, McGuigan, Cusack, Botha, Green, Wilson, Welch, Latu.
Replacements: Lawson, Harris, Hatakeyama, Mayhew, Hogg, Young, Goode, Penny.
For the latest rugby union news follow @bbcrugbyunion on Twitter.


Lancashire's slim Division Two title hopes were finally brought to an end at Chelmsford as they were forced to settle for a draw with Essex.

After resuming on 131-2, Lancashire were bowled out for 301, collecting the third batting bonus point they needed.
But, despite losing England captain Alastair Cook cheaply for the second time in the match, Essex rallied.
Ravi Bopara hit an unbeaten 52 as Essex reached 138-3, rendering the result of Surrey's game at The Oval immaterial.
As it turned out, a Lancashire victory would have given them the title, but the 2011 county champions started the day knowing they had only a slim chance of adding to the silverware they won in August when they triumphed in TwentyT20 cricket for the first time.
They had overnight Luis Reece caught behind for 82 before Ashwell Prince, given a guard of honour in his final match for Lancashire, struck an entertaining 51 from only 38 balls.
But Ravi Bopara (3-40), young spinner Aron Nijjar (2-33) and Graham Napier (2-49) then got stuck in as Lancashire lost their last six wickets in 15 overs for just 29 runs.
Lancashire needed quick wickets themselves and when they had Essex at 10-2, they briefly looked to be in with a chance.
England fast bowler James Anderson removed Nick Browne and Glen Chapple did the same to Cook's hopes of batting practice ahead of the forthcoming Pakistan series in the Persian Gulf.
But by tea, Essex had rallied and, although they lost Tom Westley for 34, Bopara and Jesse Ryder (38 not out) saw out time until hands were shaken on the final day of the season.
Acting head coach Chris Silverwood told BBC Radio Essex:
"It's been frustrating because we lost so much time to the weather. But we got enough points out of the game to ensure that we finished in third place.
"That was something we talked about when I took over four games ago. I said to them when I took over that I wanted to set the bar for next season in the remaining games this year.
"The results, and the way we've played, show how well they've responded and gone about their work. I set challenges to the players both individually and as a team and they responded positively."
Lancashire coach Ashley Giles told BBC Manchester:
"Congratulations to Surrey. They have played some excellent cricket throughout the season, they have won more games than us  and they deserved to win the title.
"It is a bit disappointing to finish runners-up because we led the table for most of the summer but we can learn lessons from that as well.
"We still need to understand where we get better and how we can improve and we'll get together next week and start to look at that."


One in five domestic violence victims in Yorkshire are men, according to a charity holding a conference in Doncaster.

The conference, organised by Mankind Initiative and held at the Keepmoat Stadium, was chaired by former abuse victim Ian McNicholl.
His ex-girlfriend is serving a seven year prison sentence for GBH and assault.
Mankind Initiative said men too often are "too ashamed" to report abuse.
Mr McNicholl, 52, from East Yorkshire, said: "Far too many men feel they're to blame, they're weak and they're alone often because they do not think there is support for them.
"We aim to change that so no man suffers in silence and realise they can escape and rebuild their lives."
Mankind Initiative said male domestic abuse figures are particularly high in South Yorkshire.
In the last three years, police received 19,459 calls from men but the charity said the real figures are likely to be higher because of under-reporting by men.
Mr McNicholl, who was in an abusive relationship for 18 months, said:
"By the time I was rescued by police I had a fractured skull, multiple fractures to my cheekbone, I've had the septum on my nose replaced, I have a scar from an assault with a steam iron.
"It almost took my life. She told me in her last assault she was going to kill me. I was also on the point of suicide."
He said he did not report it earlier because he feared for his life and was "emotionally and physically ground-down".
130 delegates from around the country attended the conference.
Mankind Initiative said men often do not report abuse because they feel "embarrassed", feel it "undermines their identity as a man" and "fear they won't be believed."


Police say a suspected firearm and ammunition have been found in Strabane, County Tyrone.

It follows a security alert at Lismourne Place in the town on Saturday.
The items have been taken away for forensic examination.
Police said there were "no further details" at this stage.


Volkswagen has offered those US customers caught up in the diesel emissions cheating scandal $1,000 in gift cards and vouchers.

The car manufacturer is offering the money as a gesture of goodwill to 482,000 US owners of the faulty cars.
It is also offering free roadside assistance to those who have owned their cars for three years.
Volkswagen said its Audi luxury brand would launch a similar program on Friday.
The offer is designed to mollify the owners of the 2-litre diesel powered VW cars as the car manufacturer works on repairing the vehicles affected.
The US Environmental Protection Agency says the cars emit 10 to 40 times the allowable amount of harmful nitrogen oxide while being driven.
"We are working tirelessly to develop an approved remedy for affected vehicles," said Volkswagen US chief executive Michael Horn in a statement.
"In the meantime we are providing this goodwill package as a first step towards regaining our customers' trust."
VW owners will not be required to sign anything giving up their right to sue the car manufacturer or forcing them into arbitration, a VW spokeswoman added.
Volkswagen has already offered $2,000 to current VW owners to trade their cars in for new vehicles as well as the $1,000 gift cards and vouchers.
It has admitted that four-cylinder diesels from its 2009 to 2015 model years have the software that can cheat on pollution tests.
About 11 million cars worldwide have the software.
Last week, the EPA accused VW of cheating with different software on larger six-cylinder diesels in about 10,000 vehicles.
The company also has admitted finding irregularities in carbon dioxide emissions in 800,000 other vehicles, all outside the US some of which it said were likely to be petrol engine powered cars.


Concerns have been raised about the "inequality" of salaries at Welsh universities after it emerged 210 staff earned more than £100,000 a year.

The union UCU said the high pay of senior staff was in contrast to the average salaries of other university teaching staff on insecure contracts.
It said they were underpaid.
The Higher Education Funding Council for Wales (Hefcw) said Welsh universities needed to compete to get the best staff.
It was commissioned by the Welsh Government to compile a report on the salaries of university leaders, after an assembly committee recommended collecting information on senior pay across the public sector.
The research, released to BBC Wales under the Freedom of information Act, found that Cardiff University had by far the largest number of higher-paid staff in Wales, with 136 receiving more than £100,000 between 2014-15.
It also found that, including pension contributions, seven of Wales' eight vice-chancellors were paid more than £200,000 last year.
Number of university staff earning more than £100,000 in 2014-15
Aberystwyth - 4
Bangor - 17
Cardiff Metropolitan - 9
Cardiff University - 136
Glyndwr University - 2
Swansea University - 28
University of South Wales - 10
University of Wales Trinity Saint David - 4
Cardiff University's Vice Chancellor Colin Riordan continues to be the highest-paid head of a Welsh university, earning £288,000 after pension contributions.
But the report stressed that pay in Welsh universities was comparable with other institutions of the same size and stature in the UK.
It concluded Welsh universities now operated in an international marketplace, and to compete at that level, pay needed to compare with that of other UK universities if the best talent was to be recruited.
It also said that some vice-chancellors' salaries were lower than similar universities across the country and comes after a warning from the previous Welsh education minister Huw Lewis that higher education could not expect to avoid cuts for ever.
However, the UCU, which represents higher education staff, said it was "concerned" about the pay gaps at universities.
"Our main concern is the inequality between the average salary of VCs in Wales, compared to the average salary of other staff in our universities, particularly when taking into account that undergraduates are likely to be taught by a member of staff on an insecure, fixed-term contract," a spokesman said.
"Staff on insecure contracts struggle to deliver the high level of professional service that they strive for, when faced with working conditions that leave them underpaid, vulnerable and constantly facing the prospect of unemployment."
A Cardiff University spokesman said it was distinct from other Welsh universities in having large medical and dental schools as well as the Postgraduate Deanery for Wales.
"The report includes clinical staff where salaries are set by the NHS," he said.
"Their salaries are set by the NHS not by universities and relate to their level of expertise."
He added: "To attract and retain the best, Cardiff offers salaries which are competitive with its peers in the Russell Group of research-led universities."


Teenage spinner Sophie Ecclestone will miss England's upcoming tour of Sri Lanka because of school commitments.

The 17-year-old took 2-28 on her one-day international debut in the West Indies earlier this month.
Seam bowler Anya Shrubsole is also unavailable after she sustained a neck injury in Jamaica, but batter Fran Wilson is recalled to the squad.
England need one win from the final three ODIs in Sri Lanka to qualify for the 2017 World Cup, which they host.
An extra ODI on 9 November has been added to the start of the tour, but only the last three of the four matches will count towards the ICC Women's Championship which determines World Cup qualification.
A 15th player will be added to the 14-strong squad, and is likely to come from an additional group of players who will join the main party for a training camp in Abu Dhabi from 1-7 November, before the ODI series takes place in Colombo from 9-17 November.
Ecclestone, who has played two ODIs and two Twenty20 internationals for England, is available to take part in the training camp because it takes place during the half-term break at her school. However, the Sri Lanka tour is during term time.
England ODI squad: Heather Knight (capt), Tammy Beaumont, Katherine Brunt, Georgia Elwiss, Jenny Gunn, Alex Hartley, Danielle Hazell, Amy Jones (wk), Beth Langston, Laura Marsh, Natalie Sciver, Lauren Winfield, Fran Wilson, Danielle Wyatt, plus one other.
Additional players for Abu Dhabi training camp: Georgia Adams, Kate Cross, Alice Davidson-Richards, Sophia Dunkley, *Sophie Ecclestone, Georgia Hennessy, Hannah Jones, Emma Lamb, Bryony Smith.
*Ecclestone will return to school after the training camp


A leading union will call on Scottish party leaders to bring forward "bold ambitious policies" in the Holyrood election campaign.

STUC general secretary Grahame Smith will warn that it could take time to take advantage of new devolved powers.
Responsibilities over income tax and welfare will be transferred to MSPs from April 2017.
Mr Smith will make the plea as the STUC annual congress begins in Dundee on Monday.
The general secretary of the Scottish Trades Unions Congress believes the campaign in the run-up to May's election "doesn't yet reflect the possibilities provided by new powers".
Mr Smith said the vote would be "the most important election to take place since the Scottish Parliament was re-established in 1999".
He wants party leaders to bring forward "bold ambitious policies" that will attempt to tackle some of the "hitherto intractable problems in the Scottish economy and society".
Mr Smith will say: "The next Scottish government really has to aspire to more than just managerial competence.
"Unfortunately, the campaign going on around us doesn't yet reflect the possibilities provided by new powers. Indeed, the nature and quality of debate suggests that it could take some time for our political parties to recognise that new opportunities exist, let alone grasp them."
He wants parties to bring forward "policies that will have a real impact on reducing poverty and inequality, that are based on the evidence of what works rather than their populist appeal or soundbite suitability".
In a statement ahead of the election, the STUC is making a number of key demands on the next government, including:
With the congress due to hear from both SNP leader Nicola Sturgeon and Scottish Labour leader Kezia Dugdale, Mr Smith will say: "We need a new approach to industrial policy, a step-change in support for childcare and for a Trade Union Bill in Scotland designed to embed Scotland's alternative approach to industrial relations throughout the public sector and the wider economy."


The Premier League starts again on Saturday, with surprise champions Leicester City defending the title they won by 10 points last season.

Who will win it this time, and how will the Foxes fare? We asked 33 BBC TV and radio pundits, presenters, journalists and commentators - and one super-computer for their one-two-three-four and an explanation of their selection.
The predictions were made on the basis of how each squad shaped up on Friday 12 August, before the opening weekend and with more than a fortnight to go before the transfer window shuts.
Seven teams feature in the forecasted top fours, compared to only four clubs in 29 of the 30 BBC predictions last season. Apart from Gullit and Wright, Keown and Nevin, and Crooks and Murray. everyone's combination is unique.
Nobody is backing Leicester to repeat their title success - their average expected position is seventh - and it is Manchester City who are favourites, with 18 votes. Manchester United get 12 votes, Chelsea three and Tottenham one.
Media playback is not supported on this device
None of our experts picked Leicester to be champions last year, and none of them think they will defend their title. All 33 put them in the top 10, but only one, Dean Saunders, thinks they will finish in the top four.
Dean Saunders: Leicester have got some excellent players, plus they work hard and have got a formula that works, so they will not just disappear. They have only lost three out of 38 league games under Ranieri so they will carry that on, especially because they have kept Riyad Mahrez and Jamie Vardy. They are going to challenge for the title again.
Danny Murphy: This season Leicester will want to maintain a high level but they are in the Champions League too. If they finish in the top eight again and have a decent run in Europe, then their fans are still in dreamland.
Manish Bhasin: Eighth would be a minor miracle - but frankly after last season, who cares?!  Seriously though, as long as we don't let Champions League commitments derail us (still sounds absurdly beautiful) I once again expect the sheer pace in the squad to cause opponents all sorts of problems.
Foxes fan Manish presents the first MOTD2 of the season at 22:30 BST on Sunday, featuring highlights of Bournemouth v Manchester United and Arsenal v Liverpool.
Pat Nevin: I would applaud them to the heavens if they make the top half again. The Champions League changes everything - they have got more games, and less rest - they will not be able to play the same team every time like they did last season. Also, when you take one player out of a unit like that then it makes one heck of a difference, especially if that player is N'Golo Kante.
Danny Mills: The Champions League is going to affect them mentally as well as physically - getting up for for big games in Europe is easy, but to then come back to a Premier League game is tough and hard to get used to. Yes they have made signings but they still don't have strength in depth, they will miss Kante and are heavily reliant on Mahrez and Vardy.
Media playback is not supported on this device
Match of the Day commentator Alistair Bruce-Ball: Leicester showed in the Community Shield that they are still a very good side despite seeing Kante go to Chelsea, but will they be as lucky with injuries as they were last time?
Jermaine Jenas: If you look at the other contenders, they are all looking a lot stronger than they were so it is going to be harder for Leicester. If Claudio Ranieri can get them back in the Champions League again then it would be another amazing achievement - but I don't see it.
Former Liverpool Ladies and Everton Ladies goalkeeper and Women's Football Show pundit Rachel Brown-Finnis: I would not be surprised if they end up in the top four. You don't win a title on luck, you win the league based on something solid and consistent, which is what they had last season, and I think they will have it this season too.
BBC Radio 5 live sports reporter Juliette Ferrington: This season will be a huge test for their squad but a top-10 finish would not be too shabby.
You can listen to Ferrington - and all the Premier League goals as they go in around the grounds - every Saturday afternoon on BBC Radio 5 live.
Media playback is not supported on this device
City are the only team to feature in everyone's forecasted top four for this season. In fact, no-one we asked thinks Pep Guardiola's side will finish lower than third.
Jermaine Jenas: When I look at everyone's squad and the transfer business that has been done, I cannot see City not winning it. People might say John Stones is not a sure-bet defensively, but he is a brilliant player and he is going to thrive under Guardiola - that signing clinched it for me - I expect them to be champions.
Chris Sutton: First of all I think this this is probably the hardest Premier League to predict of all time but if I was picking anyone, I would pick City - Guardiola has come over for a reason and he does not really know what failure is. They were massive under-achievers last season in the league and this season I think he will get far more out of a talented group of players.
Match of the Day commentator Guy Mowbray: It will be harder for Pep than it was at Barcelona or Bayern but he has the players and the financial clout behind him to win the title and all the signs from pre-season and in training are that he has settled into his new club straight away, and means business.
Media playback is not supported on this device
Trevor Sinclair: Guardiola is probably the best manager in the world and these are exciting times at the Etihad Stadium but I have gone for Chelsea to finish above City because not only have they got a lot of new players, their whole squad needs to get used to Pep's system, and I just think it might take a bit of time to get used to his complex and pretty demanding style.
BBC Radio 5 live's senior football reporter Ian Dennis: Pep talks about a "mix" of his squad adapting to his style and likewise him adapting to them. It can take time for everyone to adjust, which is why I am going for United instead.
Danny Mills: This season depends on how quickly they settle in but Pep will win the league with City at some point - it is a question of when, not if.
Media playback is not supported on this device
Last season, only two BBC experts backed United to win the title but no-one thought they would finish lower than fourth - they ended up fifth. This time, 11 people think they will win the title but two think they will miss out on the Champions League again.
Jason Roberts: I think United will win the League as Jose Mourinho has adapted his squad quickly into his philosophy by bringing in an effective spine of quality acquisitions, much like he did at Chelsea previously. This time Eric Bailly, Paul Pogba and Zlatan Ibrahimovic will give Mourinho the quality and the physical presence his teams are known for.
Match of the Day commentator Conor McNamara: Jose has cleverly brought in some big egos in Ibrahimovic and Pogba. This will give United some of their old swagger back.
Mark Lawrenson: They have got a chance of the title because I think Mourinho is the type of manager who will not be bothered about the Europa League. With all those games to play, he will not let it get in the way.
John Hartson: They will certainly get a Champions League spot this time but I am not quite sure they will be as strong as City over 38 games.
Media playback is not supported on this device
Chelsea Ladies forward and BBC Sport columnist Eniola Aluko: I think the Premier league trophy will return to Manchester either way and United will have an edge over City primarily because Mourinho knows what it takes to win it (and did so recently) whereas Guardiola, despite his strong squad, will not have the experience of winning the Premier League. Away matches against awkward opposition like Stoke may be the difference in terms of Guardiola's acclimatisation to the competitiveness of the league.
Pat Nevin: I have gone for City but it could just be goal-difference between the two Manchester clubs again like in 2012 when City won - I really do think it will be that close. City are the better team but United have got Mourinho's nous of winning the title before which will help them a lot.
Danny Mills: Mourinho has not just been there, seen it and done it, he also has a point to prove after what happened to Chelsea last season.
Chris Waddle: He knows how to get results, but will United be as exciting as the fans want them to be? I don't think he will care too much about that, because he is there to win things.
Final Score presenter Jason Mohammad: I'm going for United because I think they have made the perfect choice in Mourinho. The man loves winning trophies, and he has got one already after Sunday's Community Shield.
Final Score is live online and on the red button from 14:30 BST on Saturday, and on BBC One from 16:00 BST.
Media playback is not supported on this device
22 out of 30 BBC experts said they would retain their title last year - they finished 10th. This season, three people think they will win it, but 10 think they will miss out on a return to the top four.
Ruud Gullit: Chelsea will have ups and downs, they are in a transition - they have a new coach and a new philosophy.
Pat Nevin: I am not picking them in my top four now because they are a player or two short but if they get a left-back and some cover at left centre-back then I would say they definitely will be. I have watched every one of Chelsea's pre-season games and I have already seen big improvements in really good players in a short space of time, and also the adaptability of Conte. He will try all sorts of different things and if you are capable of manipulating your players like that you have got a real chance of doing something special.
Chelsea Ladies forward and BBC Sport columnist Eniola Aluko: I don't think Conte will tolerate under-performance and he will bring out the best in the top players like Eden Hazard but I think top four is the best Chelsea will get to without a reliable 20+ goals a season striker. Diego Costa is still the main striker but isn't always prolific enough and is susceptible to disciplinary issues. If he doesn't play, where will the goals for Chelsea come from?
Media playback is not supported on this device
Trevor Sinclair: From what I have seen of Italy under Conte they were very strong mentally and if he can give his Chelsea players the same they would be my choice. Also, Kante is an excellent signing and gives them what they missed in midfield last season.
Match of the Day commentator Steve Wilson: Conte is an intriguing addition to the fold. Chelsea have been relatively conservative in the transfer market so far, but I predict a spectacular return to form after their dire last campaign.
Four out of 30 BBC experts backed Arsenal to win the title last season, and everyone thought they would make the top four. This time, nobody is picking them to be champions, only three people are backing them to repeat their second-place from last season and 14 people think they will miss out on a Champions League place.
Ian Wright: Arsenal could not manage a title challenge in a season where Leicester won the league and this time it is going to be a lot harder for them. Chelsea are going to be back in the mix and with United's outlay and City also spending big, all three of them are going to be strong under Conte, Mourinho and Guardiola. As things stand, with no significant signings since Granit Xhaka, no new striker and injuries to their top three centre-halves, the best I can hope for Arsenal is that they make the top four again.
Chris Waddle: If their top players stay fit for the season then they have got a great chance of winning it, no doubt about that. Their problems will come when they get a few injuries again, which we are seeing already. They don't seem to have the same depth in their squad as the other leading sides.
Jermaine Jenas: As good as Arsenal are going forward, defensively I am very worried for them at the moment with all the injuries they have got. I don't think they will be far away from the top four but it will be hard for them to recover if they make a bad start.
Chris Sutton: We know what a great side they are on their day, but they just don't have the character or the ambition to win the league. Until Arsene Wenger goes, I don't see Arsenal really pushing for the title.
Kevin Kilbane: The big clubs have all strengthened a lot, apart from Arsenal - how often do we say that? This might be the year they finally miss out on the top four and Arsene Wenger's contract is up next summer. His future is up in the air and that would be a sad way for him to finish. Even if they win the league, as unlikely as that is, I still think he will go - it looks to me like this will be his last year.
John Hartson: They need another centre-half and striker but I picked Arsenal to finish second because I think they will add another couple of players before the window closes at the end of August - I think Wenger may surprise us there.
Last season not one of the 30 BBC experts asked backed Tottenham to make the top four - they finished third. Only two people think they will improve on that showing this year, including Chris Waddle, who picks them to be champions, and only three think they can repeat it. In total, 22 out of the 33 people asked say Spurs will finish lower than fourth.
Chris Waddle: A lot of people associate me with Spurs because I played there and will be thinking I am just favouring my old club but I think they will be stronger for what happened last season. They came very close and just blew up at the end but they have a lot of young players who will have learned a lot from that and will also be hungry to make amends, not just for missing out on the title but also finishing below Arsenal.
I know City have got Guardiola and United have got Mourinho but they are both at new clubs - at Spurs, Mauricio Pochettino has got a settled squad who have played under him for two seasons already.
Jermaine Jenas: What they have in their favour is that they will hit the ground running. Pochettino is not going to change the way he plays and everyone at the club buys into it and the players love playing that way.
Chris Sutton: They were a breath of fresh air last season but it is a big ask for them to repeat their success, mainly because of what the other top sides have done. I cannot see them finishing above City, United and Chelsea again, but I still put them in the top six - I have room for them there.
John Hartson: I might be doing them an injustice to put them fifth but there will be a lot more pressure on them this season and, along with having to cope with the Champions League, that will not help. You know what fans are like - they get a bit of success and expectancy level goes through the roof. It is the same with West Ham, who finished seventh last season - it will be very hard for them to repeat that, let alone improve on it.
Liverpool made it into just one top-four prediction last season. This year, 13 BBC experts think they can crack the Champions League places. One of them - John Motson - thinks they will finish as runners-up and three of them are tipping the Reds to finish third.
Jermaine Jenas: I went with them for my top four because I like what they have done in the transfer market so far and this is Jurgen Klopp's team now. This is his first full season after his first pre-season working with the players - and that makes a huge difference.
Chris Sutton: With the momentum Klopp gathered this season, it would not surprise me if they make a flying start. I don't think they are good enough to win it, but they will certainly be in the top four.
Trevor Sinclair: Sadio Mane is an excellent signing who can just ghost past defenders and he reminds me a little bit of Luis Suarez. Liverpool look like they mean business - they blew away some top teams under Klopp last season and he has had a bit more time with the players now to help them find some consistency.
Mark Lawrenson: I think they are looking at fifth or sixth unless they can make a couple more top-quality signings. They are desperate for a left-back, for starters. Having no European football will help Jurgen Klopp because he will have more time to prepare his players to play his pressing style, but I think a top-four place is 50-50 at best. If Daniel Sturridge has more injury problems then, as things stand, I don't think he has another regular goalscorer without him.
Subscribe to the BBC Sport newsletter to get our pick of news, features and video sent to your inbox.


Team GB rugby sevens silver medallist James Davies says he is grateful that Wales coach Warren Gatland did not pick him for Wales' tour of New Zealand.

Media playback is not supported on this device
The Scarlets flanker, 25, starred after instead being selected for Rio with Britain beaten by Fiji in the final.
Davies had been tipped to be part of Wales' squad for the June tour, which would have ruled him out of the Games.
"I'm just so thankful I didn't go on that tour now, but hopefully that call does one day come," he said.
Davies has previously said he made himself available for Wales' three-Test tour of New Zealand, but was overlooked, opening the way for him to train with Great Britain's sevens squad between May and July.
He was also not included in Wales' squad for the 2015 World Cup, which ran from September to October.
"I'd just like to say thanks to Mr Gatland for not picking me for the autumn because this has been the best experience of my life.
Media playback is not supported on this device
"If that call comes one day it would be another incredible achievement. I'll just wait and see."
Davies was disappointed not to win gold, but admitted Fiji were the better side as they ran out  43-7 winners.
"They were outstanding and they've been the best team in the series for two years now. They thoroughly deserved to take the gold."
Great Britain - who also featured Welshman Sam Cross - were unbeaten in the competition going into the inaugural men's rugby sevens final, which they reached with a narrow 7-5 win over second seeds South Africa.
"It does feel quite special, this is a moment I'm never going to forget. I'm just so glad to be a part of it," said Davies.
"This has been an incredible journey and thankfully the Scarlets let me do it."


The last time these two sides met, Wales effectively knocked England out of their own World Cup with a thrilling come-from-behind victory at Twickenham.

Even in the context of a long and dramatic history between the two sides that stretches back to 1881, it was an encounter of epic proportions.
On Saturday, they meet at Twickenham again in the Six Nations, Wales confident and with a strengthened team, England desperate for revenge and looking to move within one win of a Grand Slam.
It's the perfect scenario - old enemies, childhood friends and a Triple Crown to boot - but who is going to win?
Let England legend Jeremy Guscott and Wales great Jonathan Davies guide you through the issues.
Davies: The battle of childhood friends Billy Vunipola and Taulupe Faletau - the latter even lived with the Vunipolas while at sixth form - is one to relish.
But who comes out on top in the battle of the two number eights will be dictated by which of them gets the most secure platform from their team-mates.
At the moment Wales' Faletau is the best number eight in world. He's a total all-round player, as shown by his incredible stats in this Six Nations.
Billy Vunipola is a different sort of player, a big ball carrier who causes huge problems for defences - he gives England attacking options and gets them on the front foot.
We will see more of what Vunipola does because it is eye-catching, but while he is the best number eight carrying in midfield, Faletau is the best number eight overall - he has a wider skillset.
Guscott: I'm sure no quarter will be given by either Vunipola or Faletau. They have grown up playing against, as well as alongside, each other. They will look forward to a good tear-up on the pitch and a good catch-up afterwards.
Faletau is much more athletic and uses his feet to evade defenders, whereas Vunipola will draw on his power and weight to help him dominate the contact.
The difference continues in how they play the game.
Vunipola is involved more in attack than defence - getting his hands on the ball more than any other player in the tournament with 58 carries.
Faletau is the opposite, racking up a competition-high of 51 tackles.
If Wales can stop Vunipola they will believe they go a long way to stopping England.
Blind-side flanker Dan Lydiate is likely to be given the responsibility. It is a decent-enough theory, but Dan will have to tidy up his tackling technique after being heavily penalised for failing to wrap his arms in recent games.
Read more: Teams, preview & stats
Guscott: The defeat by Wales at the Rugby World Cup in September should motivate England rather than plant any doubts in the minds.
I was part of the England team that lost a Grand Slam decider to Scotland back in 1990. A lot of our players would pull on the memory of that game to help motivate themselves for years to come.
If England lose on Saturday, some in the media will point at it being a hangover from the result six months ago.
However unless England get a decent lead and let it slip or give away too many penalties as they did in the World Cup, I don't believe we can reference it.
The latter of those two things is the more likely. England gave away 12 penalties against Ireland, 15 against Italy and 12 against Scotland - more than the defeated opposition in each match.
Prop Dan Cole has a fair few to his name, while captain Dylan Hartley and back-row pair James Haskell and Chris Robshaw need to be careful as well.
Media playback is not supported on this device
Davies: Wales' win in the World Cup will be a huge motivational factor for England, but there's no doubt the visitors will go into the game full of confidence.
They had so many injuries before that game it is difficult to understand how they won.
Wales will be stronger on Saturday and a better all-round side - now they have all their players fit they will be more of an attacking threat.
But England are also looking better under Eddie Jones. They are more confident and feeling less pressure, as the new coach takes it off the team.
Davies: The breakdown is always key and Wales have the advantage.
Jones could have picked Maro Itoje at six, with the returning Joe Launchbury and George Kruis in the second row, to give his back row more dynamism.
Instead he has stuck with the industry and experience of Robshaw at blind-side and the physicality of Haskell at open-side.
If Wales can get parity in the scrum, it will play a huge part in the result.
We know Wales have an excellent power game but - and this is not criticism - I think they have the ability to play the game differently when required.
If Plan A is not working on Saturday then I'd like to see them look to go outside 13 and use the pace and guile of Liam Williams, George North and Alex Cuthbert out wide.
Guscott: England centre Manu Tuilagi may not have played for England since June 2014, but he can still have an impact, as part of a bench full of big ball-carriers.
Suddenly being required to keep quiet a player with his power after playing 50 or 60 minutes yourself is a tough ask.
I do not envy Dan Biggar, Jamie Roberts and Jonathan Davies.
England have the slightly stronger bench and Tuilagi can run home any England advantage or create the chance that decides a tight game.
Media playback is not supported on this device
Guscott: Ultimately, I don't think they will.
I hope England can win playing the heads-up rugby we've seen so far from them, with their backs scoring good tries.
A win in that style would go a long way to changing our rugby landscape which is still too focused on defence.
However, I believe Wales will prevail because of their experience of seeing out these winner-take-all matches and the fine-tuning that defence coach Shaun Edwards will have done with his side.
Davies: I don't know if they will. If the scrum is good Wales will win because individually they are better players, but whoever goes best collectively will win it.
Home advantage is a huge factor and either way it will be very tight, but if Wales play to their potential they will win.
Guscott: Wales by two.
Davies: Wales by three or four. Unless the scrum doesn't go well, in which case England by six to nine.


England will host Belgium in Rotherham as they aim to continue their 100% winning start to the Uefa Women's Euro 2017 qualifying campaign.

Media playback is not supported on this device
They will play at Rotherham United's New York Stadium on 8 April (19:55 BST), the Football Association said.
England have won their two qualifiers so far, thrashing Estonia 8-0 before a 1-0 win against Bosnia-Herzegovina.
"Belgium will be one of our toughest games in this campaign," England captain Steph Houghton said.
"Hopefully we'll get a good win and take another step towards qualification."
Mark Sampson's side, who finished third at the 2015 World Cup, are currently third in Group Seven.
Eight group winners and the six best runners-up advance to the final tournament alongside hosts the Netherlands. The other two runners-up will contest a play-off for the final spot.


Michael McKillop safely progressed to Sunday's T38 800m final on the first day of competition at the World Para-athletics Championships in London.

Ireland's McKillop won his heat in 2:07.59 as he held off France's Louis Radius by 0.29 seconds.
The overall heats standard suggests McKillop will face a battle to maintain an unbeaten Paralympic record which stretches back to 2006.
Canada's Liam Stanley was the fastest qualifier with heat two in 2:05.89.
Stanley, second behind McKillop in the 1500m at last year's Rio Paralympics, was expected to be the Glengormley athlete's main challenger in both the 800m and the metric mile at the championships.
However, Tunisia's Abbes Saidi and heat three winner Australia's Deon Kenzie were also marginally faster than McKillop in the qualifying races in the London Stadium.
Nevertheless defending champion McKillop, who has run under two minutes for 800m on numerous occasions in able-bodied competition, will still be a strong favourite in Sunday's final.
McKillop and his Irish team-mate Jason Smyth will be expected to earn gold medals within 15 minutes of each other on Sunday evening.
Smyth will compete in the T13 100m, final shortly before McKillop's race, providing he comes through Sunday mornings heats in the sprint.
County Londonderry athlete Smyth, who turned 30 recently, has never been defeated during a Paralympic career which began in 2005.
Both McKillop and Smyth will also defend their 1500m and 200m titles later in the championships.
Meanwhile, Niamh McCarthy clinched Ireland's first medal of the championships as she took silver in the F41 discus final on Saturday morning.
The Cork woman's medal matched her silver at last year's Paralympics in Rio and improved on the bronze she won in the World Championships in Doha two years ago.
McCarthy, 23, produced a best throw of 26.17m in the fifth round.


Will Australian Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull be able to form a government, or is the country on course for its fifth leader in three-and-a-half years?

Speculation, apprehension and more than a whiff of retribution. It is not the outcome Australians expected when in their millions they cast their ballots in Saturday's federal election.
But three days later, the result remains unclear and no-one is sure who will form the next government, or how, or when.
Neither of the major parties have so far won enough seats to claim an outright win as counting continues in around a dozen tightly-contested constituencies. They will decide this federal election that was fought on the promise of stability but has delivered, in the short-term at least, turmoil.
The Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull, who leads the centre-right Liberal-National Coalition, says he is confident of winning a majority.  He may just squeeze home but his leadership could be damaged beyond repair.
After all, it was the millionaire former merchant banker who gambled on dissolving both houses of the Australian parliament (the first so-called Double Dissolution election since the late 1980s) and calling an early poll.
Frustrated at the refusal of the Senate, the upper chamber, to pass key labour reforms, Mr Turnbull went to the country, but has been left clinging to power as anger within his governing coalition intensifies.
Australian PM Malcolm Turnbull urged to quit
Cartoon: Planet of Forbidden Prime Ministers
Are Australians ready to gamble on yet another PM?
The massive scale of Australia's election
Who's who in Australia's 2016 federal elections?
He is an accomplished media performer, as you might expect from a former journalist and lawyer, and came to the highest office last September, ousting Tony Abbott in a sensational party room coup.
The new man at the helm of the conservative government appeared to promise a more progressive approach than the pugilistic ways of his predecessor.
There would, his supporters hoped, be bolder policies to combat climate change in a country heavily reliant on coal (with one of the highest per capita rates of carbon pollution), and decisive action on a republic (Britain's Queen Elizabeth is the head of state here) and same-sex marriage.
But there was to be no grand theatre of reform. Was Mr Turnbull a hostage to right-wing factions within his government that were keeping him in the job, or was he biding his time waiting for an unequivocal mandate from the people?
There has, though, been no concrete endorsement from voters in an election fought mostly over jobs, health care and education. But the decisive swing against the conservatives has not seen a corresponding surge in public support for their main rival, the Labor opposition. Far from it.
While it has done better than many of its strategists had dared dream, it has almost no chance of forming a majority government. In recent years the party had self-destructed through repeated bouts of infighting as previous Labor prime ministers, Julia Gillard and Kevin Rudd, took it turns to knife each other in the back.
Although the current leader, Bill Shorten, harbours ambitions of forming a minority government, he might be best off losing this time around and sitting back and watch a weakened Mr Turnbull lead either a nervous government with a waver-thin majority or a potentially fractious one dependent on minor parties and independents.
Labor could then agitate and destabilise from opposition, and then go on to win big at the next election.
That, however, supposes that the traditional two-party system in Australia is in good health. It isn't. Minor parties and independent candidates have attracted record support in this election.
They may be a disparate and controversial bunch, who variously support tough anti-gambling policies, banning the burqa in public places and voluntary euthanasia, but millions of voters consider them to be politicians with convictions, free of what newspapers here have described as the "all-consuming narcissism" of the main parties.
Voters have raged against the two heavyweights like never before.
There are fears that Australia could lose its AAA credit rating if the current gridlock hampers the government's ability to reform the economy as a long mining boom comes to an end.
Politics in Australia is a volatile business, and there have been four prime ministers in the past three-and-a-half years, yet the economy continues to grow and its fundamentals seem strong, despite the lack of political stability in recent years.
Elsewhere, life goes on in other countries with hung parliaments and dysfunctional governments.
Australia may find itself back at the polls if the impasse can't be resolved as a new type of politics emerges, one fuelled by voters who feel disenfranchised and betrayed by the old order.
On morning radio, a government minister said that as a child he used to laugh at the regular changing of leaders in Italy, but now the joke is on Australia.


The US Department of Defense has announced a deal for 90 F-35 jets worth about $8.5bn for supplier Lockheed Martin.

The agreement brings the price for each stealth fighter aircraft below $100m for the first time, the Pentagon said.
The Pentagon says it will save around $728m compared with its last order.
US President Donald Trump has been vocal in his criticism of the price of the F35 programme.
Mr Trump tweeted in December that the costs of the project were "out of control".
However, defence analysts have said that a subsequent discount, which Donald Trump announced at the end of January, was in line with what had been flagged by Lockheed and Pentagon officials for months.
Lockheed Martin said on Friday: "President Trump's personal involvement in the F-35 program accelerated the negotiations and sharpened our focus on driving down the price."
The F-35 is the Pentagon's most expensive weapons programme, costing about $400bn (Â£316bn).
But the price per jet has been steadily declining as production increases.
The US military will buy 55 of the jets, while 35 of the F35s will be sold abroad.
The UK is to buy three of the fighter planes.
Lockheed, the main contractor, and its partners including Northrop Grumman, Pratt & Whitney and BAE Systems, have been working on building a more cost-effective supply chain to fuel the production line in Fort Worth in Texas.


Nick Grimshaw has been confirmed as the new host of the Mercury Prize awards ceremony.

The host of the Radio 1 Breakfast Show will front the event, which is on Wednesday 29 October at The Hospital Club in London.
"It's a real honour to host the Mercury Prize awards show, which celebrates the best British talent that we have to offer," said Grimmy.
"I think it's a really interesting, exciting and pretty perfect shortlist."
He has appeared as part of Channel 4's coverage of the event before, hosting backstage interviews with the nominated artists.
Previously the role of presenter has gone to Lauren Laverne, who has now stepped down.
Nominees for this year's prize include Damon Albarn, FKA Twigs and Royal Blood.
Find out more about the nominated musicians
Radio 1's Alice Levine revealed the shortlist, which features 10 artists, last month.
Previous winners of the prize, which recognises the best album by an artist from the United Kingdom and Ireland, include Arctic Monkeys, Dizzee Rascal and Alt-J.
Last year, when introducing award-winner James Blake, Laverne accidentally called him James Blunt.
Follow @BBCNewsbeat on Twitter and Radio1Newsbeat on YouTube


A man's body has been discovered in North Wales after a woman and two children were found dead at a house in Leeds.

The woman was found downstairs, while the bodies of the children were found upstairs at the home in Allerton Bywater just before noon.
Officers found the man shortly after 17:00 GMT on cliffs in the vicinity of South Stack, Anglesey, police said.
West Yorkshire Police said it believed the finds were linked.
Ch Insp Jeff Moses from North Wales Police said senior detectives were supervising the recovery of a man's body found on a cliff ledge at South Stack.
No formal identification had taken place, he said, and he could not confirm if a vehicle had been recovered.
Coastguards and the RNLI were assisting police with the operation
being conducted on behalf of West Yorkshire Police, he said.
The beauty spot is a rocky island, famous for its lighthouse and seabirds that roost in its 120ft (36m) high cliffs.
Det Ch Insp Warren Stevenson of West Yorkshire Police said the deaths of the woman and children were being treated as murder.
Post-mortem examinations would take place to establish the causes of the deaths, he said.
More on this story and others from West Yorkshire
The identity of the victims has not been released.
Sean Firth, 44, lives opposite the modern town house in Beeston Way where the bodies were found.
He said: "I only really knew them through passing in the street and playing in the park with my daughter.
"They were nice and friendly, as far as I can make out. My daughter was devastated when she came home from school."
Another neighbour, Wesley Rice, 38, said he had met the family at Halloween when he was out with his own children.
"We knocked on the door and the lady came out and gave the kids sweets. She seemed very nice."
"This kind of thing just doesn't happen. To have something like this happen so close to home is shocking," he said.
Jessica Everitt, 25, said: "It's really nice to live round here. You get break-ins and stuff but nothing like this, it's usually just kids messing about, nothing bad.
"It's usually really quiet and all the kids play out."


A cycle lane in Glasgow which had a bus stop built in the middle of it has been rerouted.

Cyclist Michael Dougall took to Twitter to voice his anger about the positioning of the bus shelter between Glasgow Green and the city's Velodrome.
Glasgow City Council apologised for the inconvenience and vowed to carry out work to change the route.
The cycle path markings have now been repainted, with the lane routed behind the bus shelter.
The site is in an area of the city which was regenerated for the 2014 Commonwealth Games.


Steel giant Tata has warned that a new carbon tax announced in the Budget dealt the industry "a potentially severe blow".

The plan sets a new minimum price on carbon emissions which Tata said would make UK steelmakers less competitive.
Tata Steel is the biggest private business in Wales, employing about 7,500 people.
The chancellor said the move would encourage billions of pounds of investment.
Karl-Ulrich Köhler, head of Tata Steel's European operations, said the tax was "exceptionally unhelpful and potentially damaging".
The UK is the first country in the world to introduce a minimum price, or price floor, for carbon emissions from power stations. It will fund investment in green energy.
Chancellor George Osborne said in his Budget: "This will provide the incentive for billions of pounds of new investment in our dilapidated energy infrastructure."
Mr Osborne plans to introduce the carbon floor price (CFP) of £16 per tonne from 2013, rising to £30 a tonne by 2020.
Mr Köhler said the positive measures in the Budget for steelmaking were overshadowed by the introduction of the floor price.
He said: "These benefits are likely to be dwarfed by the introduction of the carbon floor price which represents a potentially severe blow to the sustainability of UK steelmaking."
He said steelmakers already faced the prospect of "deteriorating international competitiveness" because of European Union emissions costs.
He added: "The CFP proposal will impose additional unilateral emission costs specifically on the UK steel industry by seeking to artificially ensure that these costs cannot fall below government-set targets which no other European country will enforce.
"This is an exceptionally unhelpful and potentially damaging measure."
The Budget predicts the levy will raise more than £740m for the Treasury in 2013-14, rising to just over £1bn in its second year and £1.4bn in its third year.
But Tata fears the floor price will lead to higher costs for generating electricity, hitting energy-intensive industries such as steel.
Steel produced elsewhere in the world would not be subject to the extra costs, the company said, making UK steelmaking less competitive.
Tata's biggest site in Wales is the plant at Port Talbot. Its other sites include rolling plants in Newport and steel coating plants in Shotton, Flintshire, and Trostre, Llanelli.
They were acquired in 2007 when Tata bought Corus.
Ian Rogers, from industry body UK Steel, said: "The problem is that it will impose a tax on us that is not borne by any other steel producer in the world.
"George Osborne yesterday made great play with the fact that the UK is going to be the first to do this but he has taken no account of the fact that, for energy-intensive users, this is a significant extra cost."
First Minister Carwyn Jones met the head of Tata Steel Europe on Wednesday to discuss the company's future in Wales.
A Welsh Assembly Government spokesman said: "We have a close working relationship with Tata Steel who are a major employer in Wales and we want this to continue.
"They are investing heavily in reducing their carbon emissions here in Wales."


Three bariatric ambulances are coming into service in the south east to cope with "increasing issues" with patients who weight up to 50st.

The vehicles, which cost Â£400,000, have been bought by South East Coast Ambulance Service (SECAmb).
The new ambulances have wider lifting equipment and specialist handling aids.
SECAmb operations director James Pavey said the ambulances were not exclusive to bariatric patients.
He said: "These vehicles can be used for any patient, from the outside you wouldn't notice them to look much different from the average ambulance."
Mr Pavey said methods of moving obese patients without specialist equipment were "not particularly dignified or humane".
"We have a number of increasing issues with people who are more than morbidly obese and weigh up to 50 stone.
"We will probably need to increase the size of the fleet to meet the demand but this is the first step."
The specialist equipment includes a Megasus stretcher, gantry and mobile hoists, threshold ramps and enhanced air cushion lifting aids as well as a stair-climber chair.
When Mr Pavey was asked if these new ambulances meant the NHS was giving up on trying to get obese people to lose weight, he said: "We're responding to the needs of patients who are acutely unwell.
"Chronic conditions turn into acute conditions very quickly because of the complications of their weight. We're by no means giving up as far as the NHS goes."
The vehicles will be based in Paddock Wood in Kent, Chertsey in Surrey and Worthing in West Sussex.