Hartlepool were denied victory by one of their own as Yeovil earned a draw against Dave Jones' side.

Glovers midfielder Matty Dolan was born in Hartlepool and has spent two loan spells at the club.
But, presented with a second-half penalty to level the scores, he made no mistake, sending keeper Adam Bartlett the wrong way from 12 yards on 69 minutes.
The penalty came after Andrew Nelson, making his Pools debut after signing from Sunderland on loan, needlessly felled Francois Zoko in the area.
Hartlepool also gave a debut to Louis Rooney, signed from Plymouth, and he was lively up front, sending Padraig Amond clear early on to lob just over.
Rooney then skirted around keeper Artur Krysiak, but his angled finish was blocked by covering defender Darren Ward.
Pools took the lead on 64 minutes when Nelson's deep cross picked out Amond and he looped home a header from 16 yards for his 11th of the season.
After Dolan's leveller, he almost won it with a curling free-kick from 22 yards which Bartlett dived full-stretch to keep out.
Report supplied by the Press Association
Match ends, Hartlepool United 1, Yeovil Town 1.
Second Half ends, Hartlepool United 1, Yeovil Town 1.
Attempt missed. Nathan Thomas (Hartlepool United) right footed shot from outside the box misses to the left.
Foul by Ben Whitfield (Yeovil Town).
Andrew Nelson (Hartlepool United) wins a free kick on the left wing.
Andrew Nelson (Hartlepool United) is shown the yellow card for a bad foul.
Ryan Dickson (Yeovil Town) wins a free kick in the defensive half.
Foul by Andrew Nelson (Hartlepool United).
Omar Sowunmi (Yeovil Town) wins a free kick in the attacking half.
Foul by Matthew Bates (Hartlepool United).
Attempt blocked. Francois Zoko (Yeovil Town) right footed shot from outside the box is blocked.
Foul by Louis Rooney (Hartlepool United).
Liam Shephard (Yeovil Town) wins a free kick on the left wing.
Corner,  Yeovil Town. Conceded by Adam Bartlett.
Attempt saved. Matthew Dolan (Yeovil Town) left footed shot from outside the box is saved in the top right corner.
Foul by Nicky Featherstone (Hartlepool United).
Matthew Dolan (Yeovil Town) wins a free kick in the defensive half.
Substitution, Yeovil Town. Owain Jones replaces Jean-Louis Akpa-Akpro.
Attempt missed. Louis Rooney (Hartlepool United) left footed shot from the centre of the box is close, but misses to the right.
Foul by Nathan Smith (Yeovil Town).
Nathan Thomas (Hartlepool United) wins a free kick in the attacking half.
Substitution, Hartlepool United. Nathan Thomas replaces Lewis Alessandra.
Goal!  Hartlepool United 1, Yeovil Town 1. Matthew Dolan (Yeovil Town) converts the penalty with a left footed shot to the bottom left corner.
Penalty Yeovil Town. Francois Zoko draws a foul in the penalty area.
Penalty conceded by Andrew Nelson (Hartlepool United) after a foul in the penalty area.
Hand ball by Omar Sowunmi (Yeovil Town).
Substitution, Yeovil Town. Omar Sowunmi replaces Tom Eaves.
Goal!  Hartlepool United 1, Yeovil Town 0. Padraig Amond (Hartlepool United) header from the centre of the box to the top right corner. Assisted by Andrew Nelson.
Attempt missed. Tom Eaves (Yeovil Town) right footed shot from outside the box misses to the left.
Attempt saved. Matt Butcher (Yeovil Town) right footed shot from outside the box is saved in the centre of the goal.
Corner,  Yeovil Town. Conceded by Matthew Bates.
Attempt blocked. Francois Zoko (Yeovil Town) right footed shot from outside the box is blocked.
Attempt blocked. Louis Rooney (Hartlepool United) right footed shot from the centre of the box is blocked.
Attempt missed. Liam Donnelly (Hartlepool United) header from the centre of the box is just a bit too high following a corner.
Corner,  Hartlepool United. Conceded by Ryan Dickson.
Attempt blocked. Louis Rooney (Hartlepool United) right footed shot from a difficult angle on the right is blocked.
Corner,  Hartlepool United. Conceded by Artur Krysiak.
Attempt saved. Padraig Amond (Hartlepool United) right footed shot from the right side of the box is saved in the centre of the goal.
Hand ball by Ben Whitfield (Yeovil Town).
Second Half begins Hartlepool United 0, Yeovil Town 0.


Ethiopia says that only a fraction of its citizens working illegally in Saudi Arabia have returned home before today's amnesty deadline.

In March, the Gulf state said that those without papers would not be arrested if they left within 90 days.
The deadline was extended by another month, but so far only 60,000 out of an estimated 400,000 Ethiopians have left, the Ethiopian government says.
Ethiopians make up a large portion of the kingdom's undocumented workers.
All those without papers now face imprisonment or forced deportation.
Africa Live: Updates on this and other stories
Ethiopia's Communications Minister Negeri Lencho told the BBC he feared what could now happen to his compatriots who were still in Saudi Arabia, adding they must return "with a sense of urgency".
"They will be imprisoned and we don't want our citizens to face unnecessary imprisonment, or suffer any physical harm or humiliation," Mr Lencho said.
One of those who returned is 28-year-old domestic worker Nura Ahmed. "Life was really tough," she told the BBC's Emmanuel Igunza just after she arrived in the Ethiopian capital, Addis Ababa.
"Sometimes I was jobless because I did not have the proper documentation, so I had no freedom to move around.
"One can never be at peace there," she added.
In 2013, a number of Ethiopians died in clashes with Saudi police as they were being rounded up for deportation.
Saudi Arabia attracts migrant workers from around the world, particularly Africa, and south and south-east Asia.
Saudi authorities estimate that up to one million people are working in the country illegally.
So far, tens of thousands of people of different nationalities have taken advantage of the grace period and have either left or acquired correct papers.


Art galleries must improve their security following recent high-profile raids, a leading investigator has said.

A Cairo gallery had no alarms working when a Vincent Van Gogh painting worth $50m (Â£32m) was stolen on Saturday.
"This doesn't surprise me at all," said Charles Hill, a former detective with the Metropolitan Police's art squad.
He said the "same sorry saga" was seen in May when thieves targeted the Museum of Modern Art in Paris, where the alarm had been out of order for weeks.
Five works by artists including Picasso and Matisse, worth just under 100m euros (Â£86m), were taken in that theft.
At Cairo's Khalil Museum, only seven out of 43 security cameras were working when thieves cut the Van Gogh painting from its frame.
Egypt's prosecutor-general Abdel-Meguid Mahmoud described the museum's security measures as "for the most part feeble and superficial".
Mr Hill told BBC Radio 4's Today programme: "If you just go back three months to Paris and the Museum of Modern Art, [it was] the same sorry saga of no alarms, or few alarms, and cameras that don't work and on and on.
"It's a wearying saga and you think, why don't directors of museums and the boards of trustees take security more seriously?
"Certainly in Cairo and Paris you've got two prime examples of people being indifferent to the need to protect their paintings."
Somebody with "inside information" about the Cairo museum's lax security could have taken advantage of the situation, he said.
But the painting was unlikely to have been stolen to order for a collector, he added.
The Van Gogh painting - known as both Poppy Flowers and Vase And Flowers - measures 30cm by 30cm (1ft by 1ft).
Depicting yellow and red flowers, it is believed to have been painted in 1887, three years before the artist's death from a self-inflicted gunshot.
The painting was previously taken from the same museum in 1978, but recovered a decade later in Kuwait.
The Mahmoud Khalil Museum also holds works by Monet, Renoir and Degas.


Pakistan one-day batsman Sharjeel Khan is joining Leicestershire to play in the T20 Blast for the 2017 season.

The 27-year-old is part of the Pakistan ODI squad touring England and recently scored 152 in a ODI against Ireland, as well as 58 off 30 balls in the match with England at Trent Bridge.
He will be available for all of Leicestershire's T20 campaign.
"Sharjeel is a powerful hitter who will offer another option," chief executive Wasim Khan said.
"We have been watching him closely this summer, where he has caught the eye with his dynamic ball striking."


Parking charges have been reintroduced in Halifax town centre after it emerged in October that no on-street ticket issued over the previous five years was legally enforceable.

Parkers were able to claim a refund after a traffic regulation order issued by Calderdale Council was found to be invalid.
Forms were filled in incorrectly in 2008 following a change in legislation.
The council estimated the blunder could cost it between £200,000 and £500,000.
To date, 3,800 claims have been made - with the council refunding more than £25,000 in the past four months.
On street parking charges were lifted in Halifax town centre on 8 October 2014. Parking charges are back in place from Monday at the previous rates.


Inspectors have found serious failings at a care home that was told to make improvements last year.

The Hallcroft care home in Hucknall, Nottinghamshire, was visited without notice by Care Quality Commission (CQC) inspectors in February.
They found poor relationships between staff and managers, incomplete records and residents left "socially isolated".
Owner Four Seasons Health Care said it had since "substantially improved the quality of care".
Issues at the home in Croft Avenue were first raised in 2014.
This year CQC inspectors found little progress had been made and rated the home "inadequate" in many areas.
Their report highlighted other issues including a lack of support for staff and agency staff inadequately trained, residents not being given showers and baths when they wanted and nursing call bells going unanswered for long periods of time.
A spokeswoman from Four Seasons Health Care said the wellbeing of residents was a "priority" and since the inspection the firm had put together an improvement plan.
"We are committed to providing person-centred care that meets the individual needs and preferences of all our residents," she said.
"We are confident that we have substantially improved the quality of care being provided."
The company said staff had been given additional training and regular meetings were taking place between residents and their relatives to update them on progress.


Burnley defender Stephen Ward has signed a new contract until 2019, with the option of a further 12 months.

The 31-year-old, whose current deal was set to expire at the end of this season, scored in Saturday's 3-2 Premier League win at Chelsea.
"It's just great to be part of a club like this at the minute," he said.
Republic of Ireland international Ward, who joined Burnley from Wolves in 2014, made 37 appearances in the league last season.
He was part of the side that won promotion from the Championship the previous season.


British troops in World War Two had "forces' sweetheart" Vera Lynn to buoy their spirits, then comedian Bob Hope entertained the US army in Vietnam and Jennifer Lopez sang in Afghanistan.

For Russia's airmen and their support crews in Syria, a New Year morale boost came from what state TV dubbed a "celebrity task force", including female singers Yulia Chicherina and Zara.
"In war there is a place for love," sang Chicherina, a rock star from the Urals, at the Russian airbase in Hmeimim near Latakia.
She strummed the ukulele as she sang, with a control tower behind her and sandbags piled up to form what looked like a gun emplacement.
The camera also homed in on a couple of silver medals on her black top.
Yulia Chicherina is one of several entertainers, including veteran crooner and MP Iosif Kobzon, blacklisted by the Ukrainian authorities for performing in separatist-controlled eastern Ukraine and Russian-annexed Crimea.
The air force at Hmeimim had already been treated to a performance by glamorous pop star Zara, who swished around the makeshift stage just before New Year in a long red gown.
The two concerts also featured some of the armed forces' own performers, including dancing sailors and military bands.
Keeping up morale is clearly an important priority for the Russian military top brass.
Russia is helping the forces of Syrian President Bashar al-Assad and their allies from Iran and Lebanon's Hezbollah against anti-government rebels and jihadist group Islamic State (IS).
In his address to Russians on New Year's Eve, President and Commander-in-Chief Vladimir Putin had a special holiday message for "our service personnel who are fighting international terrorism, defending Russia's national interests on distant frontiers, showing willpower, determination and strength of character".
The visiting entertainers also had words of support.
"I am full of admiration, as I think is the whole country, for the exploits carried out every day in the name of the fight against the terrorist threat, so it does not reach the borders of our country," Zara told news website Gazeta.ru.
In its coverage of the concerts for the troops, state TV has also kept on driving home the message that the Russian air force is waging a relentless and carefully targeted war against IS and other "terrorists".
"Musical chords are accompanied by the roar of warplane engines," ran the headline on state-run channel Rossiya 1.
Its correspondent spoke of sorties continuing "day and night", with Russian bombers carrying out "precision strikes".
But human rights campaigners have accused Moscow of using indiscriminate force. A recent report by Amnesty International has said that between September and November Russian attacks killed at least 200 civilians in Syria.
The Russian defence ministry dismissed the report as full of "cliches and fakes".
The performances will no doubt remind some Soviet army veterans of the concerts in Afghanistan in the 1980s, when Russian forces were last stationed abroad for any length of time on combat duty.
Among the leading troop entertainers in that period was Kobzon, who, as one veteran recalled, would perform from the back of a truck accompanied by five female backing singers and a record player.
Kobzon made a total of nine visits to Afghanistan during the war there.
Profile: Iosif Kobzon, Russian crooner and MP
But, according to singer Ruslan Alekhno, who was on the same bill as Zara, not all Russian entertainers are happy to support the troops.
"I won't name names, but I will say frankly: a very great many refused to go," he told Gazeta.ru.
BBC Monitoring reports and analyses news from TV, radio, web and print media around the world. You can follow BBC Monitoring  on Twitter and Facebook.


Cambodian poet Kosal Khiev first discovered poetry in solitary confinement in a US prison, serving a sentence for attempted murder.

Born in a refugee camp after his parents fled the Khmer Rouge regime in Cambodia, Khiev grew up in the US after being granted asylum, and had joined a gang by the age of 13.
At 16, Khiev was involved in a shoot-out in which two people were shot and injured. As a result, he was convicted of attempted murder and spent the next 14 years in jail.
"I remember someone telling me it takes only a couple of seconds to make a mistake, but it takes a lifetime to correct it. I'm still paying for my mistakes now," Khiev said.
Because he was not a US citizen, Khiev was deported to Cambodia, a country he had never visited before, on his release from prison.
"There was happiness when I first came back [to Cambodia], but there was also confusion, anger, bitterness and a huge fear," Khiev said.
"I've always wanted to come back to Cambodia - I just didn't think that it would be in this way."
Khiev discovered poetry while in prison in the US. He has since established himself as a poet in Cambodia, representing his country at the Poetry Parnassus, a festival held as part of the London 2012 Cultural Olympiad.
Khiev, who describes himself as "a spoken word artist, an immigrant and an exile", says his story began in a refugee camp in Thailand.
"My parents fled during the aftermath of the Khmer Rouge war," he said. "My mum saw her first husband executed in front of her, and the only thing she buried was a piece of his fractured skull."
At the age of one, Khiev was accepted, along with his grandmother, mother and six siblings, to the US as refugees. However, they were separated from his father, who was not accepted to the US.
"I always thought my father was dead, I didn't know he was alive until I was 25," Khiev said.
Life in the US was difficult, and Khiev said his sense of isolation contributed to his joining a gang.
"I remember we were living in this two-bedroom apartment, the nine of us, trying to make ends meet."
"I started hanging with guys that were coming from the same background as me, who felt like they were alone in the world."
Khiev was sentenced to 16 years in prison for his involvement in a shoot-out.
While Khiev says he regrets his actions, he is also unhappy about the way he was sentenced.
"I'm not proud of hurting anyone. I wish I never did. But I got locked up at 16, and I got tried as an adult... why would you throw away the key? Then you're saying that this kid has no more redemption."
The two people who were shot "didn't die, thank goodness, and they're well now", Khiev said.
Khiev spent time in nine different prisons, and describes parts of his time in prison, where he witnessed violent riots, as "crazy" and "like a battleground".
"When you're in an environment of monsters you almost become a monster in order to survive."
He was eventually released after serving 14 years of his term.
Although unhappy with much of his experience in prison, Khiev said one of his most transformative moments came when he was locked in solitary confinement for his involvement in a fight.
"They kept me in the hole [solitary confinement] for one and a half years. I almost went crazy," he said.
"You come to talk to yourself, and you're forced to confront yourself, all parts of yourself. It made me say - is this it? Is this all your life is going to amount to? Are you going to die in prison?"
"I wrote everything out, fears, hopes, dreams and nightmares."
"Whatever I was writing I would talk it out, and people [in the other solitary confinement cells] would hear me and say: 'Let us hear something man'".
"In a sense it was my first performance - it was dudes just being lonely and bored."
On his release from solitary confinement, he met other poets, and took part in poetry classes in an Arts in Corrections programme.
"I discovered the power that poetry has to change a person's perspective and outlook," he said.
Khiev took part in outreach programmes speaking to young people at risk of offending, and worked as a facilitator in The Prison Peace Project, a corrections programme.
Khiev said he "felt his calling" during the outreach programmes. Following his release, finding out that he would be deported to Cambodia was difficult to accept.
"I had all these dreams, all these plans [in the US]," he said. "When I first came to Cambodia I didn't know what I was going to do."
"I worked in a cinema as a movie projectionist, and on my day off I was teaching volunteering, trying to do creative stuff. It was hard, until I got mixed up with Studio Revolt [a local arts studio]."
Khiev says he cried when he received the invitation to perform as part of the London 2012 Olympics.
"I was homeless at that time - I had quit my projectionist job to do my art... I was sleeping on people's couches or staying up all night riding around. I was about to go back to the cinema, it was getting so hard."
"And finally I got the letter of invitation, and I couldn't believe it. [Performing in London] was an amazing experience."
Khiev dreams of being able to return to the US and reunite with his family one day, although for now, Khiev is working as an artist-in-residence at Studio Revolt, and running poetry workshops with young people.
"Now I've come back, I just want to do good," he said. "I just want people, when they talk to me, to get the feeling that this guy is doing good. And just continue forward, you know?"


Some police forces in England and Wales risk being "overwhelmed" by the volume of digital evidence being collected, the police watchdog has warned.

Her Majesty's Inspectorate of Constabulary said many forces had a "significant gap" in digital skills.
It said there were sometimes "unacceptable delays" in basic tasks like getting data off a mobile phone.
Minister Brandon Lewis said: "The public expect the police to reform to meet the challenges of modern crime."
Inspectors said some forces were not capable of dealing with the amount of digital evidence being gathered, especially in cases such as harassment, sexting and serious domestic abuse.
Mike Cunningham, who led the review, said every officer and member of staff needed to understand how to extract evidence from phones and CCTV as the nature of crime changed.
He said: "They are real, here and now threats. They range from the most serious kind of national terrorism threats down to... an attempt to get you to part with your money through an email.
"The urgency of the issue is not matched by the urgency with which the service is responding."
Digital crime required a different type of forensic capability to traditional offences where police looked for evidence such as DNA or fingerprints, he said.
"We are not saying that they will not have the capability anywhere in the force to extract that information," said Mr Cunningham.
"What we are saying is that they are being overwhelmed. There is evidence that there is far too much of this evidence coming in for forces to meet that demand."
The inspectors warned that delays due to such skills shortages could allow perpetrators to continue offending, or lead victims to give up on the case and drop support for the police investigation.
The warning came in a review of forces' abilities to manage demands and resources, as well as plan ahead.
Of all 43 police forces in England and Wales, it found eight forces "require improvement" in the ways they understand future demand for services and ensure staff have the right skills. Thirty-three forces were assessed as "good", which is the "expected standard", and two - Durham and West Midlands - as "outstanding".
The eight forces deemed to require improvement are Bedfordshire, Cambridgeshire, City of London, Devon and Cornwall, Dyfed Powys, Humberside, Nottinghamshire and South Yorkshire.
This is the second "efficiency" inspection carried out by Her Majesty's Inspectorate - last year one force, Humberside, was rated as inadequate. This year no force has been given the bottom rating although the number of forces rated as "outstanding" has fallen from five to two.
Inspectors said there were some signs that, after a better than expected financial settlement in police funding in November 2015, some forces had "reduced the pace and ambition for change".
Welcoming the report, policing minister Brandon Lewis said in a statement: "I am concerned by the suggestion that some forces may have reduced the pace and ambition of their reform plans.
"The public expect the police to reform to meet the challenges of modern crime. Forces owe it to the communities they serve to deliver."


Crystal Palace have reached an agreement with Liverpool to sign Belgium striker Christian Benteke for an initial £27m fee.

The 25-year-old is travelling to London to have a medical and finalise terms.
Benteke, who joined the Reds for £32.5m in July 2015, would be Palace's record signing, with the deal potentially rising above £30m with add-ons.
Winger Andros Townsend was the Eagles' previous record signing, having joined from Tottenham for £13m in July.
Palace had an offer worth £23m up front, plus £7m add-ons, for Benteke rejected on Tuesday.


The family of a second soldier who died at Deepcut barracks is to apply for a fresh inquest into the circumstances around his death.

Pte Sean Benton was found dead at the Surrey barracks with five gunshot wounds in June 1995, while on guard at a perimeter fence.
Human rights group Liberty said the Attorney General had given his family consent to apply to the High Court.
An earlier inquest recorded a verdict of suicide on the 20-year-old soldier.
The coroner at a second inquest on Pte Cheryl James, who died at Deepcut in 1995 from a single gunshot wound, recorded a verdict of suicide earlier this month. The Cheryl James inquest heard from more than 100 witnesses.
Delivering his verdict, Brian Barker QC launched a scathing attack on welfare standards at Deepcut and said there was overwhelming evidence of a sexualised atmosphere there.
Liberty, on behalf of Pte Benton's twin brother Tony and his sister Tracy Lewis, lodged an application with the Attorney General in July 2015 requesting that the original inquest of July 1995 be quashed and a fresh one ordered.
It said that since his death, many people had stated publicly and to his family that they believed Pte Benton, from Hastings, East Sussex had been the victim of physical and psychological bullying at the barracks.
"We have been overwhelmed and disturbed by all the details of the shameful environment at Deepcut which have finally come to light through the Cheryl James inquest - it is terrible to think of Sean alone there," said Ms Lewis.
"More than two decades after our brother died - and having lost both our parents in recent years - Tony and I are determined to find out what happened to Sean."
Pte Benton was the first of four young recruits to die of gunshot wounds at Deepcut between 1995 and 2002.
Liberty said the initial inquest a month after his death heard evidence from six people. Pte Benton's medical and mental health records were not obtained and no evidence was sought or given concerning his experiences at the barracks.
Liberty lawyer Emma Norton said if Pte Benton's death had been properly and independently investigated in 1995, decades of pain and uncertainty for the family would have been avoided.
Who were the Deepcut four?


Kilmarnock were knocked out of the league cup after a lacklustre display saw them slump to defeat on penalties to Albion Rovers.

After a goalless 90 minutes, Josh Magennis was denied in the shootout by keeper Ross Stewart as the Wee Rovers claimed the bonus point.
Scott McBride scored the fifth spot kick to seal victory for the visitors.
Ryan Wallace thought he had put Rovers in front in the first-half, only to see his effort ruled out for a foul.
In a week when the Killie manager had to deny stories he was about to quit, he looked a frustrated figure as his players turned in a second successive disjointed home performance.
Killie's on-loan keeper from Swansea Oliver Davies produced two moments Des O'Connor used to sing about, notably "Careless hands", as he fumbled when it looked easier to catch.
With the second he was fortunate the referee came to his aid because Wallace took advantage of his slip-up and slotted the ball in the net.
However, Bobby Madden disallowed the goal for apparently a foul on Davies.
Josh Magennis and Souleymane Coulibaly were the main Killie strikers but they failed to hit the target with any of the opportunities that fell their way in the first half.
The first effort on target came from the League One side when Mark Ferry's low strike on the hour mark saw Davies dive low to his right to turn it round the post.
In the last ten minutes Killie's full-time status seemed kick-in with Rovers more on the back foot.
Rory McKenzie fired a volley from 25 yards over the bar before Coulibaly tried an acrobatic back flick with his heel that was stopped on the line.
Miles Addison sent a glancing header wide from a Magennis cross, before McKenzie had a penalty appeal rejected after going down in the box under the challenge of Ross Dunlop.
However, a former Killie player Gary Fisher almost came back to haunt his old club with a late strike which Davies had to be alert to hold.
That meant we headed to penalties, and Magennis' miss saw the League One side prevail in the shootout.
Match ends, Kilmarnock 0(3), Albion Rovers 0(5).
Penalty Shootout ends, Kilmarnock 0(3), Albion Rovers 0(5).
Goal!  Kilmarnock 0(3), Albion Rovers 0(5). Scott McBride (Albion Rovers) converts the penalty with a left footed shot to the bottom right corner.
Goal!  Kilmarnock 0(3), Albion Rovers 0(4). Florent Bojaj (Kilmarnock) converts the penalty with a left footed shot to the top right corner.
Goal!  Kilmarnock 0(2), Albion Rovers 0(4). Kyle Turnbull (Albion Rovers) converts the penalty with a left footed shot to the bottom right corner.
Penalty saved! Josh Magennis (Kilmarnock) fails to capitalise on this great opportunity,  right footed shot saved  in the bottom right corner.
Goal!  Kilmarnock 0(2), Albion Rovers 0(3). Paul Willis (Albion Rovers) converts the penalty with a right footed shot to the bottom right corner.
Goal!  Kilmarnock 0(2), Albion Rovers 0(2). Gary Dicker (Kilmarnock) converts the penalty with a right footed shot to the top left corner.
Goal!  Kilmarnock 0(1), Albion Rovers 0(2). Michael Dunlop (Albion Rovers) converts the penalty with a left footed shot to the high centre of the goal.
Goal!  Kilmarnock 0(1), Albion Rovers 0(1). Steven Smith (Kilmarnock) converts the penalty with a left footed shot to the bottom right corner.
Goal!  Kilmarnock 0, Albion Rovers 0(1). Ross Stewart (Albion Rovers) converts the penalty with a right footed shot to the top right corner.
Penalty Shootout begins Kilmarnock 0, Albion Rovers 0.
Second Half ends, Kilmarnock 0, Albion Rovers 0.
Kyle Turnbull (Albion Rovers) is shown the yellow card for a bad foul.
Rory McKenzie (Kilmarnock) wins a free kick in the defensive half.
Foul by Kyle Turnbull (Albion Rovers).
Attempt saved. Gary Fisher (Albion Rovers) right footed shot from outside the box is saved in the centre of the goal.
Corner,  Kilmarnock. Conceded by Ross Dunlop.
Attempt saved. Souleymane Coulibaly (Kilmarnock) right footed shot from very close range is saved in the centre of the goal.
Corner,  Kilmarnock. Conceded by Alan Reid.
Attempt missed. Rory McKenzie (Kilmarnock) right footed shot from outside the box is just a bit too high.
Substitution, Albion Rovers. Ross Gilmour replaces Ryan Wallace.
Foul by Rory McKenzie (Kilmarnock).
Kyle Turnbull (Albion Rovers) wins a free kick in the defensive half.
Scott McBride (Albion Rovers) is shown the yellow card.
Souleymane Coulibaly (Kilmarnock) is shown the yellow card.
Substitution, Albion Rovers. Ross Stewart replaces Calum Ferguson.
William Boyle (Kilmarnock) wins a free kick in the attacking half.
Foul by Ryan Wallace (Albion Rovers).
Substitution, Albion Rovers. Scott McBride replaces Mark Ferry.
Attempt missed. Ross Davidson (Albion Rovers) right footed shot from outside the box is just a bit too high.
Foul by Greg Taylor (Kilmarnock).
Paul Willis (Albion Rovers) wins a free kick in the defensive half.
Substitution, Kilmarnock. Florent Bojaj replaces Jordan Jones.
Substitution, Kilmarnock. Greg Taylor replaces Josh Webb.
Corner,  Albion Rovers. Conceded by Oliver Davies.
Attempt saved. Mark Ferry (Albion Rovers) right footed shot from outside the box is saved in the bottom left corner.
Josh Magennis (Kilmarnock) hits the bar with a right footed shot from outside the box.
Foul by Gary Dicker (Kilmarnock).
Calum Ferguson (Albion Rovers) wins a free kick on the left wing.


Kate Russell's weekly review of the best apps and websites.

Media playback is unsupported on your device
4 October 2013 Last updated at 08:40 BST
There will soon be 1.4 billion smartphones in the world. They keep us connected and informed and now thanks to a booming market in fitness apps, they help keep us healthy too.
Moves on the iPhone and Noom Walk on Android are smartphone apps to track the number of steps taken. Fitness experts agree that around 10,000 steps a day is a good target for a healthy adult - that is a lot of tracking.
If serious about tracking fitness, a dedicated tracking band or other device could be a good investment, so we road tested four of the leading brands - the Jawbone UP, Fitbit's Flex, the Nike+ Fuel Band and Misfit's Shine - to compare the features and benefits.
If that is a bit too physical, a relaxing journey across the world from a birds-eye viewpoint can be achieved with YouTube channel World from Above HD.
Flickr group Landscape Photographers of Los Santos and Blaine County has been set up to capture the scenery of computer game Grand Theft Auto. The collection is filled with screenshots taken by gamers using the free iFruit iOS app.
Google has added remote screen lock and restore factory settings to its Android device manager, just in case the worst happens with a phone.
Watch more clips on the Click website. If you are in the UK you can watch the whole programme on BBC iPlayer.


Pakistani child education activist Malala Yousafzai and Kailash Satyarthi, an Indian child rights campaigner, have jointly won the Nobel Peace Prize.

At the age of just 17, Malala is the youngest ever recipient of the prize.
The teenager was shot in the head by Taliban gunmen in October 2012 for campaigning for girls' education. She now lives in Birmingham in the UK.
Malala said she was "honoured" to receive the award, saying it made her feel "more powerful and courageous".
She revealed she found out the news after being called out of her chemistry class at her school in Birmingham.
"I'm really happy to be sharing this award with a person from India," she said at a news conference, before joking that she couldn't pronounce Mr Satyarthi's surname.
The Nobel committee praised the pair's "struggle against the suppression of children and young people".
Mr Satyarthi has maintained the tradition of Mahatma Gandhi and headed various forms of peaceful protests, "focusing on the grave exploitation of children for financial gain," the committee said at the Nobel Institute in Oslo.
The 60-year-old founded Bachpan Bachao Andolan, or the Save the Childhood Movement, which campaigns for child rights and an end to human trafficking.
Reacting to the news, Mr Satyarthi told the BBC: "It's a great honour for all the Indians, it's an honour for all those children who have been still living in slavery despite of all the advancement in technology, market and economy.
"And I dedicate this award to all those children in the world."
Thorbjorn Jagland, chairman of the Norwegian Nobel Committee, paid tribute to Malala's achievements.
"Despite her youth, Malala Yousafzai, has already fought for several years for the right of girls to education and has shown by example that children and young people too can contribute to improving their own situations," he said.
"This she has done under the most dangerous circumstances. Through her heroic struggle she has become a leading spokesperson for girls' rights to education."
The committee said it was important that a Muslim and a Hindu, a Pakistani and an Indian, had joined in what it called a common struggle for education and against extremism.
When she opened the Library of Birmingham last year, Malala Yousafzai charmed the crowd by referring to them as "fellow Brummies". It was a deft touch from a teenager who many believe is destined for a life in politics either here or in her native Pakistan.
She arrived in the city in horrific circumstances after surviving an assassination attempt and was treated at the Queen Elizabeth Hospital, home to the Royal Centre for Defence Medicine.
The expertise gained by medics who are used to patching up wounded troops from conflict zones, meant it was the best place for her treatment.
She remains an outpatient, and today the hospital trust praised her for her "remarkable recovery and fight to lead a full life as a vibrant and spirited teenager".
This year's prize is likely to be seen as an uncontroversial choice from a Norwegian Nobel committee which has not shied away from controversy in recent years, says the BBC's Lars Bevanger in Oslo.
Norway's relations with China are still suffering after a Chinese dissident won the peace prize in 2010, our correspondent adds.
Malala and Mr Satyarthi will now be invited to attend an award ceremony in Oslo in December to receive a medal and $1.4m (Â£860,000) pounds in prize money.
'Pride of Pakistan'
Malala first came to attention in 2009 after she wrote an anonymous diary for BBC Urdu about life under Taliban rule in north-west Pakistan.
She was shot when gunmen boarded her school bus in the Swat Valley.
She has since recovered from the attack and has remained in the public eye, publishing an autobiography and addressing the UN General Assembly.
Pakistan's Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif congratulated Malala Yousafzai, calling her the "pride" of his country.
"Her achievement is unparalleled and unequalled. Girls and boys of the world should take the lead from her struggle and commitment," he said in a statement.
Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi joined thousands of Twitter users praising the pair, saying the entire nation was proud of Mr Satyarthi's "momentous achievement".
He also congratulated Malala for her "journey of immense grit and courage".
Malala was named one of Time magazine's most influential people in 2013, and awarded the EU's prestigious Sakharov human rights prize that year.
She had been hotly tipped to win last year's Nobel Peace Prize.
Her win in 2014 takes the number of women awarded the prize to 16 out of 95.
This year's record number of 278 Nobel Peace Prize nominees included Pope Francis and Congolese gynaecologist Denis Mukwege, although the full list was kept a secret.
Former NSA contractor Edward Snowden and Russian newspaper Novaya Gazeta had also been tipped as favourites for the award.
95
Nobel Peace Prizes have been awarded 1901-2014
16 women have been awarded the prize, including Malala Yousafzai
17 Malala's age, making her the youngest ever laureate
62 average age of laureates when they were awarded the prize
3 laureates were under arrest at the time of the award: Carl von Ossietzky, Aung San Suu Kyi & Liu Xiaobo


The Pope has questioned US Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump's Christianity over his call to build a border wall with Mexico.

Pope Francis said "a person who thinks only about building walls... and not of building bridges, is not Christian".
The New York businessman supports deporting nearly 11 million undocumented immigrants.
Calling himself a "proud Christian",  Mr Trump blamed Mexico for the Pope's remarks, calling them "disgraceful".
Mr Trump has alleged that Mexico sends "rapists" and criminals to the US.
Pope Francis made the comments at the end of a six-day trip to Mexico.
"A person who thinks only about building walls, wherever they may be, and not of building bridges, is not Christian.  This is not the gospel," he said.
He declined to say whether Americans should vote for Mr Trump, who is leading the Republican race for president.
"I say only that this man is not Christian if he has said things like that. We must see if he said things in that way and I will give him the benefit of the doubt," the Pope said.
In response to a question about whether contraception was allowed to prevent the transmission of the Zika virus, the Pope said that for some cases the "lesser of two evils" can be used. He said abortion "is a crime, an absolute evil," but that avoiding pregnancy is not.
Addressing a rally in South Carolina, Mr Trump responded to the Pope's comments.
"For a religious leader to question a person's faith is disgraceful. I am proud to be a Christian," Mr Trump said. "No leader, especially a religious leader, should have the right to question another man's religion or faith."
"[The pope] said negative things about me. Because the Mexican government convinced him that Trump is not a good guy," he said.
Did Mr Trump need to take on the Pope? Well, almost certainly yes.
Because in god-fearing South Carolina, the next state to vote in the primary process - to have the Pope say that he is unchristian is potentially very damaging.
And over the course of the campaign, the billionaire property developer has been at pains to prove his religious credentials, appearing at rallies with a copy of the Bible that his mother had given him as a child
Trump v Pope... who wins?
He also said the Vatican was the so-called Islamic State group's "ultimate trophy" and that if it attacked, "the Pope would have only wished and prayed that Donald Trump would have been president because this would not have happened".
Two of Mr Trump's Republican rivals, Marco Rubio and Jeb Bush, both Catholics, said they look to the Pope for spiritual guidance, not political direction.
Mr Rubio said the US has a right and an obligation to control its borders.
Mr Bush told reporters he "supports walls where it's appropriate" and that "Christianity is between he and his creator. I don't think we need to discuss that".
Jerry Falwell Jr, the president of the conservative Christian Liberty University and a Trump supporter, told CNN that the Pope had gone too far.
"Jesus never intended to give instructions to political leaders on how to run a country," he said.
Earlier this month, Mr Trump called Pope Francis "a very political person" in an interview with Fox News.
"I don't think he understands the danger of the open border we have with Mexico," Mr Trump said.
American Catholics are seen as an important voting bloc in US elections. Many support Republican candidates because of their opposition to abortion and gay marriage.
Mr Trump has been courting the evangelical Christian vote, often successfully, but his fellow Republican rivals have tried to argue that his religiosity is not sincere.
Ted Cruz's campaign is now running an advertisement featuring a 1999 television interview Mr Trump gave in which he said he was "very pro-choice" when it comes to abortion.
In January, Mr Trump faced ridicule after flubbing a Bible verse when giving a speech to a Christian university in Virginia.
He has said he is a Presbyterian Christian but has had trouble recalling his favourite Bible verse when asked.
He has referred to communion, the Christian sacrament signifying Jesus' last supper, as having "the little wine" and "the little cracker."
22 things that Donald Trump believes - What are his policies and beliefs?
What would a Donald Trump presidency be like? - Anthony Zurcher imagines a Trump White House
Donald Trump and the politics of paranoia - He is just the latest example of a tendency in US politics that goes back centuries
Trump turns notoriety into a win - After New Hampshire, is Mr Trump unstoppable?


Former world champion and Olympic and Commonwealth Games medallist Beth Tweddle recalls her career in gymnastics.

Media playback is not supported on this device
"I was never a kid that dreamt of becoming this big gymnast that would achieve amazing results," she said.
"I just kept loving the challenge and then the results kept getting better and better."
If you want to find out more about getting into gymnastics, read our special guide.


A woman found guilty of sex offences against teenage boys has been jailed for four years.

Stephanie Embley, 35, of Pine Road, Cantley, South Yorkshire, was investigated after the parents of one of the boys raised concerns about her.
She admitted four charges of sexual activity with a child and was found guilty of a further two at Sheffield Crown Court on Friday.
She was jailed and given a 10-year Sexual Harm Prevention Order.
That means she can have no contact, either directly or indirectly, with children under the age of 16, police said.
Speaking after the sentencing, Det Con Brian Thompson said: "Embley preyed on and took advantage of teenage boys for her own sexual gratification, which is a despicable crime.
"I am pleased that she has been found guilty of, and pleaded guilty to, these horrific offences and that she is behind bars where she poses no further risk to children.
"The victims and their families have been supportive of our investigation and I thank them for their patience and bravery throughout this inquiry."


Wales manager Chris Coleman was honoured with a Special Recognition Award at the Wales Sport Awards 2016.

Coleman, 46, guided his side to the semi-finals of Euro 2016, Wales' first major championship in 58 years.
Wales are unbeaten in 2018 World Cup qualifying and will end the year in 12th place in the Fifa world rankings.
Swansea-born Coleman received the award for his achievements in charge of the national team at the ceremony at Cardiff's Hoddinott Hall on Monday.
"We still pinch ourselves the Euros happened," Coleman said when he collected the award.
"I can't say reaching the semi-final was on our mind.
"We needed a little bit of luck, but the players deserve all the accolades, they handled the pressure and thrived in it.
Media playback is not supported on this device
"Now we are focused on the next challenge, which is the World Cup in Russia."
"This special award is a fitting accolade for a man who brought the nation together this summer," BBC Wales director Rhodri Talfan Davies said.
"None of us will ever forget how special it felt to follow the brilliant Wales team that Chris Coleman put together at Euro 2016.
"It will be a thrilling moment to see his exceptional achievements celebrated in style."
Sarah Powell, chief executive of Sport Wales, added: "Chris has provided inspiration to the people of Wales that has even transcended his team's sporting achievements.
"His fist-pumping passion, combined with his encouragement to dream, learn and strive for success have touched people across the nation.
"We will all remember the summer of 2016 for a long time to come. I am delighted we are able to recognise his contribution with this Special Recognition award."
The Wales Sport Awards is an event, organised in partnership by BBC Wales and Sport Wales. It aims to recognise the best achievements at elite and community level in Welsh sport.


Dan Biggar cannot resist a joke when he is asked if he enjoys the pressure of playing fly-half for Wales.

"I wish I played second row," he quips, before admitting he is glad he is not England football captain Wayne Rooney.
"It is what it is. Win and your number 10 never gets any of the credit. When you lose, it's all the 10's fault.
"I wouldn't change it for the world, I love playing number 10 for Wales and, I suppose, the pressure that comes with it.
"Imagine being someone like Wayne Rooney over the last three months and the press, their treatment of one of England's better players. If I think I'm having a tough time, I just look at him. The criticism doesn't bother me one bit."
The pressure will be sky-high when Biggar makes his 50th appearance in the most scrutinised and analysed shirt in Welsh rugby against Argentina.
Wales have lost their last five Test matches and there was little to redeem their 32-8 thrashing by Australia in the opening autumn international.
It is a result which has seen centre Jamie Roberts dropped to the bench after making 79 consecutive starts for his country.
Media playback is not supported on this device
Coach Rob Howley has made six changes in all, but Biggar is one of nine players to keep his place in the starting line-up.
One alteration on the bench has seen Sam Davies, who was selected for Ospreys ahead of Biggar for a big match against Cardiff Blues earlier this season, drop out of the 23-man squad in favour of Gareth Anscombe.
It's barely 14 months since Biggar was the hero of Wales' 28-25 win over England in the 2015 Rugby World Cup.
It seems extraordinary to people outside Wales that Biggar could be under so much pressure.
But this is Wales and he plays fly-half in the country that has produced Cliff Morgan, Barry John, Phil Bennett and Jonathan Davies. It is a position scrutinised like no other. Think chefs in France or rally drivers in Scandinavia.
Biggar has the confidence to handle that scrutiny.
"There are people who offer their opinion and say you could have done this or that better but that's part and parcel of it, especially being in Wales," he says.
"The boys outside of Wales sometimes don't get that sort of thing.
"Living and playing in Wales can be very much a goldfish bowl. Sometimes it can be nice to be outside of that and get on with you day-to-day life.
"I don't take any notice of the criticism and everyone wants Wales to do well and get better. Ultimately the number 10 position is a key to that.
"Ultimately as a team, we want to prove a few people wrong on Saturday. It's not about me, it's not about number 10 but about us as a collective, as a team.
"Getting 50 caps is a nice milestone, but it will soon be forgotten if we don't get a result and put in a decent performance."
Having been understudy to Rhys Priestland early in his career, Biggar knows what it is like to be on the outside looking in and understands his place cannot be taken for granted.
"It's the coaches' opinion which is the most important to me," he adds.
"We have got lots of good options in Wales with Sam Davies, Gareth Anscombe and Rhys Priestland playing well for Bath.
"I'm just the lucky one in position at the minute but if my form doesn't meet the coaches' standards, I'm sure they will be other options."
Roberts' demotion to the bench is proof of that theory. Reputation and an impressive record are not enough to guarantee selection.
"Jamie has been superb and Scott Williams is playing well, he continues.
"It won't be a huge change for us, we know our structures are in place.  And I'm sure you haven't seen the end of Jamie Roberts. He's had a brilliant career and there's plenty more in him. It's exciting times."


The police helicopter service covering mid and south-west Wales has officially come to an end.

The operations of the Dyfed-Powys Police Helicopter were taken over by the National Police Air Service at midnight.
The Pembrey base in Carmarthenshire will be retained as a "forward operating base" for now, although aircraft will not be stationed there.
Dyfed-Powys Police's commissioner said it would still mean 24-hour air cover.
The nearest helicopters will now be based at St Athan, in the Vale of Glamorgan and Hawarden in Flintshire.
The new arrangements will cost Â£890,000 a year from January - about Â£275,000 less than in 2014-15.
It come as the local service transfers from forces in Wales and England to the national service.


A river bank damaged by flooding and storms in 2013 is to be repaired thanks to a lottery grant.

The 5th Worcester Sea Scout Group has received Â£76,254 from Sport England's Flood Relief Fund.
The money will be used to restore a section of the eroded River Severn riverbank at Northwick and create a barrier to stop water getting onto the land in the future.
Group Scout Leader Robert Sidley said he was "delighted".


A football referee in the US state of Michigan has died after being punched in the head during an altercation with a player he was ejecting from a match, according to police and witnesses.

John Bieniewicz, 44, was struck on Sunday during the game in a park.
He was unconscious on the ground in the park when authorities arrived and died in hospital on Tuesday.
Baseel Abdul-Amir Saad, 36, has been charged with assault with intent to do great bodily harm.
But authorities say the charges could be amended following further investigation.
Bieniewicz was an experienced referee who worked at all levels of competition, and a husband and father of two sons, according to media reports and a memorial page set up in his memory.
"I speak for all his friends when I say we are devastated. Crushed. Just a senseless way for a great guy to go out," Bieniewicz's friend Jim Acho told the Associated Press news agency.
Witnesses at the game in Livonia reported seeing Bieniewicz stop play to eject Mr Saad, who had complained about a call and was issued a second caution.
Player Scott Herkes told the Detroit Free Press Bieniewicz was looking down and did not see the punch coming.
"The ref did nothing to provoke this attack," Mr Herkes said. "I have never in my life seen something like this."
Mr Saad reportedly left the field after the incident, and several players got the license plate number of his vehicle as he left.
His lawyer Brian Berry told local media his client was co-operating and had voluntarily turned himself in to police.
"Based on certain witness statements that have not yet been published, it is believed that the facts of this case have been mischaracterised," Mr Berry wrote in an email to the Detroit Free Press.
"As tragic as this event is, we must keep open minds and listen and wait for all the facts of this case to unfold."
It is the second such fatal case in as many years.
In April 2013, a teenaged player punched referee Ricardo Portillo during a football game in Utah.
The father of three died after a week in a coma. The teenager subsequently pleaded guilty to homicide.


Aberdeen manager Derek McInnes is being considered by Sunderland as a candidate for the vacancy created by fellow Scotsman David Moyes' exit.

Moyes resigned after one season in charge at the Stadium of Light, his side finishing bottom to exit the Premier League after a 10-year stay.
McInnes' Dons are in Saturday's Scottish Cup final against Celtic.
The 45-year-old's side also finished runners-up to Celtic in the league and lost to them in the League Cup final.
McInnes, who was appointed by the Scottish Premiership club in 2013, has had a previous stint as manager in England's second tier.
He took charge of Bristol City in October 2011 and steered them clear of relegation trouble in his first season.
However, he was sacked in January 2013 with his side again in the drop zone.
McInnes, who led St Johnstone to promotion to Scotland's top flight before moving to the Robins, was heavily linked with the Rangers manager's job after Mark Warburton left Ibrox in February.
Aberdeen chairman Stewart Milne announced that he would refuse any approach from Rangers for permission to speak to his manager.
McInnes subsequently had a public disagreement with the man who did succeed Warburton, Pedro Caixinha, saying Rangers should be embarrassed to finish behind Aberdeen in the league considering their superior financial resources.
Sunderland chief executive Martin Bain was at Ibrox during McInnes' five-year spell as a Rangers player.
The former midfielder also played for Greenock Morton, Toulouse, West Bromwich Albion, Dundee United, Millwall and St Johnstone.
Sunderland have had eight permanent managers since Roy Keane parted company in December 2008 and four since Martin O'Neill exited in March 2013.
Whoever is their next manager will face a difficult financial environment, with the Black Cats' last annual figures showing a loss after tax of £33m and a net debt of £110.4m, while relegation from the Premier League will also drastically reduce revenue.


Young voters in Yorkshire played their part in toppling two Liberal Democrat MPs on election night.

Former deputy prime minister Nick Clegg lost his seat to the Labour Party in Sheffield Hallam, as did Lib Dem Greg Mulholland in Leeds North West.
Both have strong student numbers, the Leeds constituency being the area with the biggest increase in registered voters in the past year.
Some cited their reasons for voting Labour as a protest against the Tories.
Others prioritised the NHS and local education as key election issues.
The result was Alex Sobel taking the Leeds North West seat by more than 4,000 votes for Labour and Mr Clegg losing to Labour's Jared O'Mara by more than 2,000 votes.
Alex Keen, 23, from Headingley, is studying a masters degree in biodiversity and conservation at the University of Leeds.
"I had never considered voting Lib Dem after the coalition," he said.
"I'd say I was all aboard Jeremy's bandwagon, I went to a rally and he sold his manifesto to me. As for Tim Farron, his views on same sex marriage, well that was enough to put me off.
"I am normally a green voter but this time it was about tactical voting."
Rashelle Thomas-Jarrett, 23, a healthcare student also from Headingley, said:  "I was Green all the way, but as we saw the Conservatives lead was increasing I thought I needed to do something.
"I thought if I did vote Labour there was more of a chance of getting Theresa May out.
"I'm a healthcare student so the NHS is a massive thing for one. You just couldn't vote for a Conservative government for that reason."
Elsi, 19, a midwifery student from Headingley, said: "I voted Labour. I was more anti-Tory than for a specific group. It was more of a strategic vote.
"I'm an NHS student so that was a factor. Labour is very supportive of funding the NHS and supporting that. It wasn't just for my career but it was for helping other people too."
Engineering student Dan Piper, 20, lives in Headingley in the Leeds North West constituency but cast a postal vote in his hometown of Ulverston.
"I voted Lib Dem but it was a tough choice. I think Conservative policies are not working for most people, more for the higher earners.
"I had a look at Labour's policies and thought they went a bit too far. They were trying to put a lot of money into things that they couldn't afford.
"I'm OK with tuition fees. I'm a student and my fees are Â£18,000 a year but I will happily pay."
It appears the surge in new voters in Leeds North West managed to win Labour an extra seat, possibly helped by a visit from Jeremy Corbyn during his campaign.
About 3,000 people packed a courtyard, road and parts of a park opposite Brudenell Social Club in Hyde Park, Leeds, when he visited on 15 May.
In Sheffield Hallam, young voter Amy Smith, 23, said Corbyn "speaks their language".
She said: "Young people are actually getting involved and know that there's someone out there that's not letting them down and can give them a future they can actually work for and live in.
"Corbyn has been really good at galvanising people to get out and get interested in politics because he speaks their language."
Charlie Heywood-Heath, also from Sheffield, said: "I think they've [politicians] realised actually young people probably are more important when it comes to the voting demographic."


South Africa's constitutional court has rejected an attempt by the government to keep a ban on the domestic trade in rhino horns.

The ruling that the application be dismissed means that rhino horns can effectively be traded in the country.
Rhino breeders argue that legalising the trade could cut the number of rhinos slaughtered as horns can be sawn off anaesthetised live animals.
However many conservationists disagree with the proposed policy.
The department of environmental affairs said authorities were still considering the implications of Wednesday's judgment.
"It is important to note that permits are required to sell or buy rhino horn," the department's spokesman, Albie Modise, said in a statement.
The ruling only applies to the industry in South Africa as a ban on international trade remains in force.
Rhino breeders who have argued that open trade is the only way to prevent widespread slaughter of the animal welcomed the ruling.
"We are absolutely delighted at the ruling by the constitutional court," Pelham Jones, chairman of the Private Rhino Owners Association (PROA), told AFP news agency.
Breeders also argue that the process is not permanent as the horns grow back.
The Helping Rhinos organisation however tweeted that the ruling was "disastrous".
South Africa is thought to be home to around 20,000 rhinos, around 80% of the worldwide population. More than 1,000 rhino were killed by poachers in South Africa in 2016.


Supermarket giant Asda has seen sales fall again, but there are signs that its performance is improving.

In the final three months of 2016, sales at its stores open for more than a year fell by 2.9%.
But that was better than the 5.8% slide in the third quarter, and the 7.5% fall in sales in the three months to June.
Asda, which is owned by US retail giant Walmart, is operating in a fiercely competitive market, with discount chains Lidl and Aldi expanding rapidly.
Walmart chief executive Doug McMillon said: "In the UK, we faced some challenges this past year and we're addressing this with urgency.
"I'm glad store sales improved during the fourth quarter, but we have a lot of work to do."
Asda chief executive Sean Clarke said the supermarket had gained more than 140,000 customers in the fourth quarter.
He added that Asda had "sharpened" its prices and focused on its ranges and the availability of its products.
Mr Clarke was brought in as chief executive in July last year as part of an attempt to revive the supermarket's fortunes.
Meanwhile, Walmart reported higher-than-expected US sales after a 29% boost to online sales and with more people coming to its stores.
Sales at US stores open for at least a year rose 1.8%, beating analyst estimates of 1.3%.
Visits to its stores in the US rose 1.4%, compared with a 0.7% increase a year earlier.
"We've now seen nine consecutive quarters of traffic growth in our stores," said Walmart chief financial officer Brett Biggs. "Clearly, we're gaining traction."
Neil Saunders, managing director of GlobalData Retail, said: "While some US retailers struggled over the holiday period, Walmart did not as it notched up respectable sales gains on both a total and same-store basis."
He said promotion of its "everyday low price" strategy had paid off with "price conscious" holiday shoppers.


Some of the biggest emitters of greenhouse gases have the lowest climate change targets, according to a Holyrood report.

It said the transport and agriculture sectors needed to make a greater contribution than laid out in the Scottish government's climate plan.
Four Holyrood committees have been scrutinising the draft plan which will be debated by MSPs next week.
Ministers said they would consider all reports before finalising the plan.
Four Holyrood committees - led by Environment, Climate Change and Land Reform - have been scrutinising the Scottish government's draft Climate Change Plan.
In their joint report, the committees recognise that the ambitions are high but says some sectors need to do more to tackle the issue.
The Climate Change plan sets out targets for reducing greenhouse gas emissions for eight different sectors.
Transport and agriculture are two of the biggest contributors to climate change, but the report points out that both have weaker targets than other sectors.
It says the plan does not contain enough detail about how the targets will be met and it calls for more policies to bring about behavioural change rather than so called "techno-fixes".
Environment convener Graeme Dey said: "Scotland has ambitious climate change targets and the Scottish Parliament wants to make sure that plans to reduce emissions are as robust and achievable as possible.
"Our committee feels that it is crucial for all of Scotland's sectors to play their part in reducing emissions.
"Specifically transport and agriculture - which are the biggest contributors in terms of creating harmful carbon emissions - must, in the opinion of the committee, be required to make a greater contribution in tackling climate change.
"In order for Scotland to truly be a world leader, the Scottish government needs to ensure all sectors are equally challenged in creating a climate-friendly, low-carbon Scotland."
The Environment, Climate Change and Land Reform Committee highlighted a range of issues including:
Environmental groups have already criticised some aspects of the plan which they say relies too much on technical solutions like electric vehicles.
The committee said it believed the public's role in bringing about change has also been overlooked.
Mr Dey added: "Not enough emphasis appears to have been placed upon improving everyday habits in order to combat climate change.
"We believe this is a missed opportunity. That's why we've recommended that the science of behaviour change should be included in the final plan, in order to empower the Scottish public to make lifestyle changes that can make a huge difference."
Climate Change Secretary Roseanna Cunningham said the draft plan set out a package of "transformational measures and interventions" across many sectors.
"We have already achieved our 2020 targets six years early, and this is something that we should be proud of," she said.
"This draft plan sets out the real on the ground changes that need to happen across our economy to achieve our ambitious future targets and has been developed to ensure it both meets the climate change targets and is realistic and workable.
"We welcome the publication of the four committee reports as parliamentary scrutiny is an important step in shaping the final plan. We will consider the reports along with submissions that have come directly to us, when finalising the Climate Change Plan and moving into the delivery phase."


Hartlepool United have cancelled the contract of goalkeeper Adam Bartlett, who is to take up a full-time coaching role with Middlesbrough's academy.

Bartlett, 31, made 29 first-team appearances during an 18-month spell at Victoria Park.
The ex-Kidderminster, Hereford and Gateshead player has previously coached in a part-time capacity at Newcastle.
Pools still have keepers Ben Dudzinski, Ryan Catterick, injured Trevor Carson and on-loan Joe Fryer in their squad.
"Everybody at the club would like to wish him all the very best in his new career," the Hartlepool statement read.
Meanwhile, former Bristol City and Wolves goalkeeper Adriano Basso has been appointed as the new goalkeeper coach at Victoria Park.
The 41-year-old left his position at FC United of Manchester to join up with Pools, and was part of Saturday's coaching team for the 2-0 defeat by Wycombe.


The US theme park operator SeaWorld says it is ending its controversial orca breeding programme.

The decision means the orcas currently at the parks will be "the last generation", the company said.
SeaWorld, which has 12 parks across the US, has faced heavy criticism over alleged poor treatment of its captive orcas, also known as killer whales.
Activists have called for the orcas to be released into the wild but SeaWorld claims they would likely die.
"For as long as they live, the orcas at SeaWorld will stay in our parks," the company said in a Los Angeles Times op-ed.
SeaWorld has previously announced that it will phase out live orca shows.
It said on Thursday it would also also scrap plans for a $100 million project called "Blue World" that would have enlarged its orca habitat at SeaWorld San Diego.
California Congressman Adam Schiff, who was behind an act designed to phase out orca captivity, said: "These changes are something that advocates have been urging for years and I think SeaWorld will find that visitors will reward their actions with a renewed interest in the parks."
SeaWorld's shares rose as much as 6% in morning trading following the announcement.
How Harry Styles sent SeaWorld's image diving
SeaWorld admits employees spied on animal rights groups
Dramatic displays by the orcas are the centrepiece of three parks operated by SeaWorld, in California, Florida and Texas.
The Humane Society of the United States (HSUS) worked with SeaWorld on its new policies and said the announcement signalled "that the era of captive display of orcas will end".
Animal rights group Peta told the BBC that SeaWorld should release all its orcas into sea pens or coastal sanctuaries where they can experience "the natural behaviour that they are denied" in the parks.
SeaWorld stopped capturing live marine mammals decades ago, with the majority of its 29 orcas having been born in captivity.
SeaWorld's treatment of orcas was highlighted in the 2013 documentary Blackfish, which focused on a series of violent incidents involving an orca called Tilikum.
The film also raised questions over the ethics of breeding programmes and practices such as the separation of calves from their mothers.
Since the film was released visitor numbers have fallen at Sea World's main theme parks and its share price has halved.
SeaWorld described the film as inaccurate, misleading and exploitative and launched a multi-million dollar marketing campaign to rebuild its reputation.
Blackfish director Gabriela Cowperthwaite was quoted by HSUS as saying the decision to end orca breeding represented "truly meaningful change".


Thousands of fans gathered in London's West End to meet American football stars who have come to play to sell-out crowds in the capital.

The entire shopping area from Regent Street to Piccadilly Circus was closed to all traffic for the NFL fan event.
The event, now in its fourth year, comes ahead of the clash between Jacksonville Jaguars and Indianapolis Colts at Wembley on Sunday.
A game will also be played at Twickenham for the first time.
Organisers have been drumming up interest in the game, since the first NFL International Series game in London during the 2007 season.
Fans met stars from both teams and saw special routines from both teams' cheerleaders, in addition to having a go at throwing and kicking at various interactive games set up for the event.


Four years ago, a group of upper-caste men arrived at Mehul Vinodbhai Kabira's modest two-room home in Gujarat and threatened to burn it down.

Bhayla is a nondescript village of around 450 low slung brick-and-cement homes straddling a highway dotted by pharmaceutical, engineering and bio-tech factories.
Most of the homes in this dense village are owned by land-owning upper castes, but around 70 belong to Dalits (formerly known as untouchables) like Mr Kabira, who form the lowest rung of India's harsh caste hierarchy.
Mr Kabira's crime? He dared to park his newly-bought auto-rickshaw for passengers near the village at the bus stop, which also doubled up as its three-wheeler stand.
His parents worked all their lives as scavengers, collecting manure, but their son had decided to shun the indignity of a lowly caste-based occupation. Instead, he took out a loan and started plying a three-wheeler.
"Most of the auto-rickshaws here are owned by upper-caste men. They couldn't tolerate a Dalit plying his trade at the bus stand. So they beat me up and threatened me," he says.
Mr Kabira did not take any chances. He left the village with his family to live with a relative some 15km (nine miles) away and drove his three-wheeler. When he returned to Bhayla in 2014, he sold off his auto-rickshaw, paid back his loan and signed up as a 217 rupees-a-day ($3; Â£2.40) contract worker in the "housekeeping" - a euphemism for a cleaning job - at a pharmaceutical factory.
A few houses away, Dayabhai Kanabhai Kabira, 42, faced the ire of upper-caste neighbours in a different way. A canny farmer, he had inherited two acres of farm land from his father, and sold it to buy a four-acre plot some 40km away to augment his income.
As his joint family grew, he built a second storey on his tiny plot to accommodate a growing joint family of a dozen people into four-and-a-half crowded rooms. His next door neighbour, an upper-caste farmer who lives in a shiny three-storey house, promptly built a 20ft (6m) high "caste" wall  between the two homes.
"They built the wall so they didn't have to see my face any longer," says Mr Kabira.
Dalit lives have improved in Gujarat - and all over India - and many upper-caste people are finding it difficult to digest this. "Conflict increases where social conditions [for Dalits] may be getting slightly better," says Pratap Bhanu Mehta of the Centre for Policy Research, a leading think-tank.
In the past, conflicts between Dalits and upper castes were restricted to fights over land, wages, water, housing and the practice of untouchability.
But earlier this month, things took a new, devious turn in Gujarat, one of India's most prosperous states, ruled by Prime Minister Narendra Modi's BJP for more than a decade.
A video surfaced showing four Dalit men being assaulted by zealous "cow protection" vigilantes. Their crime was that they were doing their caste job of skinning a dead animal. (Many Hindus consider cows sacred and the slaughter of the animal is banned in many Indian states. There have been attacks across India where Muslims have been accused of eating or smuggling beef.)
A night patrol with India's cow protection vigilantes
Angry Dalits came out in protest and the parliament in Delhi was in uproar. Some 30 Dalits, including women, have tried to take their own lives - and one has died - since the incident.
On Sunday, tens of thousands of community members pledged to boycott some of their traditional tasks, including the disposal of dead animals and manual cleaning of sewers.
However, atrocities against Dalits are nothing new in Gujarat, the birthplace of former India leader Mahatma Gandhi, who waged a campaign against untouchability all his life.
But, as social scientist Ghanshyam Shah says, even Gandhi was helpless when schools in Gujarat set up by organisations owing allegiance to his ideals refused to admit Dalit students. The state saw some of the earliest upper-caste agitations against affirmative action for the Dalits in the 1980s.
Gujarat has only 2.3% of India's 200 million Dalits - 14th most populous state for the community - yet it ranks high in terms of atrocities against them, with more than 1,000 cases of "crimes" against Dalits recorded in 2015.
Between 1990 and 2015, 536 Dalits were murdered in Gujarat and 750 Dalit women raped. The conviction rate is abysmal: suspects in 95 of 100 cases are freed, according to one study. Eleven districts remain officially declared as "atrocity prone" for Dalits since 1981.
"Dalits are protesting. They are asking questions, filing right to information applications, petitioning authorities and quizzing village council heads," says Dalit rights activist Martin Macwan. "Upper castes are getting jittery and the violence continues."
His organisation Navsarjan Trust carried out a four-year-long study - published in 2010 - recording 98 untouchability practices in nearly 1,600 villages in Gujarat.
Most of the findings were startling, for example:
But the recent violence against the Dalits, according to Mr Shah, is rooted in a shrill campaign by radical Hindu groups "telling people what to eat, drink, dress and monitor their behaviour".
Critics say the self-styled "cow protection" vigilantes are running extortion rackets and running amok even as Prime Minister Modi maintains a curious silence.
The agitation in Gujarat may not hurt the BJP in polls much - a third of Dalit voters have voted for the Congress party in the recent past. But, as psephologist Sanjay Kumar says, it might hurt the party's electoral prospects in Uttar Pradesh and Punjab, two states with large Dalit populations and which go to the polls early next year.
"It is a canary in the mine," warns Mr Mehta. "There is deep social conflict bubbling from below."
This cannot be good news for Mr Modi.


More than 80 pharmaceutical companies have called on governments to develop new ways of paying them to develop antibiotics.

In a joint declaration, at the World Economic Forum, they said the value of antibiotics "does not reflect the benefits they bring to society".
In return, they have promised to invest in research and improve access to antibiotics around the world.
Signatories include GSK, Merck, Pfizer and Johnson & Johnson.
There have been repeated warnings the world is on the cusp of a "post-antibiotic era", raising the prospect of untreatable infections.
It would be a world in which surgery and cancer therapies, reliant on antibiotics, would be under threat.
Drug-resistant microbes are predicted to kill 10 million people a year by 2050 and cost $100 trillion in lost economic output.
Yet there has not been a new class of antibiotic brought to market, against Gram negative bacteria, for more than four decades.
The declaration says the current approach has "largely failed" despite the investment of billions of dollars.
It also sites the "formidable" scientific challenges that have led to many pharmaceutical companies pulling out of antibiotic research.
One of the biggest issues is money - at the moment, a company is paid only for the drugs it sells.
Yet any new antibiotic would probably be used only as a last resort, so companies would not recover the development costs.
A report by economist Jim O'Neill had suggested lump-sum payments should be given to companies that created proven new antibiotics, estimating the cost to governments would be $16-37bn over the next decade.
The declaration, from 85 companies, calls "for governments to commit funding and support the development and implementation of transformational commercial models that enhance conservation of new and existing antibiotics" as well as creating a "sustainable and predictable" market for new drugs.
AstraZeneca chief executive Pascal Soriot said: "The declaration's call for collaborative action on new commercial models is timely.
"Industry is ready to engage with governments to develop alternative market structures to enable the sustainable investment that is necessary if we are to overcome the formidable technical and scientific challenges of antibiotic discovery and development."
Redx Pharma Plc chief executive Neil Murray said: "There is a doomsday clock ticking, with the effectiveness of antibiotics diminishing at an alarming rate.
"New ways must be found to support innovation and drug discovery in this critical area."
World Health Organization director general Dr Margaret Chan said: "Antimicrobial resistance is beyond the capacity of any organisation or country to manage or mitigate alone.
"WHO and its member states have called for the development of new antimicrobial medicines and affordable access to them, in line with the global action plan on antimicrobial resistance.
"This declaration affirms that the challenges of antimicrobial resistance can be addressed only through collaboration and global collective action."
Follow James on Twitter.


More than 150,000 people in Paraguay, Argentina, Uruguay and Brazil have been driven from their homes by some of the worst flooding in years.

Heavy summer rains have caused rivers to swell across a vast area.
In Paraguay, the most affected country, President Horacio Cartes declared a state of emergency, freeing up $3.5m (Â£2.3m) in relief funds.
The Paraguay river in the capital, Asuncion, is just 30cm (12in) away from overtopping its banks.
That could lead to widespread flooding in the Asuncion area.
And it could affect thousands of other people who live by the Paraguay - the country's main river - the authorities said.
Nearly 200 electricity pylons have been damaged or destroyed by strong winds.
Four people were killed in the country by fallen trees.
In northern Argentina, some 20,000 people have been evacuated.
At least two people have died in the floods, which have mostly affected the provinces of Entre Rios, Corrientes and Chaco.
In the southern Brazilian state of Rio Grande do Sul, nearly 1,800 families in dozens of towns had been forced to leave their homes.
Heavy rain began to fall in the region on 18 December, swelling the Uruguay and Quarai rivers.
South of the Brazilian border, in Uruguay, thousands of people have been made homeless in the past few days.
But most of them have now returned home.
Dry weather is forecast for the Brazilian-Uruguayan border region in the next few days, but in Paraguay and Argentina water levels are still expected to rise.


At least 13 people have died in a fire that broke out at a garment factory in the northern Indian city of Ghaziabad.

Police said three people also suffered injuries and were receiving treatment.
The fire started at 4:30am (local time), most likely due to an electrical fault, and it took several hours for the fire brigade to bring the blaze under control, they added.
Fires break out regularly in small factories around the country due to poor maintenance and safety measures.
Local police spokesperson Bhagwat Singh told the AFP news agency that the workers were sleeping when the fire broke out in the factory in Ghaziabad, a Delhi suburb.
The factory reportedly manufactures leather jackets.


Republican White House hopeful Donald Trump has said he would stop cash sent home by Mexicans based in the US, until the country pays for a border wall.

The prospect of losing a vital source of income would force Mexico into a "one-time payment" of $5-10bn (Â£3.5-7bn), says Mr Trump.
But US President Barack Obama said the plan was "half-baked" and unworkable.
Mr Trump made his remarks as voters in Wisconsin go the polls to pick their presidential candidates in each party.
The vote could reshape the Republican race, with front-runner Mr Trump, who has never held elected office, facing a strong challenge from Texas Senator Ted Cruz.
In a memo to the Washington Post, the businessman says he would threaten to change a law to cut off cash transfers.
Building a border wall with Mexico has been a core message of Mr Trump's campaign since day one, when he said there were rapists, drug addicts and criminals coming across the border.
If Donald Trump isn't the 2016 Republican presidential nominee - if some time between now and the end of the party convention in late July the prize slips from his grasp, Wisconsin could be where it all started to go awry.
At this point it's conventional wisdom that Mr Trump has had a terrible week on the campaign trail.
His top aide was indicted for accosting a reporter. He stumbled when trying to answer questions about abortion, angering both the left and the right. Wisconsin's popular Republican Governor Scott Walker endorsed his opponent, Ted Cruz. And Mr Trump saw his lead in this pivotal mid-western state evaporate.
By Sunday evening, at a rally in a half-full downtown Milwaukee theatre, the front-runner was showing signs of frustration. He mocked his opponents in the #neverTrump movement, which has vowed to fight the New Yorker to the July Republican convention and beyond.
Is it all going wrong for Trump in Wisconsin?
The wall plan has been widely condemned by, among others, Pope Francis. Mr Trump has also pledged to deport all 11 million undocumented migrants.
The Mexican central bank said that money sent home from overseas hit nearly $24.8bn last year, more than its oil revenues.
In dismissing the plan, Mr Obama said it would cause the Mexican economy to collapse, sending even more migrants north to find work in the US.
"This is another example of something that's not thought through and put forward for political consumption," he said.
The law Mr Trump wishes to change, as outlined in his memo, is part of the US Patriot Act - he would stop anyone living illegally in the US from sending money overseas.
Just the threat of enacting this would make Mexico "immediately protest," the Trump memo reads, and they would be compelled to pay for the wall.
He also proposed raising visa fees and cancelling visas for Mexicans.
If Mr Cruz wins in Wisconsin, as polls suggest, it will help him close the gap on Mr Trump in the all-important delegate count.
Delegates represent their states at the party's convention in July and are accumulated by the votes in each state.
A Wisconsin defeat would make it is far less likely that Mr Trump will have the 1,237 delegates needed to secure the nomination.
If he falls short, his unpopularity with sections of his party means he could be deprived of the nomination at the summer convention.
Currently, Mr Trump has 735 delegates, Mr Cruz 461 and Ohio Governor John Kasich 143.
Democratic voters are also voting in Wisconsin, with Hillary Clinton facing a strong challenge from Vermont Senator Bernie Sanders after his string of wins.


England's education system is failing to meet the country's long-term economic needs and requires a radical overhaul, a report warns.

A group of academics and business leaders says a new cross-party body should set long-term educational goals protected from the electoral cycle.
They also want more emphasis on team working and problem-solving, and a baccalaureate system at A-level.
But the Department for Education said it was equipping pupils for the future.
"The secondary curriculum must support the economic strategy of the country" is the opening sentence of the first of 13 recommendations made in the report.
It calls for a new independent body to oversee the development of the curriculum in England, made up of teachers, employers, academics and representatives from the political parties.
It says the body would provide "consistency" and be able to take a strategic view rather than just concentrating on the electoral cycle.
The group points out that, on average, education secretaries have remained in post for two years over the past 25-year period.
The report, Making Education Work, follows a six-month review of England's education system by an independent advisory group, made up of prominent business leaders and chaired by an academic, Prof Sir Roy Anderson.
Among its wide-ranging conclusions is a recommendation for a broader curriculum at A-level, which should be gradually changed to a European-style baccalaureate system to include the study of English, maths and the Extended Project qualification.
The group wants more emphasis on "team working, emotional maturity, empathy and other interpersonal skills", which it says are "as important as proficiency in English and mathematics in ensuring young people's employment prospects".
Sir Roy Anderson emphasised the need for a long-term view, saying: "Successful businesses have clear objectives and goals which they pursue consistently over time, yet changes in government make it difficult to achieve this for education".
"This new independent advisory group on the curriculum will build on the current government's efforts to bring in a more diverse range of experts and experience into the education system, and create a long-term vision for us to work together towards the interests of young people," he added.
Sir Michael Rake, the chairman of BT who is also CBI president, is a member of the group.
He believes the current system has failed to meet the country's economic needs.
"Over the last 25 years and longer there have been multiple initiatives from different secretaries of state which have not achieved the necessary improvement in educational standards," he said.
"It is therefore time to establish a cross-party apolitical approach to education to move on from our narrow outdated focus with A-levels, and to improve on the other competencies necessary for success, including the fundamental need to improve the basic skills of literacy and numeracy, which are at an unacceptably low level."
But the Department for Education said its "new curriculum" had been developed after "extensive consultation with a wide range of experts".
"Alongside wider reform to GCSEs, A-levels and vocational qualifications this will mean young people leave school with the skills and qualifications they need to secure a job, apprenticeship or university place," a spokesperson added.
"As this week's results show, our plan to fix the education system is working and helping ensure all our children have a secure and prosperous future."
The DfE also points out that its new Tech Level qualifications have been endorsed by leading international companies, and lead to recognised professions including engineering, accounting, IT and construction.
The Association of School and College Leaders, which represents head teachers, gave the report an enthusiastic welcome.
The association's general secretary, Brian Lightman, said it had been calling for a similar approach for some time.
"Countries that do consistently well in international comparisons, like Singapore, have a long-term plan for their education service that rises above political considerations and is not driven by the electoral cycle," he said, "and there is no reason why England should not be able to do the same."
It was also welcomed by Mary Bousted from the Association of Teachers and Lecturers.
"Teachers have long despaired of politicians trying to make their mark by turning the curriculum 180-degrees every few years," she said.
She also welcomed the report's stress on the importance of empathy and emotional maturity.
"Education should not just be about turning out effective employees, but also about developing young people to have caring relationships and to be questioning citizens."


UKIP's manifesto is the party's big opportunity to get away from the tag of being a one-trick pony on immigration.

It has always said the document would be fully costed and provide a rounded set of proposals covering the main aspects of government.
There is a UK manifesto and a shorter Welsh version, which is fifteen pages of direct bullet points. It's the kind of easily-digestible length that can be read over a cup of coffee.
The two main themes are, of course, a withdrawal from the EU (UKIP would hold a referendum as soon as possible) and dealing with concerns over immigration (for the record the latest figure we have for annual net migration in Wales is 6,500).
Arguably, the most significant result of the emergence of UKIP in recent years has been the fact that all of the parties are now addressing immigration in a way they have never done in previous general elections.
UKIP says there should be no immigration for unskilled jobs for five years and immigrants should only gain access to the NHS and welfare after five years of paying tax.
A key question is whether pledges like these give them enough of a point of difference, when the other parties are offering variations on the same theme.
The big policy for Wales is a pledge to make up any loss in regional aid it would suffer as a result of a UK withdrawal from the EU.
This deals with a question journalists always put to the UKIP leader in Wales, Nathan Gill, that Wales will inevitably lose out because it is a net beneficiary of being in the EU.
Dealing with concerns over immigration is something that filters its way through the entire manifesto.
On housing, for example, social housing would only be available to those with local connections, and the various government schemes set up to help those get onto the property ladder would also only be available to British people.
There's also some populist measures, such as re-instating weekly bin collections and things like "provide best value for money for council tax payers by cutting council costs".
Housing and local government are devolved but, like the other parties, the manifesto is full of policies that apply at a Westminster and a devolved level.
On the deficit, it speaks about the irresponsibility of leaving national debts to our children and our grandchildren.
UKIP has pledged to raise the level at which you start to pay income tax to £13,000 and raise the level at which you start to pay the 40% rate to £55,000, as well as to abolish inheritance tax.
It will be paid for as a result of savings from not being in the EU, scrapping HS2 and cutting back on funding to Scotland.
The question is whether there's enough of an overall vision from UKIP to attract voters in sufficient numbers to break through in the UK's first past the post electoral system.
In Wales, it's going to be difficult to see UKIP picking up any seats, but nevertheless its impact in constituencies such as the Vale of Glamorgan could be decisive.


Pau have signed ex-Scotland prop Euan Murray on a two-year contract following their promotion to the French Top 14.

The 34-year-old had spent a season back with Glasgow Warriors but has left the Pro12 champions and retired from international rugby with Scotland.
Pau coach Simon Mannix said: "He knows the highest level of the game and will be a bonus for our pack."
Murray earned 66 caps despite his refusal to play on Sundays because of his Christian beliefs.
He spoke in May of his hopes of staying at Scotstoun, but he was not involved in Warriors' Pro12 semi-final and final squads and now exits Gregor Townsend's squad.
Murray, a British and Irish Lion who is Scotland's most-capped prop, played for Glasgow for four years from 2003 and made 86 appearances.
He told Warriors' website: "Returning to the club and the city after almost seven years away, it's incredible to see how much the Warriors have developed both on and off the field.
"There's a special culture that exists at Scotstoun and I'm honoured to have been a part of the title-winning squad this season."
"I would like to thank everyone at Glasgow Warriors who have helped with my development and career."
The Scot, who has also played for Northampton, Newcastle, Agen and Worcester, joins two All Blacks - fly-half Colin Slade and centre Conrad Smith - in joining the promoted club.
The New Zealand duo will arrive at the club in the Pyrenees-Atlantiques region after the Rugby World Cup.
Pau have also guaranteed the services of France lock Julien Pierre, Fiji winger Mosese Ratuvou and prop Chris King, a New Zealander.
Warriors head coach Gregor Townsend added: "Euan has made a big impact at the club over his two spells here and his vast experience has been a great addition to the squad this season.
"He has always played with commitment and continues to be one of the best props in the game in the contact area.
"As a Glasgow man, he always pulls on the jersey with pride and that passion really shines through when he is representing the city and the fans.
"We wish him and his family all the best in France."


The twin brother of the police officer shot and blinded by Raoul Moat said he would carry on the work of his charity.

PC David Rathband was found dead by police at his home in Blyth, Northumberland, on Wednesday night.
His brother Darren flew back from Australia and on Saturday, he was at the weekly Newcastle Parkrun, which his brother took part in.
He said he would continue the work of the Blue Lamp Foundation, which his brother set up.
Runners in the 5km run at Newcastle's Exhibition Park held a minute's silence to remember PC Rathband
The police officer, originally from Stafford, set up his charity after he was shot twice by Moat in Newcastle in July 2010.
It aims to help emergency service staff injured in the line of duty and the target is to raise Â£1million by 2013.
In a post on Twitter, Mr Rathband said: "Makes me weep reading all your messages, broken but determined to keep David's foundation growing for others. Please help me."
In other posts, he asks people to support the Blue Lamp Foundation.
PC Rathband was hailed for his charity work and took part in a number of fundraising events including last year's London Marathon.
Following news of his death, many people paid tribute to him including Prime Minister David Cameron, former Home Secretary David Blunkett and Northumbria Police Chief Constable Sue Sim.
On Friday, the inquest into PC Rathband's death heard he was found hanged.


"Poohsticks" is what you might call entry-level hydrology.

Drop twigs over a bridge on the upstream side and then race over to the downstream side to see which bits of wood appear first.
Good fun, for sure, but the scientist in you may also learn something about stream behaviour.
This is essentially what Delft University of Technology's Thom Bogaard and Rolf Hut have been doing in Myanmar. Together with local students, they've been playing a kind of poohsticks on the Irrawaddy River... with coconuts.
Their aim has been to understand how this mighty watercourse moves, how it mixes, how it might disperse and dilute pollution if faced with such a problem.
In the West, scientists would resort to all sorts of fancy, high-end equipment that costs hundreds, even thousands, of dollars. "But this is Myanmar; they can't afford that," said Dr Bogaard. "They have no information on water quality at the moment. They know a bit about sediment, but that's it. So, we decided to use citizen science to see how far we could go to get basic data."
Start with 300 coconuts. Attach them to coloured balloons that also contain a small bicycle light for visibility at night; and then just throw them in the river.
The density of a coconut is almost one, which means it sits submerged at the surface of the water and is driven by the current alone, not the wind. It's the perfect, low-cost ("off the tree", even edible) scientific drifter.
Those dropped in the middle of the Irrawaddy will in all likelihood move the fastest; those near the bank will very probably move the slowest. "And what you do is position your student teams on bridges and watch them pass by,â€


Derby County chairman Mel Morris has become the club's sole owner after buying out the American ownership group for an undisclosed fee.

The Derby-born businessman took a 22% stake in the Rams in May 2014 and became chairman in May this year.
"I hope together we can help steer this club into a sustainable place in the Premier League," Morris said.
Morris first joined the Rams' board in 2006 and has become increasingly involved since returning as a director.
Derby narrowly missed out on promotion from the Championship when they lost the 2014 play-off final against Queens Park Rangers and fell just short of making the play-offs last term after a poor end-of-season run.
Former Real Madrid assistant Paul Clement was appointed as manager in the close season and Morris said "many of the key components were in place" to help the Rams return to the top flight.
But he said: "I am conscious that we must all commit our total support in pursuit of this goal, which I know is shared by all of us.
"I wish to pay tribute to the North American ownership group [North American Derby Partners LLP], who collectively provided the finance and leadership stability the club needed following the traumatic times which followed the 2007/8 season in the Premier League.
"They have been terrific to work with, and I am sure they will continue to follow the Rams well into the future."


Huddersfield Town winger Joe Lolley has extended his contract at the John Smith's Stadium until June 2019.

The 23-year-old joined the Terriers from non-league Kidderminster Harriers in January 2014.
Lolley, who spent time on loan at Scunthorpe this season, has scored six goals in 38 league games for Town.
Head coach David Wagner said: "Joe is a very good talent; he has good mobility, he's technically very good and can make a difference in a game one-on-one."