England manager Roy Hodgson says his side are "not frightened of anybody", despite finishing second in Group B at Euro 2016.

Media playback is not supported on this device
A 0-0 draw against Slovakia and a 3-0 win for Wales over Russia means Hodgson's side will face the runners-up in Group F - potentially Portugal.
England drew 1-1 with Russia before beating Wales 2-1, but failed to score with their 30 shots against Slovakia.
"Soon we will make someone pay, we will score goals one day," said Hodgson, 68.
"You just don't know, the way we are playing I am not frightened of anybody."
Hodgson made six changes for the final group game - including resting captain Wayne Rooney - but did not believe that his rotation cost his side against a stubborn Slovakia.
Jamie Vardy and Daniel Sturridge both started after scoring as substitutes against Wales on Thursday, while Jordan Henderson, Jack Wilshere, Nathaniel Clyne and Ryan Bertrand also came into the starting XI.
Rooney replaced a lacklustre Wilshere 10 minutes into the second half but Hodgson defended his selection of the Arsenal midfielder.
"If people are going to pick on one player that's a pity - Jack Wilshere did fine," said the 68-year-old.
"People were trying to tell me after the Russia game that I should have changed Raheem Sterling and Harry Kane. It was actually four changes from the side which finished the Wales game. You can't have it all ways.
"When did England last come to a tournament and have three such dominant games in a row? We have taken the game to the opposition, we have controlled the play."
Media playback is not supported on this device
The pundits on BBC Sport were not so kind, however - with John Hartson accusing Hodgson of taking Slovakia lightly.
"England totally underestimated Slovakia," the former Wales striker said.
"Six changes was far too many. Wales needed to win against Russia and they made one change."
"Roy Hodgson got it wrong," said Robbie Savage.
"There are too many excuses from the England point of view. You have got to score to win games and they haven't done it.
"They played Slovakia and they can't break Slovakia down - too many excuses."
Former England duo Chris Waddle and Danny Mills were frustrated at the team's failure to break down a side with a packed defence.
England had 65 shots on goal in their three Group B games - but scored just three goals.
"England have got no width. James Milner would give you width, he can do a trick and put a cross in," said Waddle.
"It's easy to say now, but they knew in all three games that people were going to sit deep and frustrate England."
"Why change the two full-backs when Kyle Walker was playing well, Danny Rose was playing well," added Mills.
"Those players will now have 10 or 11 days between games, that's too much."
Former England captain Alan Shearer felt Hodgson missed the chance to build on their last-minute win over Wales.
"I didn't agree with Hodgson making that many changes as I think it is vital to get momentum," said Shearer.
"In Euro '96 we beat Scotland and our confidence was sky high, and then we beat the Dutch 4-1. It was a great opportunity for Roy and this team to do that."
But former England midfielder Danny Murphy defended the display.
"We have played better than a lot of people expected us to and overall I think we are moving forward," he said.
"Finishing second shouldn't harm us that much, there are so many positives to look at from this England side at the moment."
Create leagues and play against your friends in BBC Sport's new Euro 2016 Predictor game


A man has been charged after a police car was hit with a sledgehammer.

It was used on an unmarked police vehicle after officers attempted to stop a black Audi in Handforth, Cheshire on 14 October.
Officers arrested a 27-year-old man in Preston, Lancashire on Saturday.
The man, from Salford, has been charged with offences including affray and aggravated vehicle taking. He was due to appear at South and East Cheshire Magistrates' Court earlier.
He was also charged with conspiracy to commit a burglary and conspiracy to cause an explosion likely to endanger life.
Two other men have also been charged in connection with the incident and officers are searching for a third.


The world's oldest professional footballer has smashed one of his own records!

Japanese football legend Kazuyoshi Miura, who's 49, has become the oldest goal-scorer in Japan's footy league - again.
"King Kazu" (as he's nicknamed) headed one in against FC Gifu.
Despite losing 2-1, he said: "I'm genuinely happy. Things felt nice during training and I was sensing I could get one."
Miura currently holds the record for being the world's oldest active professional footballer.
Before he retired internationally, he scored 55 goals in 89 appearances for Japan.
Controversially, he has never played in the World Cup, something many fans were disappointed about.


Super League leaders Hull FC will host Castleford on 5 August in the first round of fixtures in the Super 8s.

St Helens travel to Warrington in the first game the previous day, while Wigan are at home to Wakefield and Widnes are in France against Catalans.
Meanwhile, Super League holders Leeds start the Qualifiers at Championship club Featherstone Rovers on 6 August.
Leigh, who retained the Championship title for a third successive year, host London Broncos on 6 August.
Salford have a home game against Huddersfield Giants, while Batley Bulldogs start at Hull KR.
Each team plays seven games in the second phase of the season.
In the top tier, points from the regular season are carried over and the top four sides in the Super League table will progress to the play-off semi-finals for a chance to reach the Grand Final in October.
In the Qualifiers, the leading three teams will automatically earn a place in next season's Super League, with the fourth and fifth placed clubs playing in the Million Pound Game for the last remaining spot in the top flight.
Subscribe to the BBC Sport newsletter to get our pick of news, features and video sent to your inbox.


About 70 members of Russia's Olympic team have left a Moscow airport for Brazil to take part in Rio 2016 while others stay at home, banned for doping.

Members of the volleyball, handball, boxing, synchronised swimming and table tennis teams were seen off at Sheremetyevo Airport.
The World Anti-Doping Agency (Wada) wanted Russia banned from the Games.
But the International Olympic Committee left it up to individual sports federations to decide.
The IOC's decision not to act on Wada's recommendation was strongly criticised, with Wada chief Olivier Niggli saying the move would mean "lesser protection for clean athletes".
Journalist Katja Kuznetsova filmed some of the Russian team as they arrived at the airport.
Russia had hoped to send 387 competitors to Rio and more than 100 have so far been banned from going.
Among those excluded are 67 out of 68 from the athletics team; long-jumper Darya Klishina will compete as a neutral.
Some international federations have banned Russians from competing altogether, some have issued a partial ban, while others have cleared all Russians to take part. Others still are yet to decide.
Russia's President, Vladimir Putin, said there was a "deliberate campaign targeting" Russian   athletes.
He said medals won in Rio would be devalued by the absence of Russian competitors, telling the Russian team "the other sportsmen understand that the quality of their medals will be different".


A man accused of an acid attack on a journalist claimed he was "only a postman" after being pinned down, a court has heard.

Alan MacIntosh, 66, was giving evidence at the trial of Paisley men William Burns, 56, and Alexander Porter, 48.
They deny assaulting journalist Russell Findlay to the danger of his life at his Glasgow home on 23 December 2015 by throwing sulphuric acid in his face.
They also deny attempting to murder Ross Sherlock by shooting at him.
They are charged with repeatedly discharging a shotgun at Mr Sherlock at Dornoch Place and Ronaldsay Drive, Bishopbriggs, on 24 September 2015.
The prosecution alleges that the offences were aggravated by a connection with serious organised crime.
Mr Findlay was investigations editor at the Scottish Sun newspaper at the time, and is the author of books about Glasgow crime gangs.
On Monday, the 44-year-old had told the High Court in Glasgow that he opened his front door to Mr Burns, who was wearing a Royal Mail jacket and was asked to sign for a parcel.
He told the jury that, as he went to sign, a liquid was thrown in his face. He also said he grappled with Mr Burns outside.
During his evidence on Tuesday, Mr MacIntosh, one of the victim's neighbours, told prosecutor Richard Goddard that he was lying in bed at about 08:30 on 23 December 2015, when he heard men shouting outside.
He said: "I ran downstairs and put on an anorak and a pair of shoes and went outside.
"Mr Burns was on the ground and Russell Findlay was astride him. Mr Burns was shouting: 'Get this guy off me. I'm only a delivery man or a postman.'
"Russell was shouting: 'Who sent you and what did you throw on my face?'"
Mr MacIntosh added: "I seem to remember as he [Mr Burns] was being led away by the police he turned round and said: 'That's for Jamie.'"
The court heard that Mr MacIntosh had not mentioned the alleged remark about Jamie to the police.
Defence counsel Thomas Ross, representing Mr Burns, asked if he could have heard someone else mention this afterwards and he replied: "It's always a possibility. I thought I heard it at the time."
Mr MacIntosh was then asked by Mr Ross: "When the man was on the ground, what did he say?" He replied: "Get this guy off of me. I'm only the postman."
He added that he had seen Mr Findlay assaulting Mr Burns and added: "I saw Russell punching him two or three times on the face."
PC David Ross told the jury that when he and a colleague arrived on the scene Mr Burns was being pinned down by Mr Findlay.
When asked if there was anything nearby, he replied: "There was a Royal Mail jacket and a Royal Mail bag and also a set of dentures lying on the ground."
His colleague, PC Fraser Ramsay, said Mr Burns had to be treated at Glasgow Royal Infirmary for injuries which included a cut to his left ear, a cut to his chin and bruising.
PC Ramsay added: "His dentures had broken and fallen out."
The court was told that, when searched by police, Mr Burns had no car keys, bus or train ticket on him and had Â£3.05 in cash.
In relation to the attempted murder of Mr Sherlock, Mr Burns has lodged a special defence of alibi, claiming he was working at Guinea Enviro in Maryhill, Glasgow, at the time.
He has also lodged a special defence incriminating James Boyce, whose whereabouts are unknown, for the shooting.
The trial before judge Lord Matthews continues.


Major reform of the system for managing flood risk is needed, a Commons environment and rural affairs committee report has said.

There should be a UK floods supremo, new flooding and coastal boards and a rivers and coastal authority, it said.
MPs said floodwater should be stored on agricultural land, urged tougher rules on house builders and stricter standards on repairing flooded homes.
The government said it it saw no need for organisational change.
The MPs disagree. They are unhappy with the Environment Agency's recent performance over flooding and want to see it stripped of powers, which would be handed to the proposed new bodies.
This is the latest in a number of reports triggered by last winter's devastating floods in the north of England.
The government has published two reports on flood resilience, and the environmental audit committee has also reported - calling for more government long-term planning on flood defences, and better maintenance.
The Committee on Climate Change has warned that flooding has a domino effect on infrastructure.
The report from the Environment and Rural Affairs committee is by far the most drastic.
The MPs conclude that in the light of climate change and the increased risk of torrential rain, the current organisational framework for dealing with floods is unfit.
They think a new national floods commissioner is needed to co-ordinate flood-related policy across governmental departments, reporting to the Cabinet Office.
The MPs also want new regional flood and coastal boards to organise regional delivery of national plans, in partnership with local groups and authorities.
They also urge the creation of a new English Rivers and Coastal Authority, taking on current Environment Agency roles.

The committee's chairman, Neil Parish MP, said: "We propose a radical alternative to the current fragmented, inefficient and ineffective flood risk management arrangements.
"Our proposals will deliver a far more holistic approach to flooding and water supply management, looking at catchments as a whole. Flood management must include much wider use of natural measures such as leaky dams, tree planting and improved soil management. And some areas of farmland should be used to store floodwater."
Critics may wonder how the environment department Defra, already struggling under severe job cuts and wrestling with the seismic implications of Brexit on the countryside, could envisage such a massive organisational reform at this time.
Some of the MPs' recommendations, though, are less controversial. They support the fashionable idea of catching water in the uplands to prevent floods lower down the catchment, as demonstrated in Pickering in Yorkshire.
The Centre for Ecology and Hydrology cautioned about limited evidence that such natural schemes would mitigate flooding from very extreme events on a large catchment scale.
So the MPs want a large-catchment trial to test natural methods like upland bunds and leaky dams.
The MPs are critical of the Environment Agency for what they see as its over-reliance on traditional "hard" flood defences.
They are keen for farmers to be offered incentives to store floodwaters on their land. They note that the damage cost of flooding fields is far lower than for flooding towns.
Their report says: "Artificial land drainage, deforestation and urban development have increased the amount of water that runs off the land into rivers. Urban development has encroached upon floodplains, and river channels have been narrowed and straightened.
"Farming methods have had particular impact: currently around 70% of UK land is used for agriculture, and some farming practices can reduce soils' ability to store and drain water.
"Changing land management practices combined with increased rainfall mean that the likelihood of flooding is now at an all-time high and will continue to increase."
The MPs see a chance for reform with Brexit, and want to ensure that any farm payments agreed under a new subsidy regime prioritise incentives to buffer flooding.
The MPs also want to tighten up rules for developers, who, they say, can walk away from flood problems they have caused. They want the right of any home to connect surface water run-off to a mains sewer to be discontinued. New developments should be landscaped in such a way that takes care of their own run-off, they say.
Another idea is for insurers to be allowed to upgrade properties when they are flooded so they don't get flooded again. Currently they are simply allowed to re-instate what's already there.
A Defra spokesperson said: "We take a long-term, strategic approach to protecting the nation from floods.
"A huge amount of work has been undertaken as a result of the National Flood Resilience Review, including £12.5m investment in new mobile defences, such as barriers and high volume pumps.
"This means homeowners will be better protected this winter than last, as will much of our critical infrastructure.
"This is part of the £2.5bn we are spending on building flood defence schemes across the country to better protect an additional 300,000 homes by 2021, bringing an end to year-on-year fluctuations in spend.
"We are already implementing many of the suggestions this report makes, such as managing watercourses across entire catchment areas."
Rachael Maskell, shadow secretary of state said: "The committee have highlighted many of the same concerns and solutions that Labour has been raising, including the Committee Chair's feeling that the Government's Flood Resilience Review offers limited solutions.
"There is still a lack of confidence in schemes to protect businesses and the £12.5m pledged to temporary flood barriers will not bring the long-term protection required."
Follow Roger on Twitter @rharrabin


People were "trapped in their homes" by floodwater after lightning and heavy rain caused chaos in parts of Cornwall.

Water was up to waist height in some areas and more than 400 homes were left without power.
The storms began at about 15:00 BST on Tuesday and lasted for more than 12 hours.  A number of schools remain closed.
One person needed medical treatment after a terrace of four houses was struck by lightning.
The floods caused problems across Falmouth, Camborne, Helston and Redruth.
BBC Weather forecaster Kevin Thomas said a further severe storm happened between 19:00 and 20:00, with another one at about 03:00 on Wednesday.
Latest updates on flash flooding in Cornwall and other news
There are reports of surface water on roads in the following locations:
Lightning hit a terrace of four houses in Crelly, near Helston at about 04:00, with one person requiring medical attention for smoke inhalation.
Jo Moore, from Penryn, said: "I had a river in the passageway. I was up at half past three this morning mopping. The water is now trying to slip up the stairs."
Fire Service Group Manager Nathaniel Hooton said: "We had a large number of properties affected by the floods. That ranged from water being 1ft high in some areas, and up to waist high in others. In affected areas... some people became essentially trapped in their houses."
Cornwall Fire and Rescue Service said it had been "extremely busy" dealing with numerous 999 calls during the night.
Cornwall Animal Hospital's shop in Pool was badly flooded.
Staff member Trevor Chalker, said: "It's horrendous. There is about 4,000 sq ft of sale space that is immersed in water."
Hundreds of homes have been reconnected but more than 80 remain without power.
Trewirgie Junior School, Redruth School and the KS2 site of Penryn Primary Academy are closed, with flooding  expected at Portreath Community Primary School, the Environment Agency said.
The agency warned flooding was possible for Lands End, Helston, Crowlas, St Ives, Hayle, Camborne, Portreath and Perranporth.


Shares in Paddy Power Betfair fell by almost 5% after the bookmaker said that chief executive Breon Corcoran was standing down.

The company also said that Mr Corcoran would be replaced by Worldpay's UK chief executive Peter Jackson.
Paddy Power said its half-year results, due on Tuesday, would show a 9% rise in revenues while underlying earnings are up 21%.
Underlying earnings for 2017 as a whole are expected to be £445m-£465m.
Paddy Power Betfair was the biggest faller on the FTSE 100, but the index itself managed to produce a small gain, jumping 0.3% to close at 7,531.94.
The index was boosted by mining companies, which saw their shares rise on the back of higher prices for metals. Shares in Glencore and Rio Tinto rose 2.6%, while BHP Billiton jumped by 2.3%.
In the FTSE 250, shares in QinetiQ rose 3% after Goldman Sachs raised its rating on the defence technology company to "neutral" from "sell".
On the currency markets, the pound fell 0.15% against the dollar to $1.3017, and fell 0.3% against the euro to 1.1045 euros.


West Ham manager Slaven Bilic feels qualification for the Champions League this season is unrealistic.

The Hammers are sixth in the table and a point behind behind fourth-placed Manchester City, following Wednesday's 1-0 win over Tottenham.
"This season it's not realistic but there's nothing wrong with trying to achieve it," said Bilic, whose side next face Everton on Saturday.
"I hope we can aim for Champions League in the future."
He added: "Long term, I don't have a problem saying it should be part of the plan, what with moving to the new stadium and with all the revenue and the fans and the size of the club."


A Scottish artist's designs for a set of mosaics at Tottenham Court Road Tube Station in London are to be auctioned in Edinburgh.

The mosaics, by the late Sir Eduardo Paolozzi, are described by experts as iconic examples of pop culture.
They were commissioned in 1979 by London Transport and are designed to link the interconnecting spaces of the station.
They were not completed until 1986. The Leith artist died in 2005.
Paolozzi (1924-2005), Her Majesty's Sculptor-in-Ordinary for Scotland, was one of Britain's leading 20th century artists and sculptors and was been credited with inspiring the Pop Art movement in the 1950s.
Born in Leith to Italian parents, Paolozzi's first inspiration for art came from cigarette cards, handed to him by customers of the family ice cream shop.
Very few of Paolozzi's works are in the public realm, and the studies are said to be of "particular interest".
The glass mosaics themselves cover 950 sq m.
They were painstakingly restored in 2015 and, while 95% were retained in place, the remainder were removed and are now held in the collection of the Edinburgh College of Art where Paolozzi was a visiting professor and where he had himself studied in the 1940s.
Charlotte Riordan, of auctioneers Lyon & Turnbull, who are selling the studies, said: "In his designs for the mosaics, Paolozzi draws on his knowledge and understanding of popular culture and iconic symbolism.
"The concept united his abiding interest in the culture of mechanisation and his empathy with the station's historic context and its geographical location. Having taught at the nearby Central School of Art in the 50s, Paolozzi had retained a broad, deep-rooted and affectionate understanding of the local area and its diverse communities."
Other works by the artist in London include the sculptures "Newton (after Blake)" (1995) at the British Library; "Head of Invention"(1989) outside the Design Museum, and "Piscator"(1980) in front of Euston station.
The mosaic designs are valued at Â£20,000 to Â£30,000.
The sale takes place in Edinburgh on Thursday.


Novak Djokovic made light work of promising Russian Daniil Medvedev to reach the Aegon International final on his debut in Eastbourne.

The 12-time Grand Slam champion took his second match point to win 6-4 6-4 in just an hour and 22 minutes.
Djokovic is playing his first pre-Wimbledon grass-court event in seven years as he looks to improve his form going into the Championships next week.
"I could not be happier to reach the final," said the 30-year-old Serb.
In Saturday's final, Djokovic will play second seed Gael Monfils, who won 2-6 7-6 (9-7) 7-6 (7-4) against close friend Richard Gasquet in an all-French semi-final.
Seventh seed Gasquet saved two match points at 6-2 5-4 with a brilliant stretching drop-shot, before Monfils needed lengthy treatment in the next game when he injured his knee after slipping on the baseline.
Monfils recovered to take the set into a tie-break, only to miss a third match point before Gasquet, 31, forced a decider when Monfils double-faulted on the third set point.
Monfils, 30, failed to serve out for victory at 5-4, but took his fourth match point in the tie-breaker.
Find out how to get into tennis in our special guide.
"I was hoping to do well but this is the dream result. I can fight for the trophy and I hope to perform," added Djokovic.
Djokovic has dropped to fourth in the world rankings after a turbulent year in which he has won only one title and split with his coaching team.
But the top seed, who is yet to drop a set in Eastbourne, is one more win away from his first grass-court title since winning Wimbledon in 2015.
Medvedev, a 21-year-old ranked 52nd in the world, did break Djokovic's serve in the first set, but it was not enough to stop the former world number one, who did not face another break point in the second set.
Djokovic said earlier this week that 2017 had been his toughest year in tennis.
The former world number one held all four Grand Slam titles going into last year's Championships, but now holds none.
He suffered a surprise early exit to Sam Querrey at Wimbledon last year, then was beaten by Swiss third seed Stan Wawrinka in the US Open final.
Djokovic was stunned by world number 117 Denis Istomin in the Australian Open second round in January, before losing in the French Open quarter-finals earlier this month.
Three-time Wimbledon champion Djokovic will play Slovakia's Martin Klizan in the first round next week.


The leader of Australia's far-right One Nation party has worn a burka on the floor of the nation's Senate.

Pauline Hanson's entrance drew audible shock from other senators ahead of a bid by her party to ban the garment in Australia.
Government minister George Brandis condemned Ms Hanson's stunt and "counselled and cautioned" her against causing offence to religious groups.
Mr Brandis received a standing applause from opposition parties.
In an emotional speech, Mr Brandis said Ms Hanson's actions risked alienating approximately 500,000 Australians who adhered to the Islamic faith.
"To ridicule that community, to drive it into a corner, to mock its religious garments, is an appalling thing to do and I would ask you reflect on what you have done," said Mr Brandis, who is Australia's attorney-general.
He added: "No, Senator Hanson, we will not ban the burka."
The Australian Broadcasting Corp reported Ms Hanson had elicited gasps during her entrance and one senator was heard to to say "oh, what on earth".
Senate president Stephen Parry confirmed she had been identified before entering the chamber. Ms Hanson later removed the burka.
Her motion to ban the garment will be debated in the Senate later on Thursday.
In a statement online, she said "the need to ban full face coverings in public [is] an important issue facing modern Australia".
Mr Brandis's speech drew a rare overt display of support from the Labor and Greens parties, who stood and congratulated him.
"It is one thing to wear religious dress as a sincere act of faith, there is another to wear it as a stunt here in the chamber," said Labor Senator Penny Wong.
Greens leader Richard Di Natale said Mr Brandis had made a "strong, impassioned, and personal response".
Ms Hanson has repeatedly generated controversy since first being elected to parliament in 1996.
In 2016, she gave a heavily criticised speech saying Australia was being "swamped by Muslims". She also faced calls to apologise two months ago after suggesting students with autism should be removed from classrooms.


Margot Gerster was "heartbroken" by the result of the US election and, to unwind, went on a hike with her daughter and dog through the woods in Chappaqua, New York.

The last person she was expecting to see, presumably doing the same thing, was the woman who lost to Donald Trump just two days earlier.
But that's exactly what happened.
A photo of the hiker standing alongside Hillary Clinton marks the first appearance of the Democratic presidential candidate since her concession speech on Wednesday.
She even said Hillary's husband, Bill, took the photo.
Ms Gerster, who lives in White Plains, shared her story on Facebook. The post had been liked more than 110,000 times and shared by some 9,000 users before she made it private.
"I got to hug her and talk to her and tell her that one of my most proudest moments as a mother was taking Phoebe with me to vote for her," she said.
"She hugged me and thanked me and we exchanged some sweet pleasantries and then I let them continue their walk."
The Clintons live in Chappaqua, in Westchester County - it's also where Mrs Clinton voted on Tuesday.
And it doesn't seem to be the first time Ms Gerster has met the former secretary of state.
She also shared a picture with Mrs Clinton that, she said, was from her high school years, at a fundraiser hosted by her mother where the Democrat was a guest of honour.


Disturbing video of an Islamic State militant blowing himself up on the night of the Paris attacks in November has been broadcast in France.

The CCTV footage shows Brahim Abdesalam detonating his suicide belt in the Comptoir Voltaire cafe.
It has drawn shocked comments on social media but no formal complaint to France's broadcast regulator.
Documentary maker Christian Huleu said it was important to show the reality of the militants' violence.
He defended the use of the images, which are the most graphic of the attacks yet seen on French television.
The video was part of a 90-minute film broadcast on Sunday evening on Zone Interdite (Forbidden Zone) , a current affairs programme on the independent channel M6. M6 did not say how it obtained the footage.
There was widespread outrage in the aftermath of the attacks when it was reported that the Daily Mail had bought CCTV from another cafe for 50,000 euros (Â£39,000; $56,000).
The M6 documentary - which went out at 21:00 and carried a strapline warning of its explicit content - used eyewitness interviews as well as amateur and surveillance video to give a detailed chronological  account of the November 13 killings.
Brahim Abdeslam was the elder brother of Salah Abdeslam, the only surviving attacker. Salah is now in jail in Belgium.
In the video, Brahim is seen inside the Comptoir Voltaire, wearing a black coat.  He begins moving among the tables, where people are seated in twos and threes enjoying Friday evening drinks.
As he advances, he bows his head slightly and puts his left hand over his face.  The next frame shows the explosion and the top half of his body being projected forward.  In the next frame he is gone.
The faces of the people present in the cafe have been blurred in the video.  Several of them were injured but no-one died at the Comptoir Voltaire.  Elsewhere on that evening 130 people were killed.
Two million people saw the programme and afterwards social media buzzed with reaction.  Some people said they had been too horrified to keep watching.
But in an interview with the Journal du Dimanche newspaper, Christophe Huleu said, "In order to make people see the true extent of the violence, you have to show it.
"I had to find a balance between the violence of what happened and the respect due to both the victims and the TV viewers."
Huleu said he and his team had watched footage from inside the Bataclan theatre - scene of the bloodiest attack - but it was too graphic to be usable. "I wish I had never seen it," he said.
He also said he had been struck by the different public reaction that followed the Brussels attacks last month.
He said: "In Brussels a feeling of inevitability appeared to have replaced the feeling of horror. But we must never give way to feeling it is inevitable.  We must never let the violence seem normal."
Debate continues to rage in France and elsewhere over the advisability of broadcasting shock images of terrorist attacks.
Critics say it serves the purpose of the terrorists, who crave as much media attention as they can get.
Bruce Hoffmann, who wrote the influential study Inside Terrorism, said that the terrorists' aim was not just to kill "but to create power where there is none, through the publicity generated by their violence".


Tributes have been paid to historian and biographer Lisa Jardine following her death at the age of 71 from cancer.

Ms Jardine, a professor of renaissance studies at University College London and an honorary fellow of the Royal Society, was praised as "inspirational" and a "brilliant communicator".
Prof Jardine served as chair of the UK Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority (HFEA) from 2008 to 2014.
She was also a trustee of the Victoria and Albert Museum for eight years.
Listen: Lisa Jardine on BBC Radio 4's Desert Island Discs
As an author, Prof Jardine tackled subjects including Shakespeare, Erasmus and 17th Century Holland.
She was also a fellow of the Royal Historical Society and established the Centre for Editing Lives and Letters at Queen Mary, University of London.
Historian Lord Hennessy, a colleague at Queen Mary's, told BBC Radio 4's Today programme: "Lisa was a polymath. She was a natural swimmer in both the scientific stream and the arts and humanities stream.
"She bedazzled her generation. She had an inspirational effect."
The UK government's chief scientific adviser, Prof Sir Mark Walport, added: "She was a brilliant communicator.
"Life, I think, is very much what we make of it, and she really made the most of her life.
"Her work at the HFEA was enormously important because she brought together the science with the public engagement and the debate about the ethics. She was an inspiring leader."
Historian Simon Schama tweeted: "Lisa Jardine was one of the great historians. She understood that to write of humanity you needed to be fully part of it."
Former Labour deputy leader Harriet Harman wrote: "So, so sad to hear of death of wonderful @ProfLisaJardine. A great intellect & completely down to earth. A beacon for women. RIP."
Lisa Jardine was a regular contributor to the BBC's A Point of View, and featured on this website for many years. Here is a selection of some of her most popular pieces.
The power of a red dress
The man who dreamed of the atom bomb
IVF and the marketing of hope
Dazzling in an age of austerity


It's a post-apocalyptic scene in lower Manhattan today.

The streets are deserted, there is no electricity and there is debris everywhere - mattresses, sandbags swept away by the superstorm, tree branches.
At 09:07, morning high tide, the water surges once again, though it is nothing like last night's 13ft surge.
It's spookily quiet - no lights anywhere, and a dark grey, still menacing sky.
Diana on the Lower East Side tells me how frightening it was when the water rushed in, flooding their street, breaking windows in basements.
We had no idea the water would come from that side she says, shaking her head in disbelief, as she stands on her stoop.
In front of her, an enormous tree has been uprooted by the storm, and it is blocking the entire street.
Cars are piled up against one another on Avenue C - Luis has come to find his, and it is not where he left it.
"This place was a swimming pool last night," he says ruefully.
There were explosions at the local electricity sub station - "lighting up the sky," says one woman.
"We survived Irene - I never thought Sandy would be anything," says Luis, sadly.
New Yorkers across the five boroughs woke up this morning and began to take in the scale of what happened.
The worst has come to pass - massive loss of power, flooded subways, and the Brooklyn Battery Tunnel is flooded, with water spilling out into the West Side Highway.
On Wall Street, the men with generators are pumping away the flood waters.
The skyline of lower Manhattan is not twinkling on this grey morning - it is unusually dark, for there is no power.
Back on the Lower East Side, LuzDella tells me how Avenue C was swimming with cars.
Now they are strewn across the street.
LuzDella's own vehicle is sitting in the basement garage, wheels submerged. That's what insurance is for, she says, as she wades towards her car.


A recruiter for so-called Islamic State (IS) who helped two British would-be jihadis in their attempt to join fighters in Syria has been convicted.

Iraqi Kurd Awat Hamasalih, 35, from Kingstanding, Birmingham, had denied being an IS member.
He helped IS through speeches, social media and tipping off a commander of imminent attack, the Old Bailey heard.
Jurors were told he helped two would-be jihadis preparing to go to Syria using the code "car wash".
Giving evidence Hamasalih, from Finchley Road, admitted being a supporter of IS but said he was not a member and denounced the recent terror attacks in Manchester, Westminster and London Bridge.
But the jury found him guilty by a majority of 10 to two of IS membership and possessing documents likely to be useful to the terror group.
The court heard how in May last year the two men he helped were arrested.
Shivan Azeez Zangana was detained at the al Noor mosque in Birmingham and Aras Hamid was arrested en-route to Dover after being found hiding in the back of a lorry.
In January, Hamid, 27, was jailed for seven years and Zangana, 21, was handed three years after they were convicted at Kingston Crown Court of preparing for acts of terrorism.
Hamasalih, who came to the UK in 2002 and became a British citizen in 2008, had also raised funds for IS through social media appeals, jurors were told.
He was found in possession of a military document containing information about the identities of Peshmerga fighters resisting IS expansion.
In September 2014, he revealed to IS commander Khattab Al-Kurdi the Peshmerga forces were preparing to attack Mosul in northern Iraq the following Sunday, the jury was told.
The court heard Hamasalih obtained documents containing the personal details of Peshmerga military personnel, the force working to safeguard Iraqi Kurdistan from invading IS forces.


The number of cases in the Swansea measles epidemic has reached 620, with health officials warning there is no sign of the outbreak coming to an end.

The figure released on Tuesday is an increase of 32 on Friday, with up to 20 new cases being confirmed every day.
Public Health Wales said there had been an excellent response to drop-in vaccination clinics at a number of hospitals last weekend.
But it warned that 6,000 children in Swansea have still not had the jab.
Parents across Swansea, Neath Port Talbot and Bridgend are being urged to get their children vaccinated.
The total number of cases in the Swansea area is now just two short of the total in the outbreak in the north west of England in the year to February 2013. Most of these cases were on Merseyside, in Greater Manchester and west Lancashire.
It gives 99% protection against the measles virus.
One dose is better than none, but two doses is better than one. If you are concerned about travelling to an outbreak area you can bring forward the second MMR dose. Speak to your GP about it.
The advice is to go to your GP and arrange for them to be immunised as soon as possible before you travel. Measles is a dangerous viral illness that can be fatal.
BBC Health - Measles
'Death risk' in outbreak
About 1,700 people were vaccinated at special hospital drop-in clinics at the weekend, which health officials called an "excellent" response.
But they say at least 6,000 children are still unvaccinated in the county of Swansea.
More hospital drop-in clinics will be held in Swansea, Neath Port Talbot and Bridgend on Saturday, targeting children and adolescents who did not have their scheduled MMR (measles, mumps and rubella) jabs as babies and toddlers.
Some GP surgeries are also laying on special vaccination sessions, while children will be given the jab at schools in the outbreak area when they return next week after the Easter break.
'Not judging'
Dr Marion Lyons, director of health protection for Public Health Wales, said she believed the outbreak could go on for weeks.
"We cannot be confident that the outbreak will not continue to grow with so many children still at risk from this very contagious and potentially fatal disease," she said.
Some 60 people have been hospitalised since the start of the outbreak.
Sara Hayes, Abertawe Bro Morgannwg University Health Board's director of public health, said: "Many children who missed the MMR jabs when they were little will be sitting exams once they go back to school.
"We are not in any way judgmental about why their children may have missed the MMR in the past. The important thing is that they get the jab now," she added.
By Hywel GriffithBBC Wales  correspondent
Around 6,000 children remain unvaccinated and with such a large deficit that means this highly virulent and contagious disease can still spread very quickly.
On when it will peak, microbiologists will tell you it's almost impossible to know until the figures are in, but it's hoped the mass vaccination will start to have an impact within about a week or 10 days.
If you look at the interval, we have had about 32 cases in four days, which is a slightly slower rate than last week.
But we will get more figures later this week and it's probably too early to judge whether we are coming to the peak of this outbreak or not.
Concerns over the safety of the MMR jab were raised in the late 1990s when a surgeon published a since discredited paper in The Lancet suggesting MMR was linked to an increased risk of autism.
That paper, and subsequent media coverage, led to immunisation rates plummeting.
A Swansea newspaper which joined the anti-MMR campaign at that time has defended itself against claims that it was to blame for the current outbreak.
Jonathan Roberts, editor of the South Wales Evening Post, said the campaign had been hard-hitting but reflected parents' concerns at the time about the safety of the vaccine.
"It is clear that there were genuine concerns in the mid-90s about MMR and the Post gave them full and responsible coverage," he said in Ean article for the paper.
"To judge it honestly and fairly, one has to consider the fear which existed at the time, the fact that medical experts were publicly expressing concerns about the vaccine and the duty of this paper to reflect public opinion."
Mr Roberts hosted a webchat on Tuesday on the paper's website.
He was asked to account for the fact that MMR vaccination rates dropped by about 2% across Wales but by 13% in Swansea.
"When looking back at the content contained within the stories we ran, the message was balanced," he said in response.
"We had a duty to reflect the concerns of our community, we also had a duty to reflect the official view of health professionals. And this we did."
He said he would be looking into republishing online archive stories from the time.
Although the epidemic is based in Swansea, cases continue to be reported across Wales.
Most are in the Abertawe Bro Morgannwg health region, which also includes Neath, Port Talbot and Bridgend.
There are also cases in Powys and in the Hywel Dda Health Board area, which covers Carmarthenshire, Ceredigion and Pembrokeshire.
Officials have said it is "just a matter of time" before a child is left with serious and permanent complications, such as eye disorders, deafness or brain damage, or even dies.
Typical symptoms of measles include fever, cough, conjunctivitis and a rash. Complications are quite common even in healthy people, and about 20% of reported measles cases experience one or more complication.
These can include ear infections, vomiting and diarrhoea, pneumonia, meningitis and serious eye disorders.


Newspaper publisher Trinity Mirror plans to print some of its Welsh titles in London and Oxford when it closes its presses in Cardiff, BBC Wales has learned.

The group is consulting with 33 staff on plans to close its printing site near Cardiff Docks.
Trinity Mirror wants to print the Western Mail in Watford and the South Wales Echo in Oxford, it is understood.
The company said the consultation process was ongoing.
The group previously blamed "declining print volumes and the relocation of a number of titles within our print network" for the proposed closure of the print works, which is responsible for a number of Trinity Mirror newspapers as well as other publications.
Trinity Mirror also owns Wales on Sunday, which is already printed in Birmingham, as well as the South Wales Evening Post and the Daily Post.
Meanwhile, BBC Wales understands the company is in talks to sell its Media Wales building in Cardiff city centre.
The company plans to remain as a tenant when the deal is completed.
Media Wales moved into the six storey purpose-built office block on Park Street in 2008.
Staff cuts mean its sales and editorial teams now only occupy one floor, while accountancy firm Deloitte has taken some of the vacant space.
Trinity Mirror declined to comment on the proposed sale of its Media Wales headquarters.


Two more people have been arrested in connection with suspected slavery offences in Oxford.

Last Thursday police searched properties in Rose Hill, Blackbird Leys and a travellers' site in Redbridge Hollow, in Hinksey Hill.
A 59-year-old woman and an 81-year-old man, of Oxford, have been arrested on suspicion of fraud, assault and slavery offences.
Operation Rague relates to suspected human exploitation, slavery and fraud.
Two people, both from Redbridge Hollow, Oxford, have already been charged with slavery offences and remanded in custody by Oxford magistrates.
Helen Collins, 44, was charged with fraud and slavery offences and a 44-year-old man was charged with harassment, blackmail and assault and slavery offences. He is due at Oxford Crown Court on 17 April.


Hearts have exited administration after documents were lodged with the Court of Session in Edinburgh.

The Edinburgh club had been in administration since last June with debts close to £30m.
They started the season with a 15-point penalty and will play in the Championship next term after being relegated from the Premiership.
When we do hand the club over to the fans in a few years' time, it will be in the best possible shape
"We kept going and it's wonderful that we're here, eventually," said the club's new owner Ann Budge.
"There have been many days when I thought there were just too many challenges facing us but we didn't lose hope.
"We want to get a really strong management team in place - I don't just mean on the field, off the field as well - and basically ensure that this club never has to go through this again.
"When we do hand the club over to the fans in a few years' time, it will be in the best possible shape."
Budge agreed a deal with creditors to buy Hearts and quickly set about restructuring the club with Craig Levein brought in as director of football and Robbie Neilson joining as head coach.
Gary Locke, who had been manager during the administration process, left the club at the end of his contract.
The move out of administration means the ban on the registration of players imposed by the league last year will be lifted and Hearts will now be allowed to make signings.
The Tynecastle club entered administration in June 2013 with debts close to £30m, with most of the money owed to businesses in Lithuania who themselves would undergo insolvency procedures.
"It certainly has been a long year but, with hindsight, it's been a great outcome," said administrator Bryan Jackson. "For that I'm very grateful, happy and very relieved."
Jackson has successfully taken seven clubs, including several in Scotland, out of administration.
And, asked if saving Hearts had been his toughest task, he replied: "Of course it has because I say that about all of them.
"I think genuinely this one has been. It was always going to be a tough one when you saw what we inherited from day one.
"With some of the external factors, some of the third parties that were involved as well, it made it very difficult for us. New obstacles kept popping up all over the place. As we solved one, there was another one.
"So, I would say in the end it was the most difficult one and there were certainly times when I really didn't think we were going to make it this time.
"We were close to running out of money on a couple of occasions. We managed to sell a couple of players to keep us going.
"Just about everything that came in was crucial. The fans' donations were crucial as well. It was fantastic the donations we received and the support we received from them
"The income in the last few games was very important to us and I'm very grateful to the fans for the numbers that turned up to those games."


A Maryland Ku Klux Klan group has been granted a permit to hold a rally at a renowned Civil War battlefield, US authorities have said.

The white supremacist group will hold the event on 5 October at the site of the July 1863 Battle of Gettysburg in Pennsylvania.
Park officials said US freedom of speech rules required them to make the site available to the group.
As many as 50,000 soldiers were killed or wounded at the Battle of Gettysburg.
The battlefield, named for the small town nearby, is also known as the site of the Gettysburg Address, a short speech by President Abraham Lincoln that became one of the most celebrated moments of American oratory.
At the dedication of a cemetery there the following November, Lincoln envisioned "a new birth of freedom" for America out of the ashes of the war between the southern slave-holding states and the northern free states.
The Ku Klux Klan, a white supremacist group established in the aftermath of the conflict, is known for its violent past and white-hooded ceremonial costume.
Richard Preston, leader of the Confederate White Knights of the Ku Klux Klan, was quoted by a local newspaper as saying his group was a "white separatist" organisation dedicated to throwing US President Barack Obama, who is black, out of office and to advocating stricter immigration laws.
"This is about America for Americans," Mr Preston said. "The only thing we want is our country back."
The group held a membership rally earlier this month at the Antietam battlefield in Maryland, the site of the deadliest single-day battle of the war.
In a statement, the National Park Service said: "As custodians of land owned by the American people, the National Park Service has a responsibility to make that land available for exercising [free speech] rights."
Park officials added that Gettysburg staff would work "to ensure that park resources and visitors will not be adversely affected by this event".


Relatives of a Scottish woman who is suspected of helping to recruit three missing London teenagers to Islamic State (IS) have said she is a "disgrace to her family".

Aqsa Mahmood, 20, travelled to Syria from her Glasgow home to become a "Jihadi bride" in November 2013.
The Daily Mail reported she had been in touch with at least one of the three London girls, who are aged 15 and 16.
The trio are thought to have flown to Turkey in an attempt to enter Syria.
Shamima Begum, 15, Kadiza Sultana, 16,  and an unnamed 15-year-old girl, who all attended Bethnal Green Academy in Tower Hamlets, travelled to Turkey on Tuesday.
They were interviewed by police after another girl from their school went to Syria in December but were not considered as a risk.
In a statement released through their lawyer Aamer Anwar, the Mahmood family said they were "full of horror and anger that their daughter may have had a role to play in the recruitment of these young girls to Isis".
They also sent a message to Aqsa: "You are a disgrace to your family and the people of Scotland, your actions are a perverted and evil distortion of Islam.
"You are killing your family every day with your actions, they are begging you stop if you ever loved them."
The statement also said the UK security services had questions to answer.
It added: "Aqsa's social media has been monitored since she disappeared over a year ago, yet despite alleged contact between the girls and Aqsa, they failed to stop them from leaving the UK for Turkey, a staging post for Syria.
"Sadly, despite all the government's rhetoric on Isis, if they can't even take basic steps to stop children leaving to join Isis, what is the point of any new laws?"
Privately educated Mahmood travelled through Turkey to Aleppo in Syria, where she married an Islamic State fighter.
She was reported to have later encouraged terrorist acts via a Twitter account under the name Umm Layth. The account has since been deleted.
Speaking in September, her parents Khalida and Muzaffar Mahmood said their daughter had attended Craigholme School, then university and was "well integrated into society".
They also said she was brought up "with love and affection in a happy home" and appealed for her to come home.


Mel B has been named top TV personality at the Cosmopolitan Ultimate Women Of The Year Awards.

The X Factor judge was not the only winner from the talent show with 2012 finalist Ella Henderson picking up UK music artist.
The Saturdays, Abbey Clancy and Davina McCall all won prizes too at the event in central London.
The awards, hosted by Fearne Cotton, also celebrate real-life winners, chosen for outstanding achievements.
Ella Henderson said she was "very excited" to win the music award on the evening.
"To think this year has just been the year when my music has just begun to take off for me, so it's very exciting to be here," she told Newsbeat.
"I've been so crazy, especially over the last couple of months, travelling everywhere, so to come back here, get dressed up for the night. It's a really nice thing to sit down and enjoy."
Davina McCall was named ultimate editors choice for her mammoth Sport Relief challenge earlier this year, which raised more than Â£2m.
She spent seven days either running, swimming or cycling across the UK for the charity.
"I feel Grimmy was an enormous part of that, in fact Radio 1 helped me out a lot, just the support that I felt," she said at the awards.
Lena Dunham was named best writer for her book Not That Kind of Girl: A Young Woman Tells You What She's Learned.
Abbey Clancy won best style icon and Dame Vivienne Westwood picked up style icon and The Saturdays won ultimate fabulous friends.
"We're actually really honoured," Una Healy told Newsbeat.
"To win the fabulous friend award, means the world to us, we've won lots of awards in the past but never something for the actual reason I think we are still together."
The Script's Danny O'Donoghue was part of the judging panel for the real-life winners.
"I found it incredibly hard because there are so many amazing women, so many deserved winners," he said.
"I feel very humbled just to be on the same stage as them."
Ultimate music star - Ella Henderson
Ultimate TV personality - Mel B
Ultimate #FabulousFriends - The Saturdays
Ultimate style icon - Abbey Clancy
Ultimate writer - Lena Dunham
Ultimate icon - Dame Vivienne Westwood
Ultimate sports woman - Jo Pavey
Ultimate men - McBusted
Ultimate international man of the year - Samuel L Jackson
Ultimate breakthrough actress - Natalie Dormer
Ultimate international music star - Taylor Swift
Ultimate funny woman - Morgana Robinson
Ultimate celeb inspiration - Ellen Page
Ultimate editor's choice - Davina McCall
Follow @BBCNewsbeat on Twitter and Radio1Newsbeat on YouTube


A woman in the US state of Colorado has been charged with drink driving and other offences after her car sped into a flock of sheep that were in the road.

Thirty-eight sheep were killed and 12 others were hurt in the crash.
Police said Lynn Ann Michel, 47, fled the scene on Tuesday in her 2005 Isuzu sport utility vehicle, but her front number plate was left behind.
Officers used the plate to find and arrest Ms Michel. She was released pending a court date.
The incident, which was confirmed by Colorado State Patrol police, happened near the small town of Monte Vista, Colorado, about 220 miles (350km) south of Denver.


Marks and Spencer chief executive Marc Bolland earned more than £2m in the last fiscal year.

His salary included a £596,000 bonus, in addition to pension benefits, the company has disclosed.
In its annual report, Marks and Spencer said that because the business met its profit target, it paid bonuses across the company.
The High Street retail giant recently reported its first rise in annual profits in four years.
Last year, Mr Bolland and his executive team had to forgo bonuses, after the company's consistent drop in profits.
The chairman, Robert Swannell, said in the firm's annual report:  "This year, we have seen outstanding performance in some areas of the business, but performance below our expectations in others."
He said the food business had an outstanding year, while the company's international business performance was disappointing.
Steve Rowe, the executive director of the company's food division, earned a £653,000 bonus for the year, with a total package of £1.4m.


It's the relentless question that Voyager-1 scientists get asked all the time: "Are we nearly there yet?"

I myself have asked it three times of Ed Stone this past year.
When I sat down with the mission's project scientist in California in August 2012, his response was much the same as always: "My best estimate is that it will be in the next couple of years, but it may be in the next couple of days. It's unknown."
Not anymore. As we chatted on that hot summer day, Voyager-1 was actually just a "couple of weeks" from crossing into interstellar space.
Data gathered by the Plasma Wave Science (PWS) instrument on Voyager has now prompted the team to announce the exit occurred on 25 August 2012.
Stone has always been very careful not to use the phrase "leave the Solar System", mindful that his spacecraft still has to pass through the Oort cloud where there are comets gravitationally bound to the Sun, albeit very loosely. But in a new domain of space, it certainly is. And it's an extraordinary moment.
Think the first humans to leave Africa, think Magellan, think Gagarin and Armstrong - it's an exploration milestone.
Find out how long it would take you
It's been interesting also to watch the process of science at work, to see how this decision to call the exit came about.
We all knew something was up in mid-2012. Voyager's instruments had started to see a drop off in the numbers of energetic particles coming up behind it from the Sun. At the same time, there was a big jump in the low-energy cosmic rays hitting the detectors from the front. These lines of evidence indicated the probe had to be right at the very boundary between the Sun's domain and the medium that is filled with stuff from other stars - the interstellar medium. But was it over the line?
Some scientists thought so. In March this year, a paper appeared in the journal Geophysical Research Letters and was accompanied by a press release from the American Geophysical Union with a headline guaranteed to be noticed: "Voyager 1 has left the solar system, sudden changes in cosmic rays indicate". The media went into overdrive, as you'd expect, but within the hour I'd got a direct Twitter message from Nasa's Jet Propulsion Lab, urging me to hang on because the GRL paper did not reflect the consensus of the mission team. Voyager had yet to see an expected switch in the magnetic field data, Stone and colleagues said in their statement. And so we all rolled back to a lower alert status.
Alex Witze produced a superb feature in Nature magazine shortly after, in which she wrote of Stone's control over the Voyager message: "It will leave when he says it does."
Fast forward to August. Another paper, this time in The Astrophysical Journal. It argued that the magnetic changes demanded by the mission team might not be that relevant. A different model could explain the observed behaviour.
Stone's response on this occasion was slightly different to the March event. There was no flat contradiction. Rather, he said the new study would become "part of the discussion among scientists" as they tried to reconcile the complex data being acquired by Voyager's particle detectors.
Part of that changed response was undoubtedly because there was another paper in review, this time from a senior investigator on the mission itself, which would essentially confirm the exit assessment. Newly acquired measurements by Voyager's PWS had seen a big jump in the density of charged and neutral particles occupying every cubic metre of space. When that was put alongside all the other data - and arguments - Stone was happy.
"The project scientist agrees with me," said Prof Don Gurnett, of the University of Iowa and the principal investigator on the PWS. "There was quite a discussion about our result, I must say, but it's pretty clear. It's very impressive."
So, Voyager is finally out. You can debate the definition of "Solar System", but I think most people will take that to mean the heliosphere - that bubble of hot gas that surrounds our star, the Sun. The probe has crossed the boundary - the heliopause - where the matter and magnetic fields derived from the Sun butt up against the material coming from other stars. Voyager has begun a new phase of exploration.
I'm excited by it and I think a lot of other people will be, too.
Chris Riley is the visiting professor of science and media at the University of Lincoln. He's also renowned for his space films.  You may have caught the one he made on Voyager for the BBC last year. Chris mailed me to say: "It's worth reflecting on the fact that, for perhaps the first time in the history of our galaxy, a life form has succeeded in extending its physical presence beyond the influence of the star it emerged around.
"Such an achievement could be the greatest thing that we human beings ever accomplish, a monument to our existence which could outlive civilisation itself.
"Voyager-1's milestone should cause us all to pause and consider that this tiny spacecraft, now almost 19 billion km from Earth, represents us as a single species - and not as we more often see ourselves - divided by our ideologies, nationalities and religious beliefs."
Oxford University's Dr Allan Chapman - you'll have seen him on the BBC's Sky At Night with Sir Patrick Moore discussing the history of science and astronomy - sent me this tribute to Voyager.
"Farewell Voyager, after your magnificent work teaching us more about the other worlds of the Solar System.
"You were the latest 'upgrade' in optical and mechanical technology, which began in 1609 when first Thomas Harriot and then Galileo brought home to mankind that our ancestral five natural senses could be strengthened - indeed, unimaginably strengthened - by ingenious devices.
"Two spectacle lenses in a tube began the saga, 404 years ago. Then, once the penny had dropped, we quickly learned how to create ever greater magnifications.
"Then came photography, then spectroscopy - and then computing and imaging.  And then, how to send our 'artificial organs' of seeing into the very depths of space, and still stay in touch with you.
"And now, you have more than earned your keep, and deserve the long, long rest that awaits you as you glide for evermore through realms of light and energy. Vola in Pace - 'Fly in Peace'. "


A former MEP accused of claiming almost £500,000 in false European Parliament expenses has said he is being "targeted" for being anti-EU.

Ashley Mote, 79, is on trial at Southwark Crown Court for allegedly using fraudulent claims to pay people he says were "whistleblowers".
He sat as an independent MEP from 2004-2009 after being expelled from UKIP.
Mr Mote, from Hampshire, denies 11 charges including false accounting, fraud and acquiring criminal property.
Mr Mote, who was an MEP for South East England, said in court the claims he made were to pay whistleblowers in cash through third parties.
He said he would not give further details because he did not want to put those he paid at risk.
When asked by prosecutor Jonathan Davies if there was any evidence of the payments Mr Mote replied: "Well I hope not, I went out of my way to ensure that there wasn't.
"I gave my word to the many individuals involved, some of them took great risks."
When it was suggested he had been using the sums for his "own personal purposes", he said: "I was targeted for being an anti-EU MEP."
Mr Mote claimed he spent years investigating the misuse of public expenses on behalf of the people of south east England.
He denies four counts of obtaining a money transfer by deception, three of false accounting, two of fraud, and one each of acquiring criminal property and concealing criminal property.
The offences allegedly took place between November 2004 and July 2010.
While an MEP Mr Mote claimed £750,000 in Parliamentary Assistance Allowance.
Mr Mote was elected as a UKIP MEP in 2004 but was expelled from the party before he took up his seat as he was being prosecuted by the Department for Work and Pensions for benefit fraud.
He continued as an independent MEP until 2009.
The trial continues.


A man tracked down to Belgium by police has been charged with murder.

Carl Campbell, 33, was shot in the head while sitting inside a car in High Street, West Bromwich, on  27 December.
Jaspal Rai was detained in Belgium before being extradited back to the UK, police said.
The 24 year old, previously from West Bromwich but now of no fixed abode, is due to appear in court on Wednesday. Two other men have already been charged with Mr Campbell's murder.
Read more Birmingham and Black Country stories.
Mohammed Humza, 19, and Vikesh Chauhan, 24, from the West Bromwich area, appeared in court last month.


Turkish activists have held a mass protest in Istanbul, hours after Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan rallied his own supporters in a seaside resort.

Riot police used water cannon to disperse thousands gathered in Istanbul's Taksim Square.
Mr Erdogan told about 15,000 of his supporters that the protests were led by an international conspiracy.
Protests had eased since last Saturday, when police cleared Istanbul's Gezi Park, the focal point of unrest.
A small protest over plans to redevelop the park began in May.
It exploded into nationwide anti-government unrest after the police used what activists said were heavy-handed tactics.
Mr Erdogan, who has become a hate figure for the protesters, initially appeared to want to placate his opponents, but later hardened his rhetoric.
On Saturday he told thousands of his supporters in the Black Sea city of Samsun how the protesters insulted Islam.
28 May: Protests begin in Gezi Park over plans to redevelop one of Istanbul's few green spaces
30-31 May: Police raids on protest camp culminate in mass unrest
3 June: Protesters establish camps
4-10 June: Protests spread to the rest of Turkey
11/12 June: Police disperse demonstrators in Taksim Square, which adjoins Gezi Park
13 June: PM Erdogan issues a "final warning" to protesters to leave Gezi Park
14 June: Government agrees to suspend Gezi Park redevelopment plans until a court rules on the issue
15 June: Police clear protesters from Gezi Park
Erdogan tested by further unrest
Q&A: Protests in Turkey
Why is Gezi Park so important?
Profile: Recep Tayyip Erdogan
"Let them go into mosques in their shoes, let them drink alcohol in our mosques, let them raise their hand to our headscarved girls," he said.
"One prayer from our people is enough to frustrate their plans."
He also suggested an international conspiracy with financial interests that he termed the "interest-rate lobby" was behind the protests, though he did not elaborate.
In Taksim Square, thousands had gathered to once again call for Mr Erdogan's resignation.
They chanted slogans such as "Dictator Tayyip" and: "This is just the beginning."
But riot police pushed the crowd out of the square, and deployed water cannon to remove stragglers.
TV images showed protesters putting up little resistance, and there appeared to be little violence.
By nightfall, hundreds of protesters continued to mill around on the edges of Taksim Square, with riot police occupying the central area.
The protesters argue that Mr Erdogan, who has been in power for a decade, has become increasingly authoritarian.
Many accuse him of pursuing an Islamist agenda, threatening Turkey's secular political tradition.
However, Mr Erdogan flags up Turkey's impressive economic performance since he became leader, and the large majorities he has won in three elections.
Mr Erdogan has also eradicated the coup culture that plagued Turkish politics, though his critics say he has silenced dissent in the process.


A new landscape to canvas and new faces to get familiar with, BBC News NI examines significant changes to the Republic of Ireland's electoral map.

Irish parliament constituencies have changed in size and shape since the last general election, causing a headache for voters and candidates.
In 2012, the Constituency Commission recommended eight fewer TDs (members of parliament) from 166 to 158.
It also wanted the number of constituencies reduced from 43 to 40.
In the border town of Belturbet in County Cavan, boundary changes run too close for some, cutting across a bridge in the town.
One side is Sligo-Leitrim, the other, Cavan-Monaghan.
Large chunks of electoral areas like the 13,183 population of west Cavan, have suddenly found themselves in new ground.
"People feel completely ripped apart," said Daniel Downey, a community development worker.
"There are only a small amount of votes in Belturbet and I suppose voters feel that candidates just won't come to them.
"People have given up on the idea that the system works for democratic representation."
Towns were merged into larger constituencies or split up into smaller ones.
Irish Prime Minister Enda Kenny has described the changes as "radical".
Many voters in those smaller towns have said they feel swallowed up and voiceless in the move to larger constituencies.
West Cavan was previously part of the Cavan-Monaghan constituency but has now moved to the newly enlarged Sligo-Leitrim.
It takes in four counties, with four seats on offer for 18 candidates.
It has also captured parts of south Donegal, taking with it thousands of voters.
"When your town has two thirds ripped into another constituency and you're lumped with a giant constituency of Sligo-Leitrim, it leaves a sense of frustration and total resignation," said Mr Downey.
Former Belturbet town councillor Liz McDermott predicts voter turnout in west Cavan will be low on Friday.
"The boundary runs so close, people don't even know who to vote for. It means people just won't turn up.
"West Cavan, our hinterland, has been completely cut off. People are asking me 'who are these candidates for Sligo-Leitrim?'"
"They don't know them. It's a disaster and it's caused confusion."
But Adrian Kavanagh, a political geographer at Maynooth University in County Kildare, argues that this unfamiliarity of candidates "is one of the good things to come from election posters".
He added: "They can alert you to the fact that an election boundary change has impacted your area.
"You'd have people saying 'hold on a minute, I haven't seen these candidates before'. It gives you some sort of an idea of who they are."
Voters go to the polls on Friday with indications that no party will come close to getting an overall majority.
And with a radical shake up of boundary changes, it has made the outcome of this general election even more difficult to predict than ever before.


The father of two young boys found dead in the boot of a car in County Mayo has been arrested.

Sanjeev Chada, 43, was discharged from Mayo General Hospital shortly after noon on Wednesday and brought to Westport Garda Station.
He is being interviewed about the deaths of his sons, 10-year-old Eoghan and five-year-old Ruairi.
The boys' bodies were found in the boot of a car, which crashed outside Westport on Monday afternoon.
Their father sustained minor injuries when the car he was driving hit a wall at Rosbeg.
Police had earlier issued a child rescue alert seeking the public's help in finding the children.
The alarm was raised at 01:30 BST on Sunday after they failed to return the family home in Ballinkillen, County Carlow, with their father Sanjeev Chada.
The results of post-mortem examinations and toxicology tests on the brothers have not been released for what police said were operational reasons.
It is understood the boys had been dead for a number of hours prior to the crash.
Final preparations are being made to bring the boys' remains back to County Carlow.


Papers warn students in Hong Kong against seeking independence after Chief Executive CY Leung lashed out at "advocates" of self-determination.

In his first annual policy address since last year's pro-democracy protests, Mr Leung said the need for economic growth outweighed calls for greater democracy.
He also criticised the Undergrad, an official publication of Hong Kong University Students' Union, for advocating Hong Kong's independence.
The Global Times dismisses the magazine article as "nonsense".  It says mainstream society has ignored these independence activists, but "it is not impossible for them to become one of the major problems facing Hong Kong and become a tool for external forces".
"Both the central government and Hong Kong should figure out how to punish those who propagate talk of independence," it urges.
Praising Mr Leung for slamming the students, Hong Kong-based pro-Beijing Ta Kung Pao daily  says that the idea of "Hong Kong independence" is a "time bomb" that needs to be eliminated.
"The advocacy for independence is not simply about freedom of speech or an academic question. It is the root problem for Hong Kong society, a bomb that is hurting social stability and development. There must be a strong social force to stop and get rid of it," warns the article.
The Apply Daily, however, disagrees and criticises the policy address.
The pro-democracy paper describes Mr Leung as "shameless" for not resigning from his post and instead staying on to "threaten" the students.
"There should not be off-limit boundaries in academic discussionsâ€¦ What is the big deal in talking about the issue of independence when students are discussing about Hong Kong's constitution?" the paper asks, pointing out that the Hong Kong government is suppressing the students' freedom of speech.
In a milder tone, the popular Ming Pao daily criticises Mr Leung for targeting the students instead of seeking ways to resolve the political stalemate.
Elsewhere, papers criticise Japan for its "lack of sincerity" after Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe's cabinet approved a record-high defence budget.
Japan announced the 4.98 trillion yen ($42bn; Â£27.5bn) defence budget on Wednesday, a few days after Beijing and Tokyo held maritime talks.
A commentary in the overseas edition of the People's Daily recalls that both countries seemed to have reached a consensus to improve ties and their defence officials met for talks earlier this week.
"There seems to be a thaw in ties since September 2012. So when the Japanese government decides to raise its defence budget and strengthen its military equipment against China, it makes one suspicious of Tokyo's sincerity to improve bilateral relations," it says, blaming the Abe administration for causing regional instability.
The China Daily highlights that Japan's defence budget is much higher than that of China and notes that its defence minister had accused Beijing for being "a major maritime threat" during his new year address.
And finally, papers call for better measures to deal with the problem of unwanted infants after reports suggest that a number of baby hatches have been forced to close down.
China started such centres to ensure that parents could abandon their infants safely rather than leaving them on streets.
However, several baby hatches are ceasing operations, while others are struggling to stay open due to manpower constraints, the Global Times reports.
Zhu Hong, the president of the welfare centre in Nanjing, tells the paper that parents of the abandoned infants "transfer the medical burden and pressure onto welfare centres" because nearly all abandoned babies "suffer from serious congenital diseases".
Lamenting the closure, an article in the West China City Daily suggests that the authorities should step up efforts to forbid abandonment of infants.
A commentary in the China Youth Daily shares a similar view and points out that there is a lack of public assistance package for these parents.ã€€
BBC Monitoring reports and analyses news from TV, radio, web and print media around the world.  You can follow BBC Monitoring on Twitter and Facebook.


Turkey's foreign minister says officials know the identity of a gunman who carried out the Istanbul nightclub attack on New Year's Eve but he has stopped short of naming him.

Mevlut Cavusoglu gave no further details about the inquiry into the murder of 39 people at the Reina club.
Jihadist group Islamic State (IS) has said it was behind the nightclub attack in which dozens more were hurt.
A number of suspects have been arrested in the western city of Izmir.
The police operation on Wednesday was said to have targeted families who had recently travelled to Izmir from Konya, a central city where the main suspect was said to have stayed for several weeks before the attack.
Turkish authorities released images of the main suspect on Tuesday but later discounted reports that he was a 28-year-old Kyrgyz national who had flown home from Istanbul.
Turkey is under growing pressure while the gunman remains on the loose. Checkpoints were set up in Istanbul on Wednesday as officers checked cars and taxis. Police arrested 12 people in raids in the city on Tuesday.
Turkish media have run images of a suspect, saying the pictures were handed out by the police. But the police have given no official details.
In a sign of mounting anger in Istanbul, a video posted on social media showed a man being physically attacked on the Asian side of the city on Wednesday as people shouted: "It's him" and "it's the Reina attacker." The man was punched, knocked to the ground and taken to a local police station before being released.
EU affairs minister Omer Celik said the attacker had clearly had training in the Middle East, and had managed to evade police by not using technology and steering clear of "all modern intelligence techniques".
President Recep Tayyip Erdogan, in his first public comments about the attack, vowed that the jihadist would not succeed in dividing Turks. "In Turkey, no-one's way of life is under any threat. Those who claim this have to prove it. It is my duty to protect everyone's rights,'' he said.
The Reina nightclub, which sits on the banks of the Bosphorus, is one of Istanbul's most fashionable venues - popular with foreigners and often frequented by singers and sports stars.
The gunman is said to have arrived by taxi before rushing through the entrance with a long-barrelled gun he had taken from the boot of the car.
He fired randomly at people in an assault lasting seven minutes, and then fled during the chaos.
Turkey extended its state of emergency for another three months on Tuesday. It was implemented following a failed coup in July which was blamed on a movement loyal to US-based Islamic cleric Fethullah Gulen.
However, Turkey's big cities have also been targeted by IS and by Kurdish militants.
IS was blamed for an attack last June on Istanbul's Ataturk airport, in which more than 40 people were killed. Police are investigating whether the nightclub suspect belongs to the same cell.
Turkey's Deputy Prime Minister Numan Kurtulmus said on Monday that the nightclub attack was a "message" against Turkey's operations in Syria but that they would not be affected.
Turkey launched a military operation in Syria in August to push back IS and Kurdish forces.


A "taboo" subject, "ignoring a politically inconvenient truth", threatening "community cohesion", "fear of being thought racist".

The report which revealed the abuse of more than 1,400 children in Rotherham - mainly by men of Pakistani heritage - found many reasons why the shocking scale of child sexual exploitation in the South Yorkshire town remained hidden.
Councillors and council staff in particular were criticised for "avoiding public discussion"; some through fear of being thought racist, and some through "wholesale denial" of the problem.
But Zahoor Farid, a Muslim youth worker in Rotherham, described the abuse in the town as "shocking".
Professor Alexis Jay's report, commissioned by Rotherham Borough Council, said: "Several councillors interviewed believed that by opening up these issues they could be 'giving oxygen' to racist perspectives that might in turn attract extremist political groups and threaten community cohesion."
This has left the leader of a Muslim organisation in Rotherham furious.
"In the name of what community cohesion and political correctness? Not in the name of my community," said Muhbeen Hussain, founder of British Muslim Youth.
"I'm truly disgusted to see such a report in my home town of Rotherham.
"The fact these guys were predominantly Pakistani heritage men should not be a reason for providing a cloak of invisibility."
His words were echoed by Shoki Adbo, a bank worker from the town, who said: "I'm a Muslim and if I saw a Muslim person doing something like that then they would not be a Muslim to me."
Mr Farid added: "We were lost for words when we saw this report.
"It doesn't come out [that it's one person] from this part of Rotherham and one individual from that part of Rotherham, it always turns out to be a circle of friends."
Prof Jay's report said that while ethnicity did not impact on the way front-line staff dealt with cases, it did affect the wider picture, with some staff in children's social care saying they were "advised by their managers to be cautious about referring to the ethnicity of the perpetrators" in reports.
In 2010, five Asian men from Rotherham were found guilty of sex offences against girls as young as 12, and in 2011 Ashtiaq Asghar was jailed for the murder of 17-year-old Laura Wilson, who had been a victim of sexual exploitation.
But Mr Hussain cannot understand why there have not been more convictions.
"The police authorities are not making prosecutions. If a drug dealer's out on the streets, you arrest that person for committing a crime."
Prof Jay was keen to stress in her report that "there is no simple link between race and child sexual exploitation, and across the UK the greatest numbers of perpetrators of CSE [child sexual exploitation] are white men".
But her inquiry followed three others in Rotherham dating back to 2002. Those earlier reports show the abuse and issues of ethnicity have not recently come to light.
Prof Jay said the first of these reports was "effectively suppressed" because senior officers did not believe the data. The other two were ignored, she said.
In a 2003 report, Dr Angie Heal, a strategic drugs analyst, stated: "In Rotherham the local Asian community are reported to rarely speak about them [the perpetrators]."
According to Prof Jay, three years later Dr Heal "described how the appeal of organised sexual exploitation for Asian gangs had changed".
"In the past, it had been for their personal gratification, whereas now it offered 'career and financial opportunities to young Asian men who got involved'."
Dr Heal also noted that Iraqi Kurds and Kosovan men were participating in organised activities against young women.
The 2006 report stated: "It is believed by a number of workers that one of the difficulties that prevent this issue [CSE] being dealt with effectively is the ethnicity of the main perpetrators."
But was it the wider community from which a number of abusers came who put up barriers to protecting Rotherham's children, or a perception of that community and its possible reaction to being identified?
While "several people" interviewed by Prof Jay "expressed the general view that ethnic considerations had influenced the policy response of the council and the police", all senior officials questioned denied race influenced their decision making.
Meanwhile, regardless of underlying political, cultural or ethnic considerations, at least 1,400 children in the town suffered appalling abuse.
Mr Hussain said: "There's nowhere in the Pakistani culture or the religion of Islam that says child exploitation is allowed - it's completely forbidden.
"But because it's a taboo and it's not talked about, I think with this report we need people to come out and we need the Pakistani Muslim community to talk about it."
That taboo has not just prevented perpetrators being identified, but victims too.
Most of the victims in the cases examined were white British girls, but the report found the abuse of Asian girls was not necessarily reported.
Zlakha Ahmed, from the organisation Apna Haq which supports Asian women and children facing violence in the home, said there has been a long-standing problem of Asian girls suffering abuse.
She said: "The report's not come as a shock to me in terms that we've known about these issues for a number of years now.
"They follow the exact same model as the report that's been released; the difference is that the victims are Asian Muslim young girls and the perpetrators have been Muslim Pakistani men.
"It's just a pattern of abuse that's being repeated with another set of vulnerable girls."
Prof Jay reported: "Pakistani-heritage girls were targeted by taxi drivers and on occasion by older men lying in wait outside school gates.
"The women and girls feared reporting such incidents to the police because it would affect their future marriage prospects."
After four reports into the Rotherham abuse scandal that spanned 16 years and revealed at least 1,400 victims, Prof Jay concluded: "The authorities involved have a great deal to answer for."


St Johnstone extended their unbeaten streak against Hearts to six games as they held the hosts to a draw at Tynecastle.

Media playback is not supported on this device
Prince Buaben headed the capital side into a first-half lead but a classy finish from Danny Swanson brought Saints level before half-time.
Substitute Chris Kane prodded home a David Wotherspoon cross with five minutes left to put the visitors ahead.
But Callum Paterson headed home Don Cowie's corner to snatch a point.
Hearts move above Rangers - who face Ross County on Sunday - into third on goal difference, with Saints remaining fifth, level on points with the two teams immediately above them.
Both sides went into this one on the back of some ropey form; Hearts had conceded five goals in their last two, winless, games, and St Johnstone had just one victory in their last four. Recent history was interesting. Saints had three wins and two draws in their last five meetings with Robbie Neilson's side.
They were under pressure from early on, though. Hearts had more possession and more chances but it wasn't until Buaben scored midway through the half that they gained the lead. And it was odd.
A shot from Don Cowie came back off the crossbar to Buaben who sent his close-range header goal-bound until it appeared to be pawed away by a St Johnstone hand.
It was questionable that the ball had crossed the line, but then had it not, we'd be talking about a penalty and a red card. The goal was given instead and Tynecastle came alive.
Not long after his goal, Buaben tested Zander Clark in the Saints goal and in these moments Hearts were comfortable. They were hit with a sucker punch and a lot of class when Swanson got on the ball.
Steven MacLean sent Swanson through one-on-one with John Souttar and there was no contest there. Swanson turned inside the centre-half, then placed a gorgeous shot past Jack Hamilton for his 10th goal of the season and his third of the campaign against Hearts.
Swanson is already two thirds of the way towards matching Saints' leading scorer from last season, MacLean.
In the early minutes of the second half there were big moments at both ends. David Wotherspoon forced a save from Hamilton, then Wotherspoon rattled the inside of Hamilton's post with a beautiful free-kick. The breaking ball fell to Joe Shaughnessy, who tapped it home, but he was offside.
Hearts had a big opportunity of their own minutes later when Bjorn Johnsen's shot from close in was brilliantly blocked by Steven Anderson. The defender's awareness of the danger around him saved Saints.
The game had become a tight battle between two sides who looked for a while like they didn't have sufficient creativity to score again. They did. Both of them.
Saints surely thought they had won it when Wotherspoon, who got better as the day went on, found Kane, who passed his shot beyond Hamilton. Hearts complained bitterly about the goal, claiming an offside, but they wasted their breath.
Five minutes remained, but the home team dug in and Paterson got them the point they undoubtedly deserved when heading home from a corner with two minutes left.
It was the Scotland full-back's fifth goal of the season. For him, next stop Wembley.
Hearts boss Robbie Neilson: "It was a really tough game. We knew St Johnstone would make it difficult and it would be a very combative game and it turned out that way.
"We managed to get ourselves in front then gave away a poor goal and then there was an offside goal for St Johnstone and they take the lead. But we managed to fight back and show our quality and equalise.
Media playback is not supported on this device
"We are disappointed not to take the three points but the manner in which we fought back was really pleasing."
Saints boss Tommy Wright: "It maybe lacked quality at times but I think it was end to end and entertaining and I think we picked up a very good point.
"I've seen the first Hearts goal back and one thing I'll say is the referee's assistant has got a clear view of it, as in a really good position. Brian Easton doesn't think it's over, but the angle I've got on the video doesn't clear it up for me.
"For the disallowed goal the referee's assistant seems to think Joe Shaughnessy was a couple of yards offside, but I have seen that back and he looks level to me. So I think we maybe got the wrong end of the stick."
Match ends, Heart of Midlothian 2, St. Johnstone 2.
Second Half ends, Heart of Midlothian 2, St. Johnstone 2.
Brian Easton (St. Johnstone) is shown the yellow card for a bad foul.
Jamie Walker (Heart of Midlothian) wins a free kick in the defensive half.
Foul by Brian Easton (St. Johnstone).
Foul by Conor Sammon (Heart of Midlothian).
Steven Anderson (St. Johnstone) wins a free kick in the defensive half.
Attempt missed. Callum Paterson (Heart of Midlothian) right footed shot from outside the box misses to the right.
Robbie Muirhead (Heart of Midlothian) is shown the yellow card for a bad foul.
Goal!  Heart of Midlothian 2, St. Johnstone 2. Callum Paterson (Heart of Midlothian) header from very close range to the top left corner.
Corner,  Heart of Midlothian. Conceded by Paul Paton.
Goal!  Heart of Midlothian 1, St. Johnstone 2. Christopher Kane (St. Johnstone) right footed shot from the left side of the box to the bottom right corner. Assisted by David Wotherspoon.
Corner,  St. Johnstone. Conceded by Igor Rossi.
Foul by Don Cowie (Heart of Midlothian).
David Wotherspoon (St. Johnstone) wins a free kick on the right wing.
Substitution, Heart of Midlothian. Conor Sammon replaces Bjorn Johnsen.
Substitution, St. Johnstone. Christopher Kane replaces Danny Swanson.
Substitution, Heart of Midlothian. Robbie Muirhead replaces Tony Watt.
Igor Rossi (Heart of Midlothian) is shown the yellow card for a bad foul.
Foul by Igor Rossi (Heart of Midlothian).
Blair Alston (St. Johnstone) wins a free kick on the right wing.
Foul by Jamie Walker (Heart of Midlothian).
Paul Paton (St. Johnstone) wins a free kick in the attacking half.
Attempt missed. Brian Easton (St. Johnstone) right footed shot from the left side of the box misses to the left.
Corner,  St. Johnstone. Conceded by Liam Smith.
Bjorn Johnsen (Heart of Midlothian) wins a free kick in the defensive half.
Foul by Brian Easton (St. Johnstone).
Steven MacLean (St. Johnstone) wins a free kick in the defensive half.
Foul by Igor Rossi (Heart of Midlothian).
Substitution, Heart of Midlothian. Arnaud Djoum replaces Prince Buaben.
Prince Buaben (Heart of Midlothian) is shown the yellow card for a bad foul.
Foul by Prince Buaben (Heart of Midlothian).
Steven MacLean (St. Johnstone) wins a free kick in the defensive half.
Foul by Tony Watt (Heart of Midlothian).
Blair Alston (St. Johnstone) wins a free kick in the defensive half.
Foul by Liam Smith (Heart of Midlothian).
Blair Alston (St. Johnstone) wins a free kick in the defensive half.
Corner,  Heart of Midlothian. Conceded by Steven Anderson.
Corner,  Heart of Midlothian. Conceded by Steven Anderson.
David Wotherspoon (St. Johnstone) hits the bar with a right footed shot from outside the box from a direct free kick.


Party leaders have made a final appeal for votes before Thursday's devolved elections in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland, and local polls across England.

Jeremy Corbyn urged voters to "send a message" to David Cameron but appeared to back away from earlier claims that Labour would not lose seats in England, saying predictions "are not that important".
The PM said a vote for his party would secure services and keep bills down.
SNP leader Nicola Sturgeon said she was taking nothing for granted in Scotland.
Guide to May 2016 elections in UK
Final day of Holyrood election campaign
Labour enters Welsh election on 'low'
The Scottish First Minister made her party's case for another five years in power at a final election rally in Glasgow. Northern Ireland's five main party leaders have debated for the last time on the BBC.
The polls will be the largest, in terms of the number of votes expected to be cast, before the next general election. All nations and regions of the UK are going to the polls on what has been dubbed "Super Thursday".
Tap here to find out which election is taking place in your area.
As well as elections to the Scottish Parliament, the National Assembly of Wales and the Northern Ireland Assembly, there will be votes for new mayors for London, Liverpool, Salford and Bristol, as well as for members of the Greater London Assembly.
More than 2,700 seats will also be up for grabs in 124 English council elections, while parliamentary by-elections will be held in Ogmore and Sheffield Brightside, both won by Labour at the last general election.
All police and crime commissioners in England will be up for re-election.
Ahead of his first UK-wide electoral test and amid renewed speculation about his leadership, Mr Corbyn is under pressure to demonstrate his party is making progress after last year's calamitous election defeat.
Mr Corbyn insisted on Tuesday that his party would not lose seats in England and would improve on its performance in 2012 - when the majority of the seats were last fought - when Labour gained almost 800 seats under Ed Miliband.
The BBC's political editor Laura Kuenssberg said Mr Corbyn's aides were now suggesting his comments had been "misinterpreted" amid the very real prospect of Labour ending the night between 100 and 300 seats worse off.
Speaking during a visit to Wales, Mr Corbyn said: "What I said was, I was not predicting any losses". With the polls now less than 24 hours away, he said "predictions are not that important".
Mr Corbyn campaigned alongside Welsh First Minister Carwyn Jones, who is seeking to hold off a resurgent Conservative Party and win enough seats to enable Labour to maintain its 17-year grip on power there.
"The Tories' failed economic policies mean there is now a multi-billion black hole to fill in this Parliament," Mr Corbyn said. "The Tories can no longer be trusted with our communities so send them a message on 5 May."
As the Welsh campaign enters its final stages, Plaid Cymru said it could call a referendum on further assembly powers if it wins power. UKIP has said it expects to win at least five seats in Wales in what it says will be a major breakthrough.
In England, the Lib Dems and the Greens are hoping to make gains while in London, all eyes are on the contest to succeed Boris Johnson as mayor, with the Conservative Zac Goldsmith trying to extend his party's eight-year rule at City Hall.
On Tuesday evening, David Cameron joined Mr Goldsmith at his final rally of the campaign, saying he was the "right man" for the capital as a whole and Londoners should not be "lab rats" for Labour's experimental economic policies.
Labour candidate Sadiq Khan urged Londoners to choose "hope over fear" and played down suggestions he would be affected by the party's recent troubles, saying: "You won't see Jeremy Corbyn's name or Ken Livingstone's name" on the ballot paper."
BBC Newsnight's political editor Nick Watt says Mr Khan plans to keep Mr Corbyn away from his victory celebrations should he prevail, and the two men would not be seen together for several days.
But Mr Khan's team said Mr Corbyn had been invited to his post-election gathering.
Find out more about who is standing in the London elections.


A prisoner released from jail by mistake went to a pub for "a couple of pints" before handing himself in.

Lewis Harwood, 31, was released from HMP Birmingham after serving a sentence for motoring offences.
But Birmingham Magistrates' Court had remanded him over an unrelated charge three days earlier and alerted the prison by fax late that evening, said G4S, which runs the jail.
Harwood later realised he should not have been released and went to police.
His friend Darren Clifford, whose mother runs the Soho Foundry Tavern in Smethwick, about a 10-minute walk from the jail, said he had known Harwood for years and that he was a regular at the pub.
"He was relaxed, chilling - just happy to be out," he said.
"When he got home and checked, he realised the mistake and handed himself back in at the police station and they took him back to the prison."
Mr Clifford said Harwood, from Rugeley, Staffordshire, "only had a couple of pints and a sandwich".
A G4S spokesman said: "In accordance with proper procedures we performed a 14-day and a two-day check on this prisoner's release date and both of these cleared him for release first thing on Monday [29 June] morning.
"The only notification we received of a change to his status was a fax sent by the court late on Friday [26 June] evening.
"The prisoner is now back in custody and we have proposed to our partners in the court system that the way important decisions about offenders are communicated to the prison is looked at."
But a spokeswoman for HM Courts & Tribunals Service said the fax was sent before 17:00 BST.
"Lewis Harwood's hearing took place on the afternoon of Friday 26 June and he was remanded in custody to appear at Birmingham Crown Court on 5 October 2015," she said.
"The result of the hearing was checked and faxed across to HMP Birmingham, in line with standard procedure, at around 16:40 [BST] on the 26th."


England wicketkeeper Sam Billings is available to play for Kent this week following the series win over Ireland.

Billings, 25, was due to return to the Indian Premier League and his franchise Delhi Daredevils after playing in Sunday's 85-run win at Lord's.
However, with Delhi unable to reach the IPL play-offs, the ECB have agreed Billings will remain in England before a training camp in Spain on 15 May.
He could therefore feature in Kent's three One-Day Cup fixtures this week.
Billings, who scored 138 runs in six innings at an average of 23 in the IPL for the Daredevils over the last month, is yet to make an appearance for Kent this season.
The club have won all three of their County Championship games and are second in Division Two, but Sunday's win over Middlesex was their first in four 50-over matches.
The results have left Matt Walker's side in eighth place in their group, and needing an upturn in form when they play Gloucestershire in Bristol on Wednesday before further away games versus Surrey and Glamorgan.
If selected, Billings will compete with Adam Rouse for the wicketkeeper spot before heading to Spain with his England team-mates on Monday to prepare for this month's one-day series against South Africa and the Champions Trophy in June.