A month ago, the first of a group of more than 200 schoolgirls kidnapped from Chibok was freed in north-eastern Nigeria after two years in the hands of Islamist militant group Boko Haram.

The girl gained widespread coverage when she was taken to meet President Muhammadu Buhari.
Her brother, who was overwhelmed to be reunited with his sister, was told to return home by state officials during the visit and says he now has no idea of the whereabouts of her or their mother, who accompanied them.
Yakubu Nkeki, a spokesman for the parents of the missing Chibok schoolgirls, and a close friend of the girl, says he has known her since childhood and he too hasn't had contact with her since her visit to meet the president.
He told the BBC how, after she was first released, they sat together for hours and she recounted her ordeal from the very beginning.
While describing how she was taken from her school in Chibok town, she laughed, something Mr Nkeki says he found very out of place.
"After they were taken from the school," he tells me, "they were put in one place as a large group but after a few weeks they were taken further into the Sambisa Forest. There, some of the larger girls were forced to marry the militants, but at that time she was not given up for marriage because she was seen as a small girl."
She was terrified at the thought of being forced to marry someone she did not know or love but she was also relieved that she had been spared.
She spoke of the many military airstrikes on the Boko Haram fighters which meant the group had to move around often to avoid detection. The girls were then split into smaller groups and moved to different locations.
She was in a group of about six girls, and they were taken to a big building surrounded by a large fence without an entrance.
"They had to climb over with a ladder to get in but once in they had no way of getting out again," Mr Nkeki said.
"By this time, the girls had been mixed up with other girls who had been captured. They could not understand each other because they all spoke different languages."
She said that after about six months in the building, her worst fears came true when she was forced to marry one of the Boko Haram militants. The man told her that he had also been abducted from the town of Mubi and fored to become a fighter.
The building didn't have any food in it apart from a large bag of maize which they soaked in water and then ate raw. Later they found a large stone which they used to grind the maize and for vegetables, they opted for leaves from the trees.
Soon afterwards, the men started going out to raid other villages for food, cooking utensils and household items.
She told Mr Nkeki that one day the group heard a loud blast outside. It was an explosion that made a huge hole in the fence and some of the girls saw a chance to escape and ran into the thick forest nearby.
This was not a good move because many Boko Haram militants were camped there and many of those who ran away were eventually caught.
Now married to one of the militants, she said she could not escape. She said she feared she would never see her mother again and whenever she was alone she would spend up to an hour on her knees, praying that she would be rescued.
Although she told her captors that she had accepted their religion, inwardly she held on to her Christian faith.
She knew what could happen to her if she did otherwise, as she had witnessed the gruesome killing of another girl for refusing to convert to Islam.  The militants buried her waist-deep in the ground and the other captives were made to stone her to death.
"Boko Haram drove them to another part of Sambisa Forest," continues Mr Nkeki. "The girl lived with her husband and he found grass to make a thatched shelter for them in the forest.
Now there were only three Chibok girls left in the group because the other three were lost, possibly killed in military attacks. She said that in that area there were many groups of militant fighters and large numbers of women and children with them.
There were more airstrikes and many of the Boko Haram fighters were killed so her husband said he was no longer willing to continue fighting. By this time she had had a baby. That's when she and her husband decided to escape.
She had gained trust in him, believed he wasn't like the other Boko Haram members and she became confident enough to leave with him. They walked for two days before arriving in a village called Bali.
This was their first contact with the outside world, free from Boko Haram control.
The villagers there were mostly women and children and her husband, who was the only young man around, looked out of place.
He became afraid of being caught so he decided to go and hide in the bush. They stayed in the area for two to three weeks until some vigilantes arrived and asked her if there were any people who had just arrived in the village. She told them she was among the girls taken from Chibok.
She also told them where her husband was hiding, so they took them and the baby to her home and she could finally see her family again.
"Mum, is this really you?" she cried as she was reunited with her mother.
Nineteen other parents did not live to see if their own girls would also be freed, some died in Boko Haram attacks and others from suspected stress-related complications.
The girl is believed to now be undergoing rehabilitation and debriefing sessions with intelligence agencies to help provide them with information. She has asked them not to harm her husband, as she considers him a good man.
Military spokesman General Rabe Abubakar said she was being well looked after.
"Nobody is hiding anybody, we have to safeguard her and give her all the necessary security to recuperate well. As soon as everything is sorted out, she will be made accessible," he told the Associated Press.
Since being rescued, the girl has had little access to the outside world, so right now she might not have the freedom she anticipated but after two years in the hands of Boko Haram, it is freedom nonetheless.
Inside Mbalala, the town that lost its girls
Chibok abductions: What we know
On patrol in the Sambisa forest
Torment of a freed Boko Haram 'bride'
Who are Boko Haram?


The drug industry is going to court to challenge the authority of the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (Nice).

The public body authorises spending by the NHS on expensive new treatments.
In March it announced a new policy to hold back spending on new drugs that might cost more than £20m a year in any of their first three years of use.
Now, the Association of the British Pharmaceutical Industry (ABPI) will challenge this via a Judicial Review.
The ABPI's chief executive, Mike Thompson, said: "These new arrangements will delay access to cost-effective medicines and deny treatments to patients suffering from rare diseases."
"After many months of raising concerns with Nice, NHS England and the Department of Health and offering to work constructively on alternative proposals, we have applied to formally challenge these proposals in court," he said.
"We hope that the government will reverse the changes and work with us to find a solution that works for everyone," he added.
Are NHS patients getting the best medicines?
NHS to introduce £20 cap on new drugs
Nice said it had no comment to make yet on the threat of a legal challenge.
But in April it explained that the point of the new system was not to place an absolute cap on spending on any new drug, but to stop new drugs suddenly hoovering up large chunks of the NHS budget to the detriment of other health services such as general practice or psychiatry.
"When the impact on budgets is very high, it makes sense for special arrangements to be put in place so that the NHS can manage the introduction of new drugs in a way that doesn't impact unfairly on other services," Nice said at the time.
The new system therefore allows for Nice and NHS England to negotiate with drug companies to persuade them to drop the cost of their new medicines if they look likely to breach the initial £20m-a-year limit.
If agreement cannot be reached, then the use of the new medicine will be phased in by the NHS in England - potentially over three years - instead of being made universally available for doctors to prescribe within the normal 90 days of the drug's formal introduction.
The ABPI said the new approach would affect one-in-five of all new approved medicines.
The trade body described the way Nice assessed drugs for very rare diseases as "inappropriate and unworkable" and wants the policy reversed.


A section of water pipe which flooded homes in West Lothian after bursting twice in less than a week will not be brought back into use.

About 20 homes were affected by flooding in the Wester Inch estate, Bathgate, on 24 and 27 February.
The 27in (69cm) water pipe served more than 25,000 properties across Bathgate, Blackburn and Livingston.
Scottish Water said it would answer questions at a public meeting in the area on Sunday.
Mark McEwen, Scottish Water's customer service general manager, said: "We have established after detailed analysis and significant changes that we can operate the local water supply network in future without the need to use this particular section of water pipe.
"We also plan to invest in other areas of the water supply network to ensure continuity of supply in the wider West Lothian area.
"We will keep customers updated on our plans, but in the meantime can confirm that the section of water pipe where these bursts occurred will not be used again."


A man has been arrested by police investigating a report of a man armed with a knife attempting to force his way into a man's home in north Down.

Officers were called to an address at Fort Terrace shortly before 06:00 BST.
During a search, police said they found a car linked to the suspect with a drunk woman inside.  They forced open the car and found a "machete-type" knife in the vehicle.
A short time later, police arrested a 31-year-old man who remains in custody.
A police spokeswoman said the woman is "believed to have willingly travelled to the area in the vehicle as a passenger and is not suspected of involvement in any alleged crime at present".


Democratic presidential nominee Hillary Clinton has said Donald Trump incited violence when he said gun rights supporters could stop her from winning.

Speaking at a rally in Des Moines, Iowa, Mrs Clinton said "words can have tremendous consequences."
Republican nominee Mr Trump sparked a backlash after suggesting "Second Amendment people", or gun owners, could take action against her.
Mrs Clinton also said Mr Trump did not have the temperament to be president.
The former secretary of state criticised Mr Trump for his recent row with the family of a fallen American Muslim soldier, which the military refers to as a Gold Star family.
"Yesterday we witnessed the latest in the long line of casual comments from Donald Trump that cross the line. His casual cruelty to a Gold Star family, his casual suggestion that more countries should have nuclear weapons. And now his casual inciting of violence," she said.
"Every single one of these incidents shows that Donald Trump simply does not have the temperament to be president and commander in chief of the United States.
Mr Trump was speaking at a rally in North Carolina on Tuesday when he said Mrs Clinton would put liberal justices on the Supreme Court if she wins the presidency.
Fear and anger in Trump-land
The Republican nominee suggested her liberal nominations would threaten gun ownership rights when he said: "Hillary wants to abolish, essentially abolish the Second Amendment. By the way, and if she gets to pick her judges, nothing you can do, folks.
"But the Second Amendment people, maybe there is, I don't know."
Social media users swiftly responded, condemning Mr Trump for appearing to incite violence.
Mr Trump dismissed the claims, tweeting that he was trying to unify gun rights supporters to turn out to vote to defeat Mrs Clinton.
His campaign said: "Second Amendment people have amazing spirit and are tremendously unified, which gives them great political power."
"And this year, they will be voting in record numbers, and it won't be for Hillary Clinton, it will be for Donald Trump."
Meanwhile, former Nato Secretary General Anders Fogh Rasmussen said a victory for Mr Trump in the November election would undermine the credibility of the US.
A Trump presidency would signal the end of "the American-led world order", Mr Rasmussen - a former Danish prime minister who was Nato chief between 2009 and 2014 - told the Politico website.
Mr Trump has criticised US interventions abroad, notably in Syria, and has been accused of isolationist tendencies.


Here's how the BBC's 2015 Price of Football calculator and survey were compiled.

The Price of Football surveys the cost of the cheapest and most expensive match-day and season tickets, as well as the cost of a pie, programme, cup of tea and adult and junior replica shirts.
The calculator helps you navigate through this data with ease.
Simply enter the name of your club and you'll have all the key data presented and put into context for you.
In addition you can work out how much support of your team is costing you. Simply enter your ticket cost, food, drink and programme spend, plus how many replica shirts you buy and the amount you pay on TV sports subscriptions. The calculator will then compare that to a number of costs, such as player wages, transfer fees and other leisure pursuits.
Throughout the calculator, we compare how various costs have changed using data from previous BBC Price of Football studies.
Some data comparisons are not available for clubs not included in previous years.
The 'price of a goal' is calculated by dividing the cost of a club's cheapest season ticket last season by the number of goals scored by the team at home in the same season.
Some comparisons are not available for clubs not surveyed last season, or promoted to the National League.
Programme costs were not collected from European clubs, as many do not publish match-day programmes in the same way as UK teams.
The BBC contacted 227 clubs for the study. Of those, 200 were in England, Scotland, Northern Ireland and Wales and another 27 in Europe.
The data was collated and verified by BBC Sport journalists.
Swansea are omitted from the survey and calculator because they declined to take part.
All ticket prices refer to an adult ticket when bought individually.
The match-day ticket prices quoted refer to high and low prices available on the day of a game, to reflect the price for fans who decide on match day they would like to attend a game, and not individual offers.
Match-day costs reflect categories that are registered with the relevant league, rather than individual, or one-off, offers.
The season ticket prices quoted refer to the cheapest possible ticket (including early bird offers), and the most expensive season ticket.
Replica shirt prices are listed according to the official cost in the club shop or website - rather than separate retailers.


A US firefighter has been praised for giving a dog 20 minutes of "mouth-to-snout" resuscitation after the animal was rescued from a house fire.

The dog was overcome by the heat and smoke of the blaze in Santa Monica, California, and was unresponsive.
But firefighter Andrew Klein managed to bring 10-year-old Nalu, a Bichon Frise/Shih Tzu, "back from the dead".
Mr Klein discovered Nalu unconscious in a back bedroom after crawling on all fours into the blazing apartment
"He was totally lifeless," the firefighter told the Associated Press news agency. "I picked him up and ran out of the apartment because time is key, especially with a small dog... Failure was not an option.''
As the dog's distraught owner Crystal Lamirande knelt crying nearby, Mr Klein and his crew spent the next 20 minutes giving the dog oxygen and performing "mouth-to-snout" resuscitation.
"After 20 minutes, the dog began breathing on its own and regained consciousness, even regaining the ability to walk around," the Santa Monica Fire Department said in a press release.
Nalu has now fully recovered after spending 24 hours in an oxygen tent.
Ms Lamirande, a radiology nurse, said she was overwhelmed by the effort made by Mr Klein and his team to save her dog.
"His eyes were glazed over and he was not breathing and I assumed he was dead," she said. "But the firefighter said 'I'm a positive person. Let's just get him back'."


Paralympic champion Aled Davies improved his own shot put world record at the British Indoor Championships in Sheffield.

The 24-year-old Welshman, who competes in the F42 category, managed 16.14m with his penultimate throw against his able-bodied rivals, finishing fifth.
It beat his previous best of 15.93m set at last year's championships.
Davies is aiming to compete in the shot at the Rio Paralympics after his discus event was removed from the competition.
The Bridgend man, who has limited functionality of his right leg with missing bones and no muscle or ligament growth, took gold in the discus at London 2012 and bronze in the shot and is the current European and world champion in both events.


How can a sport that generates more than £1.1bn per year in revenues have teams at the back of the grid desperately struggling to make ends meet?

That is the question hanging over Formula 1 after both Marussia and Caterham went into administration, leaving the grid with only 18 cars - the lowest number for nine years.
In many ways, though, it is the wrong question. After all, football generates much more money, yet leading clubs still get themselves into financial trouble.
But there is no doubt F1 faces tough times, and the central talking point is whether the money is being shared in the right way.
Other smaller teams, such as Sauber, Force India and Lotus, are struggling to survive, while larger ones live in a different world, of budgets of hundreds of millions of pounds, underwritten by huge global companies.
Is it sustainable?
Not according to the smaller teams, whose frustrations at the situation boiled over into anger at last weekend's US Grand Prix, with Force India's deputy team principal Bob Fernley saying they were considering boycotting the race in protest.
That was never likely to happen, and although the word boycott is still being bandied about, it isn't likely to in the future either.
Nevertheless, most in F1 recognise the sport is at a crossroads, and there are demands for the money to be redistributed more equitably. Talks are ongoing.
So where does F1's money go?
Unsurprisingly, the big ones. Red Bull and Ferrari both have budgets in the region of £250m a year, perhaps a little less in Red Bull's case and a little more in Ferrari's. Mercedes' and McLaren's are a little less - at just under £200m.
But in the case of both Mercedes and Ferrari, that figure does not count the money they spend on manufacturing engines, for their works teams and their customers.
In Mercedes' case, that is another £140m or so.
There is then a yawning chasm to the rest of the grid - with Lotus operating on something like £130m, and Williams, Force India, Toro Rosso and Sauber about the £100m mark, a little more or a little less depending on the team.
Marussia and Caterham were reputedly getting by - or not, as the case turned out to be - on £70m and £60m respectively.
Some teams are secretive about their finances, so some of these numbers are estimates, albeit informed ones.
The teams' incomes are made up of two main revenue streams - prize money from the commercial rights holders, and the teams' sponsorship deals.
Of F1's £1.1bn income, 63% goes to the teams, the rest to boost the profits of the commercial rights holders (CRH). The main shareholder is a venture capital group called CVC Capital Partners; various banks and investment companies also hold shares.
The contracts that define how the teams get paid are confidential and each team has its own commercial deal with the CRH.
However, this is believed to be how it works. Bear with me, because it might make your head hurt.
Just under half (47.5%) of the profit - about £500m in the last year of results - is split in half.
One half is divided equally between the top 10 teams as defined by their results over the previous three seasons; the other is split between the top 10 from the previous year alone, with each position receiving a given percentage. The higher up you finished in the constructors' championship, the more money you get.
Media playback is not supported on this device
There is also a separate pot called the constructors' championship bonus (CCB), which is about £187.5m and split between Ferrari, Red Bull and McLaren, with Ferrari earning by far the most.
In addition, the two other teams deemed historically important and who also have permanent places on the rule-making F1 strategy group - Mercedes and Williams - each get payments of just over £18.8m.
And £6.25m is given to each team not in the top 10 but competing in the championship.
On top of that, before any money is divided up, Ferrari receive a bonus just for being in the championship, on the basis of the value their presence is perceived to give the sport.
That is worth 5% of the revenues - 2.5% of the promoter's share and 2.5% from the teams' pot. This is about £56.25m this year.
As you can see from the structure above, yes, but with an important exception.
Ferrari look like they will finish fourth in the constructors' championship this season.
But the structure of the rest of their contract means they will earn more money from F1's income than Williams, who are on course for third, and possibly Red Bull, who will be second.
How long is a piece of string? It depends on the level of the team's ambition.
To have any realistic hope of winning races consistently and challenging for the championship, a team needs an income of at least £200m.
But if you marshal your money wisely, put together an exceptional and well-focused group of people and have the right engine and drivers, it is possible to be competitive - in terms of qualifying in the first two or three rows and having a hope of perhaps snatching the odd win - on half that.
Williams are proving that this year, as did Lotus in 2012 and 2013.
But the lack of resources of those teams mean that achieving this alchemy is very hard (just look at Force India, who have the same Mercedes engine as Williams) and keeping it going is also very difficult (see how Lotus have plummeted this season as a result of a lack of investment/budget shortfalls in 2013).
And lots of money is no guarantee of success if your technical department does a bad job - hence McLaren's appalling form of 2013 and 2014 after winning seven races in 2012.
They most probably will be if they are in F1 for any length of time, but not necessarily in the way you might imagine.
The very best are paid huge salaries and are rich beyond their wildest dreams.
Lewis Hamilton's salary at Mercedes is £19.3m per year plus bonuses. Fernando Alonso is reputed to earn well over £15m - and possibly as much as £21m - from Ferrari.
Sebastian Vettel will not be far behind, if at all. And Jenson Button is on a reputed £12.5m at McLaren, possibly more. Daniel Ricciardo won't be there yet, but the way he has driven this year means he will surely soon join that elite group.
World-class talents such as these earn these sorts of sums for years on end, guaranteeing a sumptuous lifestyle for the rest of their lives.
But, just as with the teams, the chasm down to the next level is huge.
The second level of drivers - the likes of Romain Grosjean, Nico Hulkenberg and so on - will be on a few million.
Newer recruits, even those there on the basis of talent alone and in established teams, will earn less again. Valtteri Bottas, for example, is believed to be on a couple of million at Williams; Kevin Magnussen a few hundred thousand at McLaren.
And then, reflecting the financial troubles of the smaller teams as a whole, there is a substantial number of drivers who pay for their seats, although they all earn a salary of varying sizes out of that figure.
The biggest payer is Pastor Maldonado, who takes a budget of £30m to Lotus - as he did to Williams in 2011-2013 - courtesy of his backers, the Venezuelan state oil company.
Swede Marcus Ericsson, who bought his way into F1 with Caterham this year, has earned a Sauber drive for 2015 on the back of a reputed £15.7m budget from his personal sponsors.
The struggling Swiss team are expected to make a decision about who drives their second car based largely on the funds he can bring as well, with their Dutch reserve driver Giedo van der Garde tipped for the seat.
Of the current grid, at least five drivers owe their positions to financial backing in one way or another.
And if Marussia and Caterham still existed, that number would climb to nine - although in Jules Bianchi's case, he is at Marussia at the behest of Ferrari, who provide the team with engines.
As ever in F1, money makes the wheels turn. And without it, everything comes to a juddering halt.


Gap Connah's Quay are into the Europa League second qualifying round after beating Norwegian side Stabæk 1-0.

The Welsh Premier League side were held to a goalless draw in the first leg, but Callum Morris' first-half winner in Fredrikstad secured a famous victory in the club's first European campaign.
Both sides later had players red carded as Stabæk's Kamal Issah and the Nomads' John Disney were sent off.
Connah's Quay will play Serbian side Vojvodina in the next round.
The second qualifying round first leg will take place on 14 July, with the second leg to follow a week later.


A woman has been sentenced to three-and-a-half years in prison for killing a man charged with sexually assaulting young boys on the east London estate where they lived.

Sarah Sands, 32, was found guilty of the manslaughter of Michael Pleasted, 77, by reason of loss of control.
Pleasted, who had previous convictions, was on bail awaiting trial when he was killed at his flat in east London.
He was stabbed eight times and bled to death, the Old Bailey heard.
Judge Nicholas Cooke QC said it was a "truly exceptional case" as he reduced her sentence from seven years to three-and-a-half, taking into consideration her position as a single mother.
Sands, who was cleared of murder, had armed herself with a knife and carried out a "determined and sustained attack" on Pleasted at his flat in Canning Town, the court heard.
Pleasted, who also went by the name of Robin Moult, had 24 previous convictions for sexual offences spanning three decades.
He served sentences of between nine months and six years for sex crimes that included indecent assaults on a boys aged under 16 and under 14.
However, he was not on the sex offenders register as he committed his offences before it was introduced in 1997.
Sands, who has been in custody for the past 10 months, could be released on parole in 11 months.
The judge emphasised the case was "unique" as Sands had lost control rather than taken the law into her own hands and engaged in "vigilante conduct".
He said: "There must never be the slightest encouragement for mob rule."
The judge added: "This was a case in which the defendant promptly gave herself up to the police in a highly stressed state, never disputed responsibility for the killing as a matter of fact, did not take the opportunity to get rid of evidence and demonstrated remorse."
At the time of the attack, Pleasted was on bail awaiting trial at Snaresbrook Crown Court on two charges of sexual assault on two children aged under 13.
Officers were also investigating a further allegation he had abused a third boy.
During the trial, Sands told the court she had not intended to hurt Pleasted when she went to his flat with a knife, claiming instead she wanted him to admit to his crimes so his young accusers would not have to go to court.
Sands told the jury she was "frightened", adding: "It was not how it was meant to go. He was meant to listen to me".
However she said Pleasted "smirked" when he answered the door and told her the boys were all liars who had ruined his life.
During the trial, the judge said an inquiry was under way into the decision to bail Pleasted.


Mining giant Rio Tinto has lowered its minimum acceptances target slightly in a last ditch effort to takeover South Africa's Riversdale Mining.

Rio's offer of 16.50 Australian dollars ($16.42; Â£10.14) is now conditional on 47% of shareholders accepting it by 6 April.
Previously its minimum target was 50%.
The move came after talks on the A$3.9bn offer between Rio and Riversdale major shareholder, Brazil's CSN.
If it fails to reach the new threshold, Rio Tinto will pay Riversdale shareholders only A$16 a share.
So far only 41% have said yes.
The other key shareholder in Riversdale is Tata Steel of India, which recently increased its stake to 27% and also has a director on the company's board.
CSN, Brazil's largest steelmaker, has also increased its Riversdale stake to 19.9%.


Canadian pop star Justin Bieber has pleaded no contest to misdemeanour vandalism in connection with the egging of his neighbour's home and has been sentenced to two years' probation.

California's court also ordered him to pay $80,900 (Â£47,160) in damages, serve five days of community service and complete an anger management programme.
Bieber, 20, was not present in court for the sentencing.
The singer faces two other criminal cases in Florida and Toronto.
"Justin is glad to get this matter resolved and behind him," Bieber's representatives said in a statement after the verdict by Los Angeles Superior Court in Van Nuys.
"He will continue to move forward focusing on his career and his music."
Investigators searched Bieber's Calabasas home in California in January for evidence after the egging apparently caused serious damage.
One of the singer's friends was arrested on drug possession charges after that search.
The LA County Sheriff's Office say they were looking for surveillance video tapes when they spotted the drugs "in plain view".
Surveillance footage seized from the home appears to show Bieber high-fiving friends and celebrating after throwing eggs at his neighbour's home, police said.
The pop star could have faced a more serious felony charge if the damage to the home had been greater than $20,000.
He has since moved out of Calabasas to Beverly Hills.
Two previous investigations into Bieber's conduct by the sheriff's department did not lead to charges.
Prosecutors declined to charge him last year after a neighbour complained he drove recklessly through the area, and in November 2012 after a paparazzi photographer accused Bieber of assault.
He was arrested by police in Miami in January and charged with driving under the influence and driving without a valid licence and Toronto prosecutors have accused Bieber of assaulting a limousine driver in December.


Former Environment Secretary Owen Paterson has called for Britain to leave the EU and negotiate a free trade agreement with the rest of Europe.

He also said Britain should give notice to quit the EU before negotiations begin ahead of the in/out referendum promised by David Cameron.
The PM is under pressure to reduce EU migration and is expected to set out his plans in a speech before Christmas.
Meanwhile, a think tank called for cuts to in-work benefits for EU migrants.
Open Europe said access to tax credits should be restricted, reducing migrants' take-home pay, making "a huge difference to potential migrants' financial incentives".
The prime minister's promise last year to hold a vote on Europe in 2017 if the Conservatives win the next election was seen as an attempt to halt the rise of UKIP, which senior Tories feared could prevent them from winning an overall majority at next May's general election.
But four days after UKIP defeated the Tories in the Rochester and Strood by-election, Mr Paterson suggested to Mr Cameron he had to be prepared to leave the EU if he wants negotiations on a new relationship with Brussels to succeed.
He urged him to give a manifesto commitment to invoking article 50 of the Lisbon Treaty.
This would give formal notice of Britain's intention to quit the EU and would spark two years of negotiations ahead of a 2017 referendum.
Mr Paterson, who lost his Cabinet job in the summer, used his speech in London to the Eurosceptic Business for Britain group to say making such a pledge could be "enormously attractive to uncommitted voters".
And he said it would give the UK's negotiators a very clear mandate.
Mr Paterson made clear his own preferred option would be for the UK to withdraw from the political structures of the EU and instead, like Norway, forge a trade deal, which would include access to the single market.
After his speech, he told the BBC that Britain had come to a "fork in the road" in its relationship with the EU.
He said: "To sort out the nightmare of the euro, they have got to form a cohesive, effective new state.
"And meanwhile, we withdraw from the political arrangements and we concentrate on trade, which gives us an opportunity to get our seat back on the supra-national bodies which actually decide regulation affecting virtually every business in this country."
Downing Street did not comment ahead of the speech but the BBC's assistant political editor Norman Smith said it would have been met with a "collective groan" given No 10's negotiating objectives were likely to be much more limited.
Deputy Prime Minister Nick Clegg said Mr Paterson's proposals would be a "spectacular own goal", saying three million people's jobs depended on EU membership.
And Labour leader Ed Miliband said the Conservatives were "sleepwalking towards the exit door of the European Union".
"David Cameron only has himself to blame because he's given encouragement to those people in his party who think that's the right option for Britain," he said.
On Sunday, Home Secretary Theresa May admitted the UK was "unlikely" to meet Mr Cameron's target of reducing net migration to the tens of thousands before the general election, saying the scale of EU migration had "blown us off course".
Mr Cameron has called for changes to the principle of free movement of people, but this has been rejected by some other EU leaders.
Open Europe said that rather than trying to cap free movement, the government should restrict access to benefits paid to EU migrants who are in work.
The think tank's director, Mats Persson, told BBC Radio 4's Today programme people could use in-work benefits to "top up their basic pay", meaning their take-home wages were higher than they would be in their home country.
Last week, Labour called for changes to in-work benefits for EU migrants, saying tax credits were being used to undercut wages.
But Witold Sobkow, the Polish ambassador to the UK, said workers were attracted to the UK by the wages, not the benefits.
And asked whether the Open Europe proposals were discriminatory, he said: "Of course, because we pay the same taxes which pay for tax credits, doing the same job."


Working behind the counter of a Thai takeaway in south London, Mark Furness had hit rock bottom.

The Liverpudlian had previously successfully managed a technology business in the north of England, but he says that after its parent group had reneged on giving him a share of the company he quit on the spot.
Moving to London, aged 30 in 2004, to try to restart his career, he instead soon realised that he was "burnt out" by the vagaries of the business world.
Quickly running out of money, he found himself down on his luck. Out of financial desperation he had to swap selling computer equipment for Thai curries.
"By that point I didn't have a penny of savings left, and was staying with friends," says Mr Furness, now 41.
"I earned £150 a week, my rent was £120 and my bills were £25. So I was left with £5 a week to live on.
"So I bought big boxes of Crunchy Nut Cornflakes and litres of milk for my breakfasts and lunches. And then I'd have dinner every day at the Thai takeaway. I did that for seven months."
But as far as Mr Furness had fallen, he says that he was still convinced that he could - and would - set up his own successful IT company.
So in between serving customers their pad Thai or tom yum soup, he'd write down all his business ideas.
Two years later Mr Furness did indeed launch his company - Essensys - which allows small and medium-sized firms, and shared office spaces, to easily outsource all their IT requirements.
Today Essensys is the second-fastest growing IT firm in the UK, according to business magazine Inc. Meanwhile, business research group Gartner has declared that Essensys is a company to watch.
And with London-based Essensys now expanding into the US, Mr Furness, who has the chief executive role, has gone from a spare room in south London to an apartment in Manhattan.
Not bad for a man who left school at 16, and who freely admits he knows "not one jot" about how to write a software programme, or build a computer network.
Brought up in the working class Liverpool area of Huyton, Mr Furness says his dad had two jobs to make ends meet, while his mother worked in a hairdressers.
He says: "We didn't have much money, but you didn't notice that you didn't have stuff. So growing up was alright, as most kids have it, it was a laugh."
Unsure of what to do with his life, unusual fate intervened one Saturday when the keen drummer was playing drums in a Liverpool music shop.
By pure chance, the manager of a professional band was walking past, and liked what he heard.
So aged 16, Mr Furness was invited to become the drummer of a young cabaret band called Juvenile Jazz that played at corporate events across the UK and Europe.
He accepted, and his first concert with the group - the rest of whom were in their early 20s - was in London, which came with a night's stay at one of London's most famous five-star hotels.
Mr Furness says: "I had never stayed in a hotel before, and suddenly I'm staying at Claridge's.
"I remember going to my room and thinking 'this is alright'. It was one of those moments in life when I realised there were opportunities out there."
After spending a year with the band, Mr Furness says he was ultimately sacked because he "wasn't talented enough".
He then went travelling for a year, including spending time in Australia where he worked going door-to-door selling cable TV. Mr Furness says he found it "really quite easy". He adds: "I was a natural salesman, I loved talking to people."
It also marked the start of his career in the IT sector.
Returning to the UK, Mr Furness worked for a number of technology companies before washing up at the Thai restaurant in south London.
Without the money to start an IT firm, Mr Furness realised that he needed a better paying job so he could save up some funds.
So with the help of his brother, who bought him a new suit for the interview, Mr Furness got a job in sales at a computer network business.
Two years later he had finessed his idea for an outsourcing IT firm, and persuaded two of his workmates to leave with him and establish Essensys in 2006.
Each putting in £6,000, Mr Furness' two co-founders Bryn Sadler and Barry Clark had the computer skills to balance his sales and leadership talents.
Their first customer was the owner of Centre Point, the office tower block at the eastern end of London's Oxford Street, and others soon followed suit.
Essensys now handles the IT for 6,000 businesses in the UK, and 250 in the US, where it has been operating for almost six months.
Its annual turnover is more than £12m after seeing annual growth of more than five-fold per year, and it employs more than 90 people.
Adrian Mars, technology journalist and IT consultant, says it is impressive that Essensys' growth has come despite it not having any external investors.
"The firm's growth has all been organic, which is pretty good," says Mr Mars. "I think its success is down to how easy its systems are to use, it has really focused on that."
Mr Furness says his aim is for Essensys to become a multi-million dollar business, and that he has in recent years overcome his insecurities.
"I always had a fear of being found out... that I had made it up as I have gone along," he says.
"Two years ago I was still scared of that, but now I'm happy with it, as it helps us to innovate."


A plan to extend the period needed for a player to qualify for a country on residency has been backed by the Welsh Rugby Union (WRU).

A player currently becomes eligible when they have lived in a country for three years.
World Rugby is due to vote in May on extending it to five, a move also backed by England.
"We believe five years is the right thing," said WRU head of performance Geraint John.
"That's the message passed over to World Rugby when we had the meeting.
"We were in the World Rugby meeting and Martyn Phillips was representing us and our strategy is five years."
The campaign led by World Rugby vice-chairman and former Argentina international Agustin Pichot.
And John says the idea suits the way the WRU want to manage talent in Wales.
"We feel it fits into our strategic plan in terms of what we're about here in Wales - developing our own, developing players that are already here in Wales, looking at talent and trying to keep that talent in Wales," he added.
While England and Wales support the plan it has been reported that Scotland and Ireland are opposed to the change.
John has also revealed the WRU have chosen to install the Wales A team as their new captured international side rather than the Under-20s.
It is a decision designed to make it more likely for England-based Welsh-qualified players to come back into the system because now playing for the Under-20s does not tie them to Wales.
The WRU have indicated their desire to restore the A team although there is unlikely to be a fixture this season for a second string side.
"One of the difficulties we found last year was if you play for Wales Under-20s you are captured so that means you can't play for anyone else," John told the WRU official website.
"We have looked at that and there are a lot of players who are based in England who are Welsh qualified.
"Because it (Wales U20s) was a captured team, the English clubs would not release them and we could not get them back.
"We have decided our Wales A team is our next captured side and that has allowed Welsh-qualified players from across the border to come back and be involved in the U20 squad.
"We have made that statement. I think it's a big plus and will attract those Welsh qualified players who are now living in England to eventually stay in Wales."


The tobacco industry is hampering efforts to introduce life-saving interventions in low and middle-income countries, according to a report by the World Health Organization.

Countries covering two-thirds of the world's population now have measures in place to encourage people to stop smoking.
But tobacco still kills more than 7 million people every year.
Tobacco companies say they are not opposed to "reasonable" regulation.
The proportion of smokers and those using other tobacco products around the world is falling - but it is happening slowly.
One in five people over the age of 15 now use tobacco, compared to one in four in 2007, according to the WHO report on the "global tobacco epidemic".
Dozens of countries have introduced measures to discourage people from smoking over the the past decade, such as introducing higher taxes for products, advertising bans and smoke free zones.
Nepal: Introduced the world's largest health warnings on tobacco packaging in 2015, covering 90% of packets.
India: Launched a nationwide tobacco cessation programme and toll-free quit line in 2016.
The Philippines: Introduced a "Sin Tax Reform Law" which increased tax on tobacco significantly over time, earning an extra $5,2bn for other public services, including healthcare.
"There has been progress, but there's more to do," said Dr Vinayak Prasad, head of WHO's tobacco control unit in Geneva.
"Most of tobacco usage is now happening in the Middle East, in Asian economies and (tobacco use ) in Africa is also adding up"
He said that tobacco companies are now increasingly setting their sights on "easier, less regulated markets", and putting pressure on their governments.
"Many of these countries have not recognised the full value of tobacco taxation to make tobacco more expensive.
"Industry has given arguments on the economic value of tobacco or illicit trade.
"But the health cost burden and economic burden (in total $1.4 trillion) are far in excess than the contribution from the tobacco industry."
He said the tobacco industry's key aim is to make profits, and said they shouldn't be at the table when it comes to national health policies.
"We need to recognise that the tobacco industry is not a friend of the government, they are only there to make profits."
Some of the world's biggest tobacco manufacturing companies have told the BBC that whilst they do not oppose reasonable tobacco regulation, they do need to be part of the debate on policy.
Jonathan Duce from Japan Tobacco International, responsible for brands such as Benson and Hedges and Camel cigarettes, said: "We believe that public officials and policing organizations should have access to all facts when it comes to policy-making, including from businesses.
"Topics such as combating organized crime in tobacco should not be addressed in isolation of the available knowledge from various experts which contributes to informing and driving policies that are effective."


As I step into the hallway in Simon Daykin's New Forest home, his smartwatch goes into overdrive.

He is receiving messages from the house itself, warning him there is somebody inside it doesn't recognise.
"As you come in, you've already been spotted by some of our tech," he says.
"There are cameras in the burglar alarm sensors, and a facial recognition system in the house.
"If it's someone it 'knows', it will tell me. If it's someone it doesn't know, it will tell me."
He selects one of the CCTV images he has received and adds my name to it. That seems to satisfy the house - for now.
The combination of devices also enables him to talk to delivery drivers via his phone if the house is empty (and make sure they leave the parcels in the right place) - and was handy when his daughter had a fall and the family were able to share footage with hospital doctors to help them understand her injury.
It's one of many systems Mr Daykin has rigged up over the past four years years as he has painstakingly created his own unique smart home, using a combination of off-the-shelf kit, a few credit-card-sized Raspberry Pi computers and his own tech expertise.
He says the hardest part has been getting them all to coordinate with each other.
It's a labour of love and it hasn't all been cheap - but he says it is slowly paying for itself because of the savings on the household bills.
The house monitors everything and uses energy only where and when it needs to.
The Daykins also get a government incentive for using a wood pellet boiler, which is programmed to fire up just once a day, and have reduced their water costs by 40% through rainwater harvesting.
LED light bulbs have dramatically decreased the electricity bills.
Mr Daykin's primary motivation was to reduce his family's energy consumption, and he is very proud of the results.
He carries out data mining to fine-tune the house to ever greater efficiency - sensors monitor everything from humidity and air quality to temperature and toilet flushes.
Near the washing machine, in the spot where many people might keep their detergent, the Daykins have a hi-tech "nerve centre" where 2km (1.2 miles) of cabling feeds data to the home's central server.
"The house has modes," he says.
"It knows when you're awake, it knows when you're asleep, it knows when you're not here and it reconfigures security, heating, lighting."
If a room is empty, the electricity on a specially wired bank of plug sockets shuts off, and once the lights go off at night, the house goes into "sleep mode".
Family members have their own preferences pre-programmed - when Mr Daykin's mother-in-law arrives, the heating turns up because she feels the cold more.
At the moment, controlling this data requires his input - but with the rise of artificial intelligence, Mr Daykin hopes to reduce his own role in the proceedings.
"I get a lot of updates from the house, but it's very experimental and I like it because I know what's going on," he says.
"One of the big next steps is being able to talk to the house or use a digital assistant so you don't have to touch anything.
"My ultimate aim is that the house is so aware of what it wants and what you want it to be that it reacts to you without you having to tell it."
The downstairs toilet flush is also kept track of (a double flush boosts the air circulation, for those with delicate noses); and in the process of monitoring the air quality, Mr Daykin has discovered some unexpected correlations between certain adult activities and the corresponding levels of carbon dioxide.
"Maybe in the future we'll be able to predict when we'll need midwives in the house," he says wryly.
It's certainly intensely private information. But if you install a smart home operated by a tech giant, it's exactly the sort of thing you could inadvertently be sharing.
"We are all generating huge amounts of data - and big companies are using that and exploiting that to give us better services and also create better advertising.
"The system I have created, the vast majority of the data never leaves the house unless I choose to access it remotely," he says.
"I am uncomfortable about giving data to other people unless I know how it is going to be used."
As a senior IT professional, it's not surprising that he takes cyber-security very seriously, and has invested in an expensive enterprise-grade firewall "as good as a bank would have".
"It's not just because I don't want people looking into my house," he says.
"I want to protect the data but also I don't want somebody taking control of my house or exploiting it to do something else as we've seen with recent botnet attacks. I won't let that happen to my house."
But he admits that his family has had to get used to the concept of being monitored - and that by mutual agreement the upstairs bedrooms are off-limits.
"I'm comfortable with [the monitoring], the family are getting used to it, it does worry some people. I think that's one of the biggest challenges that tech faces - how do you make these things accepted?"
In fact, people in modern life are very used to being observed, says psychology professor Tim Buchanan, from Westminster University - whether that's through CCTV, smartphone use or even car registration.
"I think most people genuinely aren't aware of all the data that is collectible about them at any point in time or what the value of that data is," he says.
"I think there are many people who are uncomfortable with it - who go to great pains to try to protect their privacy - but even those people will surrender their privacy in order to access services that they need.
"Unless you were to completely strip technology out of your life, I'm afraid we are stuck with it."
Some tech has more longevity than others.
One of Mr Daykin's early experiments was a bathroom-based sound system controlled by rubber ducks that became magnetic controls when placed against the metal bath tub, allowing bathers to control the sound and change the music.
"It was good fun," he says.
"But these days they prefer watching the iPad."


A man has been charged with causing death by dangerous driving after an 18-year-old died following a crash.

A green Peugeot 206 hit a wall on Dewhirst Road in Syke, Rochdale at about 21:30 on 14 November last year, Greater Manchester Police said.
Passenger Talaina Hussain was taken to hospital but died two days later.
Jack Charles Thomas, 19, of Mountside Close, Rochdale is due to appear at Manchester and Salford Magistrates' Court on 11 July.


British number two Aljaz Bedene upset eighth seed Jeremy Chardy to reach the second round of the Valencia Open.

Bedene, at a career-high ranking of 48, swept past France's world number 31, winning 12 of the last 15 games to take a 3-6 6-2 6-1 victory.
The Slovenia-born 26-year-old, who gained UK citizenship in March, next plays Canadian Vasek Pospisil.
"I need to be ready for his big serves - not just to put in a return but to make something of it," said Bedene.
"He's a great volleyer as well and has a great forehand, so I need to be active all the time and not lose serve as I did so easily in the first set today."
Bedene won his only previous match against world number 43 Pospisil in Miami last year.
Australian Nick Kyrgios was knocked out of the tournament in a 6-4 2-6 7-6 (7-3) first-round defeat by German qualifier Daniel Brands.
World number 30 Kyrgios was 4-1 up in the first set but lost it and, despite comfortably winning the next, was beaten in a tie-break in the decider.
"I think the key was to stay calm and just to focus on the important points," said 170th-ranked Brands, who will next play David Ferrer. "I think I played some good points and a really good match."


Jon Wilkin thinks St Helens will remain a force in Super League after moving to a new stadium earlier this year.

For the first time since 2005, Saints were not involved in the Grand Final.
But Wilkin says the 2012 season must be judged as a success, purely because of how well the club coped with the
"If we had stayed at Knowsley Road, it wouldn't exist in a number of years' time. That's the simple fact," the forward told BBC Radio Merseyside.
"The club would have financially died a death. Moving to Langtree Park had to be done.
"Everybody who has invested in the club, not just the current board but in the years gone by, really deserves the credit for taking such a tough decision but to take the club into the future and make the club a profitable business.
"Ultimately, if it's not making money, the club we all love - I love to play for, the fans love to support, you love to report on - would not exist, so from that perspective, it's been a fantastically successful year."
St Helens had a good record at Langtree Park in 2012, winning nine and losing four of their 13 Super League fixtures during the regular season, although it was the scene of their
England international Wilkin is confident Saints' new home, which has a capacity of 18,000, will become just as hostile a place for opposing teams to visit as Knowsley Road had once been.
"It takes time," he said. "I don't think it's something you can achieve overnight.
Media playback is not supported on this device
"You play every team there once, so in the memory banks of every side is one game at Langtree Park.
"We need to build that up over three or four games against a team. All of a sudden, teams have perhaps not won in those four games, and then you start to reap the benefits of home advantage."
A poor start to the campaign  as head coach, with Mike Rush and Keiron Cunningham taking control of first team affairs.
The pair guided Saints to third position in Super League and within 80 minutes of the Grand Final.
has already started rebuilding his squad for next season, with Hull FC duo  and  among their new additions for 2013.
"League form very rarely lies about where you're at and I think Wigan and Warrington had been the best sides all year," continued Wilkin.
"We were probably the third best side and that's something we've got to change. We go into next year full of confidence and with some great recruits.
"We go into every year to win trophy. Not every team can win a trophy and our job is to use the hunger of not winning anything this year to motivate us next season."


A late Branislav Ivanovic header sealed the Europa League title for Chelsea, taking the Blues' haul to 11 trophies in 10 years with nine different managers.

The reigning champions of Europe were disjointed for large parts of the final in Amsterdam against a spirited Benfica. But a superb Fernando Torres effort followed by Ivanovic's dramatic winner leaves Chelsea with silverware to show for a disrupted, and lengthy, season.
Join the debate on Twitter using #BBCFootball.
Phil's view: The keeper was as reliable as ever and a calming presence for Chelsea when they came under pressure from Benfica. Made a brilliant second-half save from Oscar Cardozo to keep Chelsea level. A vital moment.
Phil's view: Suffered with his fellow defenders as Benfica ran Chelsea ragged in the opening phases but stuck to his task and added another medal to his vast collection.
Phil's view: Solid as ever and one of the real heroes of the modern Chelsea. A strong man who can be relied upon when the going gets tough - and he was here. And, of course, the match-winner with that towering header. Man of the match for the Blues.
Phil's view: Looked short of confidence in the first half but produced a brilliant last-ditch tackle in the closing seconds to deny Benfica a second equaliser.
Phil's view: Conceded a penalty and had his uncertain moments but a promising player who will be even better for these experiences next season.
Phil's view: Subdued and not able to impose his natural gifts on the game, although still showed flashes of that wonderful, natural close control.
Phil's view: It turned out to be a quiet night in midfield for the Brazilian playing against his former club, particularly for a player who has shown flashes of real brilliance at times recently.
Phil's view: Chelsea's captain for the night was quiet for periods but still such a threat. Another experienced head in some tough times against Benfica. Could have scored twice when he produced a brilliant save from Artur in the first half then hit the bar late on.
Phil's view: Always probing and trying to create, even when Chelsea's time in possession was scarce. Delivered the corner that led to Ivanovic's late, late winner.
Phil's views: Poor display from the midfield workhorse who operated on Chelsea's right flank. Lost possession and was caught offside far too often.
Phil's view: Left without support for much of the first hour but then revived memories of his magnificent pomp with a stunning individual goal.  Six goals in his last six Europa League games - not bad for a supposed flop.
Phil's view: This win was not the result of any great tactical genius but he did resist the temptation to make hasty changes when the tide was going against Chelsea. He can leave the club with his reputation enhanced and his head held high.


An exam paper for Scottish secondary pupils is being re-issued after a mistake was spotted.

The National 5 Modern Studies exam will take place on Friday afternoon.
The Scottish Qualification Authority (SQA) said the paper has been reprinted because of a typographical error.
The exams body said there was no suggestion of a security breach. A spokesman added that it had procedures in place to deal with situations like this.
The printing mistake in the original paper was in a diagram, not a question.
The SQA said it acted quickly after the error was spotted.
The reprinted paper - with the correct text in the diagram but otherwise identical - will be issued to exam centres across Scotland.
Last year the Higher English paper was replaced amid fears of a security breach.
The SQA also faced criticism over mistakes in the National 5 computing paper.
Earlier this month, the SQA announced that teachers would not have access to exam papers until the day after each test takes place.
It said the change was in order to improve security and confidentiality. The largest teachers' union, the EIS, has condemned the move.


Shrewsbury Town chief executive Brian Caldwell says increasing the League One club's core support is one of his immediate objectives.

Caldwell officially joined Town in February from Scottish club St. Mirren and has raised the concessions age on tickets to 18 years.
"We need to look at how we grow our fanbase here," Caldwell told BBC Radio Shropshire.
"The average age of our season ticket holders is, dare I say, too high."
Caldwell intends to use experience gained during his eight-year stay with St.Mirren, where he oversaw the club's move to a new stadium in 2009, to make a similar impact at Greenhous Meadow.
"We need to encourage young people, we did a lot of work with them at St.Mirren and engaged the local community and we have a great opportunity to market the club," he said.
"Even if they might have an affinity to Manchester United they're not going to be able to go there every week, whereas they can come to Shrewsbury.
"Improving the match-day experience is also on my hit-list. We have great facilities here and we can make the experience even more enjoyable and make sure people come back."
Shrewsbury are on course to secure their place in League One for next season with the club 17th in the table, nine points clear of the relegation zone, with 10 games to play.
Media playback is not supported on this device


Midfielder Anthony Wordsworth scored a brace as Southend secured a convincing win over MK Dons.

Simon Cox opened the scoring for the visitors after only two minutes as he turned and slotted home from close range after the Dons failed to clear their lines from a corner.
And just as the Dons looked to be taking control of the game, Southend doubled their lead in the 25th minute when Wordsworth fired a low strike into the bottom right-hand corner.
Dean Bowditch should have pulled one back late in the first half after finding himself one on one with Mark Oxley, but his tame effort was wide of the mark.
Wordsworth rounded off the victory for Southend - ending a run of five away games without a win - by curling home a free-kick late on.
Report supplied by the Press Association
Match ends, MK Dons 0, Southend United 3.
Second Half ends, MK Dons 0, Southend United 3.
Foul by Darren Potter (MK Dons).
Marc-Antoine Fortuné (Southend United) wins a free kick in the defensive half.
Foul by Ryan Colclough (MK Dons).
Ben Coker (Southend United) wins a free kick in the defensive half.
Darren Potter (MK Dons) wins a free kick on the left wing.
Foul by Jermaine McGlashan (Southend United).
Goal!  MK Dons 0, Southend United 3. Anthony Wordsworth (Southend United) from a free kick with a left footed shot to the top right corner.
Ryan Colclough (MK Dons) is shown the yellow card for a bad foul.
David Martin (MK Dons) is shown the yellow card for a bad foul.
Marc-Antoine Fortuné (Southend United) wins a free kick in the defensive half.
Foul by David Martin (MK Dons).
Darren Potter (MK Dons) wins a free kick on the left wing.
Foul by Marc-Antoine Fortuné (Southend United).
Corner,  Southend United. Conceded by George B Williams.
Corner,  Southend United. Conceded by Joe Walsh.
Ed Upson (MK Dons) wins a free kick in the defensive half.
Foul by Marc-Antoine Fortuné (Southend United).
Corner,  MK Dons. Conceded by Ben Coker.
Substitution, Southend United. Jermaine McGlashan replaces Simon Cox.
Foul by Darren Potter (MK Dons).
Simon Cox (Southend United) wins a free kick on the right wing.
Brandon Thomas-Asante (MK Dons) wins a free kick in the defensive half.
Foul by Jason Demetriou (Southend United).
Substitution, Southend United. Marc-Antoine Fortuné replaces Nile Ranger.
Corner,  MK Dons. Conceded by Anton Ferdinand.
Foul by Joe Walsh (MK Dons).
Nile Ranger (Southend United) wins a free kick on the left wing.
Attempt missed. Dean Bowditch (MK Dons) right footed shot from outside the box is just a bit too high.
George B Williams (MK Dons) wins a free kick on the left wing.
Foul by Nile Ranger (Southend United).
Foul by Paul Downing (MK Dons).
Simon Cox (Southend United) wins a free kick in the defensive half.
Attempt missed. Ryan Leonard (Southend United) right footed shot from outside the box misses to the left following a set piece situation.
Foul by Paul Downing (MK Dons).
Nile Ranger (Southend United) wins a free kick in the defensive half.
Substitution, MK Dons. Brandon Thomas-Asante replaces Daniel Powell.
Substitution, MK Dons. Ed Upson replaces Jack Hendry.
Daniel Powell (MK Dons) wins a free kick on the left wing.


Barnet scored with their only shot on target to snatch a narrow victory away at Yeovil.

The Glovers had dominated throughout, hitting the crossbar twice, but failed to make the breakthrough as substitute Alex Nicholls punished them late on.
Yeovil came close twice in the opening 10 minutes as Ryan Hedges and Otis Khan both drew saves out of Jamie Stephens, and then nearly broke the deadlock early in the second half when Kevin Dawson's long-range deflected effort was well parried by Stephens.
Six minutes later, the hosts thought they had their goal when Barnet failed to clear a Ryan Dickson cross and Tom Eaves' header beat Stephens, but cannoned off the bar.
And the woodwork saved the Bees for a second time when Khan's half volley flew into the frame of the goal with the keeper well beaten.
It looked as though it was only a matter of time before the Glovers found the net, but Nicholls grabbed a shock opener for Barnet six minutes before the end as his low drive beat Artur Krysiak to leave Huish Park stunned.
Khan had the chance to equalise in the final minute, but shot straight at Stephens as the Glovers left the field wondering how they had ended the game on the losing side.
Report provided by the Press Association.
Match ends, Yeovil Town 0, Barnet 1.
Second Half ends, Yeovil Town 0, Barnet 1.
Foul by Otis Khan (Yeovil Town).
Mauro Vilhete (Barnet) wins a free kick on the left wing.
Attempt saved. Otis Khan (Yeovil Town) right footed shot from the centre of the box is saved in the bottom left corner.
Attempt missed. Jean-Louis Akpa-Akpro (Barnet) right footed shot from outside the box misses to the right.
Corner,  Yeovil Town. Conceded by Michael Nelson.
Corner,  Yeovil Town. Conceded by Curtis Weston.
Attempt missed. Francois Zoko (Yeovil Town) right footed shot from outside the box is close, but misses the top left corner.
Corner,  Yeovil Town. Conceded by John Akinde.
Elliot Johnson (Barnet) is shown the yellow card for a bad foul.
Kevin Dawson (Yeovil Town) wins a free kick in the attacking half.
Foul by Elliot Johnson (Barnet).
Goal!  Yeovil Town 0, Barnet 1. Alex Nicholls (Barnet) right footed shot from the centre of the box to the bottom left corner. Assisted by Curtis Weston.
Substitution, Yeovil Town. Tahvon Campbell replaces Tom Eaves.
Substitution, Barnet. Sam Muggleton replaces Luke Gambin.
Attempt saved. Francois Zoko (Yeovil Town) header from the centre of the box is saved in the top centre of the goal.
Corner,  Yeovil Town. Conceded by Elliot Johnson.
Attempt missed. Nathan Smith (Yeovil Town) header from the right side of the six yard box misses to the right following a corner.
Corner,  Yeovil Town. Conceded by Michael Nelson.
Attempt missed. Alex Lacey (Yeovil Town) header from very close range is too high following a corner.
Corner,  Yeovil Town. Conceded by Elliot Johnson.
Otis Khan (Yeovil Town) hits the bar with a right footed shot from outside the box.
Attempt missed. John Akinde (Barnet) header from the right side of the six yard box is close, but misses to the right.
Substitution, Yeovil Town. Francois Zoko replaces Ben Whitfield.
Attempt missed. Alex Lacey (Yeovil Town) right footed shot from outside the box is too high following a corner.
Nathan Smith (Yeovil Town) wins a free kick on the right wing.
Foul by Elliot Johnson (Barnet).
Corner,  Yeovil Town. Conceded by Curtis Weston.
Corner,  Yeovil Town. Conceded by Bira Dembélé.
Substitution, Barnet. Jean-Louis Akpa-Akpro replaces Ephron Mason-Clark.
Attempt missed. Ben Whitfield (Yeovil Town) header from the centre of the box misses to the right.
Foul by Tom Eaves (Yeovil Town).
(Barnet) wins a free kick in the attacking half.
Corner,  Yeovil Town. Conceded by Jamie Stephens.
Corner,  Yeovil Town. Conceded by Jamie Stephens.
Attempt saved. Otis Khan (Yeovil Town) right footed shot from the left side of the box is saved in the centre of the goal.
Substitution, Barnet. Alex Nicholls replaces Tom Champion.
Corner,  Yeovil Town. Conceded by Michael Nelson.
Attempt missed. Otis Khan (Yeovil Town) right footed shot from the left side of the box is close, but misses to the left.


Sir Michael Wilshaw has highlighted the "scandalously poor performance" in getting the poorest toddlers to take up free nursery places in some areas.

The Ofsted chief said nearly a third of those from eligible disadvantaged families had not taken up the offer of free early years education last year.
Sir Michael said this equated to £200m of potential investment failing to reach those for whom it was intended.
The government said the scheme was providing high quality care.
Sir Michal said: "I am concerned that, as things stand, no-one is being held to account for this scandalously poor performance.
"As a result, the opportunity to directly influence the future path of thousands of poorer children is being lost."
Ofsted research, he said, had found the most effective local authorities had adapted their systems to make it easier for parents to get access to these entitlements.
They had also worked with schools and early years providers to ensure there were enough high quality places on offer, in the most appropriate settings.
But in other areas, council leaders were struggling to find enough early years providers who would offer places for two-year-olds.
"This was partly because many pre-school providers do not want to reduce the number of children whose parents pay a higher rate for their provision to accommodate a greater proportion of children on funded places that provide a lower return," Sir Michael said.
Many nurseries and pre-schools say they cannot manage the extra costs associated with the higher needs of these younger, disadvantaged children.
They are paid on average £5.09 an hour per child by the government, with the poorest two-year-olds entitled to 15 hours free childcare a week.
Sir Michael also highlighted how only the six of the 27 nurseries and childminders Ofsted had visited had prioritised admission for disadvantaged children, and how just five of the schools Ofsted went to had been prepared to take two-year-olds into early years classes despite being situated in the right areas.
"This is worrying," Sir Michael said.
"As I have made clear before, I firmly believe that schools are best placed to lead on the necessary help needed by very young children from disadvantaged homes who are at risk of falling behind."
A Department for Education spokesman said: "It is great that more two-year-olds from disadvantaged families are benefiting from free childcare and more providers are stepping up to deliver this offer - extending opportunity to all.
"We know quality childcare is hugely important for families and key to children's life chances.
"We are investing an extra £1bn per year by 2019-20 to help working families with the cost of childcare - so that parents can go back to work or work longer hours if they choose to."
Neil Leitch, chief executive of the Pre-school Learning Alliance, said: "There's no doubt that high-quality early education plays a critical role in supporting children from disadvantaged backgrounds, and in helping to close the gap between these children and their wealthier peers.
"That said, quality costs, and the fact remains that many early years settings - and particularly those in disadvantaged areas - continue to struggle as a result of a lack of adequate funding.
"This has meant that, for many, delivering funded two-year-old places - which often involves providing one-to-one care and spending a significant amount of time working with external agencies - is not financially sustainable."


A stuntman has been airlifted to hospital after a move on his quad bike went wrong at the Royal Welsh Show in Powys.

Matt Coulter, known as the Kangaroo Kid, was performing in the main ring on Monday when he fell off.
Kate Williams, from Royal Welsh Show, said he did not suffer serious injuries and was taken to hospital as a precaution.
His performance scheduled for Monday evening was cancelled.
Mr Coulter, from Australia, holds numerous Guinness World Records on his quad bike, including jumping over 14 jeeps.
St John Cymru said its volunteers positioned in the main show ring attended the patient who had sustained a shoulder, rib and leg injuries.
He was then airlifted to Morriston Hospital in Swansea.


UK unemployment has fallen again while wage growth has hit a near four-year high, official figures have shown.

The number of people out of work between February and April fell by 43,000 to 1.81 million, the Office for National Statistics said.
The jobless rate held steady at 5.5%, the lowest level since August 2008.
Meanwhile wage rises grew at their fastest rate since August 2011, rising 2.7%, both including and excluding bonuses.
The total number of people now in work is 31.05 million people, which is 114,000 more than in the previous three month period.
The employment rate for women hit a record high of 68.6%.
The government welcomed the ONS figures.
"Today's figures confirm that our long-term economic plan is already starting to deliver a better, more prosperous future for the whole of the country, with wages rising, more people finding jobs and more women in work than ever before," said Employment Minister Priti Patel.
But the unemployment rate for people aged from 16 to 24 remained higher than the rate for older age groups.
For the February to April period, the unemployment rate for this group was 16.1%.
The pound rose to a one-month high against the US dollar at $1.57, as traders reacted to news that wages are rising more quickly than expected.
Many see the wage growth as a sign that interest rates may rise sooner than expected.
"The speed in the rise in earnings will embolden a minority on the Monetary Policy Committee who feel the urge to raise rates," said David Kern, chief economist at the British Chambers of Commerce.
"However, until there is firmer evidence of comparable increases in productivity, such a move would be premature.
Analysis: Anthony Reuben, head of statistics, BBC
It's important to remember that these are not precise figures.
The headline unemployment number comes from the Labour Force Survey, in which the ONS interviews about 40,000 people every quarter. That's a very big survey, but as with all surveys it means there is a margin of error.
In the case of the number of people unemployed, it means they are 95% sure that the estimate they have produced is no more than 78,000 out either way. So when they say their best estimate is of a 43,000 fall in unemployment, they mean that they are 95% sure that the actual figure is between a fall of 121,000 and a rise of 35,000. As we can't be 95% confident that unemployment has fallen at all, it means that today's reported drop in unemployment is not statistically significant.
Some economists also cautioned that strong wage growth might not continue indefinitely, with inflation running at just 0.1%, according to figures released on Tuesday.
"It's uncertain as to how much pay growth will continue to accelerate, as low inflation will hold down annual pay reviews," said Chris Williamson, chief economist at Markit.


The City of Birmingham Symphony Orchestra (CBSO) has appointed Mirga Grazinyte-Tyla as its musical director.

The 29-year-old, who is currently assistant conductor at the Los Angeles Philharmonic, will be the only woman to lead a UK orchestra.
Her appointment makes London's orchestras look "stale and middle-aged," said critic Norman Lebrecht.
Replacing Andris Nelsons, Grazinyte-Tyla becomes the CBSO's chief conductor with effect from September 2016.
The Lithuanian musician made her debut with the orchestra in July 2015 and impressed the players so much that she was invited back last month to conduct a specially-arranged concert featuring works by Debussy, Schumann and Sibelius.
Reviewing the performance, The Guardian wrote: "She communicated something wonderfully alive and detailed to the players... [This was] a performance with fresh, clear textures and an unswerving sense of shape."
Grazinyte-Tyla told BBC Radio 3's In Tune she was offered the job shortly afterwards.
Announcing her appointment, the orchestra's chief executive, Stephen Maddock, said Grazinyte-Tyla had established "an instant chemistry" with the orchestra.
"Mirga is 29 and is thrilling audiences wherever she goes," he added. "We can't wait to start making music with her."
The conductor, a protege of Gustavo Dudamel, told the BBC: "I had the feeling, with the CBSO, it didn't matter which direction you would look, they are open to every impulse. It is a huge gift for a conductor.
"I believe we will be a great team and really look forward to making music together."
The CBSO is known for its spotting and promoting young talent. Its previous music directors include Sir Simon Rattle, who was appointed at just 25 years old, and Sakari Oramo, who is now with the BBC Symphony Orchestra.
Grazinyte-Tyla's immediate predecessor, Andris Nelsons, now leads the Boston Symphony Orchestra.
"My time with the orchestra will always be very special to me and I am sure Mirga will also be inspired by the wonderful musical family of the CBSO," he said.
Nelsons left prematurely in summer 2015, and recent months have seen several potential replacements perform with the orchestra in concerts that doubled as thinly-veiled auditions.
The daughter of two musicians, Grazinyte-Tyla went to school in Vilnius, Lithuania, and studied voice.
"As a teenager, I thought singing might be an interesting option," she told the LA Times last year. "Then, in the last years at school, we started to work with a choir and orchestra. I was loving it - being with the music and people at the same time."
She pursued her studies in Zurich, Leipzig and Bologna, eventually graduating with a bachelor's degree in choral and orchestral conducting from the University of Music and Fine Arts, Graz, Austria.
In 2012, she won Salzburg's young conductor competition in 2012; and was last year appointed musical director of the Salzburg Landestheater.
Among her conducting credits to date are appearances with the Gustav Mahler Youth Orchestra, the Beethoven Orchestra Bonn, the Danish National Symphony Orchestra, Berlin's Komische Oper and the Kremerata Baltica.
The LA Times described her as "a natural leader and a musical force of nature" after her 2014 debut with the LA Philharmonic at the Hollywood Bowl.
"Her conducting style is striking. Standing erectly with her legs apart and stationary, she operates from her upper body, vivaciously waving her arms as though corralling the musicians," wrote Mark Swed.
"My guess is that before long she will be known simply as 'Mirga'."
Full details of the musician's opening season with the CBSO will be announced in April.
Although she will be the UK's only female music director, she will not be the first. Marin Alsop previously held the post at the Bournemouth Symphony Orchestra, as did JoAnn Falletta with the Ulster Orchestra.


Newcastle boss John Carver has invited two fans who were part of a group who confronted him in Saturday's defeat by Swansea "for a cup of tea" to discuss their grievances.

Carver, 50, was involved in a heated exchange with several home fans as Newcastle lost 3-2 at St James' Park.
It was their seventh straight defeat and leaves them five points above the Premier League relegation zone.
"It's important I explain some of my actions," said Carver.
"I don't have to, but I think it's important. I'm one of them - and I want them to see I can relate to them and give them a bit of time.
"It'll be interesting to see what they say, it won't all be me me me, it will be a two-way conversation."
Carver, who has a contract until the end of the season, has come under pressure because of Newcastle's poor run of form under him.
Since former manager Alan Pardew left to take charge of Crystal Palace, Newcastle have won just two of their 14 Premier League games.
Carver plans to allow the two fans to see how he prepares for Saturday's game at Leicester.
He added: "I'll show them a little of the preparation going into the game so they have some understanding - without giving away too much of the team - and the planning we put into the week.
"It's not to get them in to have a roll around the office. I'm happy to answer their questions and have a really good conversation and say 'this is what we do'.
"I'm not one looking for sympathy but it's about getting them to understand better."


A man has been arrested in connection with a serious assault at a bookmakers in Glasgow.

The attack happened outside William Hill in Sauchiehall Street on Sunday 12 March.
A 27-year-old man was treated in hospital for a head injury.
A Police Scotland spokesman said a 30-year-old man had been arrested and was the subject of a report to the procurator fiscal.


Holders Etoile du Sahel of Tunisia triumphed at home and FUS Rabat of Morocco drew away to secure African Confederation Cup semi-finals places from Group B.

Etoile defeated  Kawkab Marrakech of Morocco 3-1 in Sousse to continue the defence of their title.
Trailing Kawkab by five points after two Group B games, Etoile then won three consecutive fixtures to take an unassailable four-point lead over the Moroccans.
Iheb Msakni scored either side of a Hamza Lahmar goal to give Etoile a three-goal advantage just after half-time before Ahmed Chagou pulled one back.
FUS Rabat booked their semi-final place in Africa's second-tier club competition with a 1-1 draw against Al Ahly Tripoli of Libya in a game switched to Tunis for security reasons.
Gambian Youssoupha Njie gave the Rabat outfit a second-half lead that was cancelled by Rabie Allafi 10 minutes later to end a run of four straight Ahly losses.
FUS have 11 points, Etoile 10, Kawkab six and Ahly one with the remaining two fixtures scheduled for 23/24 August.
In Group A,  bottom side Young Africans of Tanzania secured a 1-0 win over Algeria's Mouloudia Bejaia - their first victory of the group phase.
A goal from Amis Tambwe in the third minute was enough to keep alive Young Africans' faint hopes of progressing and puts them just a point adrift of both Mouloudia Bejaia and Ghana's Medeama.
That result will boost Medeama ahead of Sunday's match against Group A leaders TP Mazembe of the Democratic Republic of Congo, who have already qualified for the last four.
Coach Prince Owusu admits that a heavy international and domestic fixture load has affected his squad and forced him to rotate his line-up, often to the annoyance of supporters.
"We are going through hell when it comes to fixtures," the coach told the Ghanaian media. "We always seem to be travelling, either in Ghana or in Africa.
"When we return home from Confederation Cup matches, we have to play catch-up in the domestic league. It is not an easy situation.
"People say that most European clubs play twice a week so why are we unhappy, but journeys there are usually much shorter and smoother.
"I really appreciate what my boys are doing. Rotation helps, but some supporters believe we should always start with our best players."
Mazembe clinched a semi-finals place last month with two match days to go.
They are five points ahead of second-place Medeama and Mouloudia Bejaia in third.
Zambia winger and captain Rainford Kalaba scored twice to help Mazembe beat Medeama 3-1 in Congolese mining city Lubumbashi in June after Malik Akowuah had given the visitors a first-minute lead.
While Medeama are competing in Africa for only the second time, Mazembe won nine Confederation of African Football competitions between 1967 and last year.
Young Africans have a mathematical chance of snatching the second semi-finals ticket and must avenge a 1-0 away defeat by Bejaia to stay in contention.


Manchester City and Celtic played out a low-key draw as their Champions League group phase concluded at Etihad Stadium.

This was a dead rubber with City already assured of second place in Group C and Celtic eliminated with no chance of Europa League football.
Celtic started in impressive fashion and on-loan winger Patrick Roberts gave them a fourth-minute lead against his parent club with a crisp finish - an advantage that lasted four minutes before Kelechi Iheanacho drove an angled drive high past Craig Gordon.
And Celtic almost cashed in but substitutes Leigh Griffiths and Gary Mackay-Steven wasted late opportunities.
City boss Pep Guardiola made nine changes from the team that lost at home to Chelsea on Saturday, including teenagers Pablo Maffeo and Tosin Adarabioyo.
Both Guardiola and Celtic manager Brendan Rodgers seemed satisfied at the final whistle, with the only dampener on the night being when scuffles broke out between a small number of rival supporters in the second half.
No judgements can be made from this game, played out with an unfamiliar team with nothing competitive at stake - but City have shown both sides of their personality in this group stage.
If they reproduce the blistering form they demonstrated in the second half of their 3-1 win against Barcelona at Etihad Stadium, they have the style and personnel to trouble any team left in the competition.
If they show the defensive frailty that saw them lose 4-0 in Barcelona - and which they have shown in the Premier League - then they are just as likely to sabotage their chances.
Finishing second in the group usually makes life tougher and they can still land stiff opposition in the likes of Atletico Madrid, Napoli, Monaco, Real Madrid, Borussia Dortmund, Juventus or Sevilla.
Tough - but nothing to deter City if they can produce their best.
Rodgers knew it would be a tough task to progress from a group containing Barcelona and Manchester City. And it has proved difficult.
But Celtic's display here was confident and showed signs that they have learned lessons from the experience - although it must be placed in the context of a game played against an unfamiliar City team.
Celtic kept City at arm's length for much of the game and posed a threat, which is exactly what Rodgers will have wanted. They were well-organised and fiercely industrious.
If there was a fault it was that they did not make the most of their chances, with Moussa Dembele wasteful in the first half and both Griffiths and Mackay-Steven having opportunities late on.
The former Liverpool boss is in a building process at Celtic and while domestic domination looks certain to continue, Rodgers can at least take some solace that they looked to have moved forward in this European campaign.
It's another home draw for Manchester City as they struggle to rediscover the air of invincibility they carried in the early games following Guardiola's arrival.
This was a night of experimentation for the Catalan but his animated behaviour on the touchline made it obvious how much he wanted victory.
It did not materialise and City have now won only four of their past 13 matches. This comes after winning their first 10 competitive fixtures under Guardiola before a 3-3 draw at Celtic in the Champions League.
He will hope this magic touch can return soon with the Premier League entering a crucial stage and further Champions League battles ahead.
Manchester City manager Pep Guardiola:
"I am so happy. We played really good against a good team.
"The experienced players like Bacary Sagna, Gael Clichy, Pablo Zabaleta, Fernando and Ilkay Gundogan helped the young players a lot.
"It was a good experience for them. They deserved to play because they have trained well. Their behaviour is always perfect so I am so happy to give them the opportunity to play in the Champions League.
"The game was good for the spectators, both teams tried to attack. It was fun. It was a pleasure to play against Celtic."
Back to the domestic title chase for both teams.
Manchester City, who are fourth in the Premier League and four points behind leaders Chelsea, travel to reigning champions Leicester City on Saturday (17:30 GMT).
Scottish Premiership leaders Celtic go to second-bottom Partick Thistle on Friday (19:45). Rodgers' side are eight points clear of second-place Rangers, having played three matches fewer than their Old Firm rivals.
Match ends, Manchester City 1, Celtic 1.
Second Half ends, Manchester City 1, Celtic 1.
Ilkay Gündogan (Manchester City) wins a free kick in the attacking half.
Foul by Emilio Izaguirre (Celtic).
Offside, Manchester City. Willy Caballero tries a through ball, but Kelechi Iheanacho is caught offside.
Corner,  Manchester City. Conceded by Jozo Simunovic.
Attempt missed. Leroy Sané (Manchester City) left footed shot from outside the box is close, but misses to the left from a direct free kick.
Scott Brown (Celtic) is shown the yellow card for a bad foul.
Kelechi Iheanacho (Manchester City) wins a free kick in the attacking half.
Foul by Scott Brown (Celtic).
Attempt missed. Fernando (Manchester City) right footed shot from the right side of the box is close, but misses the top right corner. Assisted by Jesús Navas.
Pablo Zabaleta (Manchester City) wins a free kick in the attacking half.
Foul by Tomas Rogic (Celtic).
Corner,  Celtic. Conceded by Willy Caballero.
Attempt saved. Gary Mackay-Steven (Celtic) left footed shot from the left side of the box is saved in the bottom left corner. Assisted by Leigh Griffiths with a through ball.
Corner,  Manchester City. Conceded by Jozo Simunovic.
Attempt blocked. Kelechi Iheanacho (Manchester City) left footed shot from the centre of the box is blocked. Assisted by Tosin Adarabioyo.
Corner,  Manchester City. Conceded by Emilio Izaguirre.
Fernando (Manchester City) wins a free kick in the attacking half.
Foul by Stuart Armstrong (Celtic).
Ilkay Gündogan (Manchester City) is shown the yellow card for a bad foul.
Foul by Ilkay Gündogan (Manchester City).
Tomas Rogic (Celtic) wins a free kick in the attacking half.
Attempt missed. Leigh Griffiths (Celtic) left footed shot from the centre of the box is close, but misses to the right. Assisted by Gary Mackay-Steven.
Corner,  Manchester City. Conceded by Emilio Izaguirre.
Nolito (Manchester City) wins a free kick in the defensive half.
Foul by Tomas Rogic (Celtic).
Offside, Celtic. Stuart Armstrong tries a through ball, but Leigh Griffiths is caught offside.
Substitution, Celtic. Leigh Griffiths replaces Moussa Dembele.
Tosin Adarabioyo (Manchester City) wins a free kick in the defensive half.
Foul by Stuart Armstrong (Celtic).
Offside, Manchester City. Willy Caballero tries a through ball, but Kelechi Iheanacho is caught offside.
Foul by Tosin Adarabioyo (Manchester City).
Moussa Dembele (Celtic) wins a free kick in the defensive half.
Ilkay Gündogan (Manchester City) wins a free kick in the attacking half.
Foul by Scott Brown (Celtic).
Offside, Manchester City. Jesús Navas tries a through ball, but Nolito is caught offside.
Corner,  Celtic. Conceded by Gaël Clichy.
Attempt blocked. Stuart Armstrong (Celtic) right footed shot from outside the box is blocked. Assisted by Tomas Rogic.
Attempt saved. Gary Mackay-Steven (Celtic) left footed shot from outside the box is saved in the bottom left corner. Assisted by Mikael Lustig.


A scheme to turn Glasgow's Kelvin Hall into a cultural, research and training centre has been given initial approval for almost £5m of lottery funds.

The Heritage Lottery Fund awarded a first round pass for the plan to create a safe home for Glasgow's city and university museum collections.
The city council said it would provide access to the city's cultural legacy.
The HLF also confirmed almost £4m in funds for the Battle of Bannockburn visitor centre.
The Kelvin Hall scheme would house a combined 1.5 million treasures from Glasgow's civic collection and from The University of Glasgow's Hunterian Museum and Art Gallery.
Kelvin Hall was home to the city's Museum of Transport, before it moved to its new home at the Riverside Museum.
The hall's international athletics track is also due to close with the opening of the Commonwealth Arena and Sir Chris Hoy Velodrome. The Glasgow Club leisure facilities would remain at the site.
Councillor George Redmond, chairman of Glasgow Life, which runs arts, sport and leisure services for the city, said: "Glasgow is blessed with an abundance of cultural treasures and by working with our partner organisations, we now have an opportunity to safeguard these collections for future generations.
"At the heart of everything we do is a deep desire to ensure that the public can access their cultural legacy, investing in our shared heritage to increase knowledge and the city's reputation as a global cultural capital."
Prof David Gaimster, director of The Hunterian, said: "Kelvin Hall will deliver The University of Glasgow's strategic vision for The Hunterian as a leading global university museum service setting benchmarks in collections research, teaching, training and public engagement. This ambitious partnership between city and university is a first in the UK cultural sector."
Having been awarded a first round pass, the project now has up to two years to submit fully developed proposals for the grant of £4.8m.
The Battle of Bannockburn project has now received its funding of £3.9m for a state-of-the-art visitor attraction to commemorate the battle's 700th anniversary and its place in the history of Scotland.
National Trust for Scotland chief executive Kate Mavor said: "We are creating a stimulating experience that does this historic place justice and tells the complex story of this crucial battle as accurately as possible.
"It will bring visitors face to face with the realities of medieval warfare as well as setting the battle in the context of conflict in the 21st Century."


A Soviet-trained civil servant who turned into a rebel commander, Michel Djotodia fulfilled his long-held ambition of becoming leader of Central African Republic (CAR) when he overthrew President Francois Bozize in March 2013.

Often seen wearing a turban, he became CAR's first Muslim ruler, plunging the country into a religious conflict between the Muslim minority and Christian majority.
In January 2014, at a meeting in Chad organised by regional leaders to try to end the violence - which was attended by CAR's entire transitional assembly  - Mr Djotodia resigned and headed into exile in Benin.
Although Mr Djotodia had officially disbanded the Seleka rebel group that propelled him to power, its fighters have been involved in a vicious cycle of attacks and counter-attacks with Christian militias, known as anti-balaka.
"While Seleka fighters have notional inclinations for political Islam, they share a strong sense of communal identity and a will to avenge previous CAR regimes and their beneficiaries identified as Christians (not much of a discriminating factor, as the CAR population is more than 75% Christian)," says French researcher Roland Marchal in an article published in September.
US anthropologist Louisa Lombard, who was once based in CAR, says Mr Djotodia always pursued his political ambitions "fervently".
"Hearing the stories of his ambition during my research, I almost felt embarrassed on his behalf - he seemed like a Jamaican bobsledder convinced he'd win gold," she wrote when he seized power.
Born in 1949 in what Ms Lombard describes as CAR's "remote, neglected, and largely Muslim north-east", Mr Djotodia led the Union of Democratic Forces for Unity (UFDR) into a coalition with other rebel groups to form Seleka, which spearheaded the offensive to overthrow Mr Bozize.
For Mr Djotodia, this was sweet revenge: Mr Bozize's rebel forces had toppled his political boss, then-President Ange Felix-Patasse, in 2003.
Mr Djotodia had served in Mr Patasse's government as a civil servant in the ministry of planning after studying economics in the former Soviet Union.
According to Ms Lombard, he ended up staying for 10 years in the USSR, where he married and had two daughters.
He became fluent in several languages, "which made him useful when it came to representing the UFDR to foreigners and the media", she says.
"People in Tiringoulou [village in CAR] tell of one day, long before the rebellion, when a plane of Russian hunters unexpectedly arrived. Upon hearing Djotodia's rendition of their language, [they] declared him not Central African but Russian and brought him along for their tour of the country," Ms Lombard adds.
Mr Djotodia also worked in CAR's foreign ministry and was named consul to Nyala in neighbouring Sudan's Darfur region.
He was said to have used his time there to cultivate alliances with Sudanese militias and Chadian rebels in the area.
"It was these fighters from the Chad/Sudan/CAR borderlands who became the military backbone of the Seleka rebel coalition... The UFDR fighters I knew - tough guys, but a bit ragtag, especially compared to their counterparts in places like Chad or Sudan - could have put up a decent fight against the CAR armed forces on their own, but the 'Chadians' were what made them so unstoppable," Ms Lombard says.
Mr Djotodia was jailed in Benin in November 2006 for using the country as a base for his rebellion against Mr Bozize.
According to rights group Amnesty International's 2009 report on CAR,  Mr Djotodia and another rebel leader, Abakar Sabone were, detained without trial in Benin for more than a year, before being released at Mr Bozize's request in the hope that it would the end the conflict raging at the time.
It was probably Mr Bozize's biggest political mistake, as it opened the way for Mr Djotodia to shrewdly play the dual role of peace-maker and rebel leader until he finally seized power in Bangui.


Australia captain Steve Smith has been forced to end his Indian Premier League stay early because of a wrist injury.

The 26-year-old batsman, who has been playing for Rising Pune Supergiants, is returning home for treatment, Cricket Australia has confirmed.
Australia start a tour of the West Indies for a triangular one-day series involving the hosts and South Africa at the end of May.
Smith scored his first Twenty20 century in his penultimate match for Pune.