For two, long days the chief judge in this controversial case mumbled his way through the ruling, reading out page after barely audible page.

For most people in the small, provincial courtroom the verdict on Tuesday was never in doubt.
But now Nadiya Savchenko has been declared guilty and sentenced to 22 years behind bars, international pressure for her release is mounting.
"For Nadiya it makes no difference whether she got 10 or 20 years. She is convinced the only way she will be set free is through political negotiations," one of her lawyers, Nikolai Polozov, told the BBC outside court.
His colleagues say talks are already under way for her release, though they gave no details.
The US and EU have long condemned the trial of the Ukrainian military officer as illegal.
She's now been found guilty of directing artillery fire at the height of the fighting with Russia-backed rebels and killing two Russian journalists in eastern Ukraine. She continues to deny that.
Nadiya Savchenko also says she was kidnapped by the rebels and smuggled out of Ukraine after her capture, and then arrested.
But the court decreed that her captors suddenly let her go and she headed through rebel-controlled territory dressed in Ukrainian military fatigues to enter Russia.
"We think that is a farce," insisted Svyatoslav Tsegolko, the press secretary of Ukraine's president who attended the closing sessions of the trial.
"If Russia doesn't want more sanctions it should release her and all the Ukrainian hostages it has," Mr Tsegolko, listing Oleg Sentsov among others. The film director was found guilty of planning terrorist acts in Crimea after its annexation by Russia in 2014 - in another case deemed a show trial by the West.
Last week, US President Barack Obama raised the case of Nadiya Savchenko in a phone conversation with Russian President Vladimir Putin.
Now the US state department has confirmed that John Kerry will discuss her "unjust sentence" when he meets Russia's president in Moscow on Thursday; a spokesman described the US as "extremely concerned".
The Kremlin has previously batted away criticism, arguing that the trial must run its course. But there has been a slight shift in the language now that justice has been "seen to be done".
Ukraine's President Petro Poroshenko has announced that he is prepared to swap two Russians captured in eastern Ukraine for Nadiya Savchenko, and Moscow has not rejected that proposal out of hand.
Ukraine says Yevgeny Yerofeyev and Alexander Alexandrov are elite members of Russian military intelligence but Russia maintains they were not on active duty.
"These questions will be considered in full accordance with Russian law," Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov said on Wednesday, before underlining that any such decision would be taken by the president.
The Kremlin's spokesman has used almost identical language.
With calls in Europe for fresh sanctions in response to this case, the ball seems to be in President Putin's court.
"However you look at it, this doesn't benefit Russia," opposition politician Alexei Navalny argued in his blog.
He described the trial as such an "obvious stitch-up" you could "see the threads", and suggested whoever planned to make an example of Nadiya Savchenko - as a trophy prisoner from the Ukrainian conflict - had miscalculated.
"Most likely, this is a typical case of idiocy and stubbornness," Alexei Navalny argued, suggesting the Kremlin doesn't want to be seen to give in under pressure.
That could mean Nadiya Savchenko remains behind bars for a long time.
But she has already set her own ultimatum. Her lawyers say she's vowed to start another full hunger strike in 10 working days - as soon as her verdict comes into effect.
"She doesn't want the Russian authorities to waste time deciding her case," Mr Polozov explained. "She wants to force them to send her home, dead or alive."


A man has died after a van crashed into a stationary car in West Lothian.

Police said the crash happened at 07:10 on the B7066 Whitburn Link Road, near Polkemmet Country Park.
Several roads have been closed. They are due to open at 12:30.
The 58-year-old man who died was a driver in the stationary car.
The occupants of the van suffered minor injuries. Police are appealing for witnesses.


Bikes will be tested at the Tour de France and Olympics to try to find hidden motors and stop 'mechanical doping', cycling's governing body says.

The UCI says up to 12,000 bikes will be tested this year using a new scanning system introduced in January.
Belgium's Femke van den Driessche was banned for six years last month in the first proven case of mechanical doping.
"If you use this method of cheating, we will catch you," UCI president Brian Cookson said.
The UCI believes that its new system of magnetic resonance scanning, which detects motors, magnets and batteries, is more effective than using heat-seeking cameras.
UCI technical manager Mark Barfield says riders who switch bikes mid-race could be targeted.
Demonstrating its testing technology on Tuesday, the UCI says the one hidden motor found - in Van den Driessche's bike at the Cyclo-cross World Championships in Belgium in January - was at the first event where magnetic resonance scans were used.
Van den Driessche, the former European Under-23 champion, has denied suggestions she deliberately cheated, saying the bike was not hers.
UCI regulations, which were recently strengthened, state a rider is given a minimum suspension of six months and a fine of up to 200,000 Swiss francs (£141,000) for an offence of "technological fraud", while coaches, mechanics and other officials could also be sanctioned.


London 2012 chairman Lord Coe arrived in Cardiff to herald the start of the Olympics as the Welsh capital prepares to host the first event of the Games.

More than 40,000 fans are expected to watch the kick-off of the world's biggest sporting event as Great Britain take on New Zealand in women's football at the Millennium Stadium.
The match comes two days before the opening ceremony in London on Friday.
Lord Coe said it was important the Games was not uniquely a London story.
In pictures: London 2012 begins
Following his tour of the stadium, he said: "One of the commitments we made when we were bidding, and I felt strongly about this as somebody who was not brought up in London, was this had to be about the whole of the UK, and this is a really strong signal to our commitment to that concept.
"A lot of the Games are in London but this is not uniquely a London story.
"When I came in this morning I felt I was arriving in an Olympic city, I have been to Cardiff plenty of times but it had a different feel about it today."
The Welsh capital boasted a festival atmosphere with Olympic events being staged across the city centre for an expected crowd of 40,000 at Wednesday's first game.
At around 14:30 BST the Team GB women passed along Westgate Street by coach on the way to the stadium to cheering, flag-waving crowds.
Fans started going into the stadium just after 14:00 BST, with queues forming for people to have their bags searched.
As the game was about to kick off, fans were still queuing to get in.
One of the security staff monitoring bag searches said it was taking anything from 45 seconds to three minutes to search each bag.
He said the biggest cause of the delay was bottles of water and that he "felt sorry" for the searches who had received "some flak simply because they were sticking to the rules."
There were virtually no queues for people who didn't have bags.
Figures provided by the Welsh government show Welsh companies have won Olympic contracts worth in excess of Â£38m.
This has come partly from investment in sporting facilities which the government say helped attract teams from 20 countries to Wales for pre-Games training.
Jonathan Jones, the government's tourism marketing director, said the Business Minister Edwina Hart had hosted a reception for business people and diplomats in London looking at more investment in Wales and would be attending a global tourism investment conference in London on Thursday.
He rejected criticism that the government had not done more to help businesses gain Olympic contracts, saying they had spent years providing seminars throughout Wales on how to get involved.
"Only the main one and two tiers of (companies who gain) contracts are allowed to mention they've got contracts," he said.
"If you dig down into those supply chains you will find lots of small businesses have had contracts with those large contractors but are not allowed to say anything about it."
FIFA president Sepp Blatter is among those attending the opening event of the Games.
It will be followed by Cameroon v Brazil at 18:45 BST - among 11 matches being held at the Millennium Stadium throughout the Games.
Meanwhile, the security operation around the city is being stepped up, while roads around the stadium have been closed.
South Wales Police Assistant Chief Constable Julian Kirby said the eyes of the world are on Cardiff .
"Wales is good at big events - the World Cup, FA Cup, football play-off finals and the Six Nations," he said.
"We've stepped up from that. Our ambition is that today's event goes off and the public don't notice us. At the moment everything is in place.
"It's an Olympic football match and what has brought it home to me this morning is on the national news that all eyes are on Cardiff.
"It's my job to make sure that Wales looks good."
In terms of organisation inside the stadium, manager Gerry Toms said everything was "ready to go".
"Let's get the show on the road," he said.
"It reflects the recognition that both the Millennium Stadium and Cardiff is an ideal centre for a worldwide event."
The exact number of tickets sold for both matches is not yet known but there have been large queues at ticket booths around the stadium.
At one of the sales points there have been up to 60 people standing in line since it opened at 10:00 BST.
A last-minute surge of people queued for tickets at gate three of the stadium with an hour and a half to go until kick-off.
A Locog spokesperson said he was "chuffed" with the size of the crowd.
"The women's World Cup Final had 48,000 people and the record for women's club game in the Champions League was 35,000," he said.
"This is a massive crowd for a women's international. It's a great way to start the whole thing off."
Should the crowd at the Millennium Stadium be higher than 48,000, it will eclipse the attendance for last year's Women's World Cup final in Germany, but still fall short of the 90,000 record set in the United States in 1999.
Because of the way football is scheduled with the number of games and rest periods, the tournament has to start before the opening ceremony of the Games.
Under International Olympic Committee (IOC) rules, no events can be held in the host city until after the ceremony takes place.
Roads in Cardiff city centre are closed on Wednesday for eight hours until 21:30 BST and there will be extra capacity on train services.
Music, comedy and sporting activities are taking place around the city centre until 19:00 BST, while fans without tickets will be able to watch the action on the big screen in the Hayes.
First Minister Carwyn Jones said: "In two days the eyes of the world will focus on the opening ceremony in London, but today Wales is in the spotlight and once again we have an opportunity to show people across the globe what a fantastic host we are for top sporting events."


Almost 8,000 jobs in UK libraries have disappeared in six years, about a quarter of the overall total, an investigation by the BBC has revealed.

Over the same period, some 15,500 volunteers have been recruited and 343 libraries have closed, leading to fears over the future of the profession.
Children's author Alan Gibbons said the public library service faced the "greatest crisis in its history".
The government said it funded the roll-out of wi-fi to help libraries adapt.
The BBC has compiled data from 207 authorities responsible for running libraries through the Freedom of Information Act.  Our analysis shows:
Tap here to find out how many libraries have closed near you
Mr Gibbons, who wrote Blue Peter Book Award winner Shadow of the Minotaur, said: "Opening hours are slashed, book stocks reduced.
"Volunteers are no longer people who supplement full time staff, but their replacements. This constitutes the hollowing out of the service. We are in dangerous territory."
Philip Pullman, the author of the fantasy trilogy His Dark Materials, said the library service should not rely on volunteers.
"It is exploiting people's goodness and willingness to work and so on," he told BBC Radio Oxford.
"I am in favour of volunteering but relying on volunteers to provide a service that ought to be statutory is not a good policy. What next? Are we going to rely on volunteer teachers because we can't find new teachers because all the staffing levels in schools are going down?"
There are four areas - Sefton in Merseyside; Brent in north London, Stoke-on-Trent and Sunderland - where more than half the libraries have closed since 2010, either buildings, mobile or both.
Librarian Ian Anstice, who runs the Public Libraries News website in his spare time, said the cuts were "without precedent".
4,290
Council-run libraries in 2010
3,765
Council-run libraries now
343 libraries closed, 207 of them buildings, 132 mobile and four "other"
232 transferred, 174 to community groups and 58 outsourced
50 new libraries started, 20 of them buildings, 8 mobile and 22 "other"
111 proposed for closure over the next year
He said: "Councils learnt early on how unpopular simply closing libraries is so they have had to cut the vital service in other, less obvious ways.
"It can come across in many forms: reduced opening hours, reduced book fund, reduced maintenance and reduced staffing.
Explore the full dataset here
"In all its incarnations, it is harmful to the service, creating the risk that once-loyal users of libraries will come away disappointed and stop using them.
"Our public library system used to be envy of the world. Now it is used as a cautionary tale that librarians use worldwide to scare their colleagues."
24,044
Paid staff now
31,977
Paid staff in 2010
31,403 unpaid volunteers now
15,861 unpaid volunteers in 2010
Cuts to library services were deeper in England than the rest of the UK.
"Scotland has, until now, been faring better than south of the border for libraries, but I'm not sure it's going to be maintained," Professor Peter Reid, who oversees the Department of Information Management at Robert Gordon University in Aberdeen, said.
In England, the largest percentage drop in library workers was in Harrow in north-west London. In 2010, the council paid 164 people but today there are 60 employees, employed by an external provider, which now runs the service.
The largest rise in volunteers was in Hampshire, where 1,498 people are assisting the library service, compared with 567 at the beginning of the decade. Over the same period, paid staff in the county's libraries dropped from 760 to 525.
The East Midlands has lost 36% of its jobs in libraries, the biggest percentage drop in the UK. There were 1,905 paid posts in 2010 compared with 1,213 now.
Some authorities say changes were inevitable to the library service.  Volunteers perform a range of tasks, from reading clubs to stacking shelves, and their use varies from library to library, they argue.
'Decimated' service: What does the future hold for libraries?
Councillor Andrew Gibson, from Hampshire County Council, said: "Our volunteers are enthusiastic and knowledgeable, and are greatly appreciated by library customers. Volunteers have helped libraries to increase their opening hours."
He said 58% of people responding to a recent residents' survey agreed with increasing the number of trained volunteers.
Harrow's Councillor Sue Anderson said: "We are faced with government cuts of Â£83m and like other local authorities we need to make the most from our reduced budget.
"Yes, we have needed to close four of our most under-used libraries (and merge two others), and some staff have left. But the model for libraries that we have now is not just sustainable, it offers a bright future for public space and learning."
BBC News also analysed how library habits have changed. Through analysing Chartered Institute of Public Finance and Accountancy reports from 2012 to 2014, we found:
Find out more about how our library habits are changing
Dr Briony Birdi, who has an MA in librarianship, said: "It's not a happy picture, but there are still lots of libraries left.
"The danger is we predict the end of libraries, and it's not the end of libraries.
"We would be lying if we said [library staff] are not affected by what's going on. The way that funding has been repeatedly cut has been the most demoralising.
"I don't want people to think that libraries are over, they will just look different and I think we do accept that."
Elizabeth Elford, of the Society of Chief Librarians, said: "I think inevitably there will be fewer public libraries when we come out the other side, but they will be better and more innovative... we are really trying to be attuned to the needs of customers, above and beyond books."
Councillor Ian Stephens, who chairs the Local Government Association's Culture, Tourism and Sport Board, said: "It's testament to how much people value their libraries that so many have volunteered to help keep them open.
"Councils are doing all they can to keep libraries open and don't take decisions to close them lightly. Each council will do what works best for their communities depending on local circumstances."
A spokesman for the Department for Culture, Media and Sport said: "Libraries are cornerstones of their communities and are part of the fabric of our society, so it's vital they continue to innovate in order to meet the changing demands of those they serve.
"Government is helping libraries to modernise by funding a wi-fi roll-out across England that has benefitted more than 1,000 libraries and increasing access to digital services and e-lending.
"The Libraries Taskforce is also consulting on a new vision for public libraries that will help reinvigorate the service and ensure they remain relevant to local communities."
A spokesman for the Department of Culture Arts and Leisure Northern Ireland said it regarded libraries as a "key front line service", and had provided additional funding to protect them from the impact of budget cuts.
A Scottish government spokeswoman said: "We place great importance on public libraries and believe everyone should have access to library services."
Welsh Assembly Deputy Culture Minister Ken Skates said: "We took the decision during the worst of austerity to better protect budgets for Welsh councils and local libraries than happened in England."
Reporting team: Daniel Wainwright, Paul Bradshaw, Pete Sherlock, Antia Geada
Following publication three councils provided further information to that contained in their original FOI responses.
Derbyshire County Council has closed eight of its 10 mobile libraries while Gloucestershire County Council closed three  and Lambeth closed two.


Three cows have been struck and killed by a train in Hertfordshire.

The 14:25 BST service from Liverpool Street to Stansted came to a halt at about 15:10 near Bishop's Stortford.
Three other cows made off through the town's high street before being contained, Hertfordshire Police said. A stockman was called to rescue them. No-one on board the train was injured.
Passengers on trains between Broxbourne and Stansted Airport and Cambridge have been told to expect disruption.
Charlie Page and Hannah Turner, both from Bishop's Stortford, were trapped on board the train for about an hour.
"The train stopped just near Bishop's Stortford. The driver said 'we've struck some cows' and then about five or six police cars arrived," Miss Turner said.
"I did see one dead cow and I think one might have been under the train.
"Others were running up and down alongside the train."
A British Transport Police (BTP) spokesman said officers were called to the rail line near Cannons Mill Lane in Bishops Stortford, at 15:08.
"Officers from BTP and Hertfordshire Constabulary attended the scene and found that three cows had been struck and killed by a London Liverpool Street to Stansted Airport train," he said.


Sir David Attenborough will present the sequel to 2001's The Blue Planet, the BBC has announced.

The seven-part series, to be shown later this year, will aim to highlight recent scientific discoveries.
Filming innovations include suction cameras fitted to the backs of orcas.
"I am truly thrilled to be joining this new exploration of the underwater worlds which cover most of our planet, yet are still its least known," Sir David said.
The BBC's Natural History Unit spent four years filming off every continent and in every ocean for Blue Planet II, with support from marine scientists.
James Honeyborne, the series' executive producer, said: "The oceans are the most exciting place to be right now, because new scientific discoveries have given us a new perspective of life beneath the waves.
"Blue Planet II is taking its cue from these breakthroughs, unveiling unbelievable new places, extraordinary new behaviours and remarkable new creatures. Showing a contemporary portrait of marine life, it will provide a timely reminder that this is a critical moment for the health of the world's oceans."
Among the recent discoveries caught on camera are a tuskfish that uses tools and a new species of crab with a hairy chest - nicknamed the "Hoff crab" after Baywatch star David Hasselhoff.
The Natural History Unit's new filming techniques include "tow cams" that can capture predatory fish and dolphins head-on, suction cams which attach to the back of whale sharks and orcas for a creature's-eye view, and a probe camera that can record miniature marine life.
The BBC said the crew caught unusual examples of marine behaviour on camera, such as a coral grouper and reef octopus with sophisticated hunting techniques, a giant trevally fish that catches birds in flight, and a dive with a sperm whale mother and her calf.
It said the series would also explore new landscapes from methane volcanoes erupting in the Gulf of Mexico to the Antarctic deep at 1,000m, filmed using manned submersibles.
The Blue Planet was watched by more than 12 million people in 2001 and won Baftas and Emmy awards for both cinematography and music. The sequel will be broadcast on BBC One later this year.


The number of refugees from Syria may double or even triple this year if the conflict does not end, the UN's refugee chief has said.

Speaking in neighbouring Turkey, Antonio Guterres warned of the "risk of an explosion" across the Middle East if the crisis continued much longer.
Fighting flared up again on Sunday as rebels reportedly launched a surprise attack inside the city of Homs.
As many as 70,000 people have died in the two-year conflict, the UN believes.
More than a million Syrians have now been registered as refugees by the UN in neighbouring countries.
"If this escalation goes on and nothing happens to solve the problem we might have in the end of the year a much larger number of refugees - twice or three times the present level," Mr Guterres told reporters in Ankara.
He urged countries to help support Turkey, Lebanon, Jordan and other countries sheltering the refugees.
The reports of fighting in Homs on Sunday could not be verified independently.
A UK-based monitoring group opposed to President Bashar al-Assad, the Syrian Observatory for Human Rights, said rebels had launched an attack on the Baba Amr district early on Sunday.
Pro-Assad forces regained control of the district a year ago after fierce fighting.
"The rebels infiltrated Baba Amr during the night," Observatory director Rami Abdel Rahman told AFP news agency.
"Those manning the army checkpoints barely had time to realise what was going on."
Activists later reported government forces had launched strikes on Baba Amr to counter the rebel offensive.
Unverified video said to show fighting in Homs has been posted online. Shooting can be heard and smoke is seen rising over a built-up area.
Reports have also emerged of new air strikes by government forces on the northern city of Raqqa, which was captured by rebels less than a week ago.
According to the Observatory, 14 people died in the bombardment on Saturday.


Greenock Morton came close to snatching a late winner but had to settle for a point after a hard-fought opening-day Championship clash at Dumbarton.

Scott Gallacher made a double save from Bob McHugh and Ross Forbes with a minute left before the Sons keeper denied Forbes again in injury time.
An even first half saw Dumbarton's Ally Roy and Christian Nade both go close, but Morton created more chances.
Forbes brought another save as Andy Murdoch and Connor McManus fired wide.
David Wilson and Roy had further efforts for the hosts after the interval, while Jai Quitongo, Robert Thomson and Forbes were denied again by Gallacher and Michael Doyle poked the ball over as neither side could fashion a breakthrough.
Match ends, Dumbarton 0, Morton 0.
Second Half ends, Dumbarton 0, Morton 0.
Corner,  Morton. Conceded by Scott Gallacher.
Attempt saved. Ross Forbes (Morton) left footed shot from a difficult angle on the right is saved in the centre of the goal.
Attempt blocked. Scott Tiffoney (Morton) right footed shot from the right side of the box is blocked.
Attempt saved. Ross Forbes (Morton) left footed shot from the right side of the box is saved in the centre of the goal.
Attempt saved. Robert McHugh (Morton) right footed shot from very close range is saved in the centre of the goal.
Corner,  Morton. Conceded by Christopher McLaughlin.
Substitution, Morton. Scott Tiffoney replaces Jai Quitongo.
Substitution, Dumbarton. David Smith replaces Tom Walsh.
Hand ball by Jai Quitongo (Morton).
Attempt missed. Calum Gallagher (Dumbarton) left footed shot from outside the box is too high.
Attempt missed. Ross Forbes (Morton) left footed shot from outside the box is close, but misses to the right.
Corner,  Dumbarton. Conceded by Michael Doyle.
Attempt blocked. Christian Nade (Dumbarton) right footed shot from outside the box is blocked.
Attempt missed. Michael Doyle (Morton) left footed shot from the centre of the box is just a bit too high.
Jai Quitongo (Morton) is shown the yellow card for a bad foul.
Craig Barr (Dumbarton) wins a free kick in the attacking half.
Foul by Jai Quitongo (Morton).
Ally Roy (Dumbarton) is shown the yellow card for a bad foul.
Andy Murdoch (Morton) wins a free kick on the left wing.
Foul by Ally Roy (Dumbarton).
Substitution, Dumbarton. Calum Gallagher replaces David Wilson.
Attempt saved. Craig Barr (Dumbarton) right footed shot from the centre of the box is saved in the top centre of the goal.
Corner,  Dumbarton. Conceded by Mark Russell.
Attempt blocked. Craig Barr (Dumbarton) right footed shot from a difficult angle on the right is blocked.
Attempt saved. Jai Quitongo (Morton) right footed shot from the left side of the box is saved in the centre of the goal.
Corner,  Morton. Conceded by Sam Wardrop.
Robert Thomson (Morton) wins a free kick in the defensive half.
Foul by Dougie Hill (Dumbarton).
Attempt blocked. Michael Tidser (Morton) right footed shot from outside the box is blocked.
Attempt saved. Andy Murdoch (Morton) header from the centre of the box is saved in the top centre of the goal.
Attempt blocked. Mark Stewart (Dumbarton) right footed shot from the centre of the box is blocked.
Foul by Jai Quitongo (Morton).
Craig Barr (Dumbarton) wins a free kick in the attacking half.
Attempt missed. Ally Roy (Dumbarton) right footed shot from outside the box misses to the left.
Foul by Ross Forbes (Morton).
Tom Walsh (Dumbarton) wins a free kick in the attacking half.
Attempt saved. Robert Thomson (Morton) right footed shot from the right side of the box is saved in the bottom left corner.
Attempt blocked. Andy Murdoch (Morton) right footed shot from outside the box is blocked.


The names of the nine people shot dead at an African-American church in South Carolina have been read out in its first service since Wednesday's attack.

One visiting reverend, John Gillison, said the "devil entered" but failed to "take control of your church".
A black cloth was placed over the chair of Reverend Clementa Pinckney, who was one of those killed by the gunman.
Hundreds of people packed the Emanuel AME church for the service on Sunday morning, amid tight security.
Meanwhile, police are investigating an online post, possibly by suspected gunman Dylann Roof, which may outline his motivation for the attack.
On Sunday, bells at more than a dozen churches rang out simultaneously throughout the state of South Carolina in a sign of solidarity.
"There they were in the house of the Lord, studying your word, praying with one another," Rev John Gillison told the congregation.
"But the devil also entered. And the devil was trying to take charge," he said. But, he added, "the devil cannot take control of your people. And the devil cannot take control of your church".
Volunteers were on hand to give out bottles of water to the congregation, with many members reportedly forced to sit in an overflow part of the church.
Hundreds of people who could not get inside held their own prayers outside the building. Many had travelled from across the country to pay their respects.
South Carolina governor Nikki Haley, who has called for the death penalty for suspect Dylann Roof, attended the service with her family.
There are five chairs at the altar in the Emanuel Church. But the one in the middle was vacant on Sunday, draped instead with a black cloth.
This used to be Reverend Clementa Pinckney's seat. This used to be his congregation. But events on Wednesday night changed all that.
Visiting pastors addressed the regular congregation, who were joined by people of all ages and races, some from across the US.
"The freshness of death comes like a thief in the night," said one of the pastors. But it hasn't stolen the spirit of people here.
The service was uplifting and upbeat - worshippers including Charleston's mayor, and the Governor of South Carolina, Nikki Haley, leapt to their feet at several points, clapping and singing.
One of the songs during the service was Amazing Grace - something people here and across this city have shown in the past few days in remarkable acts of forgiveness and dignity.
Survivors say Mr Roof spent close to an hour in an evening bible study group on Wednesday before opening fire.
A group from the Emanuel AME church met again on Saturday in the room where their friends died on Wednesday.
One of those who attended, Harold Washington, said the cleaners had to cut bullet holes out of the walls so that members of the congregation would not see them on Sunday.
A number of rallies were also staged in South Carolina over the weekend, including a protest in the state capital of Columbia to demand the removal of the Confederate flag from the capitol building.
The flag was a symbol used by southern states in the civil war, when they tried to break away to prevent the abolition of slavery. It is viewed by many as a sign of the white supremacy.
Protesters chanted "take it down" and sang We Shall Overcome, an anthem of the black civil rights movement.
On Friday, South Carolina's Republican state representative Doug Brannon told MSNBC that he planned to introduce legislation to remove the flag.
On Saturday, images emerged on a website showing Dylann Roof posing with the Confederate flag. In others, he is seen burning the US flag and visiting a former slave plantation.
In one image, he is shown staring down the camera while sitting on a chair in camouflage trousers holding a gun.
It is unclear who posted the images on the site, which was found on Saturday.
The website - since taken down - also carried a 2,000-word racist manifesto, the origins of which are also unknown.
The author says Charleston was chosen for the attack because of its history of slavery and its large black population.
Internet records suggest the website's domain was registered in February but it is unclear who was behind it. The FBI says it is investigating the website.
Data from the images show many of them were taken in April and May this year.
The victims of the Charleston shooting


The Harbin International Ice and Snow Festival is in full flow in China and the Ice slide is a big hit with the visitors attracting long queues to have a go.

15 January 2015 Last updated at 14:23 GMT
In Harbin some of the world's most amazing ice sculptures go on display every year.
The festival started in 1963 and is the largest annual winter festival of its kind attracting hundreds of thousands of visitors.
Amongst the impressive ice sculptures, this year multicoloured ice slides have become a real hit with tourists.
Watch Hayley's report to see a slider's-eye view of the chilly fun!
Read more: Pictures: China's amazing ice festival


The Scottish government has introduced what it has described as a "historic bill" to create a sustainable future for Scotland's islands.

The proposed legislation aims to offer greater powers to island local authorities, including the Western Isles, Orkney and Shetland.
The bill includes giving island councils powers over activities on and around their coastlines.
Orkney Islands Council and Highland Council have welcomed the bill.
Orkney along with Western Isles Council - Comhairle nan Eilean Siar - and Shetland Islands Council have been campaigning for several years for greater powers.
The local authorities ramped up their Our Islands Our Future campaign in the run up to and after 2014's Scottish independence referendum.
The introduction of the bill marks the first stage in its progress through parliament.
Stage two would involve proposing and voting on any amendments before a third and final consideration stage.
Islands Minister Humza Yousaf said: "This government is committed to promoting islands' voices, to harnessing islands' resources and enhancing their well-being.
"The measures in this bill underpin this ambition.
"In particular, the provision to 'island-proof' decision-making across the public sector will ensure the interests of islanders are reflected in future legislation and policy from the very outset."
Mr Yousaf added: "The National Islands Plan will set out the strategic direction for supporting island communities, continuing the momentum generated by the Our Islands Our Future campaign and the work of the Islands Strategic Group.
"This is the first ever bill for Scotland's islands, marking an historic milestone for our island communities.
"I am proud and privileged as islands minister to be guiding the bill through Scotland's Parliament."
James Stockan, the leader of Orkney Islands Council, welcomed the publication of the bill, and applauded the efforts of the Our Island Our Future campaign.
He said: "But our work is not complete.
"We will be working tirelessly with Scottish government to ensure that there is an objective standard by which decisions over whether to conduct an Islands Communities Assessment are made and also how the legislation will be interpreted.
"The guidance to be issued by Scottish government will be central in determining how this will work in practice.
"We hope to have a meaningful role in the development of this guidance and will be working closely with the Minister for Transport and Islands Humza Yousaf through the Islands Strategic Group to achieve this."
Margaret Davidson, leader of Highland Council, said the introduction of the bill recognised "the importance of island communities" and the "valued contribution they make".
Highland Council has responsibility for public services on several islands, including the Isle of Skye.
Ms Davidson made her comment on the bill while on a visit to Eigg, where islanders are preparing to mark 20 years since a community buyout of the isle.
The council leader said: "I am particularly pleased that the Scottish government is seeking to make provision for the requirement to island-proof future legislation and policies.
"This is an important first step but it should not stop there. We also need rural proofing of government policies as many of our rural communities face the same issues that our islands face."
Roddie MacKay, leader of Comhairle nan Eilean Siar, said of the bill: "In practical terms, this will benefit our islands as we continue our case for flexibility and empowerment to develop our economies and support our communities and rich cultures.
"It is a significant step forward against depopulation, one of the greatest threats to our Island way of life."


Nigeria are risking a ban by Fifa after Chris Giwa failed to step down as president of the football federation by Monday's deadline.

A suspension could affect Nigeria's 2015 Africa Cup of Nations qualifiers against Congo on 6 September, and South Africa four days later.
Fifa has rejected the appointment of Giwa, which came at a controversial Nigerian Football Federation 'election' last week, which split the governing body.
Football's world governing body said it does not recognise the executives' election, but added it "it appears the ministry of sports has".
"Should there still be persons claiming to have been elected and occupying the NFF offices at midnight on Monday, 1 September 2014, we will bring the case to the appropriate Fifa body for sanctions, which may include the suspension of the NFF," said the Fifa statement on Friday.
Fifa accepted the decision of the majority congress, at which 39 of its 44 members resolved at an ad hoc general assembly, for executive committee elections in Nigeria to take place on 4 September.
The disputes within the NFF have already led to a Fifa intervention, international suspension and the enforced return - twice - of outgoing NFF president Aminu Maigari.
However Giwa, has played down the Fifa threat.
"We will present our position to Fifa by Monday morning and they will be convinced beyond any reasonable doubt that we adopted the correct statutes before organising the election," said Giwa.
"We call on Nigerians not to panic. The NFF is not intimidated and we do not expect any sanction because we have done the appropriate thing.
"There is absolutely nothing to fear. Fifa will receive the position of the Federation and will be convinced that elections have, indeed, taken place," Giwa added.
The crisis caused by the purported election has meant league matches will not be played across the country as scheduled this weekend after referees, club managers and players announced a boycott until the situation is resolved.
Football journalists in the country have called on Nigeria President Goodluck Jonathan to intervene.
On Friday, the country's National Assembly - comprised of the Senate and the House of Representatives - summoned all parties in the NFF to a meeting to resolve the crisis plaguing Nigerian football.
In addition to the deep divisions in the NFF, the Super Eagles are still without a permanent coach as Stephen Keshi's contract was not renewed after the World Cup.
He has agreed only to take temporary charge of the team for their two forthcoming Nations Cup qualifiers, having grown impatient with negotiations over a new deal.


A former children's home worker and Catholic priest has pleaded guilty to a string of historical child sex abuse charges.

Philip Temple, 66, admitted seven charges committed in the 1970s when he appeared at Woolwich Crown Court.
He pleaded to 20 similar charges and two of perjury at Croydon Crown Court in April.
In all, he admitted abusing 12 boys and one girl while working in south London care homes and a north London church.
He also admitted lying on oath in the 1990s when he was cleared of child sex abuse charges following accusations by a teenage boy from his church.
A spokesperson for the Catholic Church in England and Wales said that when concerns were raised it was limited in the measures it could take because as a monk he was answerable to the head of his order in Italy rather than the archdiocese here.
But the church said it believes he worked in Christ the King parish between 1999 and 2002 while the commission of inquiry was ongoing, meaning he would have had continued access to children.
The BBC has been told that in recent years Temple spent time at monasteries in Italy and France.
Raymond Stephenson of the Shirley Oaks Survivors Association said: "If Temple had been caught at Shirley Oaks he would not have been able to abuse anyone else."
The BBC is still awaiting comment from Lambeth Council which had responsibility for Shirley Oaks.
The BBC understands the Temple case will now be investigated by the Independent Inquiry into Child Sexual Abuse, currently without a chair after the resignation of Dame Lowell Goddard.


Fernando Alonso was fourth fastest in practice for the Indianapolis 500 as strong winds limited the number of laps done by drivers.

Alonso's best lap of 219.533mph was well down on the fastest of 222.894mph set by Ed Carpenter, but only 14 drivers of the 33-car field posted representative times.
"It was tricky, definitely," the two-time Formula 1 champion said.
"The conditions didn't help, but for me any condition is still a good lesson."
Strong winds can be a major hazard on an exposed superspeedway track, where average lap speeds are so high, as they significantly affect the car's stability in corners.
Alonso said: "Everything went according to plan. The team used those runs also to test something in the background on engine tuning, so it was a productive day."
The 35-year-old Spaniard is competing at Indy - and on an 'oval' track for the first time in his career - at the expense of the Monaco Grand Prix, as he bids to secure the next leg of the so-called 'triple crown'.
Only Graham Hill has so far managed to win Monaco, Indy and the Le Mans 24 Hours sportscar race.
Media playback is not supported on this device
His presence in the race is a major draw, in both the US and around the world, and Alonso joked that the attention on him was a bonus for the other drivers, with fans allowed close to the pits at Indianapolis.
"There is a lot of support here from the fans," he said. "They get very close to us here in the pit lane, in the garage.
"It seems that everywhere I go they follow me. I think some of the other drivers are taking advantage of that. They wait until I go, then they go without trouble.
"It's the way it is. I'm new here so they all need the autograph for the first time. I hope tomorrow they don't need it for the second time."
Alonso has to use the five days of practice this week to get into the best possible shape for qualifying on Saturday and Sunday at the Indianapolis Motor Speedway, which comprises just four left-hand turns but is an extreme challenge for drivers.
Alonso, who is driving a car branded for his McLaren F1 team, powered by Honda, which provides his engine in F1 and run by the Andretti Autosport team, said: "From the outside, compared to F1 circuits, this looks - it is - more simple. Only four corners.
"But the spread in terms of timed lap from first to last is just small details on the set-up of the car. Maybe you change a spring and you pick up 3-4mph and that makes three or four places.
"From the outside it seems too simple but what we are testing is just the fine-tuning on the set-up to gain milliseconds here and there."


A hotline is being launched to help combat the UK's £1.2bn food crime problem in the wake of the horse meat scandal.

Food crime is the deliberate manipulation, substitution, mislabelling or fraud in relation to food.
Food Standards Scotland (FSS) and Crimestoppers have created the free Scottish Food Crime Hotline.
People will be able to call in their suspicions anonymously.
The new service will aid the FSS's Scottish Food Crime and Incidents Unit, established following the 2013 discovery that horse meat was being passed off as beef in frozen foods.
The unit gathers intelligence, along with other agencies, to target food fraudsters who cost the UK food and drink industry an estimated £1.17bn annually.
Members of the public will also be able to report concerns using a non-traceable online form.
Geoff Ogle, FSS chief executive, said: "Consumers have a right to know that the food they are buying and eating is both safe and authentic. Food crime is damaging for the public and the industry, eroding trust and value.
"The launch of the free Scottish Food Crime Hotline is one of a number of steps FSS is taking to address the problem in Scotland.
"We hope it will raise awareness of the issue of food crime and give consumers a trusted point of contact to report concerns in complete anonymity.
"The intelligence we receive will be invaluable in advancing our work with Police Scotland and other agencies to hold to account those who put consumer safety at risk for financial gain."
Public health minister Aileen Campbell said: "Scotland is known the world over for the quality of its food and drink.
"This initiative is a practical and powerful way to tackle the problem of food crime. I would encourage both consumers and industry to make use of the hotline or online reporting form to anonymously share any concerns and help us stamp out fraudulent practices."
Director of policy and campaigns at the consumer group Which? Alex Neill said its research found food fraud ranging from fish and chip shops substituting whiting for haddock, to takeaways serving lamb dishes without any lamb.
She said: "The horsemeat scandal uncovered shocking failings with the authenticity of the food reaching our plates. We welcome the launch of this new food crime hotline which should help FSS gather intelligence about fraudulent practices and allow them to tackle these crimes head on so people can be more confident in the food they eat."
The new free hotline number - 0800 028 7926 - will be operational 24 hours a day, seven days a week.


A paedophile who abused his two great nephews has been jailed for six years.

The 69-year-old Belfast man had pleaded guilty to a total of 20 charges involving the sexual abuse of his two great nephews.
The court heard the offences occurred when the two brothers came to stay on weekend visits to his home.
The man, who cannot be named for legal reasons, was put on the Sex Offenders Register for life.
He was also told that when eventually freed, he would be subject to an extended eight-year period of supervised licence parole.
The court heard the abuse on the first boy began in 2005 and continued until 2011 when he was aged between nine and 14.
In 2007, the man then turned his attentions to the younger brother, who was nine. In this case, the abuse continued until the boy was 12.
A prosecution lawyer told the court that the man had committed previous sex offences in the late 1970s and early 1980s.
A defence lawyer said his client had asked him "to apologise to his victims for his abhorrent behaviour over the years".
The judge said it was significant that the man had a relevant criminal record, and had just been released from prison and completed his period under licence, when he began abusing again.


Tom Daley secured the third individual 10m European diving gold of his career with a stunning performance in London.

Media playback is not supported on this device
Daley, who won mixed 3m synchronised gold and men's 10m synchro silver earlier in the week, was in second after two of six rounds at the European Aquatics Championships.
However, he then powered past Russia's Viktor Minibaev, who won silver.
"Winning feels great, but I feel in the best place ever which is a huge boost ahead of Rio," he told BBC Sport.
Russia's Nikita Shleikher finished third, with Britain's Matty Lee scoring a career-best 465.10 to finish fifth in the 10m final.
British Diving's 11th medal soon followed, in what has become their best showing in the history of the championships.
Rebecca Gallantree and Alicia Blagg scored 319.32 to win silver in the synchronised 3m springboard event.
Italy took home gold with a score of 327.81, while Russia came third on 304.20.
"This is a brilliant result for us and makes up for missing out on an individual medal," Gallantree told BBC Sport.
Daley won individual European titles in 2008 and 2012 and just months after his last success went on to claim bronze at the London Olympics.
Commonwealth gold in 2014 and world bronze followed last year, but he has struggled with injuries this season.
"I've had a few niggles I've had to overcome so to deliver that score today feels amazing," he said, after winning with 570.50 points.
"A total like that is what you'll need for an Olympic medal so that's a great sign ahead of Rio and I just need to keep pushing from here."
British divers will next compete at the GB national championships in Sheffield, from 10-12 May.
Results there will help determine the final line-up of divers for the Team GB Rio Olympic squad.


Officers from Police Scotland join the international Running Man Challenge in front of Edinburgh Castle.

5 May 2016 Last updated at 11:01 BST
Five uniformed officers interrupt a lone piper on the castle esplanade - before breaking out their moves.
The original Running Man dance video was created by police in New Zealand as part of a publicity campaign to attract new recruits.
The New Zealand officers challenged The New York City Police Department to follow suit. They made their own video in front of the Brooklyn Bridge and passed the challenge on to Police Scotland.
Police Scotland have tagged the Metropolitan Police, officers in Toronto and their own police college recruits.


The administrators of HMV have said that 66 of the music and DVD retailer's stores will close over the next two months.

The affected stores employ 930 staff, Deloitte said. Last week, it was confirmed that about 190 jobs had been shed across HMV's head office and distribution network.
HMV entered administration in January.
It has faced intense competition from online retailers, digital downloads and supermarkets in recent years.
HMV currently operates from 220 stores in the UK.
Deloitte said no fixed date had been set for the closure of the 66 identified stores, which would continue to trade in the meantime.
"This step has been taken in order to enhance the prospects of securing the business' future as a going concern," Nick Edwards, joint administrator at Deloitte, said.
"We continue to receive strong support from staff and are extremely grateful to them for their commitment during an understandably difficult period.  All other key stakeholders remain very supportive and I continue to be hopeful of securing a future for the restructured business."
The stores earmarked for closure are:
The administrators have been in talks with restructuring specialist Hilco about taking over HMV.
Hilco, which already owns HMV Canada, has bought HMV's debt from its lenders, a move that could pave the way to taking full control of the company.


Air pollution is a "public health crisis" second only to smoking, according to Public Health Wales.

Air pollution contributes to 2,000 deaths in Wales each year - that's 6% of all deaths.
Research has found children who live on very polluted roads have slower lung development and can be more likely to cough and wheeze, while traffic pollution can also contribute to heart and lung problems in adults.
Those health problems are caused by tiny particles and a gas called nitrogen dioxide, both of which are by-products of the vehicles on our roads, and noise from traffic also plays a part.
In 2001, people were encouraged to buy diesel cars to reduce carbon dioxide levels but that has now led to an increase in nitrogen.
So, one answer is to reduce the number of diesel vehicles on the road - a solution that London mayor, Sadiq Khan, is keen on.
He has doubled spending on tackling air pollution to Â£875m. BBC Wales' Week In Week Out went to London to see whether any of the schemes there could work in Wales.
Khan has introduced an ultra low emission zone in the centre of London. It means all drivers will have to make sure their vehicles meet exhaust emission standards or pay a daily charge.
We asked Huw Morgan, chairman of the Welsh Pollution Expert Panel, whether that could work.
He said it may be time for Swansea to consider introducing diesel bans in the most polluted streets.
"I think we're at a time now where we've got to look at keeping diesels out of some very specific areas."
We also met his colleague Tom Price, from Swansea Council, who hopes a new public messaging system could help encourage drivers to take different routes at peak traffic times.
"We're developing a prediction system to enable drivers to be warned via messaging screens that there's poor air quality being predicted, or congestion in the traffic, and trying to educate drivers to change their route."
But isn't that tackling the symptoms rather than the cause of the problem?
"Yes, that's always a possibility and a likely occurrence. We work with our traffic colleagues to make sure we're not just shifting the problem somewhere else. There are other measures like increasing cycling routes and looking at the bus routes."
Electric cars and buses are another way to reduce emissions, so we took an electric car around 150 miles of south Wales roads.
It seemed to cope quite well with cities, but motorways and hills were more of a challenge and charging took a long time.
Huw Morgan told us Swansea council uses some electric vans too.
"They're fine for normal council, light van work, where you're doing journeys around half a mile to a mile and they charge up over lunch. They're good for short journeys - which are exactly what diesel vehicles are worst at.
"[Hills] are challenging for electric vehicles. Swansea, like many Welsh towns, is a hilly place. We have struggled here when we piloted electric buses."
We also struggled to find convenient places to charge the car and once we did find one, it took a long time. With only 80 miles on the clock before you have to charge, you would need to plan your journeys carefully.
London also has an Â£11m fund for five low emission neighbourhoods. Five of these zones will be set up across eight boroughs.
These areas will introduce measures such as penalties for the most polluting vehicles, car-free days and reserved parking for the cleanest vehicles.
The idea behind these is the most polluted neighbourhoods can pitch ideas that work for their local area. Proposals in Marylebone included better management of taxi ranks and an electric vehicle delivery scheme.
Westminster Councillor David Harvey said: "We hope in several years' time this entire area will have some of best measures to decrease air pollution. It's a pilot and we hope people borrow what works."
Andrew RT Davies, leader of the Welsh Conservatives, has called on First Minister Carwyn Jones to hold a multi-agency summit to tackle what he calls "Wales' air pollution crisis".
The Welsh government recently held a consultation on the way councils deal with air pollution hotspots and said it would publish its response soon.


Artwork from a tobacco firm, some showing people smoking and children handing out cigarettes, has raised more than Â£20,000 at auction.

The items were displayed as corporate art by Imperial Tobacco in Nottingham, but were never on public display.
The highest bid was Â£3,550 for a painting of a cricketer, used to promote cigarettes.
The 115 artefacts came up for sale following the closure of the firm's Horizon factory in 2016.
The oil and watercolour paintings depicting children playing with cigarettes and women gleefully smoking, were painted before awareness of smoking's health risks became more widespread in the 1950s.
The building, known as Players, after founder John Player, had the pictures displayed across five floors.
Imperial Tobacco, which had factory blocks in the Radford area of Nottingham, made more than one million cigarettes a day and employed up to 7,000 people at its height in the 1930s.
It was one of the biggest employers in the city for decades before the Horizon factory closure when about 500 people lost their jobs.
A spokesman for auctioneer John Pye & Son said: "Some of the bidders for the more iconic lots are located in Nottinghamshire so it's great to see that they're staying local.
"In the next couple of months we'll be holding another sale to auction off the plant & machinery and tooling from the site."


Reserved, thoughtful, dedicated, wise and humorous - the new US charge d'affaires in Havana, Jeffrey DeLaurentis, is all of the above, according to his former boss Vicki Huddleston.

And those will be much-needed assets in the coming months and years if the US and Cuba want to succeed in rebuilding diplomatic relationships, which have been broken for more than 50 years.
Jeffrey DeLaurentis was named head of mission in August last year. It is his third stint in Cuba.
He first served here as a consular officer between 1991 and 1992. He then returned as head of the political-economic section from 1999 to 2002.
"He knows Cuba, he can provide wise guidance to the state department and to the president, because he has a solid relationship with the Cubans," says Ms Huddleston, who was herself head of mission between 1999 and 2002.
"They know Jeff respects them and they trust him."
Mr DeLaurentis has focused on Latin America for much of his diplomatic career.
He worked at the US embassy in Bogota, at the United Nations in Geneva and in Washington where he spent time at the Bureau of Western Hemisphere Affairs and at the National Security Council.
It was at the National Security Council that Ted Piccone worked alongside him. He is now a fellow at the Brookings Institution in Washington.
"He's got just the right mix of experience that is needed in this case of a very historical special unique moment in US-Cuba relations," says Ted.
"Cuba has changed from his last posting so I think it's particularly useful to have someone who saw it previously and has a better context for the changes that have happened since then."
It is a view that Cubans share too.
"In Cuba we see him as a friend. As someone who hasn't come here to screw up the relationship," says former Cuban diplomat Carlos Alzugaray.
"I think Jeff is aware of what's happening in Cuba, he's sensitive to what might make a Cuban mad about US foreign policy. He can really understand us and you feel it."
Mr DeLaurentis has navigated difficult times while working in Cuba.
He first lived in Havana when the island was facing severe economic difficulties after the Soviet Union's collapse.
He also played a part in the story of Elian Gonzalez - the Cuban boy who in 1999 became a world-famous symbol of the bitter dispute between Cuba and the US when he was picked up in the Florida Straits.
He was one of three survivors from a group of people who had set off to reach the US in a handmade boat.
Taken to Florida, the US courts eventually got involved and ruled that he should be returned to Cuba and be reunited with his father. It was, for Cuba, a huge victory.
"We had to keep the Cubans on board with us," recalls Ms Huddleston.
"Jeff and I had to talk to Washington and tell them this was a serious moment, we have to handle it quietly and effectively and Jeff is a very effective diplomat."
As Jeffrey DeLaurentis forges a new diplomatic future, the building that will house the US embassy is living history of the turbulent relationship between Cuba and the US.
Sitting on Havana's Malecon or seafront promenade, it was the US embassy until diplomatic ties were cut in 1961. From 1977, it then became a US Interests Section under the legal protection of the Swiss government.
Across from the brown-glass building is what is known as the anti-imperialist stand, built in 2000.
It was here Cubans held an anti-American demonstration over the Elian Gonzalez case.
On the side are big letters that read "Fatherland or Death" and "Venceremos" - we will triumph, in the words of the Cuban revolution.
At the top of the plaza are around 140 flagpoles that obscure the view of the embassy building.
That of course was the intention when the US erected an electronic ticker that flashed human rights messages and criticism of the Cuban government.
Nobody wants a return to those combative times. And for the US and Cuba to triumph in the next few years, patience is what is needed, says Peter Hakim of the Inter-American Dialogue in Washington.
"I think the path now becomes deeper. I think that up until now Congress really didn't have much to do and say in this," says Hakim.
"The president wasn't violating or proposing changes to the laws. Now Congress has to be brought front and centre with the embargo and with Guantanamo eventually - they are two big steps."
But they are steps even Raul Castro has said will take determination. On both sides.


Sunderland defender Lamine Kone has signed a new five-year contract with the Premier League club.

The Ivory Coast international, 27, said he wanted to leave in August and was a target for Everton.
However, a move did not materialise for Kone, signed from French Ligue 1 club Lorient in January.
"Lamine is an important player for this club and I made that clear to him from the outset," said Sunderland manager David Moyes.
Kone was signed by Moyes' predecessor Sam Allardyce and played a key role in their survival in the top flight last season.
Moyes added: "He only been playing in the Premier League since January, but in that time we have already seen what he is capable of.
"The challenge for Lamine now is to build on what has been a very positive introduction to English football and to continue to improve and grow as a player."


The biggest fireball since the Chelyabinsk explosion has plunged through the atmosphere over the Atlantic Ocean.

The event, which has only just come to light, occurred off the coast of Brazil at 13:55 GMT on 6 February.
As it burned up, the space rock released the equivalent of 13,000 tonnes of TNT.
This makes it the most powerful event of its kind since an object exploded over Chelyabinsk in Russia in 2013.
That blast was much bigger, releasing the equivalent of 500,000 tonnes of TNT.
More than 1,000 people were injured in that incident on 15 February three years ago, most from flying glass from shattered windows.
But the fireball over the Atlantic probably went unnoticed; it burnt up about 30km above the ocean surface, 1,000km off the Brazilian coast.
Nasa listed the event on its Fireball and Bolide Reports web page.
Measurements suggest that about 30 small asteroids (between 1m and 20m in size) burn up in the Earth's atmosphere every year.
Because most of the Earth's surface is covered by water, most of these fall over the ocean and do not affect populated areas.
Follow Paul on Twitter.


When I heard about the move by Mark Zuckerberg and Priscilla Chan to give away $45bn worth of Facebook shares to good causes, my mind went back to 2008.

Facebook's founder, then 24, had come to London and gave an interview to the BBC.  I hit him with a number of sceptical questions about the social network's business model, suggested "you better start worrying about earning some money pretty fast", and then turned to the takeover offers made for Facebook the previous year. It was rumoured that Microsoft had offered $10bn - but Zuckerberg had rejected all these approaches. "That looks like a mistake now," I told him. Surprisingly, he did not agree and when I suggested he could have retired at 24 he simply said: "What would I do?"
At the time, this nerdy young man in jeans and sneakers did not look like a master business strategist or the leader of the most formidable company of the next 20 years. But that is what he has proved to be.
And his final answer in that interview, where he insists that he is motivated not by money but a desire to change the world,  rings true in the light of Zuckerberg and Chan's philanthropic announcement. Mind you, a read-through the letter to their daughter reveals that their charitable aims could align with Facebook's commercial strategy. It talks about the mission to "connect the world" - which must mean more people using Facebook. And surely participating "policy and advocacy to shape debates" is code for lobbying to get politicians to share Facebook's vision of our future.
Of course, if he had taken my advice, Mark Zuckerberg would have retired by now with a paltry couple of billion dollars, and Facebook would have merged with Yammer under Microsoft's ownership. Which goes to show why he's a visionary geniusâ€¦ and I'm not.


David Ball's double saw Shrewsbury drop back to the foot of the League One table as Fleetwood swept them aside at Highbury.

Shrewsbury frustrated the hosts in the opening stages, but Uwe Rosler's side finally found a way through in the 38th minute to continue their record of scoring in every league game.
Amari'i Bell fed Devante Cole on the left and he fizzed the ball across the six-yard box for Northern Ireland full-back Conor McLaughlin to fire home.
Bell was again influential as the hosts doubled their lead, pulling back for Ball to net his seventh of the season in the 53rd minute, after Shrewsbury had failed to fully clear
Ball was in the action 20 minutes later as the forward sublimely wrapped his right foot around the ball and curled it into the top corner from just outside the area.
The striker carved out a number of late opportunities but just missed out on completing his hat-trick as Fleetwood moved up to eighth and within a point of a play-off spot, while Chesterfield's win at MK Dons condemned Shrewsbury's return to bottom spot after consecutive losses.
Report supplied by Press Association.
Match ends, Fleetwood Town 3, Shrewsbury Town 0.
Second Half ends, Fleetwood Town 3, Shrewsbury Town 0.
Corner,  Fleetwood Town. Conceded by Junior Brown.
Ashley Hunter (Fleetwood Town) wins a free kick in the defensive half.
Foul by Junior Brown (Shrewsbury Town).
Attempt missed. Ashley Hunter (Fleetwood Town) left footed shot from the left side of the box is too high.
Attempt blocked. Ashley Hunter (Fleetwood Town) right footed shot from the centre of the box is blocked.
Attempt missed. Bobby Grant (Fleetwood Town) left footed shot from outside the box misses to the right.
Attempt missed. David Ball (Fleetwood Town) left footed shot from the centre of the box is close, but misses to the left.
Attempt missed. Victor Nirennold (Fleetwood Town) right footed shot from the centre of the box is high and wide to the right.
Attempt saved. Ashley Hunter (Fleetwood Town) right footed shot from the right side of the box is saved in the centre of the goal.
Substitution, Shrewsbury Town. Antoni Sarcevic replaces Jim O'Brien.
Jim O'Brien (Shrewsbury Town) is shown the yellow card.
Nathan Pond (Fleetwood Town) wins a free kick in the defensive half.
Foul by Jim O'Brien (Shrewsbury Town).
Substitution, Fleetwood Town. Jack Sowerby replaces Kyle Dempsey.
Substitution, Fleetwood Town. Victor Nirennold replaces George Glendon.
Foul by David Ball (Fleetwood Town).
Jack Grimmer (Shrewsbury Town) wins a free kick in the attacking half.
Corner,  Shrewsbury Town. Conceded by Nathan Pond.
Corner,  Shrewsbury Town. Conceded by Nathan Pond.
Foul by Ashley Eastham (Fleetwood Town).
Ivan Toney (Shrewsbury Town) wins a free kick in the defensive half.
Goal!  Fleetwood Town 3, Shrewsbury Town 0. David Ball (Fleetwood Town) right footed shot from outside the box to the top right corner. Assisted by Amari'i Bell.
Attempt missed. Ivan Toney (Shrewsbury Town) right footed shot from outside the box is high and wide to the left.
Substitution, Fleetwood Town. Ashley Hunter replaces Devante Cole.
Foul by Devante Cole (Fleetwood Town).
Gary Deegan (Shrewsbury Town) wins a free kick in the defensive half.
Substitution, Shrewsbury Town. George Waring replaces Ian Black because of an injury.
Delay in match Ian Black (Shrewsbury Town) because of an injury.
Foul by Bobby Grant (Fleetwood Town).
Ian Black (Shrewsbury Town) wins a free kick on the right wing.
Foul by David Ball (Fleetwood Town).
Gary Deegan (Shrewsbury Town) wins a free kick in the attacking half.
Foul by Bobby Grant (Fleetwood Town).
Ian Black (Shrewsbury Town) wins a free kick in the attacking half.
Delay in match Ian Black (Shrewsbury Town) because of an injury.
Attempt missed. Devante Cole (Fleetwood Town) right footed shot from a difficult angle on the right is high and wide to the right.
Corner,  Fleetwood Town. Conceded by Gary Deegan.
Devante Cole (Fleetwood Town) wins a free kick in the attacking half.


The International Criminal Court (ICC) has given prosecutors a one-week deadline to bring evidence against Kenya's president or to drop charges.

Further delays in President Uhuru Kenyatta's case would be "contrary to the interests of justice", it ruled.
Mr Kenyatta was the first head of state to appear before the court since he was formally charged in 2012 with crimes against humanity, which he denies.
The prosecution has repeatedly asked for more time to build its case.
It says witnesses have been bribed and intimidated, and the Kenyan government has refused to hand over documents vital to the case.
Mr Kenyatta denies inciting violence following the disputed 2007 elections in order to secure victory for then-President Mwai Kibaki and says the ICC case is political.
Rejecting the prosecution's latest request for a delay, the court's judges said it needed to indicate within a week whether it would withdraw charges or that the "evidentiary basis has improved to a degree which would justify proceeding to trial".
Mr Kenyatta won presidential elections in 2013, with the backing of Mr Kibaki.
He used the case against him to rally nationalist support by accusing The Hague-based court of meddling in Kenya's affairs.
He is accused by the ICC prosecution of being "an indirect co-perpetrator" in the post-poll ethnic massacres of 2007/2008.
Some 1,200 people were killed in the violence and 600,000 were displaced.
Mr Kenyatta's deputy William Ruto is on trial at the court on similar charges after his legal team's efforts to throw out the case failed.
He and Mr Kenyatta were in opposite camps during the 2007 election, with Mr Ruto accused of fuelling violence to bolster opposition leader Raila Odinga's chances of becoming president. He denies the charges.
Mr Ruto formed an alliance with Mr Kenyatta in the 2013 election, opening the way for him to become deputy president.
The court's decision to charge Mr Kenyatta caused international controversy, with the African Union (AU) accusing it of "hunting" Africans because of their race.
The prosecution denied the allegation, saying it pursued justice impartially.


A rise in visitors to Grayson Perry's Essex "dream house" has led to one villager creating a home-made sign to warn about traffic congestion.

The artist designed the house overlooking the Stour estuary at Wrabness and it featured in a Channel 4 programme last week.
Visitors have been driving down the narrow track leading to the house - causing problems for neighbours.
Tony Elliston has made a sign asking people to park at the railway station.
Carlo Guglielmi, Essex county councillor for Tendring Rural West, praised Mr Elliston for "taking the initiative" but added official signs were on their way.
Perry's conceptual holiday home has been built by Fat Architects at the end of a single-vehicle road called Black Boy Lane.
The artist, from Chelmsford, designed the building in homage to "single mums in Dagenham, hairdressers in Colchester and the landscape and history of Essex".
Mr Elliston, who manages Wrabness's community shop and cafe, said there had been a "noticeable rise" in visitors since the Grayson Perry's Dream House television programme.
"I think most people in the village like Grayson's house and we're more than happy to welcome visitors," he said.
"But the narrow track has no turning circle, so neighbours are getting frustrated about people using their driveways and there's congestion when cars are coming from both directions."
Essex Highways agreed to carry out works to relieve the situation in February.
Mr Guglielmi said the council had waited until resurfacing work on the village ring road was completed in the first week of May before putting in signs.
"We do accept clearer signs are needed and a whole lot of signs have been agreed - so I will be chasing the firm appointed by the council to find out when they're due," he said.


Health Secretary Jeremy Hunt has been warned by the UK's statistics watchdog over claims he made about accident and emergency waiting times in England.

Sir Andrew Dilnot said Mr Hunt was wrong to claim in the Commons that median waiting times to be seen in A&E departments had halved since 2010.
He said the health secretary "may wish to take advice on whether he should correct the parliamentary record".
Labour said that Mr Hunt had been "found out making dodgy claims".
But a government spokesperson said it had "simply been a slip of the tongue on Mr Hunt's part and that the numbers used by him and the prime minister were accurate".
The Conservatives and Labour have been involved in an increasingly rancorous fight about each other's records on the NHS in recent months, with David Cameron and Ed Miliband clashing on the issue on several occasions at Prime Minister's Questions.
Sir Andrew, chair of the UK Statistics Authority, has now responded to a Labour complaint about the use of statistics by the prime minister and Mr Hunt on accident and emergency waiting times in England.
Mr Cameron told the Commons on 2 July that the average wait for an A&E assessment had more than halved from 77 minutes under the Labour government to only 30 minutes under the coalition.
A week later, Mr Hunt repeated the same statistic but specifically referred to a "median wait".
Sir Andrew did not criticise the prime minister but said the health secretary should have used the term "mean" instead of "median".
He said the statistics showed that the mean time elapsing before patients were assessed was 30 minutes in 2012-13, down from 77 minutes in 2009-10. On the other hand, the median wait for assessment fell from nine minutes to eight minutes over the same period.
The mean is calculated by adding up all the numbers and dividing by the number of numbers. The median is the number for which half the numbers are above and half below.
Analysis by Health Editor Hugh Pym
The debate over waiting times in accident & emergency units in England is already highly charged - and it will be even more so as the election approaches.
That's why a rather dry looking letter from the statistics watchdog Sir Andrew Dilnot has some significance.
In essence, he is saying the Health Secretary Jeremy Hunt was wrong to tell the Commons that "median" waiting times to be assessed had fallen under this government from 77 minutes to 30.
What he meant was that the "mean" had come down over that time.
As it turned out the median - seen by some statisticians as more relevant when dealing with data which includes some extreme values - had only come down from nine minutes to eight.
Sir Andrew, in effect, dismisses the relevance of "time to assessment" in A&E - a benchmark used by both the Prime Minister and Mr Hunt.
He says that the "most complete" account of waiting times is time to departure rather than first assessment.
On that basis median waits are up from 122 minutes to 128.  If all this sounds technical, it is.
But it adds important detail to an intensifying debate.
In a letter to shadow health secretary Andy Burnham, circulated to Mr Hunt and Mr Cameron, Sir Andrew said data on A&E waiting times data was "complex", with both the median and mean figures being referred to in official statistics.
But he added: "Statistics are often described in abbreviated terms, particularly during public debate, and caveats are not always repeated or indeed possible.
"However, it is important for statistics to be described carefully.
"Where possible, time periods should be specified, the source data should be identified, and particular care should be taken if the mean and median are substantively different."
But Mr Burnham said it was not the first time that ministers had been "found out making dodgy claims about the NHS" in Parliament.
"Sir Andrew Dilnot confirms that waiting times in A&E have got worse on this government's watch," he claimed.
"But his analysis concludes that things are even worse than we thought, with hospital A&Es missing the government's lowered target in every quarter for almost two years.
"This is a damning verdict on David Cameron's and Jeremy Hunt's mismanagement of the NHS and their desperate attempts to paper over the cracks.
"The gap between their spin and the reality for patients is becoming dangerous."


Fans of the Loch Ness Monster will be able to explore its "habitat" using Google Street View.

The US technology company has uploaded visuals taken on and beneath the loch's surface to its Street View website.
When searching the loch, users of the site will find Google's yellow Pegman icon changes to a Nessie "peg-monster".
The Loch Ness Street View has been launched on the same date a faked photograph of the monster was published in a newspaper in 1934.
Highly respected British surgeon, Col Robert Wilson, claimed he took his photograph days earlier while driving along the northern shore of Loch Ness.
It was later revealed to be a toy submarine outfitted with a sea-serpent head.
Google has also sought to draw attention to the project with a Nessie-themed Google Doodle on its search page.
Loch Ness expert Adrian Shine spent a number of days with the Google Street View and Catlin Seaview Survey teams as they performed an operation to photograph above and below the waters.
Mr Shine said the project was "cloaked in secrecy", adding: "When people asked about the ripples in the Loch during the special diving expeditions for once I had no opinion.
"I'm so proud to have been part of this initiative and I hope people worldwide enjoy exploring Street View to have a look and then be inspired to travel to Scotland to discover this area of magical beauty and natural intrigue. "


Military action could still be used to prevent Iran developing a nuclear bomb, despite the agreement struck this week, the US defence secretary has said.

Ashton Carter made the comments en route to Israel, the first leg of a tour of the Middle East.
He is seeking to ease concerns of a key ally who has been one of the most vocal critics of the nuclear deal.
But Mr Carter admitted he was "not going to change anybody's mind in Israel".
Instead, he sought to stress that the US' willingness to protect Israel was undiminished.
"One of the reasons why this deal is a good one is that it does nothing to prevent the military option," Mr Carter told reporters.
"This is a good deal," he added. "It removes a critical element of danger, threat and uncertainty from the region."
Under the deal between Iran and six world powers, Iran must curb its nuclear programme in exchange for sanctions relief.
The Israeli Prime Minister, Benjamin Netanyahu, called the agreement an "historic mistake" that clears the way for Iran to make nuclear weapons.
In an interview on Sunday, Mr Netanyahu dismissed suggestions that the US could boost military aid to Israel following the accord, saying that would imply it agreed with the deal.
"I guess the question you have to ask yourself is, if this deal is supposed to make Israel and our Arab neighbours safer, why should we be compensated with anything?'' he told ABC.
Mr Carter arrived in Tel Aviv on Sunday. He is due to meet his Israeli counterpart Moshe Yaalon on Monday before holding talks with Mr Netanyahu on Tuesday.
He will then travel to Saudi Arabia,  Iran's main regional rival, and then on to Jordan, for talks on tackling the Islamic State militant group.


Eyewitnesses have described the scene as a vintage jet crashed while performing at an air show in West Sussex.

Vivien Ayling was driving to work along the A27 when she says the jet crashed on the road beside her. She told BBC Radio 5 Live: "I saw this plane coming towards me and I thought 'Gosh, he's really low, is that allowed?'
"And then all of a sudden he got lower and I thought 'He's going to come straight into me' and then he veered off to my right and he just smacked straight on to the opposite carriageway to me, and then there was this massive great fireball and smoke went up."
The aftermath was "like a bomb exploding", she said, adding: "I decided to drive on through it - it fortunately went over my head.
"I stopped, looked back and thought there's going to be another explosion with all this aviation fuel around so I thought what do I do? So I thought best get out of there.
"You don't know what you'd do in that situation. I did what I felt was right in a split second."
She believes pilot Andy Hill was trying to avoid the road: "He obviously was trying to get to the field rather to land on them, on the road. That's probably why he veered off and didn't end up in my carriageway."
Dave Hampton was at the air show with his family.
"We were behind the marquee at the time, having a picnic and we had literally turned up 10 minutes before," he said.
"We saw the Hawker Hunter fly over the marquee, we saw it fly up, then we saw it almost turn around to come back.
"Our two boys who are very passionate about planes asked where the plane was and we said it would be along in a minute when we heard what sounded like a sonic boom - it sounded like the plane had broken the sound barrier.
"People around us then started standing up and saying 'Oh my God, it's come down' and at that time we looked over and we saw the big plume of smoke coming over the marquee."
Gairo Gomez, who works at the nearby Ricardo Technological Centre, said the whole building shook.
"I saw the plane going down. I heard a huge bang and the glass was shaking and the doors were banging, the whole building was shaking.
"I saw some smoke later on, but at the time I didn't realise what had happened."
Archie Tipple was a spectator at the event.
"We were stood on a footbridge by the Red Lion Inn, about 300m from the A27.
"I was photographing the aircraft as it started its display and as it climbed and climbed and climbed I thought, this is pretty good.
"But he was coming in a little bit low and I was still photographing it as it came down and then all of a sudden you just knew what was coming.
"It just immediately changed the atmosphere, from a festive one to something quite sombre," he said.
Nicholas Hair described the aftermath at the airfield.
"Strangely enough the first thing that happened was silence.
"I've never seen so many grown men cry in my life. But people of all ages and genders were crying, screaming and then again just silence that just stayed over the field for 10, 15, 20 minutes."
'
Jane Groves, from Shoreham, witnessed the plane crashing after her car broke down on the A27.
"My husband and I had stopped between the slip roads going to and from Shoreham. We got out, put on the hazards and phoned Green Flag.
"We were 400 yards from where the plane crashed. The passing cars were going so slow in the traffic and people were asking us if we needed water, feeling sorry for us - they had no idea what they were driving into.
"I saw a wedding car and thought to myself 'He is having a bad day, I hope he gets to the bride on time' and then five minutes later, I watched the plane crash into the traffic.
"We stood in the road diverting the traffic down the slip road until the emergency services came. If it wasn't for that, the ambulances wouldn't have been able to get through.
"This will stay with me forever."
Ailish Southall was driving along the A27 with her two children when the plane crashed close to them.
"There were huge amounts of fire and we ran from the car to kind of avoid the debris."
Lee Allwright, who was also close, said:  "It was extremely hot. You could hear the plane as it took out the traffic lights on the road.  You could hear the scraping.
"People didn't know what to do."
Ian Whitney was standing on the grass verge opposite to where the plane crashed.
"We saw the whole thing. We were watching it as the plane looped and I said 'he isn't going to make that!' It just plunged straight into the cars.
"There was the most awful thud followed by a ball of flame coming down the road at us. We had to run to avoid the debris and the intense heat.
"Everyone ran in different directions. Then there was an eerie silence of disbelief, before lots of people started crying."
Matt England from the South East Coast Ambulance Service was at the crash scene.
"We had obviously a very challenging scene over roughly a kilometre to deal with and we sent six ambulances, a hazardous area response team, two other response cars, four officers and two aircraft from our air ambulance charity to the incident," he said.
"We did take one person who was very severely injured to the Royal Sussex County Hospital by air ambulance straight away and then the lesser injured were dealt with at the scene initially and then taken to other hospitals."


The head of the French armed forces has quit after a clash with President Emmanuel Macron over budget cuts.

Gen Pierre de Villiers said in a statement he could no longer "guarantee the durability of the army model" that he considered necessary to ensure France's protection.
France's government last week revealed major cuts to bring its budget deficit below the level of an EU cap.
Mr Macron had said he would not tolerate dissent from the military.
In a speech at the defence ministry last week, he said: "It is not dignified to hold certain debates in the public arena."
Then in an interview with Le Journal du Dimanche, he said: "If the military chief of staff and the president are opposed on something, the military chief of staff goes."
But he had also said the general had his "full trust" as long as he "knows the chain of command and how it works".
The pair had been scheduled to meet on Friday to try to sort out their differences.
Gen de Villiers' replacement will be named on Wednesday, French media said.
He will be Gen François Lecointre, Agence France-Presse reported, citing government sources.
Gen de Villiers, 60, was infuriated by an €850m ($975m; £752m) cut in the military spending budget for 2017. Most was to come from cuts to equipment.
France cuts billions from public purse
Macronomy: What are Emmanuel Macron's economic plans?
France: The economic challenge
Gen de Villiers told a parliamentary committee last week that the government should not mess with him on the matter, using a far stronger expletive.
The general, who was appointed head of the military in February 2014 and had his tenure extended by Mr Macron in June, had previously spoken out on budget cuts.
Hugh Schofield, BBC News, Paris
There are plenty of tributes being paid to the just-resigned chief of general staff Pierre de Villiers. Plenty of important people seem to be taking his side in the affair. Not many are speaking up for the president.
One reason is that Emmanuel Macron had initially raised such hopes among the military. He promised a big increase in the defence budget over the next eight years. When his first act was to cut €850m for many - not just in the armed forces  - that felt like a betrayal.
But it is also his method. When Gen de Villiers criticised the cut last week, it was at a meeting with deputies that was supposed to be off the record. His words were leaked, through no fault of his own. But the next day President Macron publicly upbraided him for speaking out of turn.  And that felt like a humiliation.
Shortly after he took up his role he had threatened to walk out over cuts that were later shelved.
As he announced his resignation on Wednesday, he said he believed it was his duty to tell politicians of his "reservations".
Former chief of the French armed forces Henri Bentégeat told Le Monde that the president had the right to impose his authority, but added: "The way he did it will leave marks. You can't publicly question a military leader like that in front of his subordinates."
Mr Macron was elected president in May, defeating the far-right candidate Marine Le Pen.
President Macron wants to get the overall French budget deficit below a European Union cap of 3% of national income for 2017.
As part of that effort, the government has earmarked €850m in savings in military spending for the year. New equipment orders will be delayed or cancelled and the defence ministry is also being asked to take on the €1.3bn cost of foreign operations.
However, Mr Macron has also said he wants to raise defence spending in 2018 by €1.5bn to €34.2bn.
Furthermore, he has pledged to lift the defence budget from 1.77% of GDP to Nato's target of 2% by 2025. That would mean a sum of €50bn - at least a further €2bn each year, unprecedented in France.
It is unclear how these pledges played into Gen de Villiers' thinking, although he told MPs last week: "I know when I am being had."


Brighton returned to the top of the Championship as Sam Baldock's two goals gave them victory at Barnsley in Chris Hughton's 100th league game in charge.

Striker Baldock struck a superb half-volley over Tykes goalkeeper Adam Davies early in the second half before slotting home Anthony Knockaert's pass.
Barnsley had strong penalty appeals waved away in the first half when Lewis Dunk appeared to handle the ball.
Marley Watkins also saw two shots saved and Adam Hammill blazed over.
Hughton called for Albion to maintain their composure after just three wins in seven games and got a fine response from his side, who moved above Newcastle and seven points clear of Huddersfield in third.
The 58-year-old, who has won exactly half of his 100 league matches since taking over in December 2014, now faces tricky back-to-back home tests against fourth-placed Reading and Newcastle.
It was a clinical performance from Brighton and Baldock but they also had goalkeeper David Stockdale to thank for their 16th clean sheet of the campaign.
His brilliant one-handed save kept Watkins' low strike out midway through the first half before blocking the winger's close-range effort to keep the score at 2-0.
Barnsley are nine points off the play-offs following sixth-placed Sheffield Wednesday's 2-1 victory at Nottingham Forest.
Barnsley manager Paul Heckingbottom:
"I thought it was an even game throughout but they were clinical at one end and gave us nothing at the other end.
"First half we did great, but didn't score when we were on top. As well as we may have been playing, they still limited us to very few chances. They're comfortable without the ball as well as with it."
Brighton manager Chris Hughton:
"I thought the front two were excellent, they worked really hard. I just thought it was a really good, all-round team performance.
"I think for us that have been in the game a long time, we know that things can be so different come the next game. We don't get much time to enjoy it, we're back in on Monday, but it's a really pleasing result."
Match ends, Barnsley 0, Brighton and Hove Albion 2.
Second Half ends, Barnsley 0, Brighton and Hove Albion 2.
Substitution, Brighton and Hove Albion. Fikayo Tomori replaces Anthony Knockaert.
Corner,  Barnsley. Conceded by Steve Sidwell.
Substitution, Brighton and Hove Albion. Chuba Akpom replaces Glenn Murray.
Attempt missed. Adam Hammill (Barnsley) left footed shot from outside the box is just a bit too high. Assisted by Gethin Jones.
Attempt missed. Dale Stephens (Brighton and Hove Albion) right footed shot from outside the box misses to the left. Assisted by Anthony Knockaert.
Attempt missed. Adam Armstrong (Barnsley) left footed shot from outside the box misses to the right. Assisted by Matthew James.
Substitution, Barnsley. Alex Mowatt replaces George Moncur.
Substitution, Barnsley. Ryan Williams replaces Ryan Kent.
Attempt missed. Anthony Knockaert (Brighton and Hove Albion) right footed shot from the centre of the box is just a bit too high. Assisted by Glenn Murray.
Hand ball by Matthew James (Barnsley).
Corner,  Barnsley. Conceded by Bruno.
Attempt blocked. Andy Yiadom (Barnsley) left footed shot from the left side of the six yard box is blocked.
Attempt saved. Marley Watkins (Barnsley) right footed shot from the centre of the box is saved in the bottom left corner. Assisted by Adam Hammill.
Attempt saved. Marley Watkins (Barnsley) header from the centre of the box is saved in the bottom left corner. Assisted by Adam Hammill with a cross.
Hand ball by Anthony Knockaert (Brighton and Hove Albion).
Andy Yiadom (Barnsley) wins a free kick in the attacking half.
Foul by Glenn Murray (Brighton and Hove Albion).
Attempt missed. Jamie Murphy (Brighton and Hove Albion) right footed shot from the centre of the box misses to the left. Assisted by Sam Baldock.
George Moncur (Barnsley) wins a free kick in the attacking half.
Foul by Glenn Murray (Brighton and Hove Albion).
Foul by Marley Watkins (Barnsley).
Bruno (Brighton and Hove Albion) wins a free kick in the defensive half.
Goal!  Barnsley 0, Brighton and Hove Albion 2. Sam Baldock (Brighton and Hove Albion) left footed shot from very close range to the centre of the goal. Assisted by Anthony Knockaert.
Foul by Adam Hammill (Barnsley).
Glenn Murray (Brighton and Hove Albion) wins a free kick on the right wing.
Attempt saved. Adam Hammill (Barnsley) right footed shot from outside the box is saved in the centre of the goal. Assisted by Matthew James.
Offside, Brighton and Hove Albion. Anthony Knockaert tries a through ball, but Lewis Dunk is caught offside.
Hand ball by George Moncur (Barnsley).
Attempt missed. Adam Hammill (Barnsley) right footed shot from the centre of the box is too high. Assisted by Ryan Kent.
Attempt saved. Anthony Knockaert (Brighton and Hove Albion) left footed shot from the right side of the box is saved in the centre of the goal. Assisted by Dale Stephens.
Substitution, Barnsley. Adam Hammill replaces Tom Bradshaw.
Offside, Brighton and Hove Albion. David Stockdale tries a through ball, but Sam Baldock is caught offside.
Dale Stephens (Brighton and Hove Albion) wins a free kick in the defensive half.
Foul by Tom Bradshaw (Barnsley).
Attempt missed. Lewis Dunk (Brighton and Hove Albion) header from the left side of the six yard box misses to the left. Assisted by Anthony Knockaert with a cross following a corner.
Corner,  Brighton and Hove Albion. Conceded by Angus MacDonald.
Foul by Dale Stephens (Brighton and Hove Albion).
Tom Bradshaw (Barnsley) wins a free kick on the left wing.


Welsh Liberal Democrat Mark Williams is the only one of the party's eight MPs to be left out of a 'cabinet' named by new leader Tim Farron.

Kirsty Williams, Lib Dem leader in the assembly, will be spokeswoman for Wales, succeeding Roger Williams, who lost his seat at the general election.
Ex-Wales Office minister Baroness Randerson will speak on transport.
Mr Farron's office said Mark Williams, MP for Ceredigion, would be given "a key campaign job" in August.
The new leader said his "excellent" team would lead the "Lib Dem fight back".
Six of its 22 members are not MPs or peers.
Mark Williams, who is now the Lib Dems' only MP in Wales, had backed Mr Farron over rival Norman Lamb in the battle to succeed Nick Clegg.


Plymouth Argyle have agreed a deal to share Torquay United's Seale Hayne training ground in Newton Abbot.

Argyle's Under 18s team and their side in the South West Peninsula League will play their home games at the facility.
The club's youth team will also train there after a two-year deal was agreed.
"We are delighted to have finalised matters with Torquay United and both parties very much look forward to our joint venture," said Argyle chief executive Martyn Starnes.
Torquay have been looking for extra ways to increase their income after a takeover was completed by a consortium of local businessmen last month.
As part of cost-cutting measures, the Gulls closed their academy so had surplus space at Seale Hayne.
"In an ideal world, all our teams would train and play in and around Plymouth - the city they represent. That is our long-term ambition," Starnes added.
"Frustratingly, at the moment, this is not feasible; there is a dearth of facilities in and around Plymouth and we have experienced real problems trying to find training pitches to the standard our academy needs to help them develop our young players."


Tesla, the maker of electric cars, saw a rise in orders during the third quarter helped by sales of the company's new Model X SUV.

Tesla had a 50% rise in orders compared with the same period last year.
However higher costs hurt profits. Tesla's profits were $231m (Â£149m) in the period between July and September compared with $251m in 2014.
The company also announced it would release its Model 3 car, a mass market vehicle, at the end of March 2016.
The company expects to sell the Model 3 for $35,000.
Tesla opened two new stores in China this quarter and said it planned to open more as sales in the country grow.
Telsa reported it delivered 11,603 vehicles in the third quarter, slightly more than 11,580 it expected.
Shares of the company were up 7.5% in after-hours trading.


A fundraising appeal for the family of a Teesside toddler who choked on a grape has reached more than £16,000.

Jacob Jenkins stopped breathing after swallowing the fruit at Pizza Hut in Hartlepool on 9 October.
The two-year-old was taken to hospital and put into an induced coma, but his parents Abigail Wilson and David Jenkins chose to turn off his life support on Wednesday.
Well wishers have so far donated more than £16,160 to help the family.
A statement on the Go Fund Me page said: "This fund will now go towards Jacob's funeral costs and gives the parents a bit of space to not have to worry about going back to work for the foreseeable future."
Pizza Hut said was  firm was "devastated to learn of Jacob's tragic death" and had taken grapes off its menu "with immediate effect".


New head coach Pierre de Bruyn expects Leicestershire to challenge on all fronts in 2017 and is excited by their "explosiveness" in white-ball cricket.

South African De Bruyn, 40, has replaced Andrew McDonald and is confident he can build on the Australian's success.
McDonald transformed a team who had not won a Championship match for two years into promotion challengers.
De Bruyn said the top four was the minimum aim in red-ball cricket.
"If you end up in the top four in September then you have a very good chance of promotion, when you can really turn the heat up," he added.
Media playback is not supported on this device
"In white-ball cricket, if you look at that T20 unit there is no reason why we cannot be at Finals Day.
"We have a fantastic signing in Luke Ronchi and the explosiveness and skill levels we have in the squad is phenomenal. We can definitely raise the bar.
"And in 50-over cricket we need to back our gameplan and we need to understand that it is a format that is much longer than you think and we need to be very clever.
"I break all the formats up into what will be a good season, but ultimately we need to have a much better season than previously."
Leicestershire begin their season with a home County Championship match against Nottinghamshire, which begins on Friday.